I had dinner here last night and i have to say i was impressed. A great atmosphere, friendly staff, and good food! Prices are right too! Not real quiet, so maybe not your romantic date night place, but no matter! Go to Cicero and enjoy... read more

Such great food! Great atmosphere! Great price point!! Awesome drinks! (Long Island is my fav) Friendly servers!

The food is very very good!! The service is great as well. Only complaint is the hostesses will not allow you to put your name in unless the whole party is there. Definitely recommend this restaurant! read more

My husband and I absolutely love this restaurant. Wednesday night filet special is fantastic! Everything is always cooked to perfection and if not it's taken care of immediately. Love all the servers but Mary from Jersey is our favorite! We tell everyone we meet about 10 West and often take other couples to have a great dining experience! read more

Went last night to 10 West. I was a little iffy about trying, but so glad we did. We called ahead and were able to get in in 30 minutes. No wait when we arrived, we were seated right away. The interior is really nicely done - I love the look and the feel of the place. Our service was great- helpful, brought us a sample of the soup to try (Tomato Horseradish....DELICIOUS). Super attentive. We sat in the bar area so not only was our waitress on top of things but the bartender would come out and do as well! We had a hard time choosing what to have from the menu as there were so many things that sounded delicious! We started with the sesame tuna appetizer. Thinly sliced seared tuna on sesame crackers with delicious wasabi cream and some ginger sauce(?). Love this, The flavors were amazing. For our meal we both had flatbread pizzas. The Caribbean and the 10 West. Having just come back from Jamaica the jerk part of the Caribbean sounded wonderful, and while I wouldn't really say it tasted like jerk, the combination of the flavors were pretty good. (It actually tastes even better cold the next morning). The 10West was good as well, garlic, balsamic, mushrooms, and bacon..mmm We finished with Carrot Cake. Totally decadent, rich, everything carrot cake should be with delicious cream cheese frosting. Looking forward to going back and trying the other items on the menu! read more

Love love love! Local, fresh market, using the resources around, fantastic!! Great service, great food! Only suggestion is to add a few more vegetarian options. read more

Very good food, worth the wait ( there is a wait). Very nice non chain destination. Great for a date with your wife or a family dinner.

I believe I have a new favorite restaurant.The atmosphere,staff and food were awesome. I had dinner with 5 of my friends and everyone totally enjoyed. read more

First time there! Tomato horseradish soup..good salad and black and bleu steak..we will go back and try the appetizers next time...

My wife and I lived in Cicero from 1990 to 1994 and never imagined a restaurant this nice and affordable would be in our city. Congratulations to the team at 10 West for outstanding service, affordable and creative entree's and a very comfortable, upscale atmosphere. I had the AYCE fish special on Friday and they even give you blackened fish for the same price. It was delicious. Drink prices were fair. I'm a huge fan. read more

10 West - View toward front of restaurant - Burgers Near Me - Cicero, Indiana

Small town great find. Nice menu choices. Blue cheese crusted steak was wonderful. Steak tips, blacken chicken sliders all good choices also. Tomato soup is a must for everyone !! Service very good :) Will be put this on our the list to return soon ! read more

My husband an I ate here tonight. Loved the food. Staff was very friendly. Waitress was a very good server we didn't have to ask for refills or bill she was very prompt. I ordered sirloin cooked perfect very tender great flavor. Great prices for the portion size. Will be returning. My only complaint would be upon arrival we weren't offered basement seating & after seeing pictures online & the reviews on here would have liked to sit down there we were on our anniversary dinner. This was our first visit & didn't know there was basement seating, maybe next time. read more

What a great restaurant! We loved it all, food, drink, atmosphere. Even the pricing was reasonable considering the quality and preparation of the food. We'll definitely go back! It's a popular place and they don't take reservations, which I think they should change, so I would suggest going on a weeknight or off prime time. read more

One of the best restaurants in the area and well worth the trip to Cicero. Great staff and fantastic food at very reasonable prices.

Love eating at 10 West. Food is terrific. Service and atmosphere are very warm and friendly. I will go again and again. Whether you are eating a burger or a steak, it is always excellent. read more

Sometimes a wait for seating. The food is very good. Had the fish tacos last night and enjoyed them very much. They were delightfully flavorful with a spicy touch The steaks on Wednesday "steak special" night are always good. Great to have a nice reasonably priced restaurant with some good food and entertainment! They serve good bar drinks too! read more

I was surely impressed with our meal as well as the prices. We had never been here before and wasn't sure what to expect. The only thing that appeared to be off was the empty glasses. Our server otherwise did an awesome job. The young men who constantly clear the table of messy dishes were great as well. read more

When you go here, it's hard to believe you are actually in Cicero Indiana. Very cool decor and ambiance. Food is really good as well. Of course you have to try the tomato soup. I didn't LOVE it like other people do, but it's good. I ordered the steak and was happy. I went down the list of martinis and was pleased with that as well. I wasn't blown away, but I have only been once and would like to try again! read more

Wow!!! 10 West should be renamed 10 Best. This restaurant has a very fun atmosphere and a terrific menu. We loved the tomato horseradish soup with cheese crostini Try to get a booth in the cellar where there is a very cozy setting. We are looking forward to coming back. read more

We just can't say enough good things about this restaurant!!! We moved to Cicero in August and were pleasantly surprised to find 10 West. Have tried many items on the menu and my husband & I enjoy all of them. We try to always sit in the cellar so we can enjoy the fantastic music that is available on Tuesdays and Thursdays. Johnny and Randy are so talented as are the guest musicians. Many different types of music and we have enjoyed all of them :) Yes, I have read the negative comments from a couple years ago and feel that they aren't even an issue now. Yes, I would love to be able to make reservations, but also feel that this place is worth the wait if needed. We have had to wait for maybe 20-30 min., but just go on down to the cellar and enjoy the bar area and music while we wait. The waiters are more than pleasant and have gone out of their way to take care of us. This restaurant has wonderful food, service, and atmosphere (especially downstairs)....everything that we look for to have a great night out!! read more

The reason I'm even writing a review is because the Manager of the restaurant is always rude. It's a great little restaurant with great food but they need to replace her ASAP! Every time I go in there she's at the front bossing around the others while telling people in a rude manner the wait time. It always turns out that there are plenty of tables available but still a long wait?!?! Just doesn't seem right especially for a place that doesn't accept reservations. Please, please just get her out of there. read more

We had a great night here. It has a nice ambience and was a great spot for our 10 year anniversary dinner. The cellar is a really cool space, but you may have to wait a bit for a table there. The service was excellent. Prices are super reasonable for a place of this quality. Even the drink prices were very reasonable too, for a generous glass. Their free bread was well buttered and tasted great. The Caesar salad was excellent as well. Had the bacon wrapped pork and my wife had chicken noodles. Both were delicious and well presented. Cheesecake and bread putting were a good sized helping and tasted great. We are looking forward to coming back ! read more

10 West is situated on the corner of West and Jackson Street in the town of Cicero. The restaurant inhabits an old building and upon entering you are greeted by modern adornments and friendly small-town service. The interior is quite lovely, a combination of industrial chic and grounded in earth colors and wooden tables. The menu has something for everyone; everything from flatbreads and burgers to twisted tacos, salads and gourmet entrees. 10 West is very family friendly and the kids' menu had three items that peaked the interest of my very picky 7-yr old including mini corn dogs, chicken tenders, and spaghetti. The on-tap beer selection included a favorite of mine, Three Floyd's Gumball Head. Delicious beer in hand and unable to yet make a decision amongst the potential delicious options on the menu; I ordered the Crab Stuffed Mushrooms for my appetizer. The wait was not long and the mushrooms arrived along with a basket of bread. First, the bread was warm, faintly garlicky, soft and chewy with the craters right-sized for butter capture; and to my further delight a perfect crunch to the crust. The mushrooms looked delectable, arrived bubblying hot, stuffed with sweet crabmeat and covered with provolone and buttered bread crumbs, nestled in a bowl of white sauce. The taste lived up to the presentation, the sweetness of the crab, mixed perfectly with the smokiness of the provolone set upon an earthy foundation of mushroom. Two of our entrees came with salads these promptly arrived after the mushrooms. The salads looked and tasted super fresh, like vegetables straight from the home garden. The house-made Green Goddess dressing was light, fresh, and a hint of acid that only emphasized the freshness of the salad. Entrees were next and our tour of 10 West continued to be a success - Chicken Milanese with Asparagus, Walleye perfectly breaded, seasoned, and buttered, and a lovely Salmon BLT. My kids inhaled the chicken tenders and French fries as well as grilled cheese along side macaroni and cheese. I do not often indulge in dessert but with Peanut Butter Pie and Chocolate Cream Pie (CCP) how could we resist! The peanut butter pie with the chocolate cookie crust was amazingly light with the right balance of sweetness and peanut. The CCP was deliciously dark chocolate. read more

Since January, our family & friends have eaten here several times. Be sure to call ahead for seating and go early, or expect to wait. Wednesday's special, Filet Mignon & sweet potato fries were excellent and would recommend. The waitress recommended, we tried the Tomato Horseradish soup.... Was outstanding! Others tried the Beef Tips and Cedar Plank salmon.. Both were perfect! On the weekends, the basement seating has entertainment. Am proud to support a local establishment! read more

The food is incredible, it is the type of fare you would expect to pay 30-60 dollars a plate for at 1/3 that price. Excellent special on Wednesdays $11 Filet meal. Always had awesome service, always ask for Trey he is very attentive and really funny. The ambiance and decor is on point, very mellow and relaxing(especially in the cellar). read more

We love it here! Would much rather wait a few minutes here and pay a little more than other local establishments. The food has always been good and comes out promptly. The service has been nothing shy of great, and the atmosphere is a great balance between upscale restaurant/bar and afternoon lunch spot. We will continue to come back! read more

Absolutely love this restaurant! We eat here regularly at least two times a month sometimes more since they opened. Never a bad meal here. Never bad service here. The chef here is top notch. We feel comfortable going in very casual as well as dressing up for a special date night. Can't give it enough stars. read more

We have been several times and have always had a great experience! Wednesday night they have an amazing special of a petite filet a side, a salad and a sampling of the creamed corn for around $14. Service is great staff is friendly. I recommend call ahead seating because it's always busy. The house Chardonnay is Douglas Hill. You can purchase it across the street at the Cicero Market for about $7 a bottle. read more

Friends took us here for dinner Saturday night. Absolutely fabulous! I had the beef tips, which were cooked to perfection and my husband had the Chicken Milanese choose pasta as one of his sides....OH MY GOODNESS! Very nice atmosphere, servers were very attentive too! Strongly suggest call ahead seating! read more

This was the second time I ate here. And I was pretty disappointed! We were seated at the large long table in the center of the restaurant and as soon as we sat down a booth opened up and I asked if we could move to the booth and they just minute and then didnt come back to the table. So I went back up to the hostess and asked again if we could move to the booth and she said NO and if we didn't want to sit at the large table we could come up to the front and wait for another table. BUT there was an open table and no one waiting. So I'm not sure why we couldn't move there. The Hostess was RUDE! Thirty minutes pasted before they sat someone at that booth!! And the food was just "OK". read more

Absolutely loved it!! Honestly can not get enough of this place!!! Great staff, even better atmosphere!! The food was delicious savory bite after delicious savory bite!! Ill be back as soon as possible!! read more

Having been to this restaurant a dozen times I just want to say it's the best thing to happen to Cicero. This place has a wonderful atmosphere both in the Cellar and upstairs but I personally like the Cellar for date night. Having been here enough I can say that the food is consistently great, and the prices are actually lower then one would expect. I often see the managers checking on the guest which is a nice touch. I think the chef makes all the desserts which is unheard of these days and they are amazing. I will continue to support this restaurant and recommend to all my friends. read more

I wanted to like this place. It was screaming "please like us Ryan... please" but it just did not happen. The only thing screaming that was the ambiance. Let me break down our visit: We called ahead and were told when we arrived that it would be about 10-15 min. That's fine... I understand how call ahead works. We ended up waiting an hour. That was after checking with the host stand at about a 1/2 hour and 45 min. At the hour mark the hostess said she could seat us but there will be a wait on service because the kitchen is behind. I said "Well you just sat a table that just walked in the door why are we will waiting?" She stated "The people that walked in are friends of the owners so they get first available seats." Wow... Guess my money is no good here. OK... by this time I just want to sit in a seat and not by the cold front door. We were sat in the basement, which is really cool and cozy. They had a piano player, also a nice touch (later in the evening he admitted to one of the ladies in our party that he had way too much to drink). Our server came over and greeted us and took our drink order. A second server came back about 10 min later with our drinks. The second server is one the one that took care of us the rest of the meal. She did not seem happy, we felt like we were outcasts and that they didn't want us there. The hostess was right on the wait. Our appetizer came out in about 20 min. Our food 45 min later (we ordered them at the same time). At the end of the meal I asked to speak to the manager. She came over and was not very nice at all. She made excuse after excuse and never said she was sorry. Excuses were: "I'm sorry we cannot control call ahead waiting" and "I doubt my hostess told you that about the friends of the owners" BASICALLY CALLED ME A LIAR and my favorite "I'm sorry we have a really small kitchen so food takes a reall long time". Cool... Thanks for giving me 3 good reasons to never come back. read more

Wow (in a negative way) is all I can use to describe this experience. Called ahead for seating an hour before and told we were on the list. Got there and told we would have a 10 minute for our table...no big deal. We waited for an hour. Anytime we asked how much longer the hostess kept saying we were next (literally nobody else sitting waiting with us) other kept walking in and were getting seated right away and appeared to be friends with servers who would come up and greet them and seat them. Finally got seated in the basement. The ambiance was really cool...I really enjoyed that and am really disappointed in our experience because I would have loved to go back. One server took our drink order and then another took our food order after waiting about 15 minutes. Appetizer came out within about 10 minutes. Spinach dip was really good. I liked the piano player but he appeared intoxicated as he sat at the bar the entire time and I saw him come out of the bathroom where he asked if I'd been drinking and then offered he had too much to drink. He played the same 3 songs over and over. So it's a nice concept maybe if he was sober and had more variety. We seriously waited over an hour for our dinner. It was hot and actually quite good but at that point it was 9:40pm and we had been there since 7:30 hungry and ready to eat. The server offered no apologies for the food taking so long and in fact never even came to our table while we were waiting. At the end of the meal the manager (a female) came up to see how our meal was. We explained about the wait for seating and food. She said she couldn't do anything about the wait for seating and that even if you call ahead you can still have an hour wait. Which is not the case at most places. She then stated that the kitchen is too small for the size of restaurant and that they were very busy and was sorry for the delay in food but that's what it was. She was actually quite rude about it and seemed very offended. We were very friendly when reporting what happened. She had, afterall, asked how our night was so we told her! She continued to make excuses and even accused us of lying about our wait time. We said we probably wouldn't come back and she just said that she was sorry to hear that and offered no reason for us to come back. When I left I went to the bathroom near the kitchen and looked in the kitchen. It is actually quite large and there was plenty of staff in there. It's clear why this was so bad...the service. When a manager is making rude remarks and making lame excuses this is going to carry over to the subordinate staff. I really hated to write this review b/c I had heard the food was great but that the wait for food was long. I was hoping that it was b/c those friends went when it opened but it seems like this a theme. I think the staff needs a major overhaul and some more skill on handling large crowds. It's the restaurant biz. You WANT it to be busy but fast so you can have quick turnover and make more tips. Don't make excuses just apologize and fix it for the next customer! read more

Have been there 4-5 x. Food is very good to excellent as are the servers and drinks..so why 1 star. The front end manager has not got the skills necessary to her position. After raving about the place (even though one request for cellar seating was accepted on call upon arrival-not available) oh well we dealt with it. Next time a group of 8-9 requested celler for a special birthday for a friend. Request made onTuesday for Saturday and accepted "reservation". Saturday at 1:30 p.m. organizer received a call stating we either had to change time or be seated upstairs (not much atmosphere). So my husband called and discussed this decision as not being very businesslike with Lisa Brown. She hung up on him. We did get seated in the cellar. As we were leaving the chef and part owner came to our table and stalked us until my husband was finished with a conversation with a friend. He then berated him for the call, upsetting his girlfriend and she had "many things going on lately"...he refused to listen to our version of the phone conversation, walked us up the stairs berating us in front of others and to the door. Needless to say we will not go back. There are many places with great food, good servers and great drinks. We do not need to spend our money, the same as whomever was going to replace our table in the cellar, to be treated by owners, front end management and chefs this way. RUDE IS A MILD WORD FOR OUR TREATMENT. P.S. Upon being seated in the cellar, we requested to see Lisa to thank her for honoring our reservation. She refused to come to our table and "had been crying all day." I listened to entire phone conversation and my husband was not one bit disrespectful to her, caustic and unkind. He simply stated that that was no way to run a business. (He being a retired business owner himself) read more

Hmmm.... let's see, upon arriving we were pleasantly surprised by the decor and were really looking forward to a wonderful meal and possibly finding a new place to go that is local and not a chain. Then it went downhill. My son has celiac disease so the first thing we ask the waiter is if the meal my son is requesting is gluten free. He goes and checks with the chef and is told it is. Salads come out and his has croutons on it, so we send it back. Next, entrees... My husband and my mashed potatoes and corn are cold, we request new. Some time later (after I have finished my steak) a new plate of potatoes come out, COLD. I call the waiter over, put my finger in them and inform him they are cold and ask him to check himself, he sticks his finger in them and he agrees they are cold. A short time later my potatoes come back, obviously microwaved, with the same finger indentations in them. MY WAITER"S FINGER!!! Seriously? Second conversation with the manager, she realizes we are not happy. Really? They take $5 off my meal for the inconvenience, gee thanks. Get home, guess who's in the bathroom with an upset stomach? Call the restaurant and talk to the manager, gee guess what? there is flour in the corn that they served my son. Really? What do they think gluten is? I'm seriously happy that it is celiac and not a food allergy. Can you imagine a guest going into anaphylaxis shock in the middle of your restaurant? Not that my son eating gluten is any less dangerous to his system but at least he wont die within minutes of eating it. Needless to say, we are not going back!!! Oh, and we never did get our corn... read more

So disappointed! We have raved about this restaurant to our out of town family. We brought them for dinner tonight. My sister ordered the filet and was served a sirloin. When she questioned our waiter he argued with her that she ordered the sirloin!! In his defense he offered to take it back after arguing with her and she chose to keep it since the rest of the table had their food. The manager then stopped and ask how how dinner was. We tried to politely explain that she should talk to her wait staff about arguing with the customer and her response back that it is a natural instinct to say that to the customer if he wrote down the wrong thing. Seriously?!?!? She totally didn't get it. She wanted to defend her waiter instead of apologizing for not meeting our expectations. We weren't trying to get a free meal. We paid for our food and left an appropriate tip.We just wanted them to talk with the waiter. All that said the food was great. Our compliments to the chef read more

Skip this until the owner gets a clue and takes reservations. We've tried this three different days of the week/time and there is ALWAYS an hour plus wait for a table. Too many other great restaurants in and around Noblesville to deal with this mess. read more

Excellent service, good food. and pleasant atmosphere! We had the shrimp bacon appetizer which the family said was excellent. It had nice sauce. The Greek goddess salad dressing was wonderful and creamy on the salad. We were brought sour dough bread which was quickly gobbled up! All the portions seemed good size for the price. The kids meals were appropriately sized...kids said the cheeseburgers tasted like the ones we make at home which is a compliment because that is a staple in the summer. Another child had the all you can eat catfish and had plenty on the first plate! The 10 west pasta was delicious and you could tell the vegetables were fresh. The only negative was sitting close to the front on a cold day as every time the door opened it got breezy! So if you are cold sensitive be sure to ask for a table near the back. They were busy and service and good was excellent! We didn't have a reservation and we were seated within 5 minutes. We will be going back as it is hard to find a non chain restaurant that the entire family enjoys! read more

We had a group of eight dine there last night. There was a lot of people waiting, but 10 West allows for reservations for parties of eight or more. Almost all of us had the $12.99 Filet Mignon Wednesday special. It comes with your choice of house salad, Caesar salad, or tomato-horseradish soup. I got both the Caesar & the soup, and both were very tasty & delicious. If I had to choose one though, it would be the soup because of the unique spiciness of the horseradish (it's not overwhelming). I also really liked the complimentary bread & butter. The bread is soft & warm in the middle, with a yummy, buttery crust. My steak was excellent, prepared just right at medium rare. Everyone in the party was happy with the meal, the portions, and the value. I had the mashed potatoes for a side-- they were fine, but not remarkable. Would probably try the onion rings or baked potato next time. I also had a very fine & strong Maker's Mark Old Fashioned before the meal. I'll definitely go again & hope to sit in the basement or front room, and I'll try the walleye, salmon, or ribeye. read more