Jericho, NY 11753 / Desserts / Dine-in, 2 Adults 1 Child +16 different flavors to choose from. All of the ones I tried were delicious and not too sweet (healthier option than sugary ice cream). +Premium toppings. +Loyalty rewards program. +Customer service was great. +The store was spacious and plenty of seating. -The loyalty rewards program and/or mobile app could use some improvement. read more

See all

My experience was amazing! The frozen yogurt tasted very good and the toppings were good as well. The service was amazing too. The workers were very kind and attended me well. The ambiance was very nice. The place was clean and smelled amazing. read more

16 Handles - Chocolate frozen yogurt - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jericho, New York

This place has gone downhill! The topping is mixed up, and the place looks messy! Thiago ice cream is still delicious, so 3 stars! Ok ok okaaayyy 4 starts for having Nerds as toppings! read more

16 Handles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jericho, New York

Walked in and asked for a Berry smoothie, to which the employee said "we don't have that." "Okay... could i do strawberry banana?" we don't have any" I was confused and asked if they had any smoothie options, to which she responded "no, we don't do those here." I'm not sure if their blender was broken, or if she just didn't feel like making one... but this was just disappointing :( read more

Best self-serve yogurt shop around. The employees are always friendly and welcoming. The store is always clean and stocked with toppings. I love trying the new flavor each month! And my little one loves the color changing spoons. So much fun! read more

I visited 16 handles on Monday and I was greeted and helped by Kelly and Brenda. They were so amazing! It's so nice to see young, hard working young adults so eager to make sure I got everything I needed! Thank you girls!!!!!! read more

Okay this place is sooo good! And it's good for its money, they are always cleaning and making sure it's a safe. The frozen yogurt was amazing and definitely would come here again! read more

I was there tonight and I had an awful experience at this Froyo store. The place smelled, and the staff were incredibly rude and unhelpful. I'm not around here often anymore but things seem to have gone down hill since I was last here in 2023. read more

we love coming to sixteen handles but stopped for about 2 years due the condition. we were so happy to see a new owner in there. we can't wait to come back read more

Always enjoy 16 handles except this time . The employee at the time was super unhelpful. Several yogurt handles were mislabeled and several were not working. We asked about the strawberry one that wasn't working. She responded something' softly, had to ask her to repeat herself several times, and she just didn't do anything. Later a man came in with 3 other people and asked about the strawberry flavor. She reluctantly went out, did something and now it was working , although we had already finished.The sweet cream had a blue yogurt coming out and she said " it's supposed to be like that!" ( that would indeed be strange ). In conclusion , some handles weren't working, some were mislabeled , and some were just out and the person working there couldn't care less. For $20 I was hoping for more. Sorry read more

best customer service the tall young guy with the met hat was the nicest person ever thank you

My best friend told me about this place years ago and I've been in love with the frozen yogurt here ever since (though a litttttlllleeeee pricey)! So much so, we don't even bat an eye at the fact that we drive 30 minutes just for a taste of this goodness!! I have two moods when I come here: fruity and chocolatey. When I'm not sold on which road I want to take, I just ask for samples before deciding and customizing my bowl. I also really love using the waffle bowls when I'm in a chocolatey mood. Noteworthy flavors: Oh My, Pumpkin Pie(seasonal); Cinnamon Rice Pudding; Graham Cracker; Pomegranate Raspberry Tart; So Fresh Mango Sorbetto; Toasty Marshmallow; and Yo Soy Vanilla. read more

16 Handles - Pomegranate Raspberry topped with fruits - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jericho, New York

While getting lunch one day we saw this place and I was like oh we must come back to try it one day! Few days later we did and yummy yummy.

Always enjoy coming here as they offer Oatly soft serve as an option if you're vegan and/or GF . Unfortunately on our last visit the place was very unkempt ( floors very dirty, toppings bar and yogurt machine areas were dirty, and don't look behind the seating as I don't think it's been cleaned in some time ) Unfortunately, the person working there at the time seemed more interested in their phone, and was not in the front of the store when another customer was looking for some help. We've been here when the employees seemed very hard working and the place was well cared for. I do hope things can turn around for the better here as it's always been one of the better frozen yogurt shops in my opinion. read more

Love the different selections of flavors here. I tried the chocolate eruption which was good, the birthday cake (literally tasted like a birthday cake but in frozen yogurt), the coffee was so-so and the red velvet which was okay. This concept is certainly not that innovative. There are plenty of chains popping up that are "create your own" just the fact that you actually serve yourself might be a bit more fun. The inside is decorated very cute - it's pinkberry meets dylans candy shop etc. I liked the idea that they display the nutrition facts on the frozen yogurt but hey with toppings like m&m's, cheesecake bits (which I loved!) and pretty much every type of candy under the sun....who's counting calories anyway?? I think this shop beats the average red mango / pinkberry and if they change the flavors it might just be a keeper! read more

See all

I actually haven't been to this location in years since they first opened many years ago. After attending an event next door, we were still hungry for dessert. As for looks, the set up is simple. Grab a cup, fill it up with the flavor(s) of your choosing and then add toppings and or syrups to your frozen treat. The flavors rotate throughout the year and are displayed on the tiny screens above the dispenser bars. Each flavor also shows you the nutritional values on the screens and whether it's gluten free or fat free. Currently they have a cereal flavors in rotation. They had the Froot Loops flavor which was surprisingly very delicious. My friends and I all agreed that the sweet taro pie was the best flavor we tried that visit. If you're not sure what flavor to choose, ask the cashier at the register for some sample cups to see what tickles your palate. Since the value of the fro-yo is dependent on weight of the cup, a little tip to make sure you don't spend a lot of money is to always choose the small cup, so you don't add more than you intended to. What is really neat now is they have cup dividers that you can add to your cup incase you want to keep flavors separated. There is also options for waffle bowls (for additional cost) or to have a smoothie. They try to promote being green to separate the waste, but it can be a little confusing where to place each piece of trash. It probably would be easier if they just labeled in parentheses to place what items where. The parking lot is shared by other businesses. From my experience, the lot does get busier during holiday times. They also have weekly specials 12pm-6pm and don't forget to check in with trust ol' yelp for $1 off your cup. read more

See all

I get we are in the middle of a pandemic that is no excuse to take advantage via high prices and small portions. Recently I ordered a small and medium and both cups were only half filled. The total cost along with 5 toppings for both cups all together was $26. Unbelievable. When we go and do it ourselves it is by weight and usually half this amount. Do yourselves a favor and stay away until after we are able to resume to normalcy. read more

good yogurt! i'm always impressed when frozen yogurt actually tastes like the flavor it's supposed to be, most of the time it feels more like "hint of ______". my only complaint was that serving sizes are very small for the price but they do give you the cute blue spoon so if you're here to visit this chain specifically it would probably be worth it. read more

Limited selection of flavors when I went in (two machines were not even being used altogether). I thought for the limited amount that you get + 2 toppings (crushed Oreos and choc chips) is a bit overpriced ($7) for the medium sized cup. I can definitely see the appeal for kids and teenagers but if you're in the mood for ice cream/frozen yogurt, there are better alternatives in the area! read more

In my search to find the perfect self serve yogurt shop I stumbled across a few other is in the surrounding area that were less than satisfactory. Therefore, by the time I came to 16 handles I was in love with everything about this shop. All of the yogurt machines are working. They are clearly labeled. You can sample whichever flavors you like. There is a huge variety of yogurts to try. There are even two sizes of cups. When I went to pay the person at the register was friendly, handed me a cute spoon, and even help me figure out if my 16 handles points card was synced with the app on my phone. Every flavor that I sampled was absolutely delicious. (I took the big cup - and tried almost every flavor!) 16 handles is clean, bright, and there is plenty of parking. This is the place to go for fresh, flavorful self-serve froyo read more

Walked in around 12:45 and more than 1/2 of the machines were either broken/turned off. Some machines were pulled back from the wall and a lady was mopping something behind the machines. When we tried a machine, it was liquid. Hence we walked out, probably never to return. read more

Let me just start off by saying that this place is managed excellently. I remember once I came in little over a month ago and the manager was very helpful and every employee had a smile on their face. Honestly the owner made an exceptional choice hiring the manager, the dude literally made me feel so comfortable. So today I come in. Place is clean, yet the asian employee was still scrubbing the floor. The tall brown worker greeted me with a smile and gave me sample cups without me even asking, it's like he knew as soon as I looked him in the eye. Everything was beautiful and I really recommend coming to this establishment. Although the frozen yogurt is very overpriced and the Euro Tart machine is always runny. read more

16 Handles - I really went all out - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jericho, New York

See all

4-5 for the yogurt. 2 on the pricing. $0.69/oz is hefty, but maybe that's the going rate on Long Island. Comparable (good) yogurt in my area is $0.51/oz. The mint choc chip was excellent and it was nice to see they offered a soy chocolate this time. read more

That's it! ...I'm in love. Yes, the romantic, gushy, silver screen type of love. I love choice, I love creativity and most of all I love froyo. 16 handles delivers. Some people think the name sounds like a new strip joint, some muster up images of 80s teen flicks in their heads - but, I knew better. 16 handles of delicious frozen treats awaited me. Self serve Kiwi Strawberry, Mango, Peanut butter, pistachio, euro tart, vanilla, chocolate... and other yummy flavors. Don't forget the 25+ toppings you can put on and caramel/chocolate syrup!! You can make your froyo so eclectic it's terribly disgusting to everyone but you. They change the flavors pretty often and some are a little under par in the flavor dept (peanut butter/cake batter/pistachio) but the key here is diversity! This place gets so crowded at night; you'd think there'd be something other than froyo attracting people like mosquitoes to the light here. Nope! Also: Good luck finding a place to sit. North shore moms in Ugg(ly) boots and furry vests will nudge you off the pastel colored seating along the wall while you're enjoying your frozen treats. Did I mention? It's pay by weight. I found it ever so slightly cheaper than red ripoff (cough, I mean red mango). Still, with all the variety, you can expect to pay around $5 walking out of here. read more

I've been going here for years and I must say its the best Fro-Yo on Long Island! I have tried the competitors and they don't come a close second. The place is always clean when you walk in and they have great staff. It's called 16 handle because they have 16 flavors of frozen yogurt and you pull the handle. You get the choice of a bowl or cone, once you decide you add any topping you like. Bananas, chocolate, cookies dough, and sprinkles are a small few they offer. After your done with the food decorations you weight it and that's how you pay! It's a great idea because if you want to save money, don't add a lot of toppings. For me it's a treat so I go crazy!! I like the brownie bites. If you need to go somewhere to hang out with friends I suggest you give 16 handles a try. Also for the great Fro-Yo too! read more

16 Handles - My Favorite - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jericho, New York

See all

You can get 16 handles without any of the love handles! Delicious low-calorie option for all you dessert lovers out there! With 16 flavors, that you can even mix two flavors together, or just get a little bit of everything, the options are literally endless. They have fruits, mini-cheesecakes, coconut, do I really need to keep going? It's a fabulous way to keep the calories to a low, and the flavors just the same! I especially love their fresh strawberries! Give it a go - avoid the peak hours, there are too many little kids and honestly they're just messy, and the toppings just get a bit dirty. Overall a good joint, watch your serving size as it gets expensive quickly - TIP: Go for the smaller cup so it'll force you to not get too much! Happy Summer! :) read more

16 Handles - Yum! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jericho, New York

ok having lost 170+ pounds, the one thing i've constantly been looking for has been anything that can satisfy my sweet cravings without wrecking my new lifestyle choices.... On a recommendation, i decided to check out this place and I must say I WAS BLOWN AWAY, literally.... Fresh and creative Yogurt flavors that have nutritional info right in front of the handle is one original idea. And the flavors are amazing, as you can choose from tart mango to white chocolate macademia and from red velvet to chocolate eruption... (and these are just 4 flavors of the many choices available with the pull of a handle, so get pulling). the idea is amazing as creativity and imagination play a big part and can keep the customer quite busy creating numerous combinations. Once you fill your biodegradable cup with some awesome yogurt, you then face a toppings bar that ranges from assorted fruits to candies and other various toppings to individualize your yogurt experience... what more can one ask for... Overall, the place is not to be missed and cannot wait till the port washington location opens up.... Love this place.... read more

16 Handles - Yeah, forgot to take pic before inhaling it... - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jericho, New York

This is your typical froyo place with 16 available flavors and even more available toppings. I looked at their entire flavors list on the website before going and was excited to try some of the flavors. Sadly, when we arrived, none of the flavors I wanted to try were there :( the available flavors were just ok - was not impressed by the cookie butter, graham cracker, peanut butter, cheesecake, or birthday cake. I ended up getting a combo of euro tart, vanilla, and watermelon sorbet. This place is definitely trying to trendy with neon lights that change color. There also seems to be lots of marketing material around to promote their "brand," but none of it has their name...lol not sure if that helps them at all...There's a whole wall of seating but no tables inside...kinda interesting. My friends and I sat at one of the only two tables outside. Overall, everything was ok, but nothing was outstanding. Lots of kids (high school/middle school) made their ways over while we were there. I'd probably come back just because it's close by, but this is nothing to write home about. read more

16 Handles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jericho, New York

First let me start off by saying that the yogurt is absolutely delicious. I got two flavors, salted caramel and birthday cake. Now for the rest of my review. I was looking up places to get frozen yogurt in my neighborhood a few nights ago. I found 16 Handles on yelp from one of their advertisements. The pictures of the yogurt looked delicious so I was intrigued. I read the reviews and found them to be mixed. Most of the reviews said that the flavors were delicious and they were correct. The negative comments came from the cleanliness, availability of yogurt and staff. I can confirm that the reviews were correct. My husband and I got to the store at 10:20, they close at 10:30. One employee had already locked the door but when she saw that we stood there and didn't move she opened the door. I picked my cup and went to the dispensers but they were messy with dried yogurt all over. It looked like it hadn't been cleaned in a few hours. I looked at the flavors that they had on offer, I stopped at toasted marshmallow and nothing came out...disappointing. There were three other flavors that weren't working and two that weren't labeled. I chose my two flavors and moved on to the toppings section. I am not exaggerating but only three toppings had spoons in them. My husband said something and the employee gave us spoons. I understand that they were getting ready to close but once people came in the spoons should have been ready. Did my first experience deter me from coming back? No, I plan on coming back because the flavors were amazing. After my next visit that will determine if I become a recurring customer. read more

I asked for sample cups and these two girls informed me that "there are no sample cups" and laughed directly in my face. I was perplexed so I asked them if they were joking because they laughed right after. And they told me no, they were not joking and continued laughing. What's the point of 16 handles if you can't try any of the flavors? Also, obviously VERY RUDE employees. Was a very disappointing experience. Will never be coming back. read more

Sooooo many flavors and sooooo many toppings! Everything is self serve - which I love because then I can't be judged for putting 6 different flavors in the same cup. Most were delicious but I didn't like one flavor - too bad they were all mixed up so I have no idea which one lololol. But seriously it was good and the place was clean. Will definitely be going back read more

16 Handles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Jericho, New York

This is a screaming ripoff. You can eat dinner for less money than it costs to get a medium frozen yogurt. Every time my kids cajole me into taking them there, I say "never again." read more

The young girl working last Friday was super nice to my child! Our sundae fell on the floor and she allowed us to replace it, with a smile! The student special for $4 was well worth it. Although this is a drive for us, we will be back. Only suggestion is to disinfect tables between customers. read more

The new nutella flavor is amazing!!! Had "miss you" points somehow (and texts they gave me $1 on my card since its raining out) so basically free fro-yo again, gah love this place!!! Edit- The new salted caramel cookie dough flavor is INCREDIBLE... At first it's a strong salted taste but I got used to it quickly tasting the cookie dough. Best flavor I've ever had there, I hope it stays! read more

Sixteen Handles offers a good range of flavor selection. I was interested in several, but when it came down to it, I had to get the taro, which is difficult to find. I know they have a rewards program which is great to keep customers loyal. We had to wait for an employee to be available to give us sample cups. In the middle of winter, I liked how they offered promotions to keep the customers coming in. Unfortunately, our visit was past the hours of the 50% off promotion, but we were able to claim $1 off with a yelp check in, which was sweet! I liked the flavor of the taro; that purple goodness is what makes my taste buds jump! When compared to other frozen yogurt places, this place, although it says it uses dairy (I am lactose intolerant), did not upset my stomach, which is a plus. I had a small taro with a few toppings. When compared to other competitors such as Red Mango, I noticed that 16 Handles yogurt is not that bound together. The way it melts is more quickly as if ice to water. Red Mango's yogurt has more a creamy consistency (which is starting to bother my stomach in recent visits, unfortunately and has me seeking other froyo options). Overall in taste, I prefer my froyo creamier which is why Red Mango is my usual go to place. This place could quickly become my second option if there were more locations. From the flavors I had sampled, it seems like the taste to me is either a hit or a miss. I sampled the hazelnut gelato, which tasted more like coffee than hazelnut. Was the wrong sign placed up (the hazelnut gelato was a written sign taped up). The other flavors I sampled were as follows: birthday cake (too sweet, tasted very artificial), and red velvet (also tasted artificial). Also I noticed the signs of two of the rows of toppings should have been switched and notified the worker. In addition, one of the machines I was trying to sample did work (no yogurt came out of the machine, so I gave up on the flavor). Since the pricing on each cup is by weight, I suggest you go light on the toppings... as you will be paying a steep price for bits of oreo cookies, cereal, or pieces of fruits. I like the mission of the franchise which tries to encourage patrons to recycle their plastic pink spoons, and to place them on the proper bins. It would surely make things easier if they labelled the bins as such: "spoons", "cups", and "everything else". You may think it is common sense but many people also lack common sense or do not care to take two minutes to think about which bin is the proper one. read more

Two stars because the yogurt is really good, but $24 for two people- we both used a small cup and mine had no toppings. This is insane. Any other yogurt place is half the price. I will not be back. read more

16 handles has an array of different froyo flavors! But not anything new that you wouldn't see at other froyo places. They have two different sizes, a small and a large. They charge you by the weight. I've filled up my small cup before, no toppings & it cost $7.50. I've filled a medium, a few toppings & that came out to $10. The prices are ridiculous for froyo! The only upside is that Monday-Friday they have deals for each day & if you check in on yelp you can get a dollar off. The froyo is good, and the place is always clean, and the staff is always nice but if you can find a cheaper froyo place in the area I would. read more

Mango is my first love but move over I have a new love thats right 16 handles has so many flavors and toppings to choose from!! First pull your flavor, then a topping then weight it and pay!! I will definitely be going back soon!!! read more

ewwww.. I walked in and it was packed filled with little kids all the way up to groups of adults, needless to say it was loud and there was no where to sit. No biggie I move on and I wait in line to get my frozen yogurt and I am really enjoying the selection of flavors, a little bit of this a little bit of that.. ohh now I get to pile on the candy.. YUM what could be bad? Then it all goes sour. I pay for my small yogurt and okay its not cheap it came out to about $9.00, fine whatever its a novelty. This is when I drew the line.. I found a place to sit after a few minutes and I am watching people pile on candy and I see this little girl peed on herself THEN she scratches her wet pajama pants and puts her hand in the candy!! VOMIT.. very unsanitary, her parents let her grab things with her hands is bad enough but the fact that she was touching her wet pee pee pants on top of everything is enough to make me want to barf. The next people to eat the oreos or whatever it was she was touching (more then one item) had a little bit of... uggh you know where I am getting at. No thanks. I am sticking with Yogurt and Such. read more

My husband and I went to 16 handles at 9:40 pm they close at 10:30 the machines were cycling there wash and they were pulling the grates out of the machines, why not just lock the doors? The staff is suppose to do that when they close not before! To bad the owner lost an hours worth of business with people walking out due to a lazy staff! read more