Pirilo is the best pizza place you'll ever find in Old San Juan! I was so excited to be back, that…read moreI forgot to take a picture of our pepperoni pie!!! We also had the Caprese salad and pulpo à la gallega (so very tasty)!!! Service is on point, great atmosphere to go with family and friends.

If you're walking by, this restaurant would be very easy to miss. The entrance looks like a doorway…read moreleading to a stairwell or service entrance, and I honestly didn't even notice a sign. Luckily, there was a gentleman outside directing people in, otherwise we may have walked right past it. Once you climb the two flights of stairs, you're rewarded with a beautiful dining space. The restaurant has a rustic, old-world charm with gorgeous décor and an Italian-inspired atmosphere. It immediately felt warm and inviting. There were four of us dining, and we started with two appetizers: the Setas Rellenas and the Chorizo al Vino. Both were excellent, but the Chorizo al Vino was my absolute favorite--absolutely delicious! For my entrée, I ordered the chicken lasagna. I expected chunks of chicken, but it was made with shredded chicken, and wow--it was incredible. The flavor was outstanding, and it ended up being one of my favorite meals of our trip. My husband ordered the beef lasagna, which was also made with shredded beef rather than traditional ground beef. He absolutely loved it. Our friends ordered the Milanesa de Berenjena and the Milanesa de Pollo with a side of gnocchi, and both raved about their meals as well. Since nearly every table seemed to be ordering pizza, we knew we had to try one. We ordered a small pizza for the table, and each of us had a slice. Now we understand why they're known for their pizza--it was fantastic! A special shoutout to our server, Rouil Rodz, who was attentive, friendly, and provided excellent service throughout the evening. Don't let the unassuming entrance fool you. This restaurant is a hidden gem with a beautiful atmosphere, outstanding food, and excellent service. If you're visiting Old San Juan, I highly recommend adding it to your list.

I love this place! I'm so happy they're on Yelp. I found them two years ago on my first trip to…read morePuerto Rico and wanted to leave a review but didn't find them on Yelp. I knew I had to come back on my second trip to the island. Delicious pizza! Hot, fresh, great cheese pull! All fresh ingredients. Service very friendly! I ordered a personal size pizza -La Selva. Ingredients: Homemade tomato sauce and fresh mozzarella cheese. Green peppers, mushrooms, broccoli, onions, cherry tomatoes, spinach.

Tried calling in an order and was told all orders must be placed online. Placed one for a large…read morepepperoni and the website tells you exactly what time it will be finished. Arrived, and it was done! Inside of the restaurant was clean and the workers were friendly. The pizza was decent. I wish it had more sauce and flavor tho. The place offers a lot more unique toppings like shrimp and avocado, than I am used too. Will def come back and try another soon.

My husband and I were in San Juan for my birthday in August, and we visited La O one evening for…read moredinner with another couple. This place is stunning! Very chic, cozy vibe. We were seated immediately and greeted by our lovely server. La O is an Italian restaurant with some Latin fusion dishes. I ended up ordering the grilled octopus and my husband ordered a pizza. Both dishes were delicious! Our table shared a pitcher of sangria which was also lovely.

I walk into a cool looking cocktail bar, to get a drink while waiting, in need of a meal....waiting…read morefor the place at the corner...and find a great restaurant in the back...winner, winner (not) chicken dinner. Had the calamari, shrimp, and burrata app. Highly recommend the burrata. The sauce on the shrimp is delicious...the texture of the calamari was nice, but wished I asked for a marinara sauce, instead of the cilantro, which came off a bit like mayo. Had the octopus main and a chorizo pizza. Loved the chorizo on the pizza, and the tamponade on the octopus. Had the passion fruit creme brûlée...my daughter ordered it...those who follow me know I rarely order dessert...I drink more, have fresh fruit or cheese. It was the perfect texture, taste and that includes the passion fruit. Ambiance is cool...bathroom is ok. Service was lovely and the staff seemed to genuinely like the owners.

As a newcomer to San Juan, and not knowing where to dine, I can highly recommend Bari Italian…read moreRestaurant. The food is absolutely delicious (each of our family members had something different, and everyone was completely satisfied! The coffee's were yummy, the wait staff (Khadijha) VERY pleasant and accommodating, the atmosphere (we chose to eat outdoors) is charming, and the parking, although limited, if you are handicapped, can park directly across the street. If not, I can't comment where to park. Maybe uber in here directly. All in all a delicious and delightful experience for our first time here. SPECIAL NOTE: We came back for a second dinner, and our server Christian was delightful and we met the Manager Julie who was so friendly and welcoming! Be sure to visit BARI if you come to San Juan!!

Delicious! Mofongo with shrimp and garlic sauce…read more Pizza Subs Service was excellent- Highly recommend

Fiore's is such a cool spot to come in and grab a pizza while sightseeing in Viejo San Juan, it has…read morea really great atmosphere and the staff is amazing. We started with the pastelillo appetizer, they were fried to crispy golden perfection and both the beef and chicken ones were delicious. The green sauce that came with them was herbaceous perfection and we even got some more so that we can dip our pizza in. We got the pie with roasted garlic, prosciutto and pepperoni which was absolutely delicious. The pizza came out hot and fresh and all of the ingredients on it worked really well together and everything had great flavor. The little bites of whole roasted garlic cloves gives you that slightly sweet, caramelized garlicky goodness that us garlic lovers adore. The legal drinking age in Puerto Rico is 18 so my 19 year old nephew was over the moon that he was able to order himself a pomegranate margarita so it was fun to see him experience ordering his adult beverage! Overall we had a really great experience and the bartender was super friendly and helpful in all of the food and drink recommendations. Definitely add this to your next stop in Viejo San Juan.

Okay, this is a super cool pizza joint located in San Juan near the ports. It is a great location,…read morewith a clean and cozy dining area inside and outside. They have big screen TV's and music. The service was great, our waitress/bartender made great drinks and our food came out quickly. The empanadas de pollo were hot, fresh, and really good! I would've ordered more but we didn't want leftovers. We ordered a really delicious pizza that had pepperoni, prosciutto, roasted garlic, and salad. It was perfection! The sauce ratio, the crust, the toppings, a true perfect blend! I know people don't travel to Puerto Rico for pizza but I had my fill of the traditional food and this pizza hit the spot! The margarita is basic, the pina colada was to be as expected, but the pomegranate mojito was extraordinary! (And really expensive! $13) Overall I really enjoyed this meal but $40 of the bill was food, $35 drinks! Next time I'll skip on the drinks or just get a beer.

We were walking the streets of Old San Juan when we stumbled upon The Mezzanine, and what an…read moreawesome find! This cozy bar and tapas restaurant has a charming speakeasy vibe that immediately made us want to stay. There were four of us, and we shared three different tapas. The meatballs were hands down our favorite--they were absolutely amazing! The hummus was delicious, and the shrimp was just as impressive. The atmosphere is cute, quaint, and incredibly comfortable, with cozy chairs and small tables that give it more of a lounge feel than a traditional restaurant. It was the perfect place to relax after exploring Old San Juan. If you're in the area, I definitely recommend stopping in. We loved everything about it and would absolutely go back!

The food was delicious. The staff was 100% amazing. They just made the entire experience perfect…read more My cousin and I sat at the bar and talked to the bartender and the server. It looked like they were having fun at work and they made our experience very enjoyable and entertaining. I learned that the bartender sings opera so definitely ask him about that lol! An absolute must visit next time in Puerto Rico! Decorations, lights, music - perfection.

We had been visiting the forts and wandering around Old Town all afternoon and were starving. My…read morehusband and I will eat nearly anything, but we had to find a restaurant that offered something for our vegetarian daughter and picky eater son. Haha. When we saw this place and the menu we decided to try it. Our server Kike was great! Very friendly and efficient. He also made the BEST n/a mojito I've ever had. It was so perfectly limey and minty and refreshing. It was days ago and I'm still thinking about it. lol. We ordered sliders, a plain cheeseburger with fries, cheese pizza and rice and beans. Everything was delicious and I thought the prices were reasonable for being in a touristy area. I loved the open air dining and the cute little bar area.

In our last few hours in Puerto Rico, we walked by La Tortuga and decided to stop in. Out of the…read moreseven days of our trip, this was the most "Americanized" place we visited, and had the most foodie creativity. It is one of my recommended spots in PR, especially for when you're getting a little mofongo'd out. Many of the spots you'll see in San Juan are "bars" (more like "drink stations for tourists") that serve some select foods. La Tortuga stood out as it's a restaurant that also happens to have a bar. In our weeks visit, that was the first one we had seen! The service was friendly and fast, with all speaking fluent English. The restaurant is geared towards tourists with an English menu, but prices weren't gouging and the food was delicious. I was craving one last beef empanada before our flight home, and was disappointed to see that these were alternative versions of empanadas... but, was happy to see they were cubano- a hybrid of two of my favorite things! The cubano empanada was grilled as opposed to fried, which was *delicious*. An absolute must try in SJ. My husband ordered the bacon and egg breakfast sandwich- no flavor. Do not recommend. However, I also wouldn't recommend ordering American food outside of the mainland :) I ordered the tostones montaditos... arguably the most flavorful dish I had ordered in PR so far. Absolutely delicious! The pulled pork was rich, topping three plantain chips were more than enough for me for a meal.

My wife and I stopped in here one evening to check out the menu and have a glass of wine. The staff…read morewere very friendly and we ended up ordering a veggie pizza. I have to say it was the best pizza we've had in Old San Juan bar none. Even better than the famous Pirilo's! Here's why; the crust was perfect, not too thin, not too thick and just the right amount of chewiness. The cheese was real mozzarella not that awful local queso that gives pizza a whole other texture. Then the toppings were REALLY fresh. TOP MARKS! The location is within walking distance of the old city and the restaurant itself isn't much to shout about, but the pizza - Trust me.. if mine was not an untypical experience, you will not be disappointed. Sorry I have no picture to post, but I will be going back, so next time I will be sure to get a photo BEFORE I eat it all!

Great place overall! Nice atmosphere, reasonable prices, and quality of food to be delighted…read more Stopped for a beer and appetizers and was just pleased by the service and attention received from the staff. The home made malanga croquettes and the spinach and mushroom empanadas were just perfect. By the freshness and taste of the ingredients, you can tell that the chef and cooks put a lot of effort on making these. Not to forget the strawberry tiramisu. Yeah, you read that right...strawberry. Like made in heaven, the perfect combination of sweet and bitterness topped with a layer of walnuts. Looking forward to go back and taste the variety of pizzas they offer!

Fast service. Friendly staff…read more We ordered the four onion pizza and it was delicious. We got the smaller size (2 pieces each) and it definitely satisfied our craving! We would return here again.

We had a pizza craving and asked our uber driver for recommendations. Pirilo was a suggestion we…read moredecided to follow. We started with a Caprese salad which had fresh cheese and tomatoes. Good salad to split. We then got a large pepperoni pizza. The pizza was big but it's prepared super thin so we only had one piece to take with us. Loved the brick oven crust which was fresh and had a nice crisp to it. Lots of toppings. We sat inside because there were no open tables on the lovely porch. Definitely better to get a table outside. Service was great. Definitely enjoyed this stop.

In old San Juan enjoy some pizza or pasta in a cool climate if you wanna escape the heat…read more We really wanted to try the meatballs and pasta-- after all it said it's the most popular item on the menu-- sadly, no more meatballs today! Had a basic ravioli with shrimp added for an extra $8. FYI, only one bathroom-- bring hand sanitizer in case they are out of soap.

Walking through Old San Juan and needed to grab some dinner that wouldn't take too long. We were…read morealso looking for a different cuisine other than PR (crazy right). Pizza Pirata was a quick walk from where we were in OSJ so we decided to give it a try. My margarita was tasty. Very fresh. Didn't seem like a mix was used which is always nice. Others has the Peter Pan cocktail and pina colada - both enjoyed. For apps, we had the meatballs and the ravioli. The meatballs were just okay. The bread that accompanied it was better with the sauce. Ravioli was good. Pizza - we got the pepperoni with the hot honey. Nice little bit of heat. It was good. Also got the shrimp with bacon and onions. It was good. A little different... gave me more of a flat bread vibe.