If you're looking for a delicious authentic Italian bakery....YOU'VE FOUND IT! The cookies are fresh, the cannolis are delicious and when you walk into the bakery the smell is heavenly! Staff gets 5 stars for always being helpful, knowledgeable and sweet. I feel like I've stepped back in time in Italy every time I go there. This bakery is a MUST TRY and my go to for all of my baked goods around here. read more

Our favorite Italian bakery near Long Beach! I love the Saviads...my wife gets rainbow cookies and Pignolis all the time. They have GIANT cannoli's too...crazy big for parties. Kicks the crap out of Country Boy in my opinion. We are regulars. read more

Really, only 2 reviews? I can only think its because all the old school die hard Italians come here, and they ain't on the Yelp ;-) This bakery is DYNAMITE! My husband & I usually buy 30 bucks worth of mini pastries, just for us, and its all gone in 2 days. Hands down the best pignoli cookies of my life, and the rainbow cookies (get the larger triangle shaped) are more than a step above any I've ever had...and Im Italian, they're a staple to my diet. I just ordered my first cake, one layer of canoli and one of chocolate pudding. I know I'm going to wish I bought a bigger size! Very unassuming, you really have to go! Better than Whistle Stop, way way better than Country Boy. read more

Really great bakery with fresh stuff! Love their sfogliatelli and rainbow cookies. Not too sweet, and so flavorful. Definitely better than another local Italian bakery many people in town are very partial to. read more

I ordered 2 cakes over the phone on a Wednesday one was for that Friday and one was for that Saturday. I went in on Friday morning and they didn't have my cake order.....the reason being that the woman that took my order had the incorrect date for both cakes. They were very nice and accommodating he gave me the cake I asked for that morning. The one thing that bothered me was that I ordered a cannoli cake with fresh whipped cream, I did get it, but there was also chocolate pudding in it. So for the first cake I thought, well it was someone else's cake and that is why, but when the 2nd cake was picked up it was the same thing. The cakes were very good, but I think if they are going to add something that is not ordered they should advise their customers. This day and age there are just too many allergies to compete with. read more

Agrigento Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Island Park, New York

See all

Never disappoints! So delicious! Everything is outstanding! If you get there early enough - make sure you ask for the cheese or meat breads!!! read more

Friendly service and the owner is lovely, Everything I tasted was yummy and fresh.. Biscotti, st Joseph's cakes *with custard and cannoli cream), eclairs and the linzar tart. Can't believe I have passed this place a million times and haven't tried it until now. Do yourself a favor and stop in and try the pastries. They will not disappoint. My new favorite Italian bakery. read more

Best bread in long Island excellent Italian pastries very helpful and friendly staff second to bklyn these pastries and bread are the best

Hands down, the best cannoli I have ever had. And my friend, I have sampled a lot of cannoli in my day. Whether you like them chocolate covered or original, if you like a good cannoli, do yourself a favor and stop in. read more

Stopped in today, wow ! What a great selection of yummy baked goods, cannolis and breads! I got an assorted box and everything was excellent. The cannolis are to not be missed they have various sizes as well as jumbo size. I stuck with the regular size. I will be back for sure in the near future for Christmas gifts. A place to check out! read more

Not only are the baked goods absolutely delicious but this is the kind of bake shop that existed in the 1950s in Brooklyn. Everyone who enters is treated like an important customer. I just got off the phone with the baker, Pasquale, about ordering something to meet someone's dietetic needs on Christmas Eve. He was so accommodating. Imagine a store wanting to do something special for a customer during its busiest season! I love Agrigento and everyone there. And where else can I buy fresh made marzipan in the shape of fruits - the best sfogliatella - a huge assortment of mini Italian pastries - I could go on and on but I'm making myself hungry! read more

I don't understand all the hype about this establishment. I came here today and bought 2 cannolis which both tasted burned. I bought a pound of cookies, they were just okay. Cosco has better tasting cookies and cheaper. I then purchased a 1/2 pound of biscotti , seems like their scale is broken, they only gave me 4 of them. I also bought a wheat pie, what a total waste. Seems like long islanders don't really know what a really good bakery is like. Villabate 18 the ave Bk , Villabate 28th ave Bk, Villabate 18th ave . This is a real Italian bakery hands down. If you can't get to Brooklyn, then bring an Entemman's , your better off, at least it's consistently. read more

After several recommendations and reviewing Yelp reviews I went and got the chocolate strawberry shortcake and since it was a Thursday and cakes in fridge I asked if it was made that day and was assured it was - the cake tasted old and was not flavorful with an abundance of icing - very disappointed. read more

Let me tell you something about picking a good bakery... If you're not picking Agrigento Bakery, YOU'RE PICKING THE WRONG ONE! This bakery sets such a high standard of excellence through both their treats and the service that it is impossible for any other place to compare. I could eat the rainbow cookies for breakfast, lunch and dinner.... and I swear the last time that I brought the pastries into work they were gone before I even got one! What a phenomenal bakery.. 5 stars are well deserved without question. read more

Great experience, friendly staff, good prices and delicious food. It's has an European flair with a small town feel.

Classic Italian bakery with delicious cappuccino. Clean and cute - cookies well done. Can't wait to try the giant canolie! Will be back -

Recently discovered this place. Their cookies are delicious. A great variety. Italian style. A little pricey.

I married into a fairly large Italian-Irish family and parties and get-togethers are large, noisy and fun. The food expectations are very high since there are a number of great cooks in the family. We always get our giant cannolli's here for special parties. Best giant cannolli ever!! The cannolli cream is perfect and so fresh. All of the pastries are so good and the owner and others that work there are exttremely nice. Highly recommended.. read more

A++ for this bakery. The breadsticks are amazing . I can't wait to try their bread (it sells out quickly) The cannoli cream is are amazing , very fresh. They make traditional Sicilian pastries. Great bakery on Long Island ! read more

Very good Italian bakery, excellent breads and pastries. Staff is very accommodating for special occassions. I really love the mini pastries. read more

My brother and I stopped here on Christmas Eve in a hurry to pick up dessert for Christmas Eve dinner at someone's home we were invited to. The woman helping us really helped identify approximately how much we'd need for the group of people we were feeding. It was VERY busy, which I always take to be a good sign! Everything we got was divine, but the rainbow cookies really stuck out in my mind. They were DELICIOUS! Highly recommended! read more

Whether you're looking for bread, a birthday cake or pastries, this is THE place for authentic Italian baked goods.

Delicious everything! The last thing I bought was butter cookies and Italian bread. Always top notch

The best jumbo cannoli! Everybody loves it when we bring it to a party. And the women who work there are so helpful

Recently had a Lobster Tail and a Cannoli and they were by far the best I've ever had. The french cream in most bakeries is too heavy and sweet. This place does it right-light, creamy and extremely addictive. Just the way it should be. After living in Manhattan and Brooklyn for years, I was shocked that the best Italian Bakery I've been to is located in Long Island. read more

If we didn't eat all the pastries so fast I would have taken a picture. I can barely get them out of the box before everyone starts grabbing and eating them. I can't say enough about this bakery. I will tell you this, please please please try the Cartocci, you will never eat another pastry ever!! read more

This Italian bakery is amazing! A benchmark for Italian bakeries on Long Island. The scent of fresh baked goods (One of the most wonderful scents in scentdom) hits you as soon as you open the door. The cases full of delicious pastries, cookies, pies, and cake. It has taken the top spot as my favorite bakery. The Sfogliatelle are amazing (One of the hallmarks of a good Italian Bakery IMO), and I just tried the Canoli tonight at the bakers suggestion. OMG! Canoli was never my favorite until tonight! AWESOME! Tried some sesame cookies, too. Nice to dunk in coffee, and they were still fresh three days later! Mini eclair were tasty as well. It's like going to a Brooklyn bakery 30 years ago when things were done old school. This place is a winner. If you're in the mood for tasty pastry, go. You will be happy you did. read more

Usually very good but I recommend they wear gloves with their products, especially during flu and cold season. We received beautiful chocolate covered strawberries with finger prints all over them. Not very appetizing :( read more

This little Italian bakery is amazing! I love the cannolies and all their cream pastries. If you want to get authentic Italian baked goods than look no further because this is the place right here. I ordered a cake the day before and they were able to make it for me and the taste was just delicious! My favorite bakery! read more

amazing bakery, some of the best pastries i've ever had and i'm so picky!

Best bakery in the area. They are from the "old neighborhood" where I grew up with all the Italians in Glendale, Queens. You will find old fashioned Italian desserts you won't find elsewhere. The cannoli dip is a hit at every party. Pastries are fresh and light. Best place around - I used to drive to Brooklyn for good pastry until I discovered this place. I walked in and knew the family from where I grew up. Small world, very good place. read more

Great bakery. Coming from Queens where we have some amazing Italian bakeries, Agrigento is right up there! Looking forward to getting some more pastries. read more

Holy cannoli!!!!!! I can only recommend the Cannoli dip and chips, but WOW- incredible- the best on LI!!

so good. biscotti - amazing, cookies great. fantastic breads. we get the strawberry shortcake for family get togethers. it doesn't get any better than theirs! highly recommended. read more