I love All Star Bagel, best bagel shop in the area by far. Sometimes I go to another shop and always regret it, they have the best cream cheese flavors, best bagel quality, and best staffing around. The jalapenos cream cheese is amazing, if you're going to other bagel shops in the area and skipping this one, you're missing out. The service is fast and the store atmosphere is also lovely. Best cream cheese flavors: Elote, Jalapenos, Honey Bacon Sriracha. read more

My local bagel place! Delicious bagels! And good service! I have been here about a dozen times already, food is always great! They have a large selection of bagels to choose from. They have the default, plain, everything, egg, whole wheat, then they have super cheesey with cheddar on top! 2 different French toast bagels! And a dozen specialty cream cheeses! They even have seasonal ones too! And they have a crazy hot food selection! I highly recommend. The staff is always very friendly and knowledgeable! Always greets you with a smile! Inside is very very clean. It has a homey vibe to it as well. Very warm and welcoming. To the right they have a couple quick games to play for fun, there are also a few pinball machines as well. Coffee is DIY. They give you the coffee and have a coffee station with dozens of creamer and toppings! Food is always out of this world! How can you ever go wrong with bacon and Taylor ham? Lol! Its fresh, fast, and delicious! All in all one of the better bagels stores im the area! read more

All Star Bagel for the win again! The owners created a new flavor, Elote (Mexican Style Corn) Cream Cheese, I added Red Pickled Onions on a Jalapeño Bagel. A must try if you love exploring new flavors! I also tried their new homemade Chipotle Mayonnaise. If you love cream cheese, and stepping out of your comfort zone it is a must try! The service was great, as always, warm and welcoming! The place is as clean and tidy as usual. You just can't go wrong with the All Star Bagel Team! read more

See all

If you have never visited All Star Bagels you are MISSING OUT on some outstanding food and coffee. We are regular customers and have never had a bad meal. The bagels and sandwiches are amazing. I purchased the bagel chips and topped them with fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, basil and a little ooo. Delish! Thank you All Star Bagel for always providing 5 star food and service. read more

Because this is next to a gas station from the outside, this looks like it might be just another convenience store. But inside it's a very clean. Well lit place with nice ambience friendly people and an incredible selection of bagels read more

All Star Bagel - They offer a great selection of bagels that are fresh and tasty - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Southampton Township, New Jersey

Somebody used a cinnamon, sugar butter Coated knife to slice/cut my savory blt(onion) w/ mayo on asiago/cheddar bagel sandwich. Very displeasing to the pallet. I'm sorry, but I couldn't eat it. Normally this place is flawless. Serve Safe would benefit everyone from the clean-up staff, sandwich makers all the way up to the managers and most importantly, the owners. Cross contamination can be serious. If they are doing it on the service line, I'm sure they are doing it in the fridges and coolers. The sweet crunch of cinnamon and sugar in butter was shocking. Not in a good way either. It made me shiver just thinking about it. We will be back because normally this place is 5's The owners need to lead by example and go through a Safe Serve coarse and then put their staff through the same proper training. It'll come back to bite them in the butt if they don't. Food poisoning and other deadly bacteria cross contamination can be more than devastating. "It's just a simple bagel shop" "it's only a possible deadly bacteria going into our bodies" From small family owned bagel shops to The finest NYC Michelin star restaurant, the simple Serve Safe rules apply. Why? Because it saves lives. The owners are clearly not involved at this location. It's cluttered up like a pack rat lives behind the deli area. Too much clutter in the customer's line of sight. I bet if the entire front end where all the customers can see was clutter free, your shop could become so much more. The attempt to copy the look of Cracker Barrel's lobby/waiting area was cute.... But no. Move all that towards the order counter and by the front door on the right coming in and that makes room left over for so much more seating. I estimate 6-8 more tables. You might need a server or two and expand your lunch menu. I think educated owners and managers would help out with properly prepared food without cross contamination. More seating with an actual server or 3 with an appealing eye catching dining room in that huge space with no clutter in customers view. An expanded lunch menu could lead to an eventual dinner menu. That space is incredible All Star Bagel shop All Star Cafe Blue Plate specials before 4:45 (make sure Leisure Town residents gets notified by flyers and mail inserts (seclusive) Simple deserts but not from this area like Banana Pudding Dirt Cake Sysco's cheese Cake w/topping choices; chocolate chip with Hershey's syrup, cherries, strawberries, bananas or bananas with strawberries, chocolate syrup and chocolate chips. Dinner dishes can start out simple/cheap Spaghetti choice of sauces like meat sauce, marinara, marinara sauce with meatballs Grilled chicken fettuccine Alfredo Blackened chicken pasta with Alfredo Meatloaf Fried chicken Pork chops Sides Starches Mashed potatoes w/ gravy/French Fries/Rice W/gravy Green Green beans/broccoli/asparagus Salad or soup Garden salad (Spring mix, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, green peppers, and red onion, raw broccoli Blt salad Spring Bacon, Lettuce, tomato, onions Bacon egg and cheese (Garden salad plus bacon, boiled eggs and choice of 2 cheeses) Soups Chicken orzo Broccoli and cheddar Loaded baked potatoe soup There's so much that this area needs since Red Lion Diner was sold out to become a Wawa. You have the spot and the space. Put your magic into it! You've already have a great shop, make it into more. You can't be scared of making money. Best of luck! Remember "mayo, butter with cinnamon and sugar" is gross. read more

Absolutely love these bagels and all the fun cream cheese flavors :) the staff is truly amazing we love you guys! Great service and great food read more

I was in the mood for a fresh bagel and did a quick yelp search and stumbled upon a gem. The shop was spacious and welcoming. The service was fast and bagel was great! read more

See all

I love the look of the place and I love that they sell local goods. Service here is very very slow. I ordered an egg scrapple and Swiss on a jalapeño bagel and a large hot coffee. Sadly there was no coffee available which was the whole point of my stop. The egg was good the scrapple was a little under cooked and the bagel was very odd. The bagel was so sweet I thought they gave me a cinnamon raisin bagel but it was a jalapeño bagel that coulda used a little more jalapeño. The bagel actually had sugar on it and some of it was crystalized like the sugar was baked in. It ruined the whole sandwich. read more

I have been to All Star bagels many times and absolutely love it. The atmosphere is done so well. The booths and the tables make it so much more than a run in and grab. We are able to sit and enjoy our sandwiches right there. The owners are always so welcoming and available anytime we have had a questions about the menu or establishment. They have done a beautiful job with the shop and I love that they also support local businesses. Anytime someone is looking for a great breakfast sandwich All Star Bagels is always our first suggestion. We will see you soon for some more delicious bagels. read more

Hands down the best bagel I have ever had. I got the spicy everything bagel with double egg, double sausage, cheese and hash browns. The flavor of the spices was second to none and it all blended together perfectly. If you find yourself in the area do not miss this restaurant read more

This breakfast sandwich shop has become a staple for me! When I head up 206 for work in ny, I stop here regularly if not on Monday and Tuesday when they are closed. The bengals rival those of NY, and the service is excellent! read more

My problem is that this shop is closed or late opening on an all to frequent basis. If it rains, snows. Just about any reason it's closed or opens late. read more

I'm local to the area and was getting my nails done and just happened to stumble upon this place next door. They opened a few months ago so I didn't know about it. However I was so pleasantly surprised at how awesome everything was and I'm definitely making this my new bagel place. The atmosphere is so nice and all the workers were friendly. I'm excited to keep getting my bagels here! read more

All Star Bagel - Plain bagel with pork roll and egg - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Southampton Township, New Jersey

My husband and I always pass this place on the way to our shore home. We never gave it a second look until today because I was starving. I ordered the bacon and Gouda bagel with bacon egg and cheese. Legit the best breakfast sandwich I've ever had. I'm definitely going back again when we pass through the area. read more

Amazing place! Always great atmosphere, service and the food is always hot ready and fresh!

Love their variety of bagels and cream cheese flavors. Staff is always friendly and owners are local.

Great Bagels. Get them all the time when I work this way. I always call ahead and it's ready.

This place looks really beautiful. However, the bagels are OK at best and for some reason their poppy bagels have melted sugar on the bottom as if they were cooked on the same paper as cinnamon raisin. I have noticed at least on three different occasions and should never happen, so we no longer go there. read more

Fresh baked bagels , some unique flavors-spicy everything, Tuscan everything - generous with cream cheese. HOT coffee with self-service "barista" bar. Pricing is appropriate. Service with a smile despite a busy and highly active counter. Casual and playful space to wait for your food order. Parking can be a challenge. read more

Bagels are decent, when you can get them. This business, like numerous others down here in South Jersey is apparently run as a hobby. The owners have clearly never stepped foot inside a real bagel shop. The bagel bins are always or nearly always empty. They have 15 girls working here all the time but still somehow the service is slow. They've recently taken to closing on Mondays, because there's nothing more normal than the breakfast spot being closed on the worst day of the week! The salt on the salt/everything bagel I'm almost certain is road salt. No one has put a different type of salt on salt bagels for the last 100 years. You're not going to start a trend in Southampton stop doing that. The prices are, of course, like everything else outrageous but they gotta pay all those people to stand around and earn enough to close on a MONDAY! read more

Pleasantly surprised when we stopped in for a quick bite on the way to the shore. This place is adorable and looks brand new. It has good bagels, great coffee and breakfast sandwiches. I had a cranberry bagel, which I never had before and it was delicious. My husband is the ultimate bacon, egg and cheese on an everything bagel and he said it was excellent. Definitely will be going back. read more

Food is awesome. Prepared to order. BEST bagels. Great place to relax with a quick cup of coffee and a bagel.

I love all star bagel best breakfast place ever first you get to put gas in your car but your kids will be very hungry if you're just traveling to New Jersey or wherever you're going is the best pick up place that I know of that third bass is so good I don't know who wouldn't like it there there's a bunch of games Pac-Man it is a lot of fun there and I highly recommend him there they can I can cheese on a bagel they have rainbow bagels they have a bunch of different kinds of pickles for a bunch of different leggings read more

Love a good fresh bagel and all star has been great! Nice variety - bonus that I can get an iced coffee without going to dunkin or Starbucks. read more

All Star Bagel is a newer and welcome addition to the area, conveniently located on Route 206. The in-house made bagels are some of my favorite. Great texture and flavor. They also offer a variety of made-to-order breakfast and deli sandwiches. The store is clean and service is courteous and efficient. I removed one star because they more than occasionally run out of bagels in the mornings, which has upended several of our intended purchases. read more

The bagels are good. Get a dozen and take them home. Enjoy! The breakfast sandwiches, not so much. Sandwich of wrapped in foil and the bagel gets doughy and spongy. 4 slices of pork roll of too much, especially when it isn't grilled well. Very little flavor, it's like they forgot the salt and pepper. Cheese was yellow and whiz-like. I'll continue to get the bagels on Sunday morning, I'll skip the breakfast sandwiches. read more

Breakfast Sandwiches are always good! Kids love the rainbow bagels! Highly recommend!

Originally gave the place a 5. Last 3 times I've been there it seems they're using precooked bacon now.... read more

All Star Bagel - Bacon, egg, cheese, & hashbrown on an everything. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Southampton Township, New Jersey

You would never know some of the best bagels are tucked away in the Pine Barrens. Everything is fresh, and my girlfriend and I love the specialty cream cheese flavors. read more

Accidentally discovered these incredible bagels when in the area. Best bagels hands down and so glad my son lives near there to bring them to us occasionally. Friendly staff, very clean store and bagels that remind me of my North Jersey roots. Nice size, sweetness to them and hot. read more

First time I went the bagels were good not toasted though. Nice service, cook doesn't seem the most friendly but I'm basing this off of the 2 times I've been there. Second time I got my egg n cheese rainbow bagel toasted and it was good , I got a chocolate chip bagel and it was super burnt :/ also the cream cheese was bland and there was way too much of it. Overall good experience but overly great. Will still go again though read more

See all

I love this place. I have been to it a few times on my way to my daughter's house and have always had a good experience. The bagels are great. We have ordered a dozen and have ordered breakfast sandwiches and they are consistent in portions and flavor. In addition to bagels they have muffins, and products from some local venders which I love. Staff is friendly and I have never once had service without a smile. No tables to sit inside but that's ok with me. I highly recommend! read more

I brought their bagels to the staff in the ICU at Virtua Memorial and the staff absolutely loved the bagels and strawberry and honey walnut cheese cream. Everyone kept asking me where they came from. The staff were raving about them and said they were best bagels they ever had! Keep up the great work! read more

This is an amazing place to get a great bagel, of any choice!!! I recently had the Grand Slam on a plain bagel and it was SO GOOD! Of course you can get something else other than a plain bagel but just saying! Also a great choice in location, easy access, etc. definitely worth a stop here!! read more