A great place to enjoy good Italian food and great service. Our server, Kendall, was fantastic and…read moremade our visit even more pleasant. We've been to many restaurants in the area, over the years, and realized that good food is even better when servers, like Kendall, are attentive in making sure you get the very best service.

Good service. Old school family restaurant ambiance. Decent pizza. I think this area overall is…read morefood challenged considering that several locals raved about Sammy's. I guess just not what I'm used to. The staff was very friendly.

Service was ok, the waitress/bartender got one of our orders wrong so didnt charge the add on that…read morewasnt. Ambiance was nice and relaxing. Beer was ice cold. Pizza was subpar. The crust was crispy, which was the only good part. Sauce was too heavy, toppings were minimal and the cheese was nonexistent on some pieces. I didnt dig their pizza slicing into small kid pieces. Salad was good but definitely not worth $6.95. Pizzas are over priced for the small portion.

Stopped by and was a very nice pizza joint! The service was good and the pizza was pretty darn…read moregood. We got a veggie pizza. I like the sauce and cheese but the crust could use a little something. Had a good crisp but taste was okay. I would stop by and check out Riverside. We enjoyed it overall.

We just had Rustique Pizzeria catering our post-elopement reception, and could not have been…read morehappier! Everything was so easy to coordinate! They went above and beyond to make sure we had options for all our guest despite having allergies. They had amazing communication and on the day of, hardly needed a thing so we could have a great time! Afterwards had so many people compliment the food! So grateful we found them and would highly recommend them for your event! Much love from the new Theado's!

Been here quite a few times. Pizza seemed a little burnt and dry. Not enough sauce…read more Was a little disappointed this time. Service was good and we enjoy the atmosphere.

While the Margareta pie makes it worth the drive, the traditional hand tossed pizza is da bomb!…read more This is best wood fired pizza on the Penninsula ! Call & pick up ... the online order seems to shut down by 6p.... Leap frog your effort & just call it in... it's all good!

Wild Tomatoes in Fish Creek is one of those places where you immediately understand why the parking…read morelot looks like a Black Friday event at lunchtime. We went around lunch and it was PACKED with of course limited indoor seating, crowded parking, people everywhere but honestly the food made it worth squeezing in. The tomato mozzarella salad was SO fresh and delicious, and the pizza absolutely lived up to the hype. We got the goat cheese & spinach pizza with hot honey and wow... whoever decided hot honey belonged on pizza deserves a raise. Sweet, spicy, cheesy perfection. Even my four year old loved a kick on the pizza. Now for the reason this isn't a 5-star review: the service. Our waiter seemed like he'd rather be literally anywhere else on earth. We had to ask multiple times for refills, and the overall vibe felt like we personally ruined his afternoon simply by existing. I totally understand places get busy, especially during tourist season, and we also had a four year old that was starving and was quiet about it with us so we weren't expecting royal treatment, but good service and a friendly attitude really do change the whole experience. The food? 10/10. The atmosphere? Cozy chaos. The waiter? Needed a snack, a nap, or maybe both. Would absolutely come back for the pizza alone. Just hoping next time our server likes people a little more. Solid 4/5.

We had Oley's cater our daughters wedding rehearsal dinner at our home and it was fabulous! The…read morepizza was great! The Service was excellent and would recommend 100%! Thanks Oley and Jennifer!

We had them cater for our wedding and it was the best decision we made! They were able to get pizza…read moreout for 150 people in a timely manner and quality was not lowered at all. Their pizza got great reviews from our guests. Would totally recommend them for any wedding or large gathering!!

Had a delicious lunch at Il Ritrovo today. We opted to sit outside and enjoy the beautiful weather,…read moreand were able to be seated immediately. Our server Dylan was excellent, and the rest of the staff kept our waters filled and dishes cleared. We tried the Vegetariano panini (fantastic) and the Lombardia pizza Bianca (also fantastic). Everything is clearly prepared with intention - the greens on top of the salad were perfectly dressed, and the veggies on the panini were chopped into small, uniform pieces so every bite was perfect. It was hard to decide what to order, so we will be back to work our way through the menu!

I've been here multiple times and although they boast about their AUTHENTIC pizza...it is ALWAYS…read moreSOGGGY! Perfect spot if you want a goopy, soggy mess. My boyfriend loves this spot, but I have no idea why. I have tried giving it a chance, but I wouldn't bring anyone here. I don't get why people like this spot. The ambiance is "nice" and the service is generally good, although all the servers are young and enjoy chatting with each other far more than doing their job. Deserts are the best part of the experience. Their pastas are also good, but at dinner you only have the option of the pasta special. Please do yourself a favor and go to Uptown Slice instead. They make way better pizza and are much less pretentious.

Delish! Thin crust pizza was delightful - chicken, bacon, pineapple, mmm. Garlic knots were the…read morebest I've had in as long as I can remember. Only complaint is that I wish we had more marinara but besides that.... A post tailgate Heaven.

Went for the lunch buffet. 9.99 sounded like a great value buffet. No drink included though, not…read moremuch of a "lunch" without a drink... Pizza flavor itself wasn't bad but definitely wasn't impressive. I felt the buffet was extremely disappointing. The pizzas they did have out (four pizzas and one cheesy bread) (quite the selection) was pepperoni, a chicken bacon, supreme and Hawaiian. I asked if they bring out any other choices, was told they do but I didn't see any one out. Then asked about a dessert pizza, was told they don't. Salad bar was the only thing I cared for. We wont be going back.

It was so insane and super good with pizza! I love it so much I rated 5 stars! ! It so tasty!read more

I have been on the search for "great pizza" in Oshkosh. That traditional very thin crust that gets…read morecrispy when baked. Homemade of course, not the cookie cutter crust. Zaronis has it! Unfortunately the toppings were missing (tomatoes) or lackluster(double sausage). Not enough cheese or too much sauce. It didn't give the vibe of $26.00 pizza. My search will have to continue. I also got the Zuggets. Tiny, very few pieces for $7.00 and then the marinara was forgotten. Delivery was on time and the pizza was cooked "well" like I asked. My search for "great pizza" continues.