I had a great experience here. I knew about it because my gym used to be across the street and the outside of it was so unique. Sadly I got into a car accident and decided to take it there for repairs. The vibe is really cool when you first walk in, very art deco and cute. More importantly, my car came back good as new. It took a really long time IMO but it was b/c I drive a Land Rover and the parts were on back order so nothing on Amato's. They were as communicative as needed and had great follow through. I hope I don't get into any more car accidents for the rest of my life, but if I do I'll happily bring it back to them. read more

STAY AWAY! They recently changed ownership: 1. Extended Wait Times 2. Communication Lapses 3. Assembly and Detailing Issues VERY disappointed with the service. I was repeatedly assured that the estimate for my vehicle would be emailed to me the same day I took it in. I've called repeatedly and no estimate. It's now Thursday afternoon and I still have nothing. The lack of communication and failure to follow through on the promised timeline has been frustrating. I trusted the information I was given. I took my car elsewhere! Unfortunately, based on this experience, I cannot recommend this body shop. read more

Made an appointment to get a quote for a scratched bumper. Met a guy who seemed nice enough. He asked if I wanted to wait for the quote or just have it emailed to me. I sad email was fine, but he never followed up. I called back and spoke to the receptionist who said he would follow up, but he didn't. It was odd and a waste of time. read more

Stay away from this place! They kept my car for 3 weeks to provide an estimate! When I picked up my car it had damage on the front window, they broke my windshield wiper fluid hose (just like they did to one of the other person on Yelp) and they don't respond to calls. They tried to collect my deductible when my car was there for an estimate only and they hadn't done any repairs. DO NOT LEAVE YOUR CAR THERE! Read the other reviews on Yelp of customers cars being damaged while at their shop. read more

Came in for an estimate. I was told they would email me a copy that afternoon. It took a week and five calls to get the estimate. Estimate was $15,000 for a door that got hit (see pictures). Ended up getting it fixed somewhere else for $3,000. read more

See all

I really liked Amato's at first. But be sure to check your itemized bill. $50 to put my Tesla in service mode--I could have done it in 5 seconds myself in the parking lot. $75 to delete my data from the car--again, if I cared, I could have done it in 5 seconds in the parking lot. $350 to drain the battery before total loss transport (by GEICO, not even by them)--they said this was Tesla policy, but I looked it up: that's only necessary with specific battery damage that my car didn't have. read more

Great place to get your car repaired with insurance. Renee kept me up to date with the schedule. You can even leave your enterprise rental there when you pick up your car. read more

We had our Audi repaired here last year and they held the car hostage for TWO MONTHS! They kept telling us that they were waiting for a specific piece to come in. They stopped answering our calls and eventually we had to just go in to ask about our car. Once we got the car back, we found out that somehow even though they were only working on front panel, they somehow severed the windshield washer fluid line and we had to take the car to the dealership to get it fixed. read more

Not like it use to be, sadly this shop is "REALLY" bad, from being a San Diego trade mark to be one more Fix, I'm going somewhere else next time, definitely not recommended, do you homework and go some where else. Avoid this place. Poor communication, and poor quality work. read more

I came in for a quote on a dent removal for my Audi. I was Promised a quote via email but never received one. I followed up with Abigail? Via email and still no response. read more

Excellent work, coordinated with insurance for us and renegotiated the estimate when more work was needed.

I requested a quote to get a paint touch up on my car's spare tire. I called and they instructed me to send in pictures which I did the same day. I called four separate times over the course of 2 weeks to follow up to which they said they needed to send the pictures to the estimator and that I would hear back by end of business that day. I never heard back from them that day despite being told I would. I eventually received the quote and it was for a brand new tire cover + labor to paint it. I had asked for a quote to touch up the paint on the existing tire cover. I responded and asked this question once I received the quote and never heard back. Pretty bizarre experience when I am trying to give them business. read more

Amazing work and the staff is friendly. Brenda, the front office lead is amazing. Communication is very good.

Avoid this place. Poor communication, service and quality of repairs - my car was better and safer before coming here and I would question the validity of their Tesla certification I went in for repairs on rear quarter panel, wheel and bumper. The 3.5wk repair took 5wks bc they accidentally broke my rear pano window and had to replace and retint (all of which I doubt they would've told me if I didn't keep asking AND I still have yet to get the paperwork + warranty details on). Anyways, after getting my car back, I had to drive back right away bc I noticed a loose panel in the car while driving. While replacing that panel, I noticed another loose panel, then another, etc - at least 3 panels ended up needing to be replaced bc the clips were all broken and the panels didn't sit right, fell off completely, and/or posed a safety hazard bc it was over an airbag. I ended up leaving after 4+hrs bc I was hungry and exhausted, but sincerely concerned about the safety of the car bc I have babies. Fast forward, I find so many other issues, from a loose door hinge, to loose wires, poorly installed molding, poorly installed tint, pinholes in the paint, exposed metal surfaces, scratched trim, airleak, etc I won't list everything, but let's just say I can't believe they're a Tesla certified shop. I've reached out to them with my concerns, and even after claiming to have the parts, they just left me waiting 3+wks and counting. I may have to just go back to my insurance to fix their mess. SMH read more

Best auto shop in San Diego! The technicians at this location. Do an amazing job will recommend to anyone in San Diego

This is the 2nd car I had auto body work done at Amato's. Their customer service and communication throughout the process was painless! Th ey do stellar work! My previous Audi A5 and my 2020 Honda Civic turned out looking brand new! Highly recommend Amato's Auto Body! read more

Amato's Auto Body - 2020 Honda Civic. The door fix is absolutely flawless with a beautiful wax detail. - Body Shops Near Me - San Diego, California

Went for an estimate on my car. I thought the damage would be about 1500-2500$. They took pictures of the car. Never touched or examined it closely. Sent me an email with an estimate for $6400. I took same car to another auto body repair and they gave me an estimate for $1750. When I explained I had an estimate from Amatos they looked at the car again. They were stumped as to why such a large over priced estimate was given to me. I had the $1750 estimate work done and was back driving in 5 days. Car looks amazing. Amatos wanted to keep the car for 3 weeks. It was scratches on a hood with no dents. Won't go back to Amatos. Encourage others to trust their gut on an estimate. If it seems too high it is too high. Go elsewhere. And when I questioned it they blew me off. read more

It's clear that this place is undergoing growing pains since Paul A. sold the business. I have taken my Merc E550 twice to them within the last 6 months due to two separate unrelated incidents that required the entire aluminum hood be replaced. The first experience with the service advisor was terrible: impossible to get a hold of, would not return calls, car was not ready when promised, leaving me to take extra trips up to Sorrento Valley from downtown, only to drive home empty handed. Things that could be easily remedied with a simple phone call. During the first pick-up, the hood was installed incorrectly, leaving an uneven gap. During the second pick-up date, the front bumper was scratched by another car in their lot, requiring the entire bumper be repainted, but they did make it right, with me just having to accept an additional delay. The second experience with service advisor Zane was absolutely fantastic! He kept me in the loop every step of the way, going above and beyond expectations. Installation was spot on. Overall, I've taken 3 cars to Amato's four times within the last 2 years, and one thing is clear: the quality of the repairs is absolutely perfect. They are expensive and do take longer than most shops but if you have the patience and time, I would not recommend any other place in San Diego. read more

I inquired about some custom work on my late model Porsche and they exceeded my expectations. Attention to detail and the work has enhanced the car. read more

Amato's Auto Body - Porsche - Body Shops Near Me - San Diego, California

I'll not take my car next time to this place. I should have paid attention to all of google reviews about this place! They don't behave professionally. They give you appointment, when you arrive, they ask you to come back next day! They have a very long delay ( wait time) to complete the work. I took my car there for a small repair, after 4 weeks and multiple times contacting them, went to get it. My car had a new damage in their shop. I was shocked ! They denied it. Although they got a big fat check from my insurance they were asking me personally to pay for the small damage that happened in their shop! They are very pricey. Save your time and money and don't take your car there! read more

We dropped our Lucid Air off at Amato's on April 22, 2025 for a tail light replacement which had a crack in it. We were told it would take 48 hours only because the light had been ordered and had arrived. The initial quote was $4490.51 There was no body damage. The work was completed and we picked up the car on May 19, 2025. That's almost a month later. The final bill for the tail light replacement was $8975.14. The price of the tail light assembly from Lucid Motors was $3200. We were told that they broke a part during disassembly which required more time in the shop and painting. $475.00 for the paint. Not the labor. They charged everything to our insurance company. The car was nicely washed. read more

Wow! Amazing work and service.. if you have a Tesla this place will do such great work that it will look and run like brand new.. Every time we need work everyone is so helpful and kind. read more

Amato's Auto Body - Getting the Tesla back .. - Body Shops Near Me - San Diego, California

See all

Had my EQS repaired at Amatos. Staffs (Brenda & Jesse) were cordial and gave me all the updates I needed to get things moving and complete. Especially for high end cars, I strongly recommend Amatos! Also they are helpful with insurance claims as well! read more

Not even a week after I picked up my Tesla Model 3, I experienced a hit-and-run while my Sentry Mode was disabled. The damage wasn't major (see pics below), but it was still incredibly disheartening to have my brand new car damaged so soon and at no fault of my own. I was referred to Amato's by a Tesla customer service rep who said they were one of the few auto shops in my area that was certified to work on Tesla vehicles. I gave them a call right away and from my first phone interaction, I knew this company was different--in a good way. I explained my situation to the female agent over the phone and she was so empathetic and really took the time to get all the necessary information to set up the earliest available appointment. On the day of my appointment, a gentleman resembling Jude Law assisted me. He took my car to the back and after no more than 20 minutes had passed, returned it as good as new! I was shocked. It was such a short encounter I had with them, but the most pleasant one. If I were to ever experience another accident (*knock on wood* that I don't), I know exactly who to trust my car with. read more

Amato's Auto Body - Before - Body Shops Near Me - San Diego, California

See all

great customer service ! sent in images to them and got a response back quick with an idea for repair. Very helpful!

Jesse helped me with any questions I had throughout the entire process without all the mumbo jumbo and extra fees. He was clear and deliberate in our conversations and helped me ultimately make the right decision for myself. read more

YOU KNOW A COMPANY HAS GOTTEN TOO BIG WHEN: They forget their decades long customers They break every promise they make during intake They lie multiple times in a single conversation They follow up their misrepresentations via text They lie in group calls, forgetting they're in group calls They completely flake on appointments They flake on appointments and then lie about flaking Their phone introduction is, "we're busy" (yes literally) They are "so busy", they insult long-term clients They're so inconsiderate, long-term clients vow never to return. read more

Amato's does great work; they are a boutique auto body shop that spares no expense to get your car's body back to factory standards. Unfortunately, they are criminally slow, and their administration doesn't communicate well. I've had my Tesla M3 in twice, but I'll seek others in the future. The first time I needed body work on my Tesla, Amato's was the only shop in Yelp with good Tesla reviews, and Tesla didn't show any approved shops south of Orange County. As an amature autobody guy in my youth, I thought that they would pound out the dents, add filler, tape around the windows, paint, and call it a day. No, no, no, that's not the way they do it there. They ordered all new body parts, and removed every - single - part - that paint overspray could touch. The result was a flawless job; though it took four weeks to achieve it. Thank goodness that insurance covered it, because it cost a small fortune. The second time I took my Tesla to Amato's I noticed that there were a few Tesla approved shops. I wasn't thrilled about taking it to Amato's because it took so long the first time and they weren't very good at keeping me informed. However, the damage was minor and they reported that they had all the parts in stock. How long could it take? It took them six weeks. Six weeks of driving my expensive ICE car. Then, I had to take it back in because they didn't repair everything. While Amato's does great work, they require too much of my time, they are very expensive, and compared to other body shops I've dealt with, they don't communicate effectively. I'll go elsewhere next time (though I hope there isn't a next time!). read more

I live downtown and picked Amato over one of their downtown competitors which was my insurance chosen shop. I could not have been happier with the results. Zane provided excellent service and always returned my calls promptly. Also unlike the competition, there was no unrealistic push to make a decision. I was able to schedule Enterprise Mira Mesa and they picked me up and upon returning with my rental to pick up my car, Amato arranged to have the car dropped off. Amato is also within a 5 min. walk of the Coaster Sorrento train station which can be convenient if you don't have a rental/ride. read more

They best body repair shop in town. The way my car was rebuilt was amazing. It almost looks better then new. Even with following all COVID protocols the customer service was excellent read more

I'm pretty thrilled with Amato's repair of our Model X back bumper repair, as well as the repair of our Model 3 front bumper repair (NOT involved in the same accident!) Renee Sanchez was wonderful from the start to finish of the entire repair process. I appreciated Amato going through the other party's insurance for me. There was also a seamless process in getting the Enterprise car rental. My cars also required a wrap, which they assisted with as well - when I got my cars back, they looked better than new! All in all, I am very happy with the excellent work that Amato's has done on both my Teslas, and the communication throughout was superb. I would always recommend any Tesla body work to be performed at Amato's. read more

I took in my Porsche Cayenne for body work and they were very efficient and repaired the vehicle to perfection. They worked with the insurance company and so I had really nothing to do with the payments. They also got my car ready faster than anticipated so I could have the vehicle for the long July 4 holiday weekend. We also used Amato's Auto Body a couple years ago on our 911 and also had great service. Thank you so much. read more

Excellent auto repair service, efficient communication, top notch customer service , I was beyond impressed by 2023 Audi FLASH is back to his handsome self thanks to Amatos I would highly recommend Amatos for any vehicle body work read more

Very prompt and professional. I ended up bumping the rear of my 2019 model3 into a trailer behind me. I took my car to amato's for repair. Amatos's was very professional about it. They worked with my insurance company in a timely manner to give me a quote on the repairs. I was amazed at the co-ordination between my insurance company and Amato's. I did not have to play middleman. In the end, my insurance company agreed to pay for repairs as suggested by Amatos! Thanks a lot guys! read more

Amato's Auto Body - Body Shops Near Me - San Diego, California

Excellent experience here! I looked all over the county for someone who could repair some damage on my Type R and nobody was up for the challenge. Then I met Zane who was very reassuring and I felt my car was in good hands. 3 weeks later I get it back and they have exceeded my expectations. They're very good at what they do. Everything will look brand new! Thank you so much I'm so happy to have my car back!! read more

We had rear damaged to our New Mercedes Benz SUV, Amato's auto shop did an amazing job repairing the damage, SUV looks new again. Great customer service . They made the process easy dealing withe insurance company as well. Emil read more

We have had our Tesla Model-S serviced for moderate collision repairs at Amato's Auto Body, the first in 2019 and the last in May 2024. They are a great company to work with, professional and dependable! The repairs were done done on time, and the work is high quality. We trust Amato's Auto Body and highly recommend them if you need collision repair. read more

Amato's repaired my daughter's 2019 Porsche Macan and it looks like a new car off the showroom floor!!! We are very pleased! Jim & Vickie Crestani Carlsbad, Ca. read more

I have never written a bad review in my life, but feel obligated to warn people not to bring their car to Amato's. I brought my Audi in on January 2nd, I was told it would take 2-3 weeks to order parts and 2-3 weeks for the repair work. I received no updates or phone calls regarding the parts for my car, I called 6x and emailed with no return call from Jesse. Finally after 6 weeks when I called I was told the parts for my car had arrived and I could book an appointment for another 2 weeks out. When I finally brought my car in I was told after the 1 week I would be able to get an updated time table for how long it would take to fix my vehicle, I never received that information, it took 9 weeks and I would often receive the same update and misleading information regarding the completion of my car. For the last three weeks I received the same update each week that my car was complete only for it to not actually be completed. I called Audi to ask why they would recommend this shop and they told me they no longer recommend this Amato's this is a poorly run shop, communication is completely unprofessional, no accountability, absolutely horrific experience. read more

Recently got into a fender bender and was recommended Amatos Auto Body from a friend. I usually let my boyfriend deal with anything autobody because let's be real I wouldn't have a clue if they added anything extra. Arrived to our appointment, met with our estimator Jesse. He went through everything with us and explained basically what I was going to pay for and got our estimate within a couple hours! I expected 24 hours but was happy I got it soon so that I can make my decision on how to proceed with my car. Decided to go with them and they did an amazing job fixing my Range Rover! Shout out to Jesse who helped answer any questions and concerns we had in a timely manner! If you're looking for quality work this is the place to go! read more