used to be a big fan of there subs back in the day but recently came back here and the product has go down hill. ordered a chicken parm sub, sub was cold after asking it to be toasted, chicken was crunchy like eating a bone I didnt finish it it was gross. The only saving grace was the bread, it's made in house. just really disappointing used to be a staple in the Victor area. Hope the place improves because I used to love coming here. read more

The woman that works here Michelle is amazing, Very Friendly just a great person. I will be back because of Michelle. The older woman did get her name that made my sub was not Friendly at all did not even look at me when asking what I wanted on my sub. It was like I was bothering her. read more

Talk about a good sandwich!! Amiel's knows how to perfect their cuts, everything is such high quality, the staff are friendly when you walk up to the counter to make your sub and the shop itself has a really cool vintage 50's vibe inside. The food here is addicting, you just might find yourself coming here every day!! read more

See all

horrible service, purchased jumbo sub when paying used touch to pay. said I hit a 5 dollar tip when I didn't ,asked for a refund. they said they didn't know how.got a total refund of the whole order. I was done being told I made the mistake wont be going to the business anymore lucky I saw the total purchase at the last second. must happen all the time, think they would fix this but probably not cause it goes to their favor shady business watch out ! read more

A great local alternative to the big national chains! The rolls are fresh and you have the option of having them lightly buttered and toasted (which you should totally do.) Roast beef is fresh sliced for each sub and the meat, while not as plentiful as some smaller local stores, is more generous than the big chains. Toppings are fresh and generous. I do wish that they had banana peppers however. The store is clean, efficient and pleasantly decorated but nothing really special... And doesn't need to be. I'm a big believer in supporting local and Amiel's makes that easy to do when I'm looking for a quick sandwich or sub. Give them a try. They might not knock your socks off but they will provide a fast and tasty lunch that exceeds taste and value of the national chains. read more

Torn between a 3-star vs a 4-star . I work nearby Amiel's- so it's a convenient location for a decent sub. I do like their toasted sub rolls and I used to REALLY love their roast beef- but I have to say the last couple of times I've gone over the last two or three months the roast beef has been dry and hard to eat (asking myself, why am I still going here??). BUT, I'm keeping hopeful it's just a fluke and will get better... read more

A great favorite spot in Rochester NY! Love their food, good service and clean locations. Their food is always great consistent. If you get lucky and see the owner that is a huge plus. He makes your day!!! read more

Should be re-inspected, because I recently got food poisoning from here. One of my go-to places, shame to see it go downhill. Workers just get slower and slower, it's almost like they've never worked in food service beofre- but they have, it's always the same people here. read more

Service was questionable. It was slow and people were not very friendly. A person we believe to he the owner was speaking loudly and was very distracting during the entire time we were ordering as well as eating. The food was ok but the service and atmosphere can be worked on. The prices for the cookies and drinks could also be put up on the wall not just the names. The demeanor of the staff made us uncomfortable and I do not see us returning to this restaurant. read more

Best sub I've ever had. Service was friendly, funny and passionate about just being there. Fresh ingredients & fresh baked bread.

Always a great experience and customer service at Amiel's! Love their tuna and Italian subs and the fact that we are always greeted with a smile makes it that much better. read more

Amiel's has my favorite subs, so when I was driving by here, I had to stop in. I had only been to this location once before, and it was years ago. I came here around 8pm, and there were two people making subs, and one person in front of me. The one girl took my order pretty fast, and she made my sub. The other girl finished with her customer, and it was clear that she could not wait for the other employee to finish my sub so that they could have a conversation. It would not have been a huge deal, but then when I went to cash out, the cashier was taking a phone order. I waited at least 5 minutes for her to get off the phone, which was just weird because I was the only customer in the place at that time. Neither of the other girls offered to take the order or to cash me out, or to help in any way. While I was waiting, I was looking around, and this place is really not being taken care of. The ceiling is this awful shade of yellow, and parts of it look like they're ready to fall off. And behind one of the counters is basically just a junk room of stuff; wet floor signs, extra chairs, boxes, etc. Customers can clearly see it, so they really should put that stuff in a closet or some place that it can't be seen. I love their subs, and the sub was good, but this place is in desperate need of some tlc. It wouldn't surprise me at all if I hear that this location closes when their lease is up. It looks like no one has taken care of it for a long time. read more

Amiel's - Sandwiches Near Me - Victor, New York

See all

Food was ok, nothing special. we got the Chick-a-miel. thought it would be sliced chicken but it was chunks that tasted like canned chicken. Buns were just white bread, also nothing special. Won't be back. read more

See all

Amiel's rules. The bread & chicken salad are so dang good and I always have to stop when I'm in Victor... delish! Add the sweet peppers! read more

Amiel's - Chicken salad - Sandwiches Near Me - Victor, New York

I have been a fan of Amiel's for years. I stopped into the Victor location to pick up a chic-a-meal. If you don't know, it's a hot sub and the roll is toasted. It includes chopped up chicken breast and whatever toppings you want. I always get cheddar sauce and bbq. They always have soups available as well as chips. Some of my other favorites are the meatball and the tuna subs. Their roast beef is very good, high quality, and sliced fresh to order. Beware that it's usually very rare. Amiel's is always awesome read more

Recently stopped at Amiel's to pick up a sub. Big mistake! The person that waited on us clearly didn't want to be there or make our sub. Never exchanged words other than what was necessary. Got a roast beef out of the refrigerator unwrapped that did not look good, cut it with a knife that was laying out unwashed, used a meat slicer that only God knows when it was last cleaned! There was literally almost no meat on the sub- see photo. Also minimal tomatoes and lettuce. The restaurant was filthy. Floors have not been mopped in a long time. Tables not cleaned off. I didn't take one bite of that sub! Wish I'd never stopped there. Do yourself a favor and go to DiBella's or Wegmans. read more

Amiel's - One of their featured subs - disgusting all the way around - Sandwiches Near Me - Victor, New York

See all

I love the beef a miel! It's always delicious and fresh. That said while we were eating in we had ordered fountain pops. We then heard a customer complain about moldy ice in the machine. After that the manager put an out of order sign on the machine. At that point I took it upon myself to return to the front with the two cups of pop and ask for bottles of pop instead. They exchanged them with no problem. I just wish they had taken the initiative since we had ordered and got out pops minutes before it was listed out of order. read more

Amiel's - Beef-a-Miel - Sandwiches Near Me - Victor, New York

First of all, I lovee the old school interior. Feels so nostalgic and comforting I can't believe it took me so long to find this place after living in Rochester for most of my life. My favorite subs for sure read more

Amiel's - the interior of a restaurant - Sandwiches Near Me - Victor, New York

I have just recently visited Amiels since I have one near my house. I always liked their subs but hadn't had one since I moved back to the area. I have, again, found that I still love their subs! I never remember to take pictures Anyway, I really like their tuna and today I'm trying Bernies Favorite who've is smoked Turkey and roast beef. They come on the freshest yummy rolls that they also sell. I will continue to come to this one. The staff is great. There currently aren't tables to sit at because of Covid. They are all ribboned off. I recommend them read more

See all

This was always my favorite sub shop when I lived in Rochester and I always make sure to stop here when I'm in town visiting family. I came today with my daughter and enjoyed the same super fresh consistency that Amiel's has had for decades. Their rolls are sooo good! Thanks Amiel's for continuing to be awesome! read more

Ordered the biggest size sub there was. Barely any meat or toppings put on the bread. Bread was mediocre because it had no flavor. It was at least soft. The meat tasted like it had been sitting for a very long time. Years ago I used to love Amiels's. Now we will never go here again. The prices were outrageous & the customer service was ok. I will happily go spend more money somewhere for a way better experience and sub. read more

I googled sub shops nearby ( Victor ) and decided to order here after checking reviews . I usually travel to Wegmans for my subs but decided to try something closer to home. I ordered a jumbo Bernies Favorite( smokehouse turkey/roast beef) on sesame roll to split with the wife and I ( what we usually do with a wegmans sub) . Toppings were limited we went with onions and sweet peppers provolone . Since its called a jumbo I figured it would be enough to share between 2 of us. My expectations of something similar to Wegmans size or Calabresellas ( my fave but not nearby) size subs. Sub was delicious. Sesame bread was fresh . Everything was so good. The only downside for me was not enough meat to even call it a sub .Its a bread sandwhich. The 1st pic down below . If you prefer more bread Amiels subs will work just fine for you . For me I'd prefer to have a regular meat portion and topping variety . So 2 out 5 stars. ****There is an extra meat option for $2.00*** . I get it , its $2 but im not paying an upcharge for it to be a normal size sub. This might be my last and only review for Amiels. Im not sure if all subs from Amiels look like the one I got today or someone forgot the rest of my meat . No second chance on a 1st impression . read more

Amiel's - Actual photo of my sub from Amiels ( jumbo sub ) - Sandwiches Near Me - Victor, New York

See all

Very surprised to find so many mediocre reviews, but on the other hand, also many happy customers. Not living near Victor, I'm obviously not a regular, but Amiel's has been a sure lunch stop once or twice a year for many years, whenever we are in the Eastview Mall area. I love their subs. The rolls are hearty and crunchy, giving your jaw a workout. Perfect! The seeded variety is just loaded with sesames. I never knew about the "lightly toasted and buttered" option until just now reading these reviews. The staff never, ever asked, but I won't take away a star for that disservice. The meats on my favorite Italian Assorted always fresh and the cappicola never fatty. I love the finely shredded lettuce. Their special oil is flavorful. Like DiBellas and Wegmans, they offer 3 sizes: 7, 9 and 14 inches, but not as wide. Service is always efficient and friendly. Reading some of the positive reviews, my next choice will definitely be one of their chicken subs, as they seem to be a unique favorite of many. I'm sure they will be a favorite of mine also. read more

The best tuna sub on the planet. It is the only thing that I get when I go there. I have been eating Amiel's tuna subs for at least 20 tears, probably more. They use white albacore tuna all the time and are always exactly the same. read more

Amiel's - The worst Amiel's tuna sub that I ever had, It was not constructed even close to what it should have been, The bread was not cut through, - Sandwiches Near Me - Victor, New York

Subs are absolutely delicious. Amiel's Club is phenomenal, and it will fill you up for sure. Only issue is that the staff is pretty stingy with the ingredients. Watching the employees delicately and precisely put tiny slivers of meat on your sandwich one at a time like they are painting the Sistine Chapel can get kind of ridiculous to watch. It's a sandwich, not an art project. It's supposed to be messy. Slap the meat on there and get on with it. read more

I'm so happy to have re-discovered Amiels. Is it just me, or have they gotten better over the years? Love their buttered & toasted rolls. Very tasty alternative to Subway's bland subs and DiBella's. Don't get me wrong, I love DiBella's, but Amiels subs are tastier. read more

Amiel's - Get the buttered & toasted roll! - Sandwiches Near Me - Victor, New York

Formerly one of my favorite sub shops the quality has declined drastically. Roast beef dry. Portions (amount of meat on sub) are poor - 4 slices of ham , 4 slices of turkey and 2 slices (4 halves) of provolone is not worth $10... sad. read more

Amiel's - Sandwiches Near Me - Victor, New York

See all

It's been a long time since I've had regular access to this place. I stopped in recently for lunch and it hasn't changed much in the last decade, menu and overall place looks exactly the same. The subs are good, but I'm not sure that they are any better than other big local competitor. The service is pretty fast and they churned through the lunch line very quickly. Good option for a quick lunch spot if you don't have time to sit down at the other restaurants in the area. read more

Eaten here numerous times for lunch and the bread and meat can be very delicious. There are days the roast beef can be a little dry, but if you ask for rare roast beef, they usually oblige and find you something better. Sub sizes are filling and fairly priced with multiple chip and drink options. Their chocolate chip cookies are one of my favorites. Amiels is a clean and friendly environment and they do a good job during busy lunch rushes read more

Get ready to pay huge money for an empty roll, air sandwich. I wanted a cold roast beef sub with LTO and mayo, light salt and heavy pepper. No sweet peppers here kids. Salt and pepper is mixed, WRONG. The roast beef was fresh out of the oven and my sandwich was a cooked mess. At $6.39 - $9.79 you want more than 6 thin pieces of roast beef for the middle range sub. Try chilling it before cooking my toppings to a wilted mess as well as my mayo in to a runny slop. It cost $20 for two 9" subs and drinks. No, never again. Not unless I am eating at Applebee's or TGI Friday's. 50's music is too loud to talk over. The dirt shows through in the ceiling vents, behind napkin dispensers caked in years of food and dust. Not the way I would like to have wasted my money. read more

See all

they have ok food but they are scamming people they will charge you twice for your food and then when you tell them after 2 day's trying to find the manager she said she refunded the money but never did read more

I moved from DC to Rochester. Always missed the great Italian subs I would get there. My son bought me an Italian sub last week and it took me back to the BEST ITALIAN SUB I HAVE HAD. Great place to get an original Italian sub. Amy K read more

Okay prices are not wonderful but not horrible. Ordered a large 9 inch Italian assorted sub. 4 different meats at 3 pieces each. Not anywhere enough meat for a $7.39 sub. Very limited in cheese selection and only lettuce, tomato, onion and hot peppers as toppings. The sub once rolled into the paper was very thin and very messy to eat. Spent $19 for 2 subs and one fountain drink. Restaurant itself was dingy but decorated in a 50s/60s style motif. Was not real happy with the back of house visible to customers. With that you need to be extra clean and on top of all food prep areas. It wasn't. Meat was sitting on the deli slicer for who knows how long. Slicer wasn't cleaned after each use. Meat bits and pieces were all over the slicer table. Employees handled cooked meat out of oven with parchment paper used to wrap subs instead if tongs or something else. My friend brought me here special as he enjoyed this place previously. Needless to say this visit didn't live up to previous ones. When you can spend $7.99 for a supermarket sub and get double amounts of meat and toppings this place isn't worth its price read more

This place sucks. Used to be the best subs IMO. I have alway notice the roll are either fresh out of the oven soft, or little chewy. Today sub roll was so hard that if not for my hunger it would been trashed. There are skimpy on the meat and cheese now to the point you cant tell if there was any on the sub by taste. The one making my sub had no personality at all. Back to wegmans for subs. read more

I consider this to be one of the better sub shop in the Rochester area. Ingredients are so so compared to others. We mainly come here due to the fresh butter toasted rolls (which are delicious), and my daughter loves the hot peppers here. Service is so-so. The manager, who sometimes makes subs isn't very friendly and there is an older lady making subs at the slowest possible pace. In one instance, she sliced by sub roll with a knife that had tuna all over it. I asked for another roll and a clean knife and she obliged. I still come here often and always hope to get one of the friendlier employees. read more

Amiel's is my favorite sandwich shop in Victor. It's 5 minutes from my office, in Cobblestone Court, across from Eastview Mall. I look for several things in a sub shop, quality of roll, meats, and toppings, consistency, and cleanliness. Amiel's nails it nearly every time, and I have eaten there easily 30 times in the last few years. They bake their rolls fresh on site daily, and that aroma is part of the Amiel's experience. The rolls are a perfect shiny brown outside with chewy white goodness inside. However, lately I have eschewed the wonderful rolls for a wrap to save carbs and cals. Incidentally, they have a lovely toaster conveyor mechanism to warm your roll or wrap...(note: wraps are father sam's, not home made)...if you want to get really crazy, you can even have them butter it. That is sweet if you dont mind the extra calories, and really makes for a decadent sub. I order the exact same thing every visit, small cajun chick-amiel on a wheat wrap. They warm a 12 inch wheat wrap and then place a mound of shredded lettuce, thinly sliced onion , tomato, and a nice 3.5 ounce portion of poached, lightly seasoned chicken breast in the center. Then a healthy dose of their spicy mustard, sliced hot cherry peppers and a shake of their red cajun seasoning. This is a really delicious combination, and very low calorie, about 300, and guaranteed to leave you satisfied...or you could get one of their delicious oatmeal raisin, peanut butter, or chocolate chunk cookies to go with it...not gonna lie, that's usually part of the ritual :-). I love their spicy mustard, it has a wicked shocker horseradish burn that will defoliate your nasal hair if you go too heavy, so be warned. Despite high turnover, they almost always take the extra step of removing the stems and tops from the cherry peppers. It's an awful sensation to bite into when those are left on, so I appreciate their attention to detail. And the tomatoes are always nice, never hard or green, even in January. Dibellas gets most of the love in the ROC, but these guys have quietly been making great sandwiches for a long time, and deserve to be mentioned among the better sub shops in town. Their soups are also great. The white chicken chili is nicely spiced and is loaded with chicken. In summary, an affordable, clean sub shop that serves up great quality food. Even at peak lunch hour, there are enough staff to keep the wait time down to usually less than 5 minutes. read more

Amiel's - Cajun chick-amiel: poached chicken breast, LTO, hot cherry peppers, spicy mustard, cajun seasoning on wheat wrap. Spicy good! - Sandwiches Near Me - Victor, New York

Excellent sandwich shop. Great selection, but the best on the menu is the roast beef sandwich with horseradish. Also, even though it's not great health-wise, I definitely recommend having them butter and toast the roll, absolutely delicious. The decor is a throwback to old fashion diners but you order at the counter, pay, then sit so you don't have to wait for servers to come around. Prices are also very reasonable. read more

Good freakin' sandwiches. One of the few things that ended up as good as the town's residents claimed. YUMMMY. Large selection of sandwich options, lots of seating, and reasonable prices. You order at the counter, they make it, and you go to the register to pay. read more

By far my fav sub shop. Bread is incredibly soft. Even the day old bread is still soft! And yes they do sell day old bread! I love their smoked turkey. Thinly sliced and moist. Condiment selection is good. I wish they had different types of cheese though. read more

Tuna sub. 40% tuna, 60% mayo = 100% gross. I got the sub cause I was starving. I ate half and threw the other half away. I understand that the tuna is probably more expensive than the mayo .. but - jeezus! If you can squeeze it out of a tube .. its not really tuna is it?! Blech! Never again.. read more