I came in with my family for some delicious food; that is exactly what we got! The inside of the restaurant is nicely decorated with beautiful murals which I enjoyed. The staff here was also nice and very helpful with the menu. I ordered the three tacos for $15. I got the carne asada, which is steak, avocado salsa, pico, and cotija cheese. Then I got two of the $1 upgrade tacos, which were the citrus shrimp taco, which is citrus shrimp, cabbage, pico, crema, and then the flyin' Hawaiian, which is huli chicken, pineapple salsa, scallion, and soy glaze. These tacos were spectacular! I loved every single one of them, and they are some of the best tacos I've had in Rochester. The chips and salsa that came with the tacos were also pretty good. For my drink, I ordered some pretty good horchata. My mom got the chimi carnitas burrito, and it was massive! It is a fried burrito, choice of carne asada, chili beef or carnitas, filled w/ pinto beans, Mexican cheese served w/ lettuce, avocado salsa, pico, crema I do have to say the entrance to the restaurant is extremely inaccessible on top of a hill with stairs, so I had to take off a star for that. read more

See all

Love coming here for the 3 tacos for $15. I always get the carne asada tacos and the elote bowl. The tacos come with chips and I love dipping them in the elote which is so flavorful. The tacos are cooked to perfection and the meat is so juicy and tender. Service is great as your food comes out very fast. After you pay at the counter, you get a buzzer which lets you know when your food is ready. We sat outside this weekend where there's ample seating available, and the weather was perfect. read more

See all

Ordered take out on their web site which was very easy. When I got there the place was busy. The staff was very helpful and pleasant. We had the soul man and the veggie burrito. read more

The food was delicious. While it is a bit pricier than other locations, the food taste great and the portions are very large. The service is great, the person taking my order let me sample the al pastor to see if I liked it and was very accommodating to the modifications I made to my bowl. The ambiance was laid back and relaxing. The food came out very quick. read more

Old Pueblo Grill - Becca bowl with chicken and Al pastor - Mexican Near Me - Victor, New York

A bit of organized chaos to pick up an online order. If their food wasn't so good we might reconsider ordering from them. Tacos are amazing! Elote salad is dive-in delicious. Fun ambiance if you dine in- order at counter and get a number when your order is ready. No alcohol - soft drinks only read more

Old Pueblo Grill - the counter and menus - Mexican Near Me - Victor, New York

See all

We were greeted at the counter by Rebecca. She was friendly, helpful and patient while we decided what to order. The menu has lots of options and it took a few minutes for us to decide. They also have a nice selection of drinks. We decided on tacos. The tacos were delicious and the chips and salsa (traditional and green mild) were good too. The restaurant was clean with a cool mural on the wall. I am glad that my wife suggested this restaurant for lunch. We will be back. read more

Old Pueblo Grill - 3 Tacos - Mexican Near Me - Victor, New York

See all

The service is awesome, the burritos are sooooooooo good: and the home made salsa is spicy is such a great way!!! We will be back

I had food from the Victor location. Becca bowl with chicken .. so yummy. Lots of chicken and overall best food, great value, so delicious!!! My questions were answered about getting GF , they still use a dedicated fryer for chips so that was great to hear Whenever back in area would go there again! Wish they were in Dayton OH. read more

We have never been to the Rochester location but have always wanted to. When we saw that Victor had a location, we were eager to stop in. Located across from Eastview Mall, behind prior North Face location. Modern indoor décor, music was a bit louder than I would like but very bright and colorful aesthetic. Indoor and outdoor seating options. Street parking available in the front of the location, which was simple. Multiple options on the menu with fish, shrimp, pork, chicken, and beef as well as some vegetarian options. Portions are large and easily shared. I had a variety of tacos served with chips and salsa. The hot salsa was hotter than I expected, so if you like more of medium salsa I would get the milder one. The tacos were all very flavorful, chips were fresh. Fountain soda available, no alcohol on the menu (that I saw). They have take-out available as well. Highly recommend checking out the menu and stopping in or getting take-out. read more

Old Pueblo Grill - 3 Tacos and Chips, Excellent! - Mexican Near Me - Victor, New York

While shopping at The North Face, an employee recommended this place. I'm glad he did. Service was great and the elote bowl & the carne asada tacos did not disappoint. They were so flavorful. The Cali Swag burrito on the other hand was a bit of a disappointment. I would have preferred my burrito with less fries and more meat. Other than that, if your looking for some decent tacos this place is it. I will definitely be back. read more

See all

We ordered this for delivery for the first time, and I could tell by the pictures it was going to be good. But OMG this place is amazing. Despite the 17 mins drive to our house, the food held up amazing. Everything was so flavorful and delicious. Even the tortilla chips were out of this world. We ordered the Al pastor, chili Colorado, and carne asada tacos, the bird gang burrito, taquitos, and beans. Everything blew me away. I wish I could have taken a picture to share but we started gobbling everything up immediately. Can't believe I haven't been here or ordered from here before. We will definitely be ordering again! read more

There's a reason why the New Pueblo Grill didn't work out, it's because the Old Pueblo Grill is grilling up instant classics. I know this might sound confusing because the Old Pueblo Grill is relatively new, but I guess everything in life is relative. Regardless this is a five star place, although I might be too strong for the plastic forks. The burrito I got was huge so I decided to go knife and fork for it. About half way or maybe two thirds of the way through, I broke my fork. Not a knock on the restaurant, just want people to know. At about 7:10 it seemed like the music volume was turned up slightly and it got a more rock and roll vibe. At the end of the day this is a place you want to be. read more

I was pleasantly surprised by the bold yet balanced flavors in the Elote Bowl. Our Carnitas Quesadilla was also delicious. The pork was moist and had the slightest but perfect amount of crunch and chew. I will definitely go back because there are more menu items I need to try. Some people may disagree, but my 3 star rating would be higher if the place was more comfortable and pleasant to eat in. While there's some colorful decorations, overall the high warehouse ceiling along with the hard metal chairs scraping on bare concrete floors create unpleasant cavernous sounds. I feel like they are going for eat and leave please. There's some outside dining available. Overall, really good food but not a great place if you want to relax and have a conversation. read more

See all

No gluten free! So sad ! No longer designated fryer for gluten free chips! So no nachos! Makes you wonder if celiac safe place anymore! read more

We eat at Old Pueblo Grill weekly -- can't recommend it enough! Tons of great menu options, consistently delicious food, and awesome, friendly staff. read more

Old Pueblo Grill - Veggie Taco - Mexican Near Me - Victor, New York

The food was incredible and the service was top-notch highly recommend and we will be coming back to this place. I'm also sorry I didn't take any pictures but believe me the nachos with the chicken was incredible and my three tacos were awesome. read more

Love that Becca bowl! Service is quite fast even when busy which is most nights. Has Mexican feel . Order at the counter and pickup when ready. read more

Ordered some nachos and. They were piled high with list of toppings. Delicious as well. I wasn't a fan of the elite dip, I prefer the con itself. read more

I had the bang bang shrimp tacos very good. The service is great. We accidentally ordered the wrong meal and they replaced it for free. Quickly becoming a local favorite. read more

My husband and I entered Old Pueblo Grill in Victor expecting to be seated and served. Discovering you order at the counter was disappointing. The wall menu is too tiny to read. We were glad to find the printed version. Beverages were self serve, The angle of the sun was such that most patrons akwardly shifted seats and tables to find a spot where they were not blinded, Despite the intense sun, the dining room was unpleasantly cool. Not one table was bussed during the entire hour we were there. Patrons needed to wipe down tables and chairs with napkins, step around food dropped on the floor. The space lacks attention to sound absorbtion - cinder block walls, metal chairs, high ceilings with exposed HVAC. The noise level left us uncomfortably shouting to communicate above the din. We were anxious to leave. Overall a noisey, fast food experience with $3 drinks and $15-$18 meals. The redeeming factor for me - delicious food in small enough portions I could eat my entire meal. My husband was disappointed in the flavor impact of his choice. Perhaps one day we will revisit on an off hour when the place has fewer patrons. read more

Old Pueblo Grill - Metal and cinder block walls. - Mexican Near Me - Victor, New York

The food is fabulous. Not much ambiance and it's disappointing there is still no bar.

I just love old Pueblo grill. The quesadilla is always delicious and comes with guacamole, crema and pico--which in my opinion you don't even need. I also love the elote bowl--it is only $6 and huge and so delicious. I tried the Baja fish taco and it also was very good. I am never disappointed when I go to old Pueblo grill and it blows chipotle out of the water for around the same cost. read more

Take out order. Loved the food at old place. Pollo loco chicken sandwich does not compare! Bready huge roll,minimal chicken! So disappointing . Saving feature, drunken sailor fish burrito tremendously delicious and nice portion of fish! Chips and salsas included were also good. Will try again soon! read more

We were on vacation in Rochester and wanted to try a local place for dinner. The staff were very friendly and answered all of our questions about the menu. The restaurant was very vibrant and colorful and the food was delicious. read more

Very good food, the flyin Hawaiian taco is one of the most delicious tacos I've ever tried. The service is great and fast.

Best burritos in the city. Try the Seoul man such a great flavor. We got here just a few min before closing and they didn't complain and said they would make our food still. Solid service. read more