Great pizza spot in Garner. We walked in without a reservation and were seated after about a 15-minute wait -- they even had a comfortable couch for waiting, which was a nice touch. Service was quick and friendly from start to finish. We started with the meatballs and focaccia, and the bread was absolutely to die for. The salad with pears, cherry tomatoes, and vinaigrette was fresh and flavorful. For pizza, we had the buffalo cheese and it was excellent. We also took tiramisu and cannoli to go -- generous portions and all delicious. Good prices, cute atmosphere, and everything we tried was wonderful. Definitely coming back. read more

See all

We tried a few times to order pizza from Amore Mio Pizza in Garner, North Carolina. The first time, the pizza oven wasn't working. The second time, the air conditioning wasn't working. But our third attempt was so worth it because the pizza was excellent! We had very friendly service, the restaurant was very clean and the food was excellent! So glad we kept trying! read more

Amore Mio Pizza - Meat Amore Mio - Pizza Near Me - Garner, North Carolina

1st time here, close to interstate 40, Small and nice, food taste was awesome, we went for the Smoked Pizza and enjoyed it very much.

Cool little spot with unique interior. Blend of 4 person tables and bench lining wall with tables. Service was excellent, explained the menu well and set the expectation which didn't disappoint. Pepperoni rolls was beautiful and tasty. Order Crostata was beautifully presented and flavor blew me away. Don't miss out on this place. read more

Amore Mio Pizza - Pepperoni rolls - Pizza Near Me - Garner, North Carolina

See all

Wonderful little atmosphere. Great food! The apps were amazing, and the pizzas were full of flavor and authenticity.

New to the area and was seeking good local pizza. I think we found it! Fresh Artisan style pizza with tremendous flavor. The order was real easy over the phone and very helpful. The pizzas are closer to personal size, but delicious and reasonably priced. We ordered 4 plus an app for 6 of us and it worked. We got takeout, but the interior was cute. We'll be ordering again soon! read more

See all

First time trying this place and I now have a new pizza place! The hot honey pepperoni pizza and buffalo wings were hot and fresh. The restaurant was clean and the staff were polite. read more

Amore Mio Pizza - Pepperoni & Hot Honey - Pizza Near Me - Garner, North Carolina

See all

My boyfriend and I decided to try this place after reading all of the rave reviews. The pizza is cooked in an Italian oven and it's delicious! We dined in for dinner and each ordered a pie; he got the Hawaiian and I got the Meat Amore - they were both incredible! All of the ingredients were top notch and fresh. The dining area is small, trendy and cozy. Our waitress was very friendly and attentive. We look forward to dining here again. read more

See all

Pizza was so yummy I could've ate it all by myself. Glass was chilled to perfection for my beer. 2 cannoli were large and also perfect OG flavor with mini chocolate chips and a tiramisu was a big piece. Service was attentive and quick read more

Amore Mio Pizza - Ice cold Beer - Pizza Near Me - Garner, North Carolina

See all

Food is amazing! We have been there twice, the first time we got pizzas (which are so flavorful!!). The Margueritta pizza is so simple yet so packed with flavor. The second time we got the buffalo wings ... believe me when I say this, best wings I have had in a really long time. The place is small and intimate, which makes for a nice ambiance. Service - top notch! We got the owner to wait on us both times read more

A nice little locally owned truly Italian restaurant with Italian folks running it. Pizzas come out quickly and with unique ingredient combinations. Salads are fresh and the tiramisu might be the best you will ever have and with a generous portion. read more

Amore Mio Pizza - Beautiful house salad - Pizza Near Me - Garner, North Carolina

See all

The pizzas and the service here are probably the best in the Clayton/Cleveland area! The owner is so nice, and the place is cozy whether you come in to stay to enjoy your food or wait for your pizza to be ready with a glass of wine on the couch. It's a great addition to the area! read more

This place was nice! The waitress was kind and friendly throughout the entire night. The menu has a variety of options to choose from al I'm sure everyone can find a pizza for themselves. I definitely enjoyed the 4 cheese pizza as it was light and I didn't get filled off just the bread. The ambience is nice, with conversations kept low so you aren't screaming to hear your date. I definitely recommend this place to anyone looking to try a new pizza place! read more

Amore Mio Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Garner, North Carolina

See all

Great Food. Standard and more gourmet toppings in a small setting where conversation is not drowned out by the crowd.

Not your normal pizza place, wings were great and pizza was awesome. Service was prompt, wait staff were courteous. Not a big place, it was cozy and even though they were busy there was no delay in our service. read more

The pizza was incredible! Don't expect Domino's! This is the real deal minimum ingredients with maximum flavors! I had the pepperoni and burrata with hot honey!! So yummy! I also had a slice of my partner's chicken, ham, bacon and trifoliati fungi pizza which was also yummy. Great service, friendly staff!. Casual environment with a modern space. Get ya some! read more

Amore Mio Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Garner, North Carolina

Best pizza since living in Garner.the dough/bread is what really makes it so delicious. Will definitely return when I'm craving piz

AVOID AT ALL COST waited for 1hr 30 for two pizzas while owner sat next to us drinking beer with his friends while we waited on our order. Rude staff. AVOID read more

Fantastic little pizza restaurant. Really good quality pizzas with perfect crusts and unique toppings. This is not your average pizzeria. The garlic knots are on the online menu and not the restaurant menu but if you ask for them they'll happily make them for you. I would definitely get them. They're made with sourdough dough and are super garlicky. Delicious. We had the pesto pizza with burrata and balsamic glaze. Was fantastic. And the truffle pizza, my husband loved it. Their tiramisu is really good too. Worth getting it even if you can't finish it all! read more

See all

This place is amazing. I'm from the north so I know good pizza in this place definitely has good pizza. I had the smoky mozzarella one and the Tartafutti (sp) .... The garlic knots are also amazing. read more

Great pizza and appetizers. Unique and different Italian pizza. Excellent crust and flavorful sauce.

My boyfriend and I are in town visiting and we stopped here as it was super close to our hotel and had super good ratings! We were not disappointed. The place is very cute and the employees are nice. We started off with the pepperoni rolls and they were SO good. We both got our own pizzas and I got a cheese pizza with buffalo mozzarella cheese and jalapeños. My boyfriend got the smoked pizza and he loved the honey was super good on the pizza. If we were in the area again we will be stopping by. read more

See all

Really great food! Garlic knots were amazing I love the Alfredo been here twice and had it both times. Nicely decorated on the inside read more

Amore Mio Pizza - Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Garner, North Carolina

See all

Great pizza spot, the owner was super nice. They took time to explain the menu and even helped us when deciding what to eat. The inside was kind of small, but it was perfect for lunch. Definitely one of the better pizza spots in the area. read more

Amore Mio Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Garner, North Carolina

Found this authentic italian pizza place! Unique pizzas with great flavors. We will be coming back!

Terrible! Employees lie about wait times. Told me 30-40 minutes and I come back in 40 and my pizza isn't even in the oven. This overpriced pizza isn't worth it at all. read more

This is a GREAT family owned establishment! The pistachio pizza is delicious! Service was impeccable. It is a small space but the pizza oven and the decor is really cute! Check it out- if you are disappointed, then you don't know good pizza! read more

I'm from this area but live in Maryland now, me and my brother were looking for a great slice of pizza. We went to Amore Mio and just had three great pies!!! Staff were excellent and service was over the top too! We're looking forward to trying their Nutella dessert pie on next visit! J. Phillips read more

We live the pizza here, different combinations and very artisan flavors. one of my favorites pizza places in Garner/Clayton area !!! read more

Constantly busy it seems, but the pizzas are great!!! It's a little "hole in the wall" pizza place so seating is hit or miss.

Wow! Pizza is excellent! Usually a pizza place drowns the pizza in tomato sauce and that gives me a tummy ache. Amore KNOWS how to make a good pizza with fresh ingredients and they don't use tomato sauce as a crutch. Big chicken pieces and big vegetable toppings. The pizza we got was the Chicken, Ham, Mushrooms, and Bacon Pizza - really big, dense toppings, they didn't hold back. Service was very fast, the salad we shared ahead of the pizza was HUGE - even though advertised as the "House Salad" - the Della Casa - it has romaine lettuce, spinach, olives, cheese, crouton bits, and many other kinds of other good things on it; it was very hearty. Many restaurants these days don't do veggies well, and Amore does a great job with this simple house salad above and beyond expectations. I really want to come back and try their other delicious salads. You can eat healthy here and come away full. Pretty simple and comfortable setting hidden in a strip mall, but has an inviting interior. This place is delicious and we will be back! read more

Amore Mio never disappoints! We love the food, the service and the owner! We have been coming here for 2 years and it's consistently delicious! read more

A few weeks later and Amore Mio has been consistent and high quality. They're our gibts now for pizza in Clayton/Garner. Each of their boxes has a hand written kind note, putting a smile on our faces. A few weeks ago our very picky grandsons were visiting and so grandma left a note on the yelp order to remove Basil and another ingredient and make it as plain of a sauce, cheese, pepperoni (their loss) pizza as possible. Not only did they follow the instructions but the lid note said, "With love for your grandson." This weekend, yelp wasn't working right and orders could no longer be placed online. I called the restaurant and they offered to take the order over the phone or to use the Slice app. A quick install later, we were off to the races. And, maybe because of delays with Yelp-Grubhub or maybe batched delivery with multiple stops before getting to us, but the Slice delivery (restaurant straight to us) was quick and the pizza was still hot, crunchy, and extra tasty. "Now this is some f-ing great pizza" was our consensus. I prize consistency in my restaurants and it's not always easy to deliver or find. Amore Mio has provided an excellent experience every time across now more than a dozen orders. read more

See all

Best pizza in the area, hands down! Second time ordering takeout - first pickup, second delivery - this time I got a cute personalized note on the inside of my pizza box. My order was neatly packaged with utensils and sauces included. The Bufala E Crudo pizza was delicious - the dough is the perfect texture and thickness and the tomato sauce is fresh and flavorful. The Della Casa salad was a great pairing - all fresh ingredients as well. The Nutella Rolls were the perfect way to end the meal, and honestly, I'd trust that anything from this restaurant is delicious. Definitely my go-to pizza spot from here on out! read more

Amore Mio Pizza - Bufala E Crudo - Pizza Near Me - Garner, North Carolina

Honey pepperoni is just amazing! So good I will eat it though I don't like pepperoni pizza even. Mushroom bacon ham chicken pizza is just wow. Even my "cheese pizza only" kid is hooked on it and gets it every time. This place is great for foodies who value fresh healthy ingredients and a clean friendly staff. My # 1 pizza place!!! read more

I order takeout from this place the other day. I got the margherita pizza. The presentation was really cute. Unfortunately the pizza was not a margarita pizza. It was more so a cheese pizza. The cheese to sauce ratio was very imbalanced and it was mostly cheese. Overall pizza is pizza and it was cooked well. However this was not what I was expecting when I ordered a margarita pizza read more

Amore Mio Pizza - Margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Garner, North Carolina

This is a small and cozy place with good food and great service. We ordered takeout on Super Bowl Sunday and were pleased with the service and the quality of food. Being from out of town, we like to try small businesses and this is one we will come back to in the future. read more

This pizza is absolutely delicious! I got a meat lovers and a vegetarian! Both cooked perfectly! The garlic knots were very tasty as well!

Really great pizza and service here! Also very clean restaurant! We enjoyed our experience here as a family!

I just turned 21, I went to this place because I know I've visited it before. The pizza tastes amazing as always, however when the staff asked how old I was and I mentioned to them that I turned 21 today because I was trying red wine, one of them came and asked if I wanted a dessert free of charge! It was the tiramisu, and it tasted amazing, better than the one I made in highschool a few years ago. The people here are friendly and the place itself is just a vibe. If I could rate more stars, I'd give it a 10/10 read more