Ordered via Doordash for pickup -- the pizza was hot, fresh, crispy/crunchy crust. Their prices are much more fair compared to surrounding NY style pizzas around Raleigh. The owner & staff were super friendly & generous. While waiting for my order you can tell there were quite a few regular customers so it says a lot about their food and customer service. Would recommend read more

No frills, no nonsense, basic old school pizza. Recommended by a coworker who's from Queens. To quote her "you can taste the New York". Cheese slice about $3, big enough to fold but not too large that you have to pass up a second slice. Large pie $12.99. Freaking delicious. read more

Brooklyn Original Slices - I started chowing before I remembered to take a pic. - Italian Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

Pizza was not good. 3 or 4 out of 10. Chefs salad was okay but had no turkey. Ranch is very thick. Pepperoni pizza was brown somehow- briwn mozzarella cheese? Crust seemed frozen, not fresh. Sauce didn't have flavor or seasonings. I wish this was still Italian Kitchen, that place was soooo good. read more

Brooklyn Original Slices - Italian Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

The pizza is New York size but it's a bit too doughy for New York style. Still, good flavor and texture with plenty of cheese. I stopped in at 5:30 pm and ordered the two slices special with was $10 with drink and the change in the tip jar. It was less than five minutes and I was burning my mouth on hot cheese! A little extra parmesan, a little sprinkling of red pepper flakes and it was good stuff. The restaurant is clean, including the restrooms. I'd choose this again. [Review 2443 of 2024 - 3899 in North Carolina - 23456 overall] read more

See all

I'm looking a new pizza place for pick-up between my job and home. I ordered at 4:50 online with a 5:30 pickup. It was closer to 4:40 before it was ready. The staff was direct but not rude. The food was good the lasagna pizza was good but it was slightly burnt which was disappointing. The white pizza was delicious and pepperoni and bacon was good. The cheese bread was also good but I really want to try their garlic knots. Will I try them again, yes... though not sure it's my new pizza place yet. read more

It's ok. It's not really a pizza shop. We had some slices and a chicken Philly. It's got decent prices, service was a little slow but it's just ok. read more

Pretty good pizza. I am a sauce girl so I could used a little more on the slices. I also tried the Stromboli. Staff was friendly

Good pizza for the price. Not my go to place but better than Domino's or Papa John's.

I love coming to this pizza shop! I'm originally from Brooklyn and this pizza is the closest to New York pizza in the area. I've been here maybe 7-10x atp lol. My sizes are always hot, fresh, and crispy! It's never too loud and I have always received spectacular customer service. If you want some good pizza at a decent price check them out! read more

See all

Do not get the Margherita pizza. It's so bad it ruined my whole night. Who puts sesame seeds on crust? Absolutely nasty. Don't want to be mean but I just threw $20 down the drain because it tastes that bad. read more

this is the absolute best food i have had in raleigh as far as italian dishes go!!!!!! and, the staff is incredible and the restaraunt is always clean and stocked. sooooo glad i found you guys!!!!!! read more

Amazing food! Nothing disappointed!! Highly recommend if you are in Raleigh and want good Italian style food, this place is the best!

Good pizza, good wings, friendly and efficient staff. Good for a quick bite worth your money.

Pizza is tasty. Awesome like Brooklyn authentic! The toppings were high quality and the sauce was very flavorful. But that crust was the best I've had since I've been in this town. read more

Confused by these reviews. I went here based on it being well reviewed. I'm glad people like it, but I found the pizza toppings were low quality, including basic cheese, and everything was surprisingly season-less. Continuing the search for Raleigh non-chain pizza. read more

As a New Yorker, I am always intrigued at restaurants using the NY in their name, and this place even uses Brooklyn in its name too. Walking into this place, I see quite a few NY & Brooklyn items but that doesn't mean the food is as good as NY, or does it? I am skeptical, but their garlic knots are the very best that I have eaten in a very long time, you owe it to yourself to try it...the garlic knot was so soft, fresh and the garlic taste is just escaping my words. The cheese pizza pie had so much cheese on it that for sure, it is more like NY than any pizza I have tried outside of NY. My only regret was to not ask for extra krispy bottom but since I couldn't finish the entire pie, I will reheat on a nice & hot cast iron pan to get the pizza krispy. If you are a regular customer here, I am sure you know how good the pizza is by now...this place is "legit". read more

Always a great place for a slice. Pizza is great and quick. I live close by and it's an easy pickup option for me. The staff is friendly and communicate well, great service. Inside is setup for a quick in and out with some tables to dine at. read more

The lasagna pizza, pepperoni rolls and garlic knots were all delicious!! I was pleasantly surprised because the prices are more than fair. read more

Brooklyn Original Slices - Lasagna pizza - Italian Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

Service poor! Food comes out slow! They have enough people working not to be so slow!

It's New York pizza delicious garlic knots delicious only problem with this place is the New York attitude from the staff I really don't like you to ask questions read more

Worth the wait. We were there to eat-in, during an apparently Very busy online order rush. The employees were getting it done! What seemed like attitudes of indifference when we tried to order turned to clear friendliness when the rush was done. The food...so good!!! Totally worth it! read more

It was my first visit and I ordered the lasagna pizza for carryout. The pizza was delicious!

Best Ny style slices in North Raleigh... Reminds me of the mom and pops pizza parlor in NYC

after over a year of searching, finally found pizza that tastes like it's from NYC. This is as close as it gets my friends

I always order 2 slices of pepperoni ,mushroom and Dr Pepper. Pizza is delicious just the right amount of sauce, not to consume either with to much sauce. Atmosphere is okay, it could be better. More of a welcome is needed and communication. Even given a drink cup, point where machine is located so you do not have stand and wait to ask the question. Other than that, place is fine read more

Dont even waste your time. I walked in to place a to go order. Completely ignored by the staff. I was the only customer in the store. I shouted for some assistance they acted like I was inconveniencing them. I walked out. That mentality might work in Brookly, definitely not here in Raleigh. I won't be back. read more

Excellent NY style pie. Good service. Ordered the 18 in cheese pie. Took half home with me. Pizza is good reheated too. Very happy!

Very good NY style pizza. Two large cheese slices (or pepperoni) and a drink for $8 at lunch. Great deal. Paying for food not overhead. Recently in a well known regional tourist city and went to two of the "best pizza" places. This was better then either. read more

Great pizza sauce, quality toppings & cheese. Plus the crust is just the right thickness

Unable to edit original post..But they returned my money. Company never responded to my inquiry and had to go through a 3rd party, but regardless they did right by me. I may give them another shot, probably not though. read more

Yuck!!! If you like to eat pizza that taste like a pizza mix (out of a bag), this is your place... I guess "Brooklyn" is the new pizza hype name. Maybe we will start having the John's pizza insanity here, as they do in NYC. I honestly thought that this was a new restaurant that I have been hearing about, I just couldn't remember the name, they just opened up here from NY. I should have looked it up, I should have paid attention to the lack to business, I should have paid attention to the existing pizza on the counter. They do have other items, if you're a fan go... read more

Best garlic knots I've ever had. Pizza and calzone crust is delicious - crisp, not the floppy/foldable kind. read more

Brooklyn Original Slices - Calzone - Italian Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

The first time I went, the customer service and food was absolutely awesome. The last 2 times I went the pizza was ok and the customer service was awful. I tried it a 3rd time because my co-worker wanted pizza and one bad service can happen to anybody. But this LAST time.... Customer service was HORRIBLE! The guy giving out the orders to customers snapped at my co-worker like she was an inconvenience, I almost asked for my money back as the workers are back there putting pizza's in the oven with bare hands. I asked the guy why he was so rude and he just stared.. last visit.. no worries. read more

Every time I order from here the food is consistently delicious. I've ordered the Italian White Pizza, a pepperoni pizza with various veggies, cheese sticks, and mozzarella sticks. Definitely one of my go to pizza places. My only complaint, which I did not take off a star for, is that there is a glitch on Uber Eats when you try to order the 3 topping pizza and cheese stick deal. After you select the required 3 toppings you are required to select 3 more toppings, and of course each one costs an additional price. Would have liked to go with that deal, but didn't want 6 toppings. Just wanted to bring that to someone's attention. read more

This spot is wonderful the have everything same NY coming trying months looking for real pizza finally I found good pizza and pasta yummy read more

Brooklyn Original Slices - Meat lovers - Italian Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

See all

Its a family owned pizzeria, with great service and a friendly new owner that serves amazing pizza and tasty wings. I suggest to buy a fresh pie to experience the quality of said pie, and of course their garlic knots. read more

The pizza is amazing. The owner is super nice. If you haven't tried this place you should. You will not be disappointed.