We were delighted to find this gem close to our home. From the moment we walked in we were impressed. The restaurant's decor was pleasing with an Italian mural covering one wall. We were quickly seated, then greeted by our wonderful server, Trenton. We started with the bruschetta which was delicious. Then our entrees came. A calzone, spinach ravioli, and fettuccine Alfredo for my friends, and chicken siciliano for me. Wow! It was my first time tasting this recipe and I was not disappointed. The sauce was magnificent! Capers, mushrooms, and artichoke hearts cooked in a lemon butter wine sauce served over spaghetti with 5 strips of chicken. I have a new favorite Italian meal. And I took leftovers home. I had a nice white wine with my meal and then finished with the limoncello mascarpone. Yummy! I will definitely return for more of that Siciliano. It was so-o-o good! read more

Amy's food is wonderful. The rolls are amazing. Don't forget to grab desert to go because I always take food home.

Love their food! The chicken siciliano is to die for! So is the fettuccine Alfredo and the clams and linguine. Great service too.

Great food. Second time eating there. First time, service and food outstanding. Second time, a young college age waiter got mouthy and turned his back on me when I asked if he could bring me a small plate for bread. He then lied to the owner/manager saying he was kidding around. Not even close. Don't know what burr was under his saddle but the good food and polite manager is not worth going back. Won't spend my money where the service personnel seem to have missed the lesson on courtesy and service. read more

Excellent food. Great portions fine Italian style cooking great service.. worth the money

Deliciousness. Needing more places like this on the East side. Family really enjoyed dinner and the tall beer!

We thought the atmosphere of the restaurant was good. The staff was professional and friendly. The food was similar to Italian chain restaurants. We did not like the food. Food and soft drinks at this restaurant are way overpriced. We are not likely to go back. read more

Always had a great meal at a reasonable price here. The servers are friendly and attentive and the kitchen staff prepare meals that are just right. The atmosphere is open and relaxed. I highly recommend this restaurant. read more

Very good food. They have a friendly staff. I'm very glad that there is a good Italian restaurant on the east side of Norman now! read more

The best Italian restaurant in Norman. Everything is amazing, but I absolutely love the sausage pepper parmigiana!

Homemade pasta is fantastic! Our server, Sydney, was so polite and professional. We will definitely be back!!

Food was good, but a little on the expensive side. I had the spaghetti with Italian sausage and it was very good.

The food was very good, the crab pasta and linguine was awesome. The service was slow due to an apparent shortage of employees, however our waitress did an awesome job keeping up with all of the tables as there were only two people waiting on tables. We will be back to try more of the menu hopefully they can correct speed of service. read more

Exquisite homemade flavor!! Reasonable price for our times Excellent service !! Sabor casero exquisito!! Precio razonable para nuestros tiempos Servicio excelente !! read more

The food was exceptional, the service was unmatched, and the ambiance was just right! I would highly recommend this restaurant to any wanting good food, and awesome customer service! read more

Food was excellent! Service was friendly and fast even while they were extremely busy. The bread was delicious, appeared home made, and came out hot! I will definitely be back. read more

Yummy food - we had the lasagna and the petite sampler. Portion sizes were good and prices were reasonable. Enjoyed the bread with olive oil & balsamic. Our server, Gracie, was great - friendly, knowledgeable, and attentive. Seating was comfortable and the Italian music was a nice touch. So glad to have a nice sit down restaurant on the east side. Will definitely be back! read more

Amy's Italian Restaurant - Garlicky Rolls & Petite Sampler. - Pizza Near Me - Norman, Oklahoma

See all

Food is very good. Calamari was a little bland. Calazone was great!! Marinara is very good. Amy's bead is light and fluffy. Service was nice and friendly. Ambiance was casual. Overall experience was enjoyable. read more

Amy's Italian Restaurant - Calamari and marinara. - Pizza Near Me - Norman, Oklahoma

Server was really good food was excellent pizza was amazing and good bread definitely suggest

We were excited for a new Italian restaurant closer to our house but we were disappointed with the quality and high prices. Spent $30 for a Rib Eye Steak and it was paper thin and they advertised backed potatoes but didn't have any. Staff is super friendly but the food is fair. Recap over price for marginal food at best. We spent over $105 and disappointed read more

Great selection, everything that we had was great tasting, new so clean, tables or booths

Service was prompt, staff friendly and accommodating. Spinach ravioli was very good, as was the calamari. Will definitely visit them again.

Amy's has great Italian dishes. My family has eaten her 2 times now and we have tried the Pizza, lasagna, spinach ravioli, baked ziti and Alfredo Pasta. Portion size was decent and Price range is between 15.00-30.00 dollars depending on the dish. If you like to enjoy a cocktail or wine with your meal. There is a bar to choose what drink tickles your fancy. The ambience place up beat music that makes you want to sing and dance as you eat! We will definitely be back again read more

Over priced for normal Italian food. People were nice, just don't want to spend $22 on a chicken pasta that takes like a chain Italian restaurant read more

Great service friendly people and really good food , will definitely be back ! Love the bread !! That comes with everything!!

The service was awesome, the lasagna was delicious, and the bread was delicious as well. I'm glad to see an Italian restaurant on the east side of Norman. read more

If I could give 0 stars I would. We were excited for a good Italian restaurant but was severely disappointed. Everything tasted frozen and extremely bland. The bread that was brought out had an obvious taste and feel of pre-frozen that was chewy and flavorless. The balsamic vinegar and olive oil tasted of very low quality (have better at home). My gf and I both got Caesar side salads - they were both very over-dressed and the Caesar dressing was extremely sweet. I got the chicken parmigiana and gf got the chicken alfredo. My chicken tasted like it came from Sysco - pre-frozen and bland. The breading was very soggy, falling off the chicken and paper thin, there was definitely no egg wash that you would get with fresh and the chicken has the texture and had the firmness of frozen. The marinara was very sweet and the pasta tasted like they had just went and picked some up from Walmart. The chicken alfredo, I could tell was going to be extremely bland as soon as it was placed down. There was no salt or pepper, at all. The alfredo tasted bland and had a chalky texture, I've had better jarred alfredo. The chicken had the same consistency and pre-frozen looking/feeling. We only ate because we were starving. This was extremely disappointing and the only good thing I can say was the staff was nice and it did look nice inside. read more

Just finished dinner at Amy's. Delicious lobster ravioli and cheesy bread. Good service and pleasant surroundings.

We had Petite Pasta Sampler, The Works spaghetti plus salads and desserts. The meals and salads were fine and the rolls were exceptional. I would skip the dessert. I don't know if it's made in-house, but it was not anything to write home about. read more

My family had our first and last meal at this establishment. The food was sub par and I had better from the frozen food section from my Grocery Store. read more