We got a yelp review made item. Pesto pasta baked ($3 bake charge) w mozzarella. Oily not sure if there just how pesto is ! Was good. Bruschetta was nice and light. Coconut pie was light and tasty too. read more

See all

I thought the decor and ambiance was classic Italian stereotype but in a super awesome way. They had the drippy candles and the soft lighting. Apps...decent. The mushrooms were stuffed but didn't have a ton of flavor. I got the Chicken Othello which would have come with spaghetti and tomato sauce but the waitress suggested extra cream sauce-excellent choice! Hubs got the lasagna with sausage. He wasn't a huge fan but he said it was pretty good. Kiddo got the penne Alfredo and crispy chicken. I snagged a bite of chicken and it was great! Penne Alfredo with sausage was another winner. We took home the regular and chocolate cannolis. The filling was great but the shells were a bit soft. I wasn't a fan of the chocolate dipped. It was too much chocolate for me. They weren't filled all the way so it was a little disappointing. The service was a bit slow but it was Fathers Day and it was busy. They have a patio so if you have a large party they can accommodate. There was a paid parking lot across the street but it's free on Sundays. Definitely going to go back! read more

See all

My wife and I visited for Valentines Day! We were not disappointed one bit! The food was great! She had Spaghetti, I had Pat's Special. The people were all so polite & took care of us, even though we were 5 minutes late for our reservation, they made nothing of it, just sat us as the table was available. It was a great setup, even though we were sitting close to others, it was like having our own little spot! read more

A girlfriend and I stopped in for a late dinner. As we walked in the aroma brought delicious memories reminding us of the best local family Italian restaurants from our hometowns. We were greeted promptly and seated. The server was training a new employee both of them were very attentive, Ryland and Skylar. We enjoyed a couple of apps - meatballs and cheese sticks. Both were very good! Then ordered the steak special. It literally was cooked perfectly, melted in the mouth and fabulous flavor. As for sides we enjoyed gnocchi and Nancy's Pasta. It was prepared perfectly. To complete the meal we enjoyed their speciality - coconut cream pie. I can sincerely say it was the best coconut cream I've ever had. We left with a thank you and felt welcomed to be there. I will definitely come back and share the experience with other friends who live in OKC area. read more

Food was super good but service was really slow. So just expect slow service and enjoy the company you're keeping and you will have a good time. read more

Big menu and great service! Went on a Wednesday night and it was a low key vibe. Drinks were good and the food portions are massive.

The juiciest steak I ever ate. Amazing Nancy pasta. Don't leave without eating the coconut cream pie YUM

We got a garlic rolls with cheese and came with a small bowl of marinara sauce as the appetizer. We order the special which was a spicy tortellini, I think there was sausage, either way it was good just the right amount of kick. We also ordered a build your own pasta with Rigatoni with breaded chicken and tomato sauce and it was really good hit the spot. We did order a Cannoli as a dessert and that was amazing. Good sit down restaurant and the service was good. I do recommend this place if you are around campus corner in Norman. read more

We had a 70th birthday celebration on their newly renovated patio area. The ambiance was fantastic. The fire pit was so pretty. Thirty five people attended. There was live music by Edgar Cruz and his band, delicious food, attentive and friendly waitresses. It was a wonderful experience, enjoyed by all. read more

Saw the add for half price pizza and live music so decided to pop in!! Immediately loved the atmosphere.. Definitely a place I could come to often and vibe to. I sat at the bar and was asked how I was and given both drink/food menus which was nice although the guy(Gabe) had somewhat of a dry personality. After that I was left unattended for about 15 minutes,I had to ask to order. The food was good,service wasn't terrible but also didn't make me feel very welcomed. Maybe it was me because everyone else seemed to be receiving really good service. on the way out the girl cleaning silverware thanked me for coming in,she was the most hospitable person I encountered. read more

Othello's Italian Restaurant - Pizza was on point and half price!! - Italian Near Me - Norman, Oklahoma

Their food is so good I swear they put drugs in it. I got the vegetable soup it was incredible. Followed that with the shrimp scampi. It was amazing. Perfectly fine! The waitress knew the menu like the back of her hand. Knew everythung that was in every dish. Anyway I go for the food.... But there were these awesome candles there . The bathrooms were so clean and the food came out at the right pace. Not too fast or too slow. If I could give this 6 stars I would! read more

Othellos offers real Italian food. It was delicious and plentiful. The lasagne was tasty and a good sized mound of it. The penne was fresh and delicious. The breaded chicken was crunchy outside and moist inside - perfect. Good wine selection as well. If you don't know Italian food the Olive Garden or canned spaghetti will work. But if you really know Italian food, Othello's is the place to go. Only complaint at all is parking is tight. But it's worth going there or order online! You won't be disappointed! Mangia! read more

Our group paid a reservation fee ahead of time for 20, arrived and they only had room for 16, proceeded to tell us to work four more chairs in somewhere. Some pastas were decent to good, both pizzas were nasty. One was soggy/mushy to the point you didn't want to grab a slice, so nobody did. The second was basically a Tony's frozen pizza that was soft and underdone (even after ordering it well done/crispy), and had zero flavor. Our waitress was great. We had bad experience and food a few years ago, thought we'd try again since it was a friends birthday. Nah, never again. If ai want Italian, I'll go to DONI on 36th or at least three other Italian restaurants in Norman. read more

The absolute worst service I have ever had. There 40 minutes and I had to ask for us to see a waitress

I love this place and while parking is always an issue we get it handled. The wine pricing is a little high, but food portions are oversized as easily splittable. Management is always on top of everything in the service is always good. read more

See all

First time going to Othello's. It was nice. Similar to other Italian Restaurants. The unique feature for them was this candle on each table that had multiple different colors cause it was multiple candles over several years melting on top of each other. My friend got pasta with mussles (might be spelling that wrong) in them. I made my own Alfredo pasta with chicken. Everything was good. Server was great! Super nice, wasn't pushy, and was very attentive to our needs. Definitely would reccommend others to visit! read more

Othello's Italian Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Norman, Oklahoma

See all

Enjoyed Othello's for Valentine's Day. They were very prepared for a busy Saturday. Food was excellent as always! My wife got Lasagna with Marinara and I got Chicken Parmigiana. Toasted ravioli and Caesar salad were good to stay off meal. Violinist added a touch of ambiance. Pleasant experience on a holiday! read more

The food was fine, but the service was absolutely terrible. The staff acted like they couldn't care less about the customers, ignored our table most of the time, and had an attitude any time we asked for something simple. Easily one of the worst dining experiences I've had in a long time. Won't be coming back. read more

Service sucked! The waitress was clueless about the menu and happy hour specials. We were seated in the far back corner of the restaurant no one ever told us that there was a piano player that nite. The food was mediocre at best. Recommend having staff members that are well trIned, it was a typical experience when high school or college kids try to operate the floor. read more

The 1st time I met Toby Keith was at a small base in northern Iraq. The 2nd time I met him was at Othello's. It's Norman. The staff, food and crowd are incredible. read more

Super-cute Italian restaurant. Aperol spritzes were fantastic, as was the garlic bread! We started The Taster appetizer, which was good. A few of us were intrigued by the Artichoke Parmigiana, but were disappointed when it came out. It was just a weird presentation. There are a number of other dishes on the menu that I look forward to trying on future visits. My niece was happy that she was able to order her meatballs (without cheese) and she thought they were delicious. We had the skillet chocolate chip cookie for dessert and it was probably the best I've ever tried! read more

Great food, even better people! We hang here before and after the OU games. It's perfect for the whole family.

I went by myself for dinner the other night. The service was exceptional. Every server was so kind and personable. The tiramisu was too die for. I'm so glad I was recommended it. I definitely plan to come back even if it's just for a slice. Truly wonderful. read more

Othello's Italian Restaurant - Tiramisu - Italian Near Me - Norman, Oklahoma

Pretty good food! On Tuesdays they have a 2 for 1 parmigiana deal. Restaurant is fairly dark inside and service is great! read more

See all

The food here was mediocre, I do not think I've ever had a pasta this bland & on top of that the service is extremely slow. I'd only come here again for their drinks and tiramisu! read more

Othello's Italian Restaurant - Best Tiramisu! - Italian Near Me - Norman, Oklahoma

Very friendly, great staff and the food is wonderful. Love their pizza! Great environment for family or date. We will for sure go back.

Slowest service in Norman, food was average to good but that service or lack of is a killer!

SOOOO good! First timer here and I loved it! Got Nancy's reccomended by the waiter and yumm! read more

Othello's Italian Restaurant - Nancy's Penne Tomato Alfredo - Italian Near Me - Norman, Oklahoma

See all

Honestly very solid food across the board. I was super delighted by the Lasagna. It brought back good memories about home. We enjoyed the garlic rolls and pepperoni chips. Service was amazing. However gotta dock you one star for not having the Gnocchi. That's pretty important for us. It's one of our favorites. I will however revise this review if you have gnocchi the next time we come. We will be back :) read more

Othello's Italian Restaurant - Lasagna - Italian Near Me - Norman, Oklahoma

The food was great! We're able to make modifications to fit what I like! Service was a little slow but over all very pleasant! Will definitely be back! read more

The food was good. It's not the best Italian restaurant but good for a one time try. The pricing was a bit much for the menu. There wasn't much selection in my opinion. We went here for a celebration and I wasn't super impressed. read more

Visiting our son at OU. Othello's was a delicious treat for an Italian dinner. Seated promptly for an early Sunday dinner. Server was helpful and provided recommendations when asked. Enjoyed Fried Calamari for an appetizer. It was excellent. Very tender and lightly breaded. We then turned to the Customer Creations part of the menu for our dinners. The dishes named Karen's pasta, Pat's special and Angel's chicken and spinach were very flavorful. read more

Othello's Italian Restaurant - Angels Balsamic Chicken and Spinach - Italian Near Me - Norman, Oklahoma

See all

Brought my wife here for Valentine's Day before the dinner rush and we had a great time. They handed my wife a rose which was warmly received and the service was top-notch (thank you Chloe). Chicken Alfredo is my favorite to order - creamy sauce and flavorful, and the bread was crispy and warm. The ambiance is perfectly set with Sinatra and Louis Prima softly playing combined with their colorful candles. Love coming here. read more

The food was awful, I will not go back! I even tried staff recommendations. The staff was amazing and very kind and attentive!! My only problem was the stuffed mushrooms were disappointing to say the least I ate two, the bread was okay, the salad was the worst part! I did have a drink which was good. Spend 35 for one person! read more

Othello's Italian Restaurant - Malibu peach Bellini - Italian Near Me - Norman, Oklahoma

See all

Ordered a pepperoni pizza from Othello's. It was hands down the worst pizza I've ever had in my life. How do you ruin pizza? The crust was stale like it had been pre-cooked and kept in a refrigerator for a week. It had the consistency of cardboard and was completely flavorles. The cheese was very low quality and the whole top of the pizza was heavily sprinkled with oregano. Inedible. read more

Bruschetta was delicious and the fried ravioli was awesome! Chicken Marsala and they had a special 2 for 1 Chicken Parmesan! Great meal for our family! read more

Food was mediocre. Place was slowwwwwww and that should of been our 1st clue. Only older people were eating there. We had the youngest table. They had to be constantly told we had a birthday at our table. ( we hand an out of state birthday person at our table . which we told 4 different employees and finally got it ). Probably not the place to go if you want to show off OK to of state guests . read more

The best history and Italian fare in Norman The veal parm. The noodles. The mushrooms. The bread! Full bar. A must go before Sooner royalty shows up read more

Food was delicious as always. I got the Angel's balsamic chicken with penne and we split the taster and two desserts (cannoli and spumoni gelato cake). Everything was delicious. Their patio is a great place to listen to live music. read more

Othello's Italian Restaurant - Spumoni - Italian Near Me - Norman, Oklahoma

See all

Didn't care for the red sauce- was quite bland. However, a friend got fettuccine that I tried that tasted much better. Didn't care for the atmosphere of the restaurant- decor is outdated and the restaurant set up felt cheap with the outdated tables and red coke cups for drinks that u get at Pizza Hut. I did love the candles in the Chianti bottles on each table and the mural painting. The visit was mediocre - not bad but certainly not what I expected for a weekend Italian dinner dining experience. read more

Othello's Italian Restaurant - Table candle - Italian Near Me - Norman, Oklahoma