THE. BEST. Each and every time! Andy's is full of flavor, no matter what you choose. It's creamy, delicious, and melt-in-your-mouth satisfactory! It truly hits the spot. We have tried many of their items, including the Rico Suave, Turtle Sundae, Banana Split, Soft Serve, and Nutty Waffle Crunch, among others. Each item has its own flavor and is balanced really well. I cannot wait to go back! read more

I've always had fond memories of Andy's from my time in Evanston, so when my family and I moved to the western suburbs, I was excited to see this Andy's in Bolingbrook. Overall, the items are quite delicious and reminiscent of what I remember. Only issue is the customer service - people aren't the kindest at this location, but I partially think it's due to stress of flowing through patrons. read more

My husband talked about Andy's so much and we finally got our banana split last night! The vanilla custard was perfect and isn't overwhelmingly sweet. I can't wait to try their other menu items next time we are in Bolingbrook again. read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Vanilla custard banana split. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bolingbrook, Illinois

best custard ever!! I come here often with my grandmother and we love love love it. ryan the general manager goes above and beyond expectations. thank you for being our go to spot !! read more

Can't go wrong with Andy's! But I will say the price for a medium concrete almost $10... geez I'll check other new places nearby more often I guess.... read more

Yummy! I love frozen custard. This is one of the best things the Midwest has introduced me too. I happened upon this Andy's by happenstance, so if you're not from Bolingbrook or one of the nearby suburbs it's probably pretty easily missed. As it's summer, and its peach season, one of their specials was a peach concrete or peach sundae. I will admit that the peach concrete was pretty good, but I'm glad I stuck with my standard strawberry banana concrete. One thing that's somewhat disappointing is that even in the era of COVID, they haven't made any changes to their ordering scheme. They're "old fashioned", so even at the drive-up you have to order directly from the window--no speakers to order from here. It gets insanely busy here; luckily I was there when there was only one or two other cars there, but by the time I was heading out there was a like of 5-7 out the parking lot. They're open late, though--until midnight--so if you get a craving you just can't shake, Andy's is there to satisfy it. #575 - October 14, 2021 read more

See all

ANY GIVEN SUNDAE Nothing says summer quite like Andy's Frozen Custard. Last year was the first time I got to experience Andy's, and now we've got two--2!--in Bolingbrook to choose from. There's a location on Boughton & Rt 53, plus this one on Weber just north of Lily Cache Ln. During warmer weather (June-Sept), this place gets absolutely buzzin' between the hours of 6-9pm, even moreso on weekends and holidays. The drive thru line can stretch more than a dozen cars long, but their system runs smooth like caramel. Just like at Portillo's, an order taker with a tablet comes over to your car--hopefully you've peeped the menu ahead of time or have committed your "go-to" to memory--and you simply drive to the pickup window having already paid. Don't panic if you can't make up your mind, they'll circle back to you....but don't dawdle. My wife's favorite is the key lime cheesecake concrete ($6), a seasonal treat that's only available during the summer months. Then there's the Rico Suave jackhammer ($7 for a medium): vanilla custard blended with pecans & Oreo bits, filled with a hot fudge core. I'm still amazed when someone can finish a sugar bomb like this in a single sitting. They've got a ton of toppings to pick from: 'fruity' (bananas, pineapple, cherries), 'crunchy' (pretzel pieces, heath bar, M&Ms), 'chewy' (cookie dough, crushed nuts), and 'drizzly' (mint syrup, butterscotch). First topping is always included, additional stuff is 85¢ extra. Some of the presets (like the 'AJ almondinger') might not be your cup of tea, so customizing can be a wise choice. It's not crazy expensive. Prices are comparable to Culver's concrete mixers and Dairy Queen blizzards, usually $5-8 depending on size. Last time we were here, they gave us a coupon for a free sundae with any $10 purchase. I signed up for Andy's rewards program; we'll no doubt become frequent flyers once our little guy is old enough for desserts. * TL;DR * DQ is good for a quick dilly bar and Oberweis has certain appeal, but when you feel like spoiling yourself, head to Andy's. Whether you're celebrating a big win from little league, or celebrating little wins throughout the week, there's no shortage of reasons to find yourself back here ordering a large James Brown Funky Assblaster ("what do you mean that's not what it's called?.....then what have I been ordering all this time??") read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Andy's sign off of Weber Rd. This place is a summertime treat and attracts quite the crowd during PM hours! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bolingbrook, Illinois

See all

I'm just a Southern California visitor writing about frozen custard. I shared in another review that it's not really a thing in SoCal.  The only places I know of locally is Rita's in OC, CA, Shake Shack in Los Angeles area, and just recently tipped by a yelp friend --Joe Schmoe's in OC, CA.   Frozen custard is a cold dessert similar to ice cream but, made w/eggs in addition to cream and sugar.  I had a lil taste and it seems to have a very smooth consistency. When trying something new, I just go w/a conservative flavor like vanilla. I like it! Hubby likes Andy's Frozen Custard a lot! The ones we visited or passed by have a very busy drive thru! (hey CA friends--like In N Out lines!) Great business for them! Go Andy's!! 4/4.5 yelp average seems fitting! We'll be back. read more

Great pl as ce with quick service. There is only outdoor seating at this location so we went through the drive thru. Tons of choices so I would look at the menu on your phone prior to jumping in line. But very nice portions and reasonable price. It was also delicious!! I would recommend for any ice cream/ custard lover! read more

Small Boot Daddy=$5.59 It may be a little overpriced, but it's so good! The Caramel and Cookies mix really well. read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Small Boot Daddy=$5.59 It may be a little overpriced, but it's so good! The Caramel and Cookies mix really well. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bolingbrook, Illinois

So glad there is one close by. This place has a huge selection of treats! Their custard is so creamy and the taste is always consistent. I like that they offer peanut butter topping. I've not had me thing that wasn't so good! It can get crowded on a hot day but all ordering is outside which in this day is good. read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bolingbrook, Illinois

Best custard in the Midwest. Weekends in the summer are very busy. Their frozen custard is made through out the day. Most of the locations I've seen are drive thur with only some seating and mostly outdoor. The custard is always fresh and delicious. Andy's has that old fashion vibe well lite and bright. As you approach the place, There's an exciting factor knowing your in for a good treat. The only thing I would say as a customer is not knowing the menu well they usually have a team member taking orders before you get to the menu board. I understand they are being proactive in controlling the long Lines but it's exciting see all the options they offer. read more

It's really bad that I moved so close. because well......goodbye summer body, helllloooooo andys!!!!!!! Dear chocolate lovers, do yourself a favor and get this: Chocolate concrete Coconut brownies almonds strawberries & hot fudge if you're feeling frisky. YOU ARE WELCOME! read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - yummy goodness - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bolingbrook, Illinois

[COVID-19 Drive-Thru Review] As the weather gets warmer, I'd imagine Andy's drive-thru would be super busy! Luckily, the weekend we visited wasn't too warm so the drive-thru was easy breezy! We drove up to the look at the menu and there was a masked-attendant ready to take our orders. Within minutes our order was ready and handed to us. I ordered the Strawberry shortcake Sunday and it was so good! There were 2 scoops of vanilla custard, 2 shortcake, and topped with fresh cut strawberries. Definitely a larger cup than I thought it would be initially!! read more

Andy's has really darn good ice cream, and it's not too expensive. Everything I've had from there tasted amazing. I just wish that they had a little less calories and a little less expensive. Also I think adding some indoor seating would be a game changer. Had some Andy's tonight, and I enjoyed it. 4/5 - wish it was a little less expensive, but really darn good ice cream. read more

We LOVE Andy's frozen custard! What's not to adore?! -the friendliest staff ever -an incredible, giant menu of decadent treats -a drive thru! -LATE hours! Got a craving for custard at 10pm?! NO problem when there's an Andy's nearby! -you can never get lost going to Andy's because their lights are so bright, I'm fairly certain you can see it from space. Many a night during the pandemic, we'd cruise over here from sheer boredom, grab an old fashioned chocolate soda (with chocolate custard - sooooo good!) and a smile from the delightful young staff and pretend the world wasn't a total disaster. So worth it! read more

There are so many great choices at Andy's. Custard is the creamiest most smooth frozen treat and Andy's knows how to do it right. I usually get a concrete, and especially love the peanut butter and Oreo ones. The Italian ice mixed with custard is also amazing and you should try it at least once. The small is huge so get ready to be full of delicious custard! read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bolingbrook, Illinois

This is one of the places I frequented during COVID lockdown. I gained weight. Not happy. It's not really their fault. I like chocolate! read more

Great service! Great custard! Friendly, but you can only visit certain locations if it's not raining.

Great custard! The staffs do an efficient job in directing traffic, taking orders in advance, and completing them too. I tend to get a simple vanilla or chocolate cone most of the time but once in a while indulging in their cherry bash concrete makes me one happy gal! read more

This place is extremely addictive! If you happen to come at a time when they make their cones, they taste amazing! Fresh or not but fresh just adds a bit more punch to a already great cone! Tons of options to pick from and service is always super fast! They do get a bit crowded during the warmer days/nights but definitely worth it! Highly recommend! read more

I had the triple chocolate concrete, and it was delicious. But I had one problem. There was barely any cookie dough chunks, and those are my favorite part. Please add more Cookie Dough Chuncks!!!!! read more

It's solid. It doesn't beat out other custard places I've been to but it definitely is a crowd pleaser.

I love Andy's but they took about 15 minutes for one small ice cream. The ambiance it amazing too.

Service is awesome, Ava does a great job! Great custard and fast service. Heaters are placed by windows if you get cold when ordering or drive through is quick. read more

Great taste and wonderful customer service and I'll be back for sure Great team you guys made me happy

Good custard. Good service. Love the casual ambiance. Will we be back? I mean, the most expensive frozen custard on the menu is still cheaper than a therapist's fees. So yeah, we've been coming back year after year. read more

We were first time visitors to Andy's on a Saturday night. The place was busy, but not horrible. However, their parking situation is a nightmare. We had to park on street behind the building and walk in. I have no idea who all those cars parked there belong to, unless they allow their employees to park up their own lot. The custard was good, but not stellar, almost like traditional ice cream in that it lacked the traditional "custard" smoothness. Prices are a little high, so you do not "get what you pay for" in this case. I think the best part was sitting in the waiting area and watching the people. Too bad the area needed cleaning up; several used custard cups sitting under the benches from people too lazy to put them in the trash receptacles . read more

The past few years this establishment has gone into the gutter!!! My five star review is now 0 stars. They consistently mess up my order and are not considerate of other peoples time whatsoever. Your ice cream will be good but messed up. The manager I spoke with tonight was rude and not accommodating to my messed up order. The ambiance is awful. read more

I live frozen Custard. I especially love the butter pecan concrete here. I don't need a ton of caramel sauce but OMG, the salty, buttery & crunchy pecans make me soooooo happy read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bolingbrook, Illinois

Love Andy's. Quick service through the drive thru. Friendly employees. And the frozen custard is delicious!

Great flavors and unique offerings, a regular "go to" when craving sweets and not just for warm summer days.

Best frozen custard anywhere around. The turtle sundae is the best. Many choices all of them yummy. Drive through is very convenient or you can walk in. Busy place because the flavors are delicious. read more

Love the pumpkin pie ice cream! 10/10 would recommend. The location in Bolingbrook is always quick and friendly. read more

Just that they have the basics down better than most. Couldn't go wrong with stopping by Andy's!!

A-N-D-Y! I may or may not have been cheering that with each spoonful. Oh my goodness this custard is what dreams are made of. I have a sensitivity to dairy but this was WORTH it. I got a custom concrete which is vanilla frozen custard blended with a topping of your choice. I chose peanut butter, of course because it's my all time favorite. The consistency of this custard is what is so amazing. I thought I could use a straw for it because it almost looked like a shake but NOPE. It's so thick and creamy and you can really taste the topping that's blended. I also adore the outdoor seating and window that you walk up to order from. It's gives you an old-time simpler days feel. People were actually off their phones and talking to one another while they enjoyed their custards- how crazy is that?! I didn't get a photo because I was pretty unplugged too on our date night but I can tell you, you need to plan some time on the next perfect summer night and give this custard a try! read more

Great tasting custard! Reasonably priced. Lots of choices. Not a lot of seating, but that's fine. read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bolingbrook, Illinois

OK I'm giving them five stars even though their prices are high. Their customer service is fantastic, anything you want they will make happen within reason. I love how they deal with little kids and treat them very very well. Also, they have some really awesome flavor combinations and or custard, although extremely high in fat I am sure, has a consistency and great taste that I keep coming back for. I highly recommend Andy's! read more

Delicious and great seasonal flavors! Just wish they had whipped cream! Great location and service You read more

Customer service lacks here. They could really care less about you, but their ice cream is damn good so who cares about the service, right?!