My wife and I thoroughly enjoyed the food and service. We highly recommend the Shrimp & Grits. Our servers, Abby and Brian, were the best! We'll be back! read more

We came here on Mother's Day in a torrential downpour. Their check-in system makes it possible to take your mom out for a well-deserved and incredibly delicious brunch. I have a hard time finding a breakfast place I want to go back to, but Another Broken Egg Cafe does not disappoint. It's one of my top favorites in Indy for a yummy breakfast spot! read more

We went here for breakfast in March 2021 and it was such an amazing experience. Our server was Emily and she was knowledgeable, friendly and was very good knowing what we may want to try. Everything was wonderful, we had five different breakfast meals and each one was tasty, fresh and flavorful. I love the area the restaurant is in which adds to the vibe. If I lived here I could see myself going here often. Thank you Emily! read more

Great food and Ashley our waitress was so kind and attentive . I had the lobster omelette and it was delicious. My sister had the Apple fritter French toast and it was amazing. read more

First time here, Terri was FANTASTIC! We told her it was our first time and she immediately brought us free beignets! She was so kind and attentive we will definitely be back!! read more

I've gotten more picky with my five star reviews, but this place certainly earned it! Sunday morning breakfast just before 10am, and somehow my group of 5 was seated right away! We must've hit it at just the right time. Our waitress was very attentive and got our orders placed very quickly. She made sure our coffees were full and drinks replenished. She was also very helpful for my friend who had questions about gluten free options. The restaurant is very accommodating and even has a (long!) gluten free menu. I ordered the mixed berry pancakes, which also came with two eggs and meat. Lots of food! I couldn't finish it all. The berries came on top of and inside the pancakes. Super good. And the pancakes were a moderate size, not quite as big as my plate, which is exactly how much I like to see. My friend ordered the French toast and was also offered eggs and a meat. We were surprised to get so much with our meals. She actually turned down the eggs and meat. I'm not sure if the price was changed to reflect that. The location is brand new and beautiful. Lots of natural light and very clean. They even have a small little bar area you can sit at. The cocktail menu is impressive for a little brunch joint! We didn't get any drinks, but I might just have to try a specialty mimosa next time. read more

Biscuits and gravy... unfortunately my fellow patron didn't like the gravy much. It had the sausage outside of the gravy, but gravy flavor. Kutos on the biscuit and potatoes though. The blackened eggs Benedict was good best hollandaise sauce, tomato a cool touch, but burnt crumbled bacon ruined it. Wish it was Canadian bacon it would've been awesome. All in all I was inspired to review because the service top notch. Offered samples, cute cups for coffee purchases and the waiter, drink deliverer and all offered recommendations and their time excellently. read more

See all

Good food, decent service. Quirky inside. Very fun experience if you like more out there restaurants

Our server Ashley was wonderful. She was super helpful, service was great, and very professional. Definitely will be dining again. Our hostess Lily was also very polite and helpful suggesting food. She cleaned up our plates very quick and service was great. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Excellent Bloody Mary - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Sheena did a great job waiting on us today! Professional and courteous too. Food could have been a little bit more flavorful. My grits and shrimp needed more spices like salt and pepper or Cajun. It is a New Orleans plate. Maybe, add some umbrellas for outside heat and shade into the budget. Coffee is always delicious. Our server was phenomenal! read more

Have eaten at the Pensacola FL site and loved it. Godiva chocolate chip pancakes so good as was the eggs Benedict. Service very good and friendly staff. read more

My husbands shrimp and grits were awesome!!! I had the crab cake dish, don't order that! Staff was very nice and attentive. I'll go back to try something else. read more

Honestly one of the best breakfast places I have ever been to. Menu is by far the best thing here. They have so many amazing and unique options. I could get a new thing every time and would be so happy. The actual food itself is pretty good. Not much to complain about. The bloody mary is actually good. I would get a few of those any time. Great place but very small in the winter due to being all indoors. read more

My boyfriend and I came this morning, our first visit. We checked in through this app, so we had almost no wait when we got there. The service was fast and lots of people were walking around making sure we had everything we needed. I ordered the cinnamon roll French toast. It comes with your choice of egg and either sausage or bacon. I chose the sausage and scrambled eggs. The French toast was great, the eggs were basic, but the sausage was interesting. It was very herby. It wasn't bad, just wanted to give a heads up for others. My boyfriend got the chicken and waffles, it was great! They had a great variety of cocktails as well. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Nate was a great server check all the boxes , fast friendly, knowledgeable and funny. The food was hot fresh and tasty . Great spot for a great tasting food in finshers read more

We had a return visit and this place did not disappoint. Service was attentive, food piping hot, and delicious. We had two of the seasonal selections and would highly recommend. Rum cake french toast - yum and chicken piccata Benedict. Another Broken Egg back on our breakfast circuit!! read more

This place is awesome! Had the chicken and waffles...so good! Drinks were on point! The menu have a little of everything. Just try it! Very nice ppl. read more

My favorite breakfast spot! Consistently yummy food and great service! My favorite dish is the Crab Cake Benedict and their coffee is much better than your typical restaurant coffee. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Crab cake Benedict - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

I am so happy I found this place! We arrived on a Sunday morning around 10 and were seated immediately, but shortly after it got pretty busy in here. It is a smaller cafe near Louvino in the municipal circle complex so you will need to park in the garage or if you're lucky you can find some parking spots in the circle. You can join the waitlist via yelp which is an added bonus. Service was very speedy and our waitress checked in on us often to see if we needed anything. For my gluten-free fan club they even have a specific two-sided menu just for you! If there's something on the regular menu too that you'd like your waitress can help you figure out if that can be prepared gluten free too. I personally ordered the Monterey Omelette without the sauce (as the waitress informed me that there was gluten in there) with a side of fresh fruit and a gluten free pancake. The omelette was a good size, covered with cheese, and topped with slices of avocado. My fruit cup had pineapple, strawberries and blackberries, and some melon, and indeed tasted pretty fresh. My omelette was cooked to perfection- it was nice and fluffy and had tons of flavor with the various spices and vegetables. I was also pleasantly surprised with my gluten free pancake. This was my first experience trying one as a matter of fact and I'm not so scared now. The pancake was not as fluffy as the traditional style, as to be expected (there was a little but of fluffiness) but still very soft and had a nice texture. The pancake was slightly sweeter than normal too, which I enjoyed. read more

See all

The kiwi mango mimosas were awesome. The fruit bowl was out of the norm but amazing blackberries, kiwi, pomegranate and strawberry. The potatoes were super tasty. There isn't anything we did not like. Customer service goes above and beyond. The open and airy location is very refreshing. Our favorite is the blackberry stuffed French toast. Can't wait to come back! read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Amazing blackberry French toast. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

first time visiting in Castleton. Way overpriced for what we received. One small pitcher of mimosas w/mostly juice, a vegetarian omelette & huveos rancheros ....which was pita chips on top of very watery beans (weren't drained) & eggs. $70. Server never took away dirty dishes so we could work, took them inside ourselves. Not awful, but not good enough to ever go back. Back to Wild Egggs. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Excellent service! It was my first time here, a little skeptical about trying new places however my server KD made the experience all worth it! She explained all the questions I had on the menu and even gave me complimentary first time guest biscuit beignets! The pricing was average for great service and great food which made it an even better location for me to dine In. Definitely my new go-to breakfast place read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Pictured is an orange mimosa, southwest scramber with no meat and my choice of potatoes,and biscuit beignets - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

I would recommend checking in online before you go! The wait was very long but with Covid and half of the tables closed it is understandable. Once we got there we still had to wait quite a bit before were seated- almost an hour past our quoted time. The service and the food made up for the long wait. If you were in a hurry though I would not recommend a Saturday morning at this place. We were given a free order of been yeas because it was our first visit. I had chicken and waffles and my friend had an omelette both were delicious. read more

My family visited this location on Memorial Day and had a wonderful experience. We made reservations and got to sit outside on the patio which was beautiful. The food was delicious and we loved everything -- some of our favorites were the Tito's bloody mary's, eggs benedict, and beignets! Our server Amber was so nice and attentive and we were appreciative of all the suggestions, keeping us updated for when food was arriving, and accommodating our requests. Thank you for a lovely brunch and we will absolutely be returning to try more yummy dishes. read more

We tried ABEC for the first time today, for Father's Day, and it was wonderful. The Beignets were delicious and the lobster and brie omlette was to DIE for. They also offer mimosas that you can get by the glass or pitcher, the strawberry was very good. Bryan, our server, was amazing and we hope to get him again! He was wonderful with our little girls, which made breakfast that much better. read more

See all

Holy cow....everything was phenomenal! Biscuit beignets were a great start, the salted caramel (spiked) coffee was nice and strong (in a good way), and my hash brown Benedict was awesome. City grits were heaven! Service was slow, but it was busy. Our waitress wouldn't allow subbing out toast for a biscuit (just said no, not an up charge option thing), and the salted caramel rim was straight up table salt, my poached eggs were hard, but it happens. Would definitely return! read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Biscuit beignets - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

This place has a cool vibe. The staff is excellent! Okay the gold standard of course is Walker Bros. Coffee - very good, but too bad they don't use cream or half and half that isn't in the (Delight) small containers. I know cream in your coffee! I am part of the "He Men Coffee Lovers Club" so leave me alone! lol Orange Juice - Minute Maid I had the Blueberry Toast breakfast and it was excellent. From what I could tell everyone was raving about the food. The eggs Benedict looked amazing. Again the staff is amazing! read more

Rachel was our server, she was friendly, and introduced me to an amazing Eggnog drink! The food was perfect and our server made the experience wonderful! Will definitely come here again. read more

My server Olivia Pace was wonderful. Today was my birthday and she made me feel very special.

We love it here. We come twice a month. Service is great. Book ahead on the weekends if you dont want a oong wait.

A friend and I came here for brunch last weekend. We didn't know we could check in early, so we had to wait 40 mins but we grabbed a mimosa pitcher and chatted at the bar until we could be seated. The mimosa and food was DELICIOUS and we were seated within 40 mins. I'll definitely be back! read more

I was thrilled when I found out a new breakfast spot came to downtown Fishers. This is just what the area needed in the new buildings downtown. The menu had plenty of options, but not overwhelmingly so. I was pleased to see that there were some healthier options since restaurants serving breakfast do not always consider that. I chose a veggie omelette that was served with fruit and an English muffin. It was just the right amount of food and everything was delicious. The service was quick and my coffee was constantly refilled. There was a good amount of seating, but I can imagine that this place is a little small for the weekend crowd. read more

This was our first ever visit to this cafe for breakfast. We were welcomed & taken to be seated straight away. Our party ordered the chocolate Belgian waffle, huevos rancheros & coconut quinoa power bowls. Everything was so well presented & tasted fantastic. Their bold roast coffee was excellent. There's a great choice on the menu catering to different tastes. All staff were friendly & attentive. People of Indiana are lucky to have this cafe in their state! read more

This breakfast/brunch place was better than I thought! I've tried their blue cheese pancakes (highly recommend), shrimp and grits, French toast and biscuits+ gravy. The blue cheese pancakes are a must try, and the shrimp and grits were great as well! The French toast is quite eggy, but I personally like it that way. The service was outstanding, our waitress was super kind and I had two managers come up to make sure everything was good well. The food came out pretty quickly, too! The only downsides for me personally was that the prices are alittle high, and the wait even when you waitlist on yelp is alittle long. But other than that, this is a great place to try. read more

See all

This is a great weekend brunch spot - just make sure to check in before you go, the wait is usually pretty long. The portions are great, food is wonderful and the cocktails are a fun way to start your weekend. Cons: Food is a bit pricey, but you're paying for the in-fishers experience. I wish the place was a little bit bigger - it's a tight squeeze on the weekends when it's busy. read more

Just had the best breakfast at Broken Egg! Our server Rachel was awesome! I took her recommendation and got the salmon Benedict with the city grits - and it was amazing! Best Benedict I've had, (and grits) I'll be coming back again. read more

So good for hearty breakfast. Good selection across the board. Broad menu makes it hard to decide. This location is in an "urban expanse area" which means grouped in new wave shopping center in hip reconstruction. Some street work going on. Parking can be limited but on weekday morning no issue. Prompt seating and service. I jumped on the original Benedict. Executed well. Fresh squeezed OJ was awesome. It's cool and could see this being packed with hipsters for brunch on weekends without being pretentious. Will be back with skull cap and dog in tow to match the area. read more

If you're looking for an amazing breakfast place on a weekend, make sure you get on the waitlist ASAP. We've been to Another Broken Egg before so we expected the hour wait for a Saturday brunch and it is extremely worth it. This visit was unlike all the others though. Our waitress, Ashley, was completely fantastic. She was so sweet, interactive, and made our breakfast experience just fantastic. She worked with all the modifications we made with our orders, came with many many suggestions, and was just a joy to have as our server. The food was so delicious and the mimosas were amazing. Ashley made us feel so welcome. I hope we get her again the next time we come out. Edit: I also wanted to note that this place is very accommodating to vegetarians! I was able to substitute meat for avocado no problem. read more

I love this place! (Although, unpopular opinion: I don't find the biscuit beignets all that awesome. I know other people love them, but I'll just stick with my toast, thanks.) Super tasty food and very kind and attentive service. read more

Had a wonderful lunch and was served by the amazing Terri! She always made sure we were well taken care of. I was a server for 5 years and it was a pleasure to be served by her! LOVE YOU TERRI read more