Saturday afternoon lunch did not disappoint. We ordered some beers, the eggplant Marino, and the square margherita pizza. Service was excellent, they doubled checked allergens for us and we had a lovely lunch. Food was great - loved the pizza and anticipate coming back To take advantage of some of their daily specials and to enjoy the patio. read more

See all

Even when the parking lot looks busy, this place rarely is. The staff is awesome. Great people who make your experience even better. We usually order takeout, but we have eaten here many times too. Pretty cool that the prep stations are at the entrance of the restaurant. Even if you are just picking up takeout, you can watch them make pizzas and put the finishing touches on garlic breadsticks. Anthony's does burn your pizza on purpose and yes... it tastes good. But this place NEEDS to be known more for their chicken wings. The classic wood fired wings smothered in caramelized onions will be my favorite, but they just added some dry rubs that are also phenomenal. Big wings, cooked perfectly, and that smoky flavor is not matched in Monroeville. read more

See all

Food was excellent. Service from Paypay B(Assuming not real name) was not good. Three times the server forgot to bring out all our food. We didn't get one of our Pizza's till we were done eating,so we had to take it To go. I tiped her accordingly. read more

These wings are not jumbo wings despite the menu description. Some were over cooked so trying to eat the meat was difficult, I gave up on a few. Chicken is forgiving but only to a certain point before drying up and becoming leatherlike. Paying $18.99+ tax ($20.32) for "10 Original Wings" equates to actually paying $20.32 for 5 whole wings, which is insane! For the first time in my life, I went to another place for the same type of food that I just ordered elsewhere to get something better. I ordered 3 whole wings from another restaurant that actually serves jumbo wings for $7.76 (tax & carryout fee included). The wings weren't dried, hard, or completely burnt and they were larger than Anthony's. I like Anthony's way of switching up the wing game but I won't be going back. Not for overcooked, small pieces at ridiculous prices. That being said, my server was very nice and cheerful. read more

I have been here a few times before but it has been a good 2 years since I was last able to visit . Upon entering, the hostess and a male server were fighting about taking a table, it made for quite the awkward entrance. Fortunately, another male server walked over and offered us a table which was super nice. We sat a low top by the bar and admired all of the famous entertainers photos on the wall . We had mojitos and an Italian lemonade , delicious ! For food, we ordered the Stromboli , meatballs and Italian tuna sandwich. All were absolutely to die for ! Our waiter was very pleasant and we were overall very happy with our meal. read more

See all

Too expensive. Service was slow. Went at happy hour but didn't get happy hour drink price

The cauliflower pizza that we ordered today was not good. the cauliflower was not cooked properly, not marinated, it was dry. I have noticed it has been hit or miss lately. So next time can someone make sure this is taken care of? also, make sure each slice has equal amount of cauliflower. $25-$30 for a pizza I expect a exceptional pizza each time. read more

We dined in on a cold Sunday night, so it wasn't really busy but that's understandable. Our service was super friendly and quick and was really accommodating with our infant son! We started with the Caprese salad that was really good. I do think that it was overpriced considering it was two slices of tomato and two slices for mozzarella for $10. The pizza was cooked perfect in their coal fired oven. Would definitely go back and try some of the other dishes. read more

See all

The food and service are excellent! My favorite pizza location in the Monroeville area!

When I tell you the pizza was delicious & the eggplant was so flavorful They will let you do a half & half which is great because you can try 2 of the great combinations in one visit. My new buddy was Shaine because he was so much more than a server! Not only helped with menu selections he was attentive filled our drinks and confirmed to ensure. Top tier service because I don't like when I start with a Diet Coke and have a regular coke returned. He even brought a to go cup with ice for me when he brought the box to take home the rest of the tasty pizza that was perfect the next day in the air fryer. We had half ricotta, hot peppers & sausage and the other half was carnivore - loaded with meat! The restaurant is decorated with such classy pictures mixed with sport pictures and has an entirely cool vibe with an awesome mix of music that lets you hmmm & sway a bit as you enjoy the deliciousness of the food. It is a great place for a date or family dinner. Looking forward to trying the unique style of chicken wings that smelled and are served with sautéed onions! Well done all around read more

See all

Anthony's is always great - the meatballs and white pizza are the absolute best. Nicky waited on us and she was so fun and sweet. We have been many times and will be back again ! read more

A tale of two meals had a sausage sandwich here and it was amazing the next day I had the Alfredo which was a massive letdown.

If you order their pictured pies, they're priced as cheese, marinara and bread: soooooooooooo overpriced garbage.... The pictures are NOT accurate of what you'll get. These guys are garbage read more

Anthony's was amazing!!! It was some of the best pizza I have had. The garlic knots are where it is at! My wife didn't really care for the dressing on her salad. I had wings that were really good. It seemed family friendly and had a nice bar area with TVs. read more

Went in on a Saturday night service was friendly, but food was just "ok"-ordered the house, salad-way too much vinegar dressing, Pizza was OK. On top of everything, I forgot a small purse at the table, but when I called the next day, they said it could not be found... Sadly, I won't be coming back here read more

A good spot to grab some pizza, along with other menu items! Although it is not my favorite spot, it's a go to and is always consistently good! Worth a visit! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

See all

Great food and service. We've been coming here for years. We especially love hand tossed pizza with prosciutto , artichokes, and olives. The prices are good, atmosphere is cozy. The staff has consistently been excellent, friendly and professional. We rushed to the movie last night, Jesse brought the drinks and food super quick. The manager, Adam, changed TV upon the request. We made it to the movie on time. Thank you, Adam and Jesse, for your great service yesterday. read more

I love Anthony's coal fired pizza. They have one of the best pizzas you can get. The crust is always crispy and delicious. We loved the wings too (must have). The place is set up like a restaurant and not a dingy pizza parlor like a lot of other places. I like how you can see the people over the counter being clean along with the servers being people who are actually attentive and do a good job. I was thoroughly impressed with my experience here. read more

Sports Bar like restaurant. The prices are kinda high for pizza. Additional toppings on a pizza are $3 each with the cheese pizza starting at $14.99 for a 12 inch. For starters we got the wings 5 for $9.99. They came out warm not hot. The garlic knots are more like rolls. Those were good. Also had the "homemade" lemonade very syrup sweet. The thick cut (not really) pepperoni and sausage pizza. It was very oily from the pepperoni grease. It tastes good those especially the sausage nice and crumbly. Daughter had the White pizza and added spinach and prosciutto. Daughter kept asking for extra napkins but never got them. read more

See all

Here frequently. Always good service and food. No complaints. Fire. Lit. Lava. Tots. ......boom! read more

See all

Atmosphere boring. For the price, food mediocre. Salad had 1/2 hard boiled and 1/4 tomato. Pizza took a while to come out. When it did, 1/2 burned to a crisp. And, it was served! Did bring out another. Not worth the wait. Thin crust ok. Sauce tasteless. Not enough cheese. Did give first pizza to take home. Including the burned part. Guess they couldn't be bothered to throw it out. Head that Dan Marino is involved in chain. Don't think his Italian ancestors would be proud. read more

My son and I came to Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza after Christmas shopping at Miracle Mile. I liked the atmosphere, they have a nice seating area and a decent size bar. Our server was very attentive and friendly. We started out with some garlic knots, which were ok. We also split a pizza. We did have cheese and half Kalmatta Olives. I really liked the sauce and cheese. The olives gave a nice salty touch. Definitely a pretty good meal! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

See all

Pizza comes well done, wings are excellent and the white sangria definitely tasted like apple. Our service was excellent! It's a little on the noisy side. read more

See all

We have been here at their location and a few others and have always enjoyed the pizza, wings and especially the meatballs!! I get the kettle of meatballs to go at least once a month. This time we had a picnic family gathering in Boyce park in monroeville and decided to make it simple ! It was STEVE YOU ARW THE MAN !!' ordering with him was a joy ! The service and professional manor was appreciated! Call and talk to them, yes you can order on line but the extra care given over a phone call or I. Person is so much better. The meal was great ! Thank you STEVE for making our picnic a success read more

See all

We were hesitant to try something so different, but Paulie's Pie was phenomenal. The pepper's were sweet and well roasted, the sausage was packed with flavor, and the ricotta balanced everything out. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Paulie's Pie 16" - Pizza Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

My boyfriend has been wanting to try this for months now, so we got takeout last night for dinner. The worker at the front was very kind but we both forgot to grab my cans of pop, went back in and got them with no issue. Now the food, I love a good coal fired pizza but this one seemed to be a bit more charred on the edges than I like. My boyfriend didn't like the pizza at all, nor did he like the sauce because almost every bite he took had a huge chunk of tomato. We prefer the tomato's to be more fine in our pizza sauces. The garlic knots were good but also a little burnt on some of them. I did enjoy the Caesar salad, I was excited for the croutons but they were soft. If you like chunkier pizza sauces I'd say this is your place! read more

See all

We went to Anthony coal fire pizza on 9 4 25 for lunch we ordered salad tuna sandwich , pizza ,chicken wings, mozzarella slices with tomatoes everything was delicious the staff was friendly and accommodating our server was excellent hats off to Anthony fire coal 5 stars were definitely going back service was excellent read more

After a very long day, Saturday night my daughter, my guy and I went to one of our favorite eateries and decided to eat at the bar as the seating was comfortable. Bronlyn was the fab bartender who quickly brought our Kentucky bourbon chilled to perfection beers in the perfect goblets. She was above and beyond as our server while she took care of everyone at the bar. We started off with their amazing Caesar's salad to share, the original wings with sautéed onions which were the best we've ever had. The large pizza, all with sweet peppers and one half with crispy prosciutto and half with pepperoni was served piping hot as she plated a piece for each of us. She made our night even better due to being friendly, attentive and so on point. Oh, don't forget to be a member of their rewards program for special offers and points accumulated for future savings! Price point worth every well spent penny. Thank you Bronlyn and Anthony's! Love the atmosphere, TV in our view and the staff being ever so polite and helpful with great attitudes and sense of humor! read more

See all

Brandon, you are the best man, you do it all, great mojito, good server. Everything just as ordered, and brought out promptly. I always love the Caesar salad with fresh dressing, idelicious, although, a little disappointed in the croutons, too soft. I tried a new appetizer, an eggplant Marino. Thinly cut, fried and covered in marinara sauce with parmigiana cheese, then baked, very good. Pizza is always good, our favorite in the 'burgh. Perfectly done, crispy on the edge, because they use a 900' coal oven, hard to find. Brandon suggested we join the rewards program. Why not?! We'll be back! read more

Amazing food and great service. My husband and I sat at the bar. We were given samples of the beer on tap and the white and red sangria so we could make a good choice on something we would enjoy - and it worked! We each found something we liked and ordered a drink. For food - we had garlic knots (complimentary since it was our first time there), the house salad - get a small and split it as the small is quite large - chicken wings with the dry rub, and the Margherita pizza. The bartender gave us a free meatball to try also and it was amazing. I have not eaten that much in a long time! Highly recommend trying this restaurant! The bartender also shared with us they have a rewards program where you get a free pizza when you sign up. We don't live in the area so we didn't sign up but we will eat here again when back in town. read more

The service is abysmal on the weekend. They get orders wrong and are disrespectful when they are asked to correct it. Grubhub does not help. They do not listen to instructions and state "it's not their problem ", when you complain. I'm good. Will not return. read more

Once again totally disappointed. I used to work for this restaurant many years ago under Anthony himself, and he would totally be ashamed of what is served from this restaurant. The pizza was hardly baked, we come here for the coal fired pizza. It's supposed to be "well done" . Wings we're so over cooked they were like jerky. Salad was blah. Garlic knots were so chewy they were inedible. Totally horrible experience. The kicker was ordering curb side, calling the store multiple times with no answer, and seeing employees outside smoking. I had to go in and was still ignored for about 5 mins. read more

Wow, this pizza is thin and crispy. Hands down the best pizza I have had in Monroeville, PA. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - My left overs. - Pizza Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

See all

The oven does not compliment or match the dough recipe. Something is off. The oven should enhance the flavor of the dough. I think this might be the wrong style of pizza dough. Maybe it was not cooked correctly. Idk. I'll try again and take a closer look. Pizza was ok. Meatballs and sauce were good. Service was very good. The restaurant overall has a nice, warm, welcoming ambiance. read more

This is an absolute staple for lunch. I havent had too many pizzas places that I appreciate this much in the pittsburgh area. Great selection of different pizzas. A personal favorite is the carnivori, I end up getting the large and I have dinner for days. Their chicken wings are not joke either, extremely moist interior, crispy exterior and they have a wonderful flavor. The staff here are so expedient and delightful, will be coming back frequently. read more

The pizza was pretty good... It The sauce and cheese were fantastic but the crust was super crispy. I am not a huge fan of crispy crust, however hubby seemed to really like it. The drinks were also pretty good but also quite pricey. The service was very friendly! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

Personally I love the pizza & dry rubbed wings @ Anthony's! In fact I love the dry rub wings so much I save the leftover dry rub in the box for my own wings. But that's just me! The pizza has a terrific crust & the rest of pizza has a unique taste. It seems like every Friday night we order from Anthony's. If you go online you can save a little money as well. Can't wait until next Friday! Yummy! read more

It went above and beyond my expectations. The pizza crust was baked just right in their coal oven. Sauce was seasoned just right, not too sweet or spicy. Toppings were generous and fresh. Salad was tasty and fresh as well. The server was attentive and friendly. Nice atmosphere Classic Italian Salad and Italian Classic Pizza read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - a half eaten pizza - Pizza Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

Outstanding pizza! The dough is amazing. Service was very quick and pleasant. The décor is tastefully done, and the place had a nice, friendly vibe. I'll definitely be coming back. read more

See all

The pizza is absolutely delicious here but it's way overpriced. Go to BLAZE Pizza its close-by instead and it's WAY more affordable and its absolutely delicious too. read more