Ashley was our Bartender-Server. She was excellent. It was around 3pm, with only two customers. The location was extra clean. We just missed lunch menu but arrived for Happy hour 3pm to 6pm. $5 menu appetizers and $ off bottle beer. Cold beer, the meatball sliders on garlic knots were excellent. The meatball, sausage, bacon, pepperoni pizza with extra cheese amazing. I have not had a better pizza in South Florida. The leftovers were just as good. Fresh tossed crust could not be, brick oven cooked perfectly. Unbelievable. read more

See all

Here now on 8/18 4:35 pm and sign says closed due to maintenance. I wish that information was reflected on all sites to avoid the drive I just made. read more

Went in today for my "birthday pizza on us!" today for lunch. They wanted $5 for it. Obviously they do not understand what the parent company means by the words "on us". The manager told me the rules have been changed recently. But not before I got my birthday email. So I walked out. Honestly, the pizza's not that great anyway. So small. A slice can fit literally in the palm of my hand! Never going back. Hope upper mgmt. reads this. No stars, Obviously. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Italian Near Me - Wellington, Florida

I had their "pizza" this past Monday and what an absolute disaster. The site said it would take approximately 20 mins to complete. I waited the 20, went inside (the place smelled like sewage for some reason??), and picked up my order. The pizza had been sitting there for so long that it was probably warm at best. Finally we get home and open the box...I've had better pizza from my high school cafeteria years ago. The cheese looked cheap, the sauce was barely present albeit the few dollops we got were heavy. It looked like they place the sauce on the dough and forgot to actually spread it around. The flavor itself? What flavor?! I added salt, pepper, red pepper flakes, olive oil. Noting helped. Do yourself a favor and get pizza from literally anywhere else. It's a shame how far from grace Anthony's has fallen, absolutely unpalatable. read more

Always great service, food ambiance! Always spotless and beautiful! Matthew is a one man wrecking crew!! Wow! He is service with a smile! Was constantly checking on me and the other tables! He deserves a raise!! Great new options on the menu! Their desserts are not to be missed! I highly recommend! read more

See all

Good clean pizza. A little loud for dine in for my tastes but the pizza is made with fresh, tasty ingredients that somehow leave you feeling light after eating. Will return. read more

I came in to order to go food and it took over 30 minutes to arrive.Not only that they only have one server working the entire restaurant who was doing her job but the kitchen cannot keep up. I am personally a server in the restaurant business and I understand to be patient at times however this was just ridiculous. Also the server tried defending the kitchen staff when my food finally arrived by saying "you know 28 minutes is actually a good ticket time for our kitchen staff, we only have two people working back there". I will not be returning to this location ever again. Absolutely not the way a restaurant should be ran. read more

We were missing the focaccia in our wings that was a 40 piece wings for $43. They were also overcooked and not their typical great flavor. The large carnivori pizza came cold. The three kids meals came fine other than the fact that there was hair in the pepperoni pizza. I asked for a side of balsamic and I did not receive it. I love Anthony's, but this is possibly the worst experience I've ever had. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Italian Near Me - Wellington, Florida

If your looking for an actual pizza do not order a margarita pizza. Called in and ordered and they did not specify this Was a flat bread and not an actual pie. Slices were cut extremely thin to make it look like 8 slices , it was really maybe 4. Not filling, a small was 24$ over priced and bad service. Manager did not honor a single thing for this error due to the store. Very deceiving , go elsewhere if you want more bang for your buck and quality read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Flat bread - Italian Near Me - Wellington, Florida

Amazing pizza. Great crust, sauce stands out compared to other pizza places around it and their thick pepperoni w/ honey pizza is amazing

Shout out to LIZ in Wellington, FL. She jumped in When the pizza counter & carryout were swamped on a Sat evening & she turned it all around in 15 min! While waiting for my to-go order, I watched her check food quality, pull items from the coal oven, box or plate & take to table, and follow up with carry-out!!! She single handed got the team through the weeds & I also noticed everyone was very attentive to their specific job, it was just a super busy evening! Way to go, Liz, my pizza was delish & every restaurant should be lucky to have a LIZ!!! read more

Heard good things about there wings but wasn't what I expected . I like fresh small wings that's deep fried and add sauce . These wings are oven baked , char broil with a sauce . It's like going out to a restaurant and ordering chicken . Taste was fine , but wasn't anything I expected for chicken buffalo wings . Plus , does not come with carrots , so I knew something was off . Heard their pizza is good , so if I go there , I try the pizza instead . I did order from there online service and that worked ok read more

We were in the plaza to get DOG food (see my prior review) & decided to give Anthony's another shot. It was 6 pm and only one table had people eating. Should've taken that as a sign but we sat down, were greeted immediately by our waitress (a really nice girl who seems to truly love her job). Ordered the wings we've always loved, but they fell flat. Where was the 2 large pieces of fresh focaccia?? The small slivers were hard and stale. Pizza. Where is the coal-fire?? Where's the sauce? The eggplant marino pie had one layer of eggplant. It used to be heavy & thick. By the time we left, there were a decent amount of customers, most from the 55 & over communities nearby. Maybe that's why the pizza has no salt? No flavor? This is definitely my last review of Anthony's. The place could also stand a facelift. Farewell. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Thinnest eggplant marino pie we've ever seen - Italian Near Me - Wellington, Florida

Cannot understand how this pizza restaurant is rated so highly. Super expensive and soggy pizza, as far as taste goes 1to10 give it a 3... Will not return, many pizza pick-up shops superior and less expensive.. read more

We stopped by on a moderately busy Tuesday evening for a quick bite of Coal fired cheese pizza and Garlic knots. Both were delicious and served right on time. In addition the service was excellent, our server was very responsive to our requests and checked on us to ensure we were happy with the food and nothing else was needed. The ambiance was nice but seating area is very limited. They will have to make accommodation for a party of 8 or above. There is a small outdoor seating area as well. If you enjoy coal fired pizza than Anthony's is a must check out spot read more

See all

Huge disappointment time and time again. We had the worst experience the last couple of times at this location so we stopped going and we decided to try it again after 2 years of not going here. We were greeted at the door (or should I say not greeted) by the hostess who said something about a ticket being late. We had no idea what she was telling us so my husband asked her to clarify what tickets are you talking about. Then she said there was no staff available and that we would be able to sit down but our food wouldn't come for 30 minutes. So we said it was fine, as long as we could get some drinks. We were seated and we just watched our waitress pass our table back and forth without any acknowledgement. 20 minutes later, I asked another sever if we could get some drinks and she said that we would have to wait for our server because she was extremely busy which we understood because she wasn't our server. Our server finally came over to us and asked us if we would like something g to drink but at this time, we had just started to stand up to leave when she came over. We told her that we were leaving and she said okay bye. No apology or is there something we can do. It's okay because we'll never go back. Keep your meatballs and your Ron. Service is still horrible!!! Shame on us for thinking there would be any kind of change with this place! read more

I tried the Mike's hot honey wings and preferred them over the roasted chicken wings that come with the onions. Food and service was great at the bar and a tv to enjoy sports in a few places inside. Many specials for the week and To Go for those as well. read more

See all

Wellington Anthony's Coal-Fired Pizza - $78 for a Soggy, Inedible Mess I placed an online order for two large pizzas, expecting a decent meal. Instead, I got a total disaster. They didn't follow my order instructions, gave me the wrong toppings, and somehow managed to serve something that was both floppy and soggy when I specifically requested well-done. Order Instructions? Completely Ignored. I clearly asked for well-done pizzas, yet what I received was the opposite--a limp, wet, undercooked mess. The crust was so soft and soggy that it folded in half when I picked up a slice. It was like eating raw dough with barely any structure. The Pizzas Were Inedible Let's break it down: * Crust? Soggy, floppy, and completely undercooked. * Cheese? Oily, uneven, and pooling in certain areas while non-existent in others. * Sauce? Watery and tasteless, like they used a hose to rinse it onto the dough. * Toppings? Wrong. Plain and simple. What I ordered was nowhere to be found. For $70 + an $8 tip, I expected at least something remotely edible. Instead, I got a pizza that was borderline raw. The Manager's Response? Insulting. When I called to complain, I was met with zero accountability and a ridiculous excuse for a resolution. The manager only offered half off ONE pizza or a discount on my next order. Why would I ever order from here again? That's like being served garbage and being told, "Don't worry, next time it'll be slightly cheaper!" No thanks. Corporate Needs to Step In NOW This is beyond bad service--it's an absolute failure. If this is how Wellington Anthony's operates, they need to shut down or get completely new management. The food was a joke, the service was even worse, and their attempt at "fixing" it was laughable. Final Rating: A Complete Waste of Money This place is a disgrace to pizza. Do yourself a favor and never, ever order from here. At least if McDonald's get your order wrong, they'll make it right... or literally anywhere else! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Italian Near Me - Wellington, Florida

Best fried eggplant ever! Had the hot honey pizza too. Plus the prosciutto sandwich. This place never disappoints!

Stefanie is a very nice person and the pizza is the best!!! The cesar salads, is the true cesar sause, Love this place read more

Get the classic wings. Get any pie. I'm a classic pepperoni girl and we added fresh garlic. My eyes rolled back. Also Paulie's pie, picture here, was cheff's kiss. I have a feeling the whole menu slaps. Just go. You won't be sorry. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Paulie's pie - Italian Near Me - Wellington, Florida

Let me start with something nice. The salad was good. Arrived at 5:40 and requested outdoor seating. I was told that the wait was less than 10 minutes because one of the tables was paying (this was after I was told I couldn't be seated at one of the tables because it was broken). We needed to sit out because we had our dog with us. I wait for a while and then grab a drink at the bar while my husband sits outside with our dog. After I order my drink, I'm told that the hostess made a mistake and the people weren't actually leaving and it would be about 20 minutes. Ok, fine. 40 minutes after arrival, the table is empty but it still has to be cleaned. The hostess let me know they are working to clean the table. I attempted to pay for my drink at the bar for over for 10 minutes, zero response from the bartender. Since the table is finally ready, I head outside to eat, finally. As we sit at the table and wait and wait, I notice people sit at the bar where I had been sitting, my trash still there as the bartender speaks to the new patrons. Our waiter comes over, we place our full order as we have known what we wanted for a very long time at this point. We place our order at 6:24 pm. Water for my husband, rolls, salad and pizza. The rolls were delivered at the same time as the water, and just as cold at 6:36, twelve minutes later. At that time, I ordered a Stella At 6:46, ten minutes later, my Stella finally comes out, we are told that the keg had popped.6:52, pizza is finally delivered, we are offered fresh plates which we sat yes too. They are delivered while our dirty plates and glasses are left. We finish our pizza and my beer stays empty, I never got my 2 for 1. Our plate is full of dirty dishes while we wait for the check. The check arrives, it takes more than 5 minutes to return with a receipt to sign. Overall, this was a 0 out of 10 experience. If we had been told up front that it was going to be a 45 minute wait, we would have left. The service was horrible, and the food was mediocre at best. I used to love this place, I'm not sure what happened. read more

See all

Classic Anthony's salad, pizza and wings. Always fresh and hot. Great server and service. However- they use a portable machine to take payments. It suggests the tip amount. I was planning to tip 25%, but that percent showed a tip of $9.92 on a $33 check. $10 on $33 is way more than 25%!!! I've seen these table-side systems before but the math was always right. Be careful and check the math!! read more

ordered a 12" pizza with extra toppings. sausage, onions and hot peppers. two slices did not have any sausage. another slice didn't have any onion. I don't mind paying extra for the extras but would like them to be on the pizza. Like other successful restaurant, Anthony's has substituted quality for profits. shame on them. Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza is dead to me!!!!! read more

Pizza I must say is phenomenal!!! The staff here are Superb! And it's a perfect lit place for a small intimate date or even a family night out! So completely recommend ! The garlic rolls are so so good!! The pizza is amazing! I kept pushing this place aside until I folded and to be honest I'm glad I bent the knee it was just fabulous! They have excellent family cheese pizza nights and I'm guessing daily specials too! Seem like they were regulars still speaking highly of this pizza place too! I loved both of our servers the two times we have been ! Sign up for the points too!! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - This was half pepperoni and half PAULIE'S ( with sweet pepper not spicy peppers ) - Italian Near Me - Wellington, Florida

Ordered from Uber eats last night so can't comment on what the place is like inside. Ordered a meat ball pizza (added Italian sausage), so good!! Always love their meat ball. (You can order a pot of meat balls too! So good). Last night we also ordered some wings, half original (comes with cooked onions on top) and half dry rub, both are so good!! I have had their salad in the past too and that's always consistently delicious. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Meat ball pizza 16 inch plus Italian sausage - Italian Near Me - Wellington, Florida

See all

We love Anthony's! The food is always delicious. Stephanie was our server tonight and she was phenomenal. She was friendly, attentive and on point. Kevin, the bus boy, was hustling! read more

Terrible pizza tonight. They said the oven was broken. They offered to make another pizza, but if the oven is broken, how would it be different. They charged me for the pizza as well. Just awful. This I guess has been an ongoing problem. A couple of weeks ago, they were closed at 8pm because the oven was broken. read more

lunch specials in picture website don't match what is served plain and simple deception

First time trying ACFP. Went on a Friday night, this location was a bit busy when we walked in. Unfortunately, we ended up standing there waiting a bit too long with no assistance. So, we decided that might be a bad sign and walked out. It was then that the manager Liz ran out and stopped us. She apologized and convinced us to come in. I won't get into everything that Liz did to turn around the experience, but let's just say she went above and beyond to ensure our first visit was a memorable one. The wings and pizza were delicious and the service from Liz was great. She made sure everything was perfect, making up for a one-off short staffed evening. So, big thanks to her. We will definitely be back. And I recommend giving this place a try if you're looking for a new pizza spot. read more

Tasty pizza with one of the best tomato sauces I've tasted and crispy crust. Fresh salad.

When my boyfriend and I want to enjoy a low-key dinner out and are craving pizza, Anthony's is are go-to!! The coal fired pizza is so good. We always order a salad and wings to start then get a 16" pizza, all to share. We usually get a pepperoni pizza but our last visit we saw one with prosciutto and arugula (definitely next on our list). The restaurant has a fun vibe! There's pictures of, I'm assuming the owner, with a bunch of different celebrities and historic pictures of the restaurant's origin. They have indoor, outdoor and bar seating. Our server was great! Very friendly and quick to get our orders out. We were pleasantly full when we left and had some leftovers which still tasted delicious the following day. The price vs. value is spot-on! I would recommend Anthony's to a friend and my boyfriend and I will definitely be planning more date nights there in the future. read more

See all

The service was very poor. We ordered 2 different pizzas and they had placed the sauce on top of the pizza. Which made some slices extremely saucy and some with no sauce. Horrible experience. read more

This is by far my favorite pizza! I get the Paulies pie so gooood! The hot peppers are very spicy so be careful if you do order them. This will forever be my favorite pizza I have yet to find a place a good. I've had pleasant service every time I've gone there (many times) and some days it can be busier than others but always an enjoyable environment. read more

Highly disappointed, my wings were burnt and. hard, one looked eaten! Was so looking forward to eat here, not anymore! At the Wellington location, state Rd 7 read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - See the wing looks half eaten! - Italian Near Me - Wellington, Florida

Super disappointed that we had drinks, appetizers and then ordered a large order or the original wings and pizza. (Our Bartender was very generously tipped - we don't play around- she is happy) BUT!!!!!---- The wings had ZERO bread pieces in the package. Isn't that what they are known for? Wings and yummy bread chunks???? The Anthony's wings with sautéed onions and triangle cuts of bread are what they're known for; super popular appetizer. Thumbs down. We spent a boatload on drinks and our wings were overcooked with ZERO signs of the yummy bread they come with. What's up with that?!?! Just eh... read more

Meatballs are where it's at. I don't know why they got rid of the baby meatball pot. Bring it back. Also the cauliflower pizza is amazing. The eggplant app is amazing. Fun overall fancy pricey pizza but they use good ingredients and big sizes read more

If you're reading this please wake the F-Up! Customer appreciation went out the window with this disaster. If YELP had a minus column which YELP should have, this place would be a prime example. Fist off just look at the pizza, they had us wait 1hour and 20minutes for. I get it it's Friday your busy yada yada yada save it for your Monday meeting. A picture is worth a thousand words but I'm adding a few more. The so called pizza chef should be fired and never allowed near anyone's oven. The fact this was ordered at 8:50pm and arrived at 10:15pm and then to get this was a joke. This was the Wellington location. So Mr Manager you need to get a handle on your quality control! There is no excuse for a restaurant to dish up this type of service to paying hard working customers. You seriously need to show this to your staff and use it as an example of what kills small business! read more

I'm a fan of Anthony's. I started going to his restaurants in Fort Lauderdale when they first opened. I used to eat there frequently when I worked in downtown Fort Lauderdale. We've been to several of these CFP ones including a couple in the Tampa and Orlando area. The kids like pizza and the adults do too. And when we've treated family it's not too expensive, either. We were meeting my college girlfriend and her husband. Sue is a vegetarian so their pizza and salad is a good option. Little did we know when I suggested meeting here was that her husband's favorite pizza is from an ACF nearer to their home. We walked in on a Saturday night and they were packed! Almost every table was taken. I wasn't expecting that. Luckily Sue had gotten there early and snagged one of the last open tables. It also turns out that we both are part of their rewards programs. In fact, Ed has just taken advantage of a Father's Day promotion to buy a gift card for $50 and get $20 in gift cards for yourself. We enjoyed a well done mushroom pizza and their house salad. We both ordered the same thing but they got it in the larger size so Ed could have leftover pizza to take to with for lunch. The service was fast and friendly. The food cooked perfectly. And we weren't even rushed from our table to leave as we lingers to chat. We know we will be back here again, soon... read more

Best in town from scratch great atmosphere and great personal we will be back every week