Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Arbella Insurance

    2.5 (2 reviews)
    Closed 8:30 am - 5:00 pm

    Services - Arbella Insurance

    Car and truck insurance

    Homeowner or property

    Vehicle

    Arbella Insurance Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Arbella Insurance

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Arbella Insurance

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Auto Insurance 270 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Arbella Insurance Group - Team Arbella at the Stop the Stigma Walk to support Interfaith Social Services.

    Arbella Insurance Group

    (174 reviews)

    I had my homeowners and auto insurance with Arbella for many years. Recently I changed to Geico…read morefor the auto insurance because it was half the price. The only two claims I have ever had with Arbella were two homeowner claims in the last three years (for $16k ice dam damage in 2015 and $7k for damage from a pinhole leak in a copper pipe) but this was enough for them to decide (at first) not to renew my policy. After posting this review on Yelp! I received a phone call from Bearingstar Insurance, agent for Arbella. They have now offered to renew my policy and I have accepted their offer. I am grateful for their follow-up to my complaint on social media, although it would have been even better had they listened the first time when I called them up after receiving my notice of non-renewal. I have therefore raised my rating to three stars and thank Megan (who commented on this review) for her assistance in this matter.

    Well, their client tried to kill me when totaling my car in November 2025. They made me go 42 days…read morewithout a car. I'm trying to be reimbursed for my rental car that I had to pay out of pocket for because Arbella WOULD NOT accept liability even though my police report CLEARLY STATED THEUR CLIENT IS 100 percent at fault. So now, not only did I lose an $8k vehicle they've stuck me with a $2600 rental car bill. I asked to be contacted by a supervisor because David was NO Help. He just ghosted me not once but 2 times! I wouldn't use this insurance company. Considering I could have died. I was lucky to not get injured but we were both going about 40miles an hour for an almost head on collision. You're going to have to fight to get your money. And looks like they're sticking me with a bill their client is liable for. The photo is HER car!

    Cleary Insurance

    Cleary Insurance

    (2 reviews)

    One star is generous for this place. I obtained an insurance policy through their agent Jenn. She…read morecompletely lied to me about what my options for insurance were. Specifically, she told me the largest deductible I was allowed to have was $500.00 because that is required by my car's lien holder. Additionally, she told me my lien holder required I have to have specific amounts of coverage, in the hundreds of thousands of dollars. I was foolish enough to think she was honest and have insured through them for over a year. I actually spoke with my lien holder yesterday who informed me that none of those things were true: my deductible can be $1,000 and the limits she said I had to have are not only false they are ridiculous given what car I have and the fact I have no assets. Basically, she lied so I had to pay for a much more expensive policy than was necessary. When I confronted her with her lies her response was to lie again and say that what she told me was "it was her company's policy" to have these limits - - 100% NOT TRUE!! Their only "company policy" is to screw people over so they can make more money. DO NOT DO BUSINESS WITH THIS PLACE!!!

    Cleary 'bought' my policy from another agency. I never heard a word from them-no friendly…read morecheck-ins, no calls to make sure we had the right coverage/enough insurance,...nothing. Last month, when a tree came through our roof, I couldn't even get the agent on the phone, and so I called the insurance company directly. An adjuster came right out to assess the damage, and the insurer cut a check. The only problem was that they paid it to a mortgagee who was paid off more than a decade ago. When I called the agent to get this corrected, he put it back on ME to deal with the insurer, but said he would call to 'get it expedited'-that the new check would be sent to me the day the insurer received the bad check back. As I have a giant hole in my roof and we live in New England, with really bad weather expected, I asked if I could txt or email a photo of the voided check to speed things up...he refused to even ask if that was an option. I asked him for the street address of the insurer, so that I could overnight the information...he said "they don't have one on their website, but I'll make sure they get the right check to you the day they receive the bad one." That was last week. I called the insurer today, and they've had the bad check since Monday, but never heard anything from the agent, and so didn't realize the urgency. They're cutting the check today. No surprise, the Cleary Insurance agent wasn't available to speak to me today, either. His only suggestion was to get the roof replaced before the claim was paid, because it's 'the homeowners duty to prevent further damage to the property". So at least we know he can read from the manual. I wish he knew how I might come up with an extra $10k from thin air to fix the roof before the claim is paid. These people take a commission from your insurance premiums and do NOTHING to help you when you need it. I told the lady in their office today that mine may be only one policy lost for them because of poor service, but I'll do everything one person can do to make sure others know how lazy and ineffective they are. I had to manage my own claim ENTIRELY. CLEARY INSURANCE DID NOTHING.

    Arbella Insurance - autoinsurance - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...