Best pizza in the 1000 Islands. Pair the pizza with an antipasto or some wings. Great river views on the deck. read more

Ordered a sausage pizza here once. It was cut into squares. Each square literally had precisely ONE PIECE OF SAUSAGE placed dead center in each square. I regret not taking a picture. CASH ONLY is a pain in the ass. read more

Pizza and location are great. Customer service, not so much. Too bad since it's such a classic staple in Clayton. Worth getting your pizza and enjoying it by the water! read more

Attilio's Pizza and Chicken - two slices missing - Pizza Near Me - Clayton, New York

The best pizza ANYWHERE!!! Always enjoy every bite. Nobody makes the crust/ sauce or sausage like Attilio's / Arts Jug. Highly recommend.

Should have read the reviews and skipped this place. Upon entering they tell you you have to put in your order and pay before you get your food, not a good sign. Then they say they don't take VISA or debit but you can use their ATM machine. I would have walked but friends just wanted to get seated and eat. So in we went and got seated on the balcony overlooking the river. It took forever for our food to come out. Not sure in whose mind this abomination is considered a pizza but as you have to pay up front you can't send it back! Pizza was square and made on an oven sheet pan. The crust was greasy, sauce was bland, and the cheese was, well just not melty good. I don't recommend. read more

Attilio's Pizza and Chicken - Abomination on a sheet pan - Pizza Near Me - Clayton, New York

Great pizza! A great place as well to sit and enjoy a few slices or a whole pizza out on the deck!! Prices are very reasonable as well. It's nice because a lot of the other restaurants in the area are much more pricey. You can smell the pizzas cooking from the sidewalk and that's what drew us in. Homemade dough and a delicious sweet sauce. We got a cheese and a pepperoni pizza and both were great. Staff is also very friendly!! A few other of these local places have sassy young girls who seem as if they'd rather be elsewhere. This one is run by a family who take pride in their business. No, it's not nice on the inside or even fancy at the least but the food is great! You go for the price and the taste, not the ambiance. read more

Attilio's Pizza and Chicken - a group of people sitting around a table - Pizza Near Me - Clayton, New York

Well, as pizza goes we've tried a lot across many states. Being located on the waterfront made us hesitate to try this place. Unfortunately we bought a 17 dollar "large" pizza. In most all shops it would be considered small. They apologized for putting the large into a small sized pizza box. You can see from the photo...it was a small. Cheese did not cover the pie. The sauce was pretty tasty. So for $17, gas station pizza has a lot more toppings for half the price.. read more

Attilio's Pizza and Chicken - Today's "large" pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Clayton, New York

Maybe things have changed since I went here, but when I watched them peel off sliced provolone to top the pizzas which they then plunked onto the moving toaster oven, I vowed that I would never eat their pizza again. I've had worse, but there's lots better in town than that. read more

After a day of boating there's nothing like docking downtown to pick up pizza here. A summer favorite. Always wonderful. Right on the water and walking distance from the docks. read more

This place is truly a small little restaurant on the St. Lawrence. Staff is super friendly this year and their pizza is to die for! You can tell their dough is homemade and their sauce. I think they said their sausage was homemade as well! Delicious true Italian pizza. Prices are fair considering their ingredients are fresh. Beautiful view of the water!! read more

Attilio's Pizza and Chicken - a view of the water from the deck - Pizza Near Me - Clayton, New York

Poor excuse for an Italian restaurant or pizza place. The pizza is frequently better quality at a gas station. And they use gas station pizza equipment. No conventional pizza oven, just the little conveyor belt convection. Thin soft crust. Ordered a large antipasto salad. Basically 1 head of iceberg lettuce, less than half a tomato, 4 peppers, half dozen olives, 1 slice of provolone quartered, one slice of provolone quartered, and a quarter cup of Italian dressing on the side. What a joke... read more

One thing that really gets in my craw is half assed food with snippy attitude. Heat rack pizza where I grew up is tantamount to fiscal suicide, but up here in Northern NY the throngs of mediocrity from Syracuse/Rochester with taste buds as bland as cement bricks keep this place and Foxy's alive. The gal working here looked at me like her mouth was stuffed with vinegar and lemon as well. It's Italian in name...but anybody from Providence, Connecticut, or Utica will probably get a good laugh here. read more

It smells so good from the outside, but the taste just does not live up to the wonderful aroma. Boring frozen stuff for appetizers, tasteless pizza.....edible, but forgetable. Location is great, but customer service is lacking. Been there twice, and both times was treated as if it was a pain to serve me. Don't bother with this place, keep walking.I gave it two shots, but that's it, I won't be going back. read more

I am reviewing this establishment as a take out place, thus 4 stars. Although, if it were for sit down service 2-3? We have eaten here several times over the past few years. We call ahead and pick up. No credit cards. I think the pizza is excellent. Sitting there and eating, service is sub par and most everyone is disinterested in your business. So if you want to pick up a pizza and bring it back home/on the boat/to the cottage- great place. Just don't forget your cash. read more

I just love how great the service is here. I had had this amazing chef named Adam, he makes a greats pizza that can't be beat anywhere else. They make their own wings and they are so amazing. They also make their own sauce that has the perfect sweetness and tanginess. Me and my family of five enjoyed our white pizza and our great broasted chicken. i recommend this place to anyone with a heartbeat. read more

Don't waste your time or money. They don't wear gloves, don't wash their hands, rip you off, and then get your meal wrong. You're better off at McDonald. read more

IF I COULD DO A 0 STAR REVIEW I WOULD Pizza tastes like it was pulled from the freezer and warmed up... You can only get cheese or pepperoni longer slices... the old lady who works there emptied the trash can on the back deck with no gloves.... then went back inside to continue preparing food WITHOUT washing her hands.... The young girl up front doesn't know what she's doing and make you wait for 5-10 min between customers... and then when we got to order, I gave her my order then she just ignored my girlfriend and and didn't take her order This place is a joke and I would not recommend stoping here to eat... we are here on vacation and with her not washing her hands now we have to worry about being sick on vacation... read more

I enjoyed my frozen DiGiorno's the night before better than this. But service was good, price good, and the view at sunset from the tables at the Clayton Pier couldn't be beat. read more

Great location and friendly staff was not enough to compensate for very doughy pizza. Buffalo wings were also very disappointing - they give you battered wings with a buffalo dipping sauce. Hopefully they can turn it around! read more

We were visiting from out of town and were given a memorable experience in the worst possible way. From the beginning of our experience we we were greeted by a less than knowledgable staff wearing t shirts stating what they did not have and what you, the customer, could not do. They do not accept credit cards. They do not have menus. They do not even have a bathroom. What they DO have is a can't do attitude. When we asked them for Parmesan cheese we were glared at and told to read their t shirts. The food here was over priced, greasy, and a poor excuse for pizza ( their specialty). I highly recommend that you don't waste your time or your money being mistreated at this poor excuse for a restaurant. read more

Limited toppings; sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, olives, green peppers. No bottled water, only tap. For 20$ pizza, I expect more, even if it was NYC. read more

Best pizza in Thousand Islands by far. Handmade sauce and dough are excellent. Breaded chicken wings are amazing. Service is slow when it is busy and it is busy a lot on the weekends. Still worth it! read more

Visited Aug 5 and 6 ,2019. Arrived at 8:30 and 8:00 pm respectively. Closed. Staff said they adjust hours when not busy. Disappointed. Love the view and look forward to this each Aug vacation. Needs to be better managed. read more

We had pizza and antipasto there this Thursday. They make their own pizza crust . Absolutely delicious ! We also had a platter w fresh mozzarella and tomatoes. Again , very fresh and delicious. The view is an added bonus . It was a delicious and wonderful experience. I will be returning soon ! read more

Outdoor seating overlooking water was great, but that's about it. Extremely overpriced pizza & wings. I've had better frozen pizza and their definition of a large is a small cookie sheet size. Wings weren't any better as they were served plain with buffalo sauce on the side. Poor excuse for pizza & wings. This place needs a lot of work on their recipes. read more

Loved the Pizza the staff was friendly and the deck has a beautiful view! St. Lawerence small town charm leave your city attitude behind and just enjoy. read more

Calling this hideous mess "pizza" is an insult to actual pizza. The conveyor oven and stacks of cookie sheets should have been a tip-off; what you will get is a minimal amount of sauce, cheese and toppings, on some kind of Bisquick "crust". It's horrifying. Don't waste your money. If you're looking for some good NY Pizza, you're not going to find it here. read more

The absolute BEST pizza in the North County! It is a weekly treat for us!!! Note: it is a BYOB place so bring your own beer! You can also come by boat...they have their own dock. Seating overlooks the St. Lawrence and Calumet Island. Gorgeous sunset views!!! read more

Unfriendly, rude staff. Passable but not exceptional food. I placed my to-go order with the unfriendly counter staff teen, paid cash for it and was told it wold take about 25 minutes. It was not busy and I saw only one other customer during my entire encounter. I took a walk and came back 20 minutes later to pick up the order. A different counter staff teen gave me my order, and was making to ring it up again when I told her I'd already paid for the order. She turned to the other worker and said "did she already pay?" When the other worker affirmed that indeed I had already paid for the order, she slid the box across to me. Not one "thank you" or pleasantry of any kind was ever uttered, no less any sort of apology for questioning the veracity of my stating I had paid for my order. The pizza wasn't so great that I'd put up with the rude staff to order there again. Update: same complaint, different counter staff. read more

Every time we were near this place it was closed for some different reason. Just frustrating!

Water Front dining is the best here, very lovely..I enjoy Attilio's Pizza and All their food, service is okay for the most part sometimes they could be a little rude and prices aren't wonderful. But nevertheless, I'm a fan and my stomach grumbles for their everything pizza with bread sticks. read more