Food, service, atmosphere (relaxed) very good. All food was good, but their homemade soups are…read moreoutstanding! Especially loved the tomato bisque.

Worst service and food ever. Orders completely messed up. Service not good at all didn't write down…read moreany of our orders and they both came back completely wrong. Cooks take no pride in their food. Could have got a better meal across the road at McDonald's. Probably at half the price also. Would not recommend anyone to waste their money on this place. Waited over an hour for food with only a couple of tables in the whole restaurant now I see why. Waitress really didn't care if she was there or not from the way she was acting. Will not go back ever again.

What could improve, clean up the place and the staff. Then manager is the owners daughter and is…read moreseldom there which is reflected by the staff. This bar is a place for local's to get trashed every night. The bathroom and rest of the building are reflective of the operation. The insect life includes roaches and bed bugs. The food has more grease than beef.

I can tell you from experience working there. It's nasty. you try to get the owner to do something…read more but he has his favorites and nothing will change. A lot of stuff that gets served is put dated or should be thrown away. the closing cook doesn't wrap any off the food up. leaves it open to air and bugs. the basement where they keep food is full of spiders and bugs and water.

Delicious food. Husband and myself had the Hot Beef sandwiches. They were so big, we could only…read moreeat 1/2 of it. Definitely going back.

Lively fun atmosphere with great friendly service! We tried the taco salad, potato skins and fish…read moredinners, all delicious! The fish & salads were perfectly crispy, veggies fresh, both Diet Pepsi & Coke (how great is that?) and fresh green beans with the fish (a wide array of sides to chose from). Will definitely return to try other items on the menu!

We visited there tonight, and was pleasantly surprised how well the food tasted. We almost missed…read moreit because it's towards the end of the building and we didn't see the sign at first don't let the building turn you away. The food was excellent. The young man that was working with very pleasant but does need to talk. Louder for the hearing impaired. I highly recommend this place. The fries were excellent, the pulled pork was excellent. Only suggestion I would say would be a bigger bun.

Very welcoming spot, customer service was pretty good and I didn't have to wait that long. I…read moremust've caught it at a great time because there wasn't that much traffic inside of the restaurant. My cheeseburger was very good, cooked with a slight pink in the inside, I'm not a fan of well done beef. The smoked wings were definitely "smoked" and was good as well. There was a lot of options on the menu, looking forward to coming back to this location and trying out the other options that they do have.

Not at all a good experience. We won't return…read more We went to Old City Hall for dinner to celebrate our 41st wedding anniversary. We made a reservation through their website, which sent us to the "Taost" app. When prompted in the app, we included info about food allergies and mentioned our anniversary. Though the app prompted us the provide this info, no mention was made of either at dinner. Though the dining room was almost empty, the hostess seated another couple at the table right next to us a few minutes after we sat down. As it turned out, I was closer to the man from this other party than I was to my wife....not an ideal setting for what was meant to be a romantic anniversary dinner celebration. It was especially annoying because there were so many other empty tables available. We each had a cocktail, (A "Mule" and a "Perjury"), which were excellent. Dinner was another story. Petite Caesar Salads were ok, not great. Chicken Picatta and Lobster Oreganata were horribly salty. The chicken and lobster were cooked alright but were almost inedible because of the saltiness. Either the "chef" didn't taste the sauces or didn't care. Either way, yuck! Never again.

Let's start with a positive... Our server Stacey was absolutely phenomenal! Her customer service…read morewas spot on. Her timing was amazing. She knew the menu and was absolutely excellent. But despite her best efforts and doing absolutely everything she could and beyond she couldn't fix the problems with the food. The chicken tenders and fries were absolutely amazing and delicious but everything else thereafter was a hot mess. There has been some sort of change with the menu, which I can only imagine is because of a change in the kitchen or ownership. I have to stress that whatever change happened to either the kitchen, the Chef or the ownership, the quality and taste of the food has gone absolutely down the drain. The chicken piccata was completely inedible because it was literally a nasty par boiled piece of chicken that was rubbery with nothing but butter and lemon as the sauce. Again, Stacey was fantastic and immediately took care of my concern and offered me another dish. Thank you Stacy. She recommended the jambalaya. Unfortunately, the jambalaya was just as bad as the chicken piccata. That was because the jambalaya used the exact same nasty chicken that was again rubbery. The shrimp was overcooked. The sausage was decent. The rice and sauce were fine. The lamb chops were unevenly cooked. One was overdone. One was underdone. The third was apparently Goldilocks and in the middle. This used to be one of my most favorite places, with the best location and atmosphere, but ever since the change... which I can't even pinpoint... resulted in poor menu, choice changes and horrible food. They need to go back to what they used to do... Because the food now is not worth either the price or your time. What a shame. I would love to give Stacey five stars and the rest of our experience one star.

Great view! The staff very friendly and knowledgeable. The food was good, we had the perch with…read morevegetables and mashed potatoes. We should have ordered without gravy, potatoes good, gravy was not so much. All in all very good. Peace

The location of Castaways is excellent as it is right on the water and has both outdoor and indoor…read moreseating. The ambiance is relaxed with a nautical theme. Adam did an excellent job and he made quite a few recommendations as we were first timers. As the prices were reasonable, we started off with pretzel bites and were pleasantly surprised as they came out quickly and were delicious. My son ordered the Stromboli and wow, that thing was huge! It was delicious and there was more than enough to feed two adults. My husband had the brisket burger with waffle fries while my daughter ordered the veggie roll. Both said that their meals were amazing and that they wish we had found this place sooner. I ordered the chicken quesadilla and it was extremely tasty. I can't recommend this place enough! We will definitely be back.

Such an amazing atmosphere we went here after a day of baseball with a large group on a whim. They…read morewere so accommodating and welcoming. Our server was absolutely amazing she got nothing wrong and dealt with a big loud group with grace. The food was amazing I heard no complaints from anyone. Highly recommended.

Based on previous reviews - people either love or hate this place! But after our visit, I'd say…read moreit's a mixed bag. My wife had gotten take out previously, and loved the food so we wanted to try dining in. It's open and inviting - no issues at all. Drinks took a verrrrry long time to arrive, and we were informed that my wife's drink couldn't be made because of no orange juice. Next drink - missing ingredient there so on to the third drink, but she liked it. Chips and salsa were good, she got the street tacos which were good. My fajitas were better than average, with plenty of steak. I'ts a solid 4 stars, but definitely has a few things to improve upon.

My family stopped in for breakfast this weekend and had an ok experience. We were a large group…read more(six couples) so we were sure to tell them how we were splitting the checks when we ordered our drinks. We started with one server and they decided to have a second server split the table with her which didn't really work well for us. Three couples had one server and the other three had a different server. We sensed some tension between the two servers, and having waited tables in the past, I know from experience that you need to work together and not against each other. Good communication and teamwork is critical if you are going to split a table and we felt some disconnects here. One server got her orders in before the other, so three couples were eating while the other three waited for their meals. One brought ketchup and hot sauce and did not communicate with the other server so she asked if we needed any and it was already on the table. There were a few miscommunications about the orders and when one couple needed something and had to ask the server that did not take their order, there was a bit of confusion. They did bring us pitchers of ice water and a coffee jug to the table since we had a large group and they were semi-busy, which worked out well. Aside from the service hiccups, we felt the food was average and the prices were fair. I ordered a polish omelette with sauerkraut because I have never heard of such a thing before, but didn't get any sauerkraut which was disappointing. I was hungry and didn't want to complicate things so I ate it anyway and it was still good. I was also slightly confused with the 'hot cakes' items on the menu. I ordered a short stack of French toast thinking I was going to get French toast flavored pancakes since it was listed under 'hot cakes', but I got actual French toast and it was very plain. Biscuits and gravy were also listed under this heading so I should have put two and two together! Others at the table enjoyed their meals and felt the portions were very large. Those who had omelettes would have liked to get home fries or hash browns with it, but it only came with toast. They did have an Apple cinnamon jelly for the toast which isn't something you see at most breakfast spots, and it was a nice treat! I'm sure we'll be back as we have close friends in the area, and I look forward to trying other items from their menu.

The food had so much salt, and was gross. My friend ordered a wet burrito, with no sauce, and no…read morecheese. The gravy tasted like someone put the whole salt shaker in the gravy. The turkey sandwich was disgusting