While in town I ordered a lunch box from this location. I ordered the rigatoni spicy chicken pasta. When I arrived I parked in front of the building. I walked in and was greeted. I gave my name and grabbed my food and left. When I dug in the pasta was good with the right amount of spice. I definitely enjoyed. read more

See all

Fantastic place! Super nice server, plus the owner stopped by to go over some choices. We ordered toasted ravioli, rosemary chicken, veal and peppers(all excellent) and the home run of the evening, manicotti made with a crepe. Pricing was moderate/low, for the quality. read more

See all

I've had many different items from Augustine's Club 17 and none have disappointed me. Very friendly staff and super quick on having orders ready when they say a time to be there. I will be back there many more times. read more

Placed an order tonight through Grubhub. Total for the food was around $35 which I thought was pretty pricey for what we ordered but it must be big portions. The Mac & Cheese is pictured, a 5 year old would eat more than that. 14 dollars for that! We also ordered the meatballs for 10 dollars and they gave us 3 meatballs. Unbelievable! I called and spoke to the "manager" who told me the Mac & Cheese is the correct portion and we were supposed to get 4 meatballs. I said we got 3. The reply was "Sorry about that" and I was hung up on. I will never order from here again and will definitely be letting others know. read more

Augustine's Club 17 - Mac & Cheese- 14 dollars!! - Pizza Near Me - Old Forge, Pennsylvania

We ordered for delivery. Grub hub est of delivery was 8:34 received our food at 9:10. Tried to call the restaurant 3 x with no one picking up. When we received the food it was all cold. read more

Their white pizza is incredible!!! Fresh dough that is nice and crispy !! Would definitely recommend to others !!!

Yuck. The food is subpar. The place is filthy. What restaurant has carpeting in the bathroom!? Ew.

I had the best gnocchi and best service here. The band was excellent and entertaining

Usually only do take out from here, but always great! My favorite is definitely the round white and coyote pizza. We have tried a bunch of the specialty pizzas and love them. Food is ready at the time promised never have to wait. I definitely need to go one night and try some of the drinks too! read more

My dad just started working here so I have I almost every day I usually have a personal pizza and mozzarella sticks and a glass of water this food is so old I don't think I would get sick of it because I'm there almost every day read more

Great food, and cheap. We had a very good waiter named Sue. The wing bites and pasta fagioli were great. read more

Augustine's Club 17 - Pizza Near Me - Old Forge, Pennsylvania

Great pizza and mini strombolis! They have entertainment on the weekend. It's all ages, so it's nice to come out with the family and listen to some music while you eat and have a few drinks. read more

I guess we should have left when we found a dead fruit fly on one of the plates that was set up in our table when we arrived. My son simply brushed it away before I even thought about it. Then once I sat down the first thing I see is a dead fly on the table. And dozens of live flies in the window by our table. When the drinks came, my soda had a fruit fly in it. The glass that my sons soda was in still had dried food stuck all over the outside of it. Over all it was an unpleasant experience and we will not be back. read more

We came here for lunch on a Saturday afternoon to try some of the famous Old Forge pizza we've heard about. The place was rather empty (just one other customer), dirty from the night before (our server explained there had been a band and they were still cleaning up from that), and was pretty cold (it felt like they didn't have the heat on). Maybe we should've taken any of these as a sign not to eat here, but we decided we're here and might as well try the food. When we asked for waters, they gave us bottled instead of tap water (hey that's ok - I'm not cheap enough to complain about paying $2 for bottled water). There was a special deal on Yelp: $15 for $30. When I asked our server about it, she said our bill was less than $30 but that we could use it. We ordered mozzarella sticks and a traditional Old Forge red pizza. The mozzarella sticks were good and the pizza was too if you like your pizza greasy. When we went to pay the bill, our server told us that tax and tip was not included with the Yelp deal. Ok - I can accept that. Our server, however, decided to add an automatic gratuity of 25% for herself for our little party of two! I know people often don't tip on the full amounts like they should, but that doesn't mean you get to give yourself an automatic 25% tip! She then had the nerve to explain her math and "logic" telling me that she told me at the beginning of our meal not to use the Yelp deal...which is only partly true. She told us our bill was less than $30 and that we could save more if we saved it for another time. Needless to say, we paid the tip we thought she deserved and won't be returning, because this place and its food is nowhere near worth the hassle. And here's a tip for Augustine's: Don't put a deal up on Yelp if you don't want people to use it or if you plan on adding 25% automatic gratuities to try and con us out of our money... read more

Terrific old school family pizza place with some interesting appetizers and gourmet pizza options. They always have great specials, too! One of my favorites among classic Old Forge pizza landscape. read more

This restaurant is overall wonderful the food is great the employees are great my personal favorite from this restaurant would be there pizza it is absolutely delicious pizza they have a variety of subs soups and dinner in trees and they have kids meals if you would like a glass of wine with your dinner they can provide that they also have a small small bar a pool table and juke box very good environment for friends or with your family and with your kids I suggest this is a great place to have a business meeting of about 15 and 20 people they can accommodate it just always call ahead they are closed during one week day I'm not 100% on it you have to call them but I do know for a fact this is an outstanding restaurant bar place the environment is great bathrooms are always a hundred percent clean this is a very very clean restaurant you would want your children to be on their best behavior unlike mine but the waitresses are very sweet they let the kids color all over usually they give you a place not that you can color on for the children pretty much overall it's a great place read more