I order each year with no issues. This year not so much. The products I received twice were expired, unsealed and leaked all over the inside of the shipping box. No refund and no response. I have seen other complaints, possibly gone/going out of business? read more

I had bought a sampler pack for my pregnant sister-in-law for Christmas and they realized 2 of the 6 containers were expired. In general, I know mistakes happen so I had messaged customer service with picture of the peanut butter and their expiration date. They replied at first, but after it was just crickets. I emailed them back following up and they said they would send me new ones. It's been over a week and still no new ones. Overall, the peanut butter is great, but the customer service needs some improvement. read more

I totally intended to snap a photo of my jar of Go Lucky, but then, suddenly ... it was gone. That's what happens with B. Happy Peanut Butter, it seems: one minute you open the jar, and the next minute you've eaten it all. I did snap a photo of the cookies that I made with the peanut butter though, so check the photos to see Go Lucky-filled peanut butter thumbprint cookies. This stuff is addictive, especially for people who like to eat peanut butter straight from the jar. My jar of Go Lucky had milk chocolate, toffee bits and rice krispies in it. It was sweet, a little salty, crunchy and creamy. It was delicious. One of the reasons I love B. Happy because they are a family company. The company was started in their kitchen, and the whole family (kids included) take part in every aspect of the business, from making the peanut butter, to packaging it, to working out the financials, to selling at the Zionsville farmers market. It's nice to come across a quality, local product that is made in small batches and with lots of love behind it. I would probably have multiple jars of B. Happy in my kitchen cabinet, but I know I would just eat them all so I save this stuff for special occasions (or to add to baked goods when I'm baking for people). read more

B. Happy Peanut Butter - Peanut butter cookies filled with B. Happy's Go Lucky peanut butter - Specialty Food Near Me

I just realized that while I have single handedly consumed dozens of jars of B. Happy Peanut Butter, I've never taken a photo or written a review. This needs to change TODAY! If the amount of time that one jar lasts in our household of 2 adults is any indication of just how good this stuff is, then it's hands down the best. I seriously have to make myself stop eating it by the spoonful every time I walk by it. It's also amazing on graham cracker sticks, pretzels, or by the finger-full. Don't judge me. I LOVE that it started out as a local, family owned and run business and has blown up to the point where I can stop at a few places all around town to get my B-Hap fix. Find it at Twisted Sisters (my fav), R2Go, Goose, Rail, Homespun, and more. We love all of their flavors, but Joy to the World seems to last the shortest amount of time in our house. Honorable mention goes to Don't Worry (with coconut), Go Lucky (with Toffee), and the Happy Trails, as those are in constant rotation and devour as well. Who would have thought that I would be obsessed with peanut butter? That reminds me...I'm almost out. Gotta go get more. See ya. read more

See all

Kudos to Yelp Elite Brooke A for leading the pack on this one. I was actually just chatting with B.Happy last night about her amazing review (Brooke, they were in love with your recap and so grateful!). So what is B. Happy you ask? It's the unofficially official best peanut butter on the planet made in Indianapolis with tasty ingredients like dried cranberries, white chocolate chips, toffee bits, pretzels and more No matter which chunky container you choose, you're guaranteed to B.Happy after the first spoonful enters your mouth. Yes, this peanut butter beautifully stands alone without bread, jelly or the sort. In fact, before you go out to buy some, do yourself a favor and make some extra room in your gluttonous "hidden drawer" of eats because you'll want to hide this one from the family before it's all gone! *I would love to see more B.Happy on the charcuterie board menus throughout the city. Fingers crossed it's on the way. Maybe some gourmet PB&J's with a Preservation partnership? read more

B. Happy Peanut Butter - jars of peanut butter - Specialty Food Near Me

One spoonful. That's all it took for the sea to part, the Hallelujah chorus to ring out, and for me to fall in love with the one, the only, B. Happy Peanut Butter. Yelpers RAVE about it and now I know why. Just ask somebody who's had it and you'll be met with wide eyes and "OMG"! I should preface this review by saying peanut butter is hands down, my #1 favorite food of all time. I eat it every day and could not live without it. If I could only bring 3 items to a desert island, one of them would be a heaping jar of pb. This is how serious my addiction is, folks. So then I hear about a peanut butter that is 1) local 2) delicious and 3) infused with goodies like cranberries, pretzels, and/or chocolate. Check, check, check! I knew I had to get my hands on it sooner or later. Well folks, that magical day finally arrived. I stopped in Wildwood Market and was browsing their local goodies, hoping to find it. I turned the corner, looked at the top shelf, and there it was in all it's glory. I nearly squealed with excitement. I had to restrain myself from getting one of every flavor, so I settled with Joy to the World, a concoction of white and dark chocolate with cranberries. For $5, you get a sizable container that would make a great gift or stocking stuffer (*cough cough*). B Happy isn't going to be your go-to for a sandwich I view it more as a dessert to be enjoyed on special occasions. But holy mackerel, IT'S GOOD. One spoonful, and it was hook, line, and sinker. I'm hooked. Joy to the world indeed. I'm going to try to enjoy it in moderation. But I probs won't. IT'S TOO DELICIOUS. Next time you're around town, do yourself a favor and pick up a jar. And maybe one for me. You won't regret it. read more

See all

Yummy, yummy, yummy! Like many others, I found B. Happy at the Yelp Christmas Market and have been a fan ever since. It makes for great presents! I suppose I could spread it on other things but it is usually best eaten right out of the jar. Just writing about it makes me want some. The mixture of salty and sweet is awesome-keep up the good work, B. Happy! read more

I first found BHappy Peanut Butter at the annual Yelp Christmas festival at the Central Library a few years ago. Back in those days, you could get out with other people and get free samples of vendor products. One of the highlights of that event was discovering BHappy Peanut Butter. On that night, I discovered my favorite of their offerings, the "Joy to the World" flavor combo. This is really great around the Christmas season since it brings together a lot of great tastes like peanut butter, cranberries (dried), and both white and dark chocolate bits. But I don't wait to buy it then. Not only can you find this in some local groceries Like Target and Fresh Thyme, but at some local shoppes that sell Indiana products and even at some County/city welcome centers that carry local products as well! Since I have seen these tasty treats all around, I haven't used the online service to order them. I am strictly giving my rating based upon the end product. These don't need to be refrigerated and if you have lots of willpower, they will last a long time if you can hide it from your family to make it last longer. Even if you are successful in keeping your 12 oz. jar hidden, it may have some of the peanut butter oil separate. But if you simply take a spoon and stir it up, it returns to the wonderful taste and texture that you expect. Based upon all the nibs and items in my selection, the peanut butter was on the crunchy side, less creamy. I like it that way, but it doesn't spread on butter as easily, but like most reviewers, I simply use a spoon to get a big bite and nurse it for awhile just to show I have will power! Review #3884 read more

As others have noted, this stuff is seriously addictive and jars never last long around my house either! I was first introduced to B. Happy Peanut Butter at the Yelp Paints the Town Red event, and had some trouble finding it for awhile- places that carried it were often out, but now, fortunately, it seems to be much easier to find! They're carrying it at Market District in Carmel which makes me very happy! But....sort of bad since now it is a regular impulse purchase! I'm now never without a jar or two in the house! Joy to the World and Go Lucky are a couple of my favorites but I've yet to try one of their flavors I don't like! It is truly good just eaten with a spoon, but also excellent on apple slices and pretzel chips. Many family members received jars of B. Happy as part of some fun Indy food goodie bags I put together for Christmas. Everyone got a different flavor and I told them they could swap away with each other if they wanted to...everyone wanted to swap for each other's flavors, but didn't want to give theirs up! Definitely a great local product! read more

You guys - I used to HATE peanut butter! Like I would leave the room if my boyfriend was eating it because I couldn't stand the smell. I was so hungry at an event last night that I decided to take a spoonful of the "Go Lucky" Chocolate Toffee peanut butter and I LOVED IT! I am mind blown. It's not like the sticky, creamy kind you find with your big brands. B. Happy is more of a crunchy consistency that is very snack-like. Tip: they are found in a bunch of grocery stores, markets, and even a shop online. They make it super easy to find on their website. I cannot wait to get a jar of my own! *runs to the grocery store* read more

This is the best thing that's ever happened to food. I just recently discovered the company at the "Yelp Paints the Town Red" event and fell in love. It honestly doesn't matter what flavor you buy because they are all delicious. I personally am attached to the "Go Lucky" flavor which has chocolate, toffee, and rice krispies added in and I'm not ashamed to eat it straight out of the jar. read more

Looking for a REAL treat? WE FOUND OURS, HERE!!! Peanut butter that you eat with a spoon!! YUM I discovered B. Happy Peanut Butter in 2017 at the Yelp's Totally Bazaar and have been purchasing them (often 3 at a time) monthly, every since!! I've tried each flavor, and liked EVERY one of them... the label tells you what's in them, and I'm sure you can guess which you will like based on your person likes. A few we like the best: Go Lucky with milk chocolate, toffee and rice crispies Don't Worry with dark chocolate, almonds and coconut And the Joy to the dry cranberries, white and dark chocolate Here in Indy you can find them in Fresh Thyme, Nicole Taylors Pasta, Goose theMArket, Needlers, Soupremacy, Market District, Trader's Point Creamery, and now even some Targets! And the story behind this company is so wonderful... it was a bit of a fluke that it took off like it did! If I remember correctly, it was originally to be a small attempt for a family to show their kids how our economy works and how to market and sell a product... and now here we are with it available across a few states! If you haven't tried it, you are missing out! IT IS SO GOOD! We don't have much for treats and sweets in our house... but we will keep this one for sure! (Everything in moderation! HA!) read more

I can't remember the day that I discovered B Happy Peanut Butter, but I know that I have at least a couple jars in my cabinet pretty much all the time. When I run low, I start to panic and run to the nearest boutique market and cross my fingers they haven't sold out. It's happened before.. the B Happy family went on vacation last summer and didn't make anything for about a week. The stores started to run out. People (me) started to go through withdrawl. Man.. those were some tough times. Seriously though.. if you haven't tried B Happy Peanut Butter yet, stop by Homespun or R2Go or Goose and pick some up. Homespun usually has samples.. not sure about the other places. A little chunkier than normal peanut butter, this stuff goes great on just about anything, although I usually tend to eat mine with a spoon. Sure.. I've tried spooning it onto a banana before, but that just involves another step and all I really want is the peanut butter anyway. Why bother with the banana? A few of my favorites: Don't Worry.. a combination of dark chocolate, shredded coconut and almonds mixed with their signature honey roasted peanut butter. Joy To The World mixes dark chocolate, white chocolate and dried cranberries with the peanut butter.. delicious! So Happy Together blends Inga Smith's Snickerdoodle popcorn and the KeeP Smunchy honey roasted peanut butter into a match made in foodie heaven. All of the B Happy products come in 12oz containers, are 100% vegetarian and contain zero trans fats. You won't find a better peanut butter on the market.. and it's made right here in the area (Zionsville) in small batches.. with love! A warning.. it's addicting. Before you know it, you'll be keeping a few extra containers on hand in case they take another vacation! read more

B. Happy Peanut Butter is one of my go-to local gifts (stocking stuffers, anyone?). You really can't go wrong with any of the flavors.. unless you have a nut allergy, I guess. My favorite is always Go Lucky which has peanut butter, milk chocolate, toffee, and rice crispies. It's designed to be eaten with a spoon and good luck pacing yourself. read more

I love everything about this business! First and foremost, their product is amazing. I did not realize that I actually like crunchy peanut butter or fresh peanut butter. Other "natural" PBs have a layer of oil on top and you have to have the muscles of a body builder to mix it all together. Not B Happy. They use honey roasted nuts, so somehow the oil magically stays mixed. I assume this stuff is good on sandwiches, but truth be told, I have never made it that far. I've had it by the spoonful. Also, I have microwaved it (alone and mixed with Nutella) for a tasty apple dip. Bonus -- the owners of this company are charming. I met them at the Yelp Ten Minute Talks and you cannot help but fall in love with this family. They are so honest and humble and they LOVE their product. read more

I can't even think of a word to describe B. Happy Peanut Butter...Remarkable? Fantastic? Exceptional? Outstanding? Smunchy? Perfect? There isn't a single word that can some up how UH-MAZING this peanut butter is. I have yet to buy a jar that wasn't empty by the end of the day. It's the most dangerous, ADDICTIVE food I've ever encountered. There should probably be a support group for us B. Happy fanatics. "Hello, My name is Allison, and I am a (proud) B. Happy's Go Lucky Peanut Butter addict." Unfortunately for my waistline, I have no desire to fight this addiction. read more

Dear Kathy Weed and Family, My sister sent me a six pack sampler of your peanut butters and WOW. Have been a peanut butter fan for most of my seventy-five years and spooning it almost all of the time during these these years - is there any other way to eat it? Thank you for a wonderfully wild peanut butter ride! Wishing you all a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year as you continue to make these absolutely delicious peanut butters. With gratitude, Noreen read more

The peanut butter is so creamy and still manages to keep the pretzel/nuts very crunchy!! I love having some of the peanut butter with some overnight oats. They also make a great gift for anyone (because who doesn't love peanut butter??). Support a local business and eat more peanut butter!!!! :) read more

Wow. Doesn't last after one sitting. Great flavors! Easy to find if you shop local and a great gift for peanut butter lovers.

There is no better peanut butter than B. Happy! I get some every chance I get and talk about it all the time! Even my secret Santa got me a big ole jar of Pay it Forward! I opened that jar up at work and made others try it...got B. Happy a few more fans! Beyond the great taste, B. Happy has a great story! I love how they got their whole family involved in designing and packaging the product! Go. Go buy some now. You won't be disappointed. read more

I first came across B. Happy Peanut Butter at Yelp's Bold & Beautiful party. I was wondering, why is everybody flocking to their booth? Then I had a tasting and I knew why. They turned something as common as peanut butter into something unique and good. How do they do it? By experimenting and blending different ingredients into a tasty product. I was happy to see B. Happy at a subsequent Yelp event and tasted a variety of flavors. They blend their peanut butter with chocolate, which seems easy in theory but hard to execute. Have you tried to make a PB and chocolate sandwich at home? You wouldn't but now there is a spread for you. I also like the other ingredients that they put in, like cranberries, coconut, and pretzels. You wouldn't think to try it but now they have your favorite flavor. And best of all, unlike some natural peanut butter, there is no separation of peanut oil from the PB. B. Happy's peanut butter has a very nice consistency. Like they said, just Eat It With A Spoon! There is no shame in eating peanut butter straight out of a jar when it's this good. read more

Fake reviews and rude owners with awful customer service. Refuse to respond to any thing I send out after getting mold in my jar !!

This peanut butter makes me SO HAPPY!!! I first discovered this gem at the Yelp "Craft Rave" at Central Library a few Decembers ago and have never looked back. While there are other brands on the Indy scene, this remains my favorite because: 1. It is a (seemingly healthy) indulgence. I usually do eat this with a spoon and not on a sandwich. 2. They have several locations with their products, so it is very helpful to add on a jar to my Soupremacy order. 3. The diversity of flavors responds to any taste my palette may have. While my favorite remains Joy to the World, I would also strongly recommend Dream Big and Count Your Blessings. Cheers to B Happy and all the happiness they bring to PB enthusiasts. read more

Can't believe I've never written a review for B. Happy. Honestly, Yelper Katie U. says it best, "One spoonful. That's all it took for the sea to part, the Hallelujah chorus to ring out, and for me to fall in love with the one, the only, B. Happy Peanut Butter. Yelpers RAVE about it and now I know why. Just ask somebody who's had it and you'll be met with wide eyes and 'OMG'!" Don't expect peanut butter that you can keep in the pantry for long periods of time. This stuff goes in days (hours maybe...?). It's dessert in peanut butter form, and eating it straight from the jar is the best way to go at it. I've also tried added it to toast / bagels before, topped with fruits and other seeds/nuts, and it's just as delicious. If you ever seen a long, long line at a food festival/event and B. Happy is there, they're most likely giving out samples. The price is a little hefty, but it's worth it if you're craving it. You can find them around Indy in specialty, local grocers like R2Go and Wildwood. Always a nice treat. read more

There is peanut butter (boring) and then there is B. Happy Peanut Butter (mind blowing)! Imagine opening a jar of fresh sinful honey roasted peanut butter. You lift the vessel to your nose just to breathe in the sweet essence of a creamy peanut butter cup. You say to yourself..."only one spoonful"..."you got this"..."be strong." The rich butter melts on your tongue, crunchy pretzel pieces add the perfect layer of salt, oh..is that a sweet chocolate chip? The sweet, salty, crunchy, creamy, peanutty decadence starts playing a symphony in your mouth. Suddenly, your reaching for a second spoonful, then a third, then a fourth, will the madness ever end? The world all of a sudden stops. You have entered heaven and the clouds are made of B. Happy (Dream Big) White Chocolate Pretzel Peanut Butter. Eventually you snap out of it and the 12 oz jar you were holding has now become 4 oz. Bewildered, you think how did that happen? You chuckle to yourself and say -- "thank goodness I bought a second jar" -- and keep eating. True story...and that is just a taste of what it's like eating this amazing peanut butter. This dreamy stuff is made in small batches in Zionsville, Indiana. Check their website for retail locations and to place orders online. You should do it soon before I buy all of it! read more

B. Happy Peanut Butter - Dream Big - White Chocolate Pretzel - Specialty Food Near Me

See all

This stuff is truly amazing. I found it at Fresh Thyme in Carmel, IN and was intrigued since it was marked as a locally owned product. The only mistake I make was that I only purchased one jar. As soon as I took a bite, I looked at my boyfriend and said "oh crap". We both knew the jar wouldn't last the next day! Since then I've made several trips back to get more and I will continue to do so for as long as they make it. Great job! read more

Throw away your pints of Ben and Jerry's! We have a new and better option when it comes to indulgence (or when life just sucks :P) I've been eager to taste this stuff for quite a while now and thanks to Yelp's 10 minute talks, I finally have my chance! The story of how this company came to be is very sweet in itself. The entire family is involved in the business and I love seeing how fast it has grown over the past year! Don't let the small container's fool you - the minute you put a spoonful of this stuff into your mouth, you'll travel to another dimension. The chunky, gooey, salty, sweetness in each bite is just amazing. Whats great about this is that they honey roast the peanuts before the processing begins - this helps to eliminate the separation of the oil and the solids in the container. It never fails that when I start to remix the oil back into the peanut butter, some of it splashes out/onto my shirt. Who wants that? NOT ME - and definitely not you! B. Happy Peanut Butter does just as it says - makes you happy (and keeps your shirt clean) read more

So these jars are single servings, correct? I bought a jar of 'Joy to the World' and I feel that about sums up everything nicely. I first found them at Yelp's Christmas Bazaar, thank you for that, and promptly needed a new jar two days later, which I found at Wildwood Market. It is small batch homemade peanut mixed in with different types of chocolate, dried fruits, as well as pretzels, toffee, and flax seed. The combinations are Delicious and the only downside, is that clearly I cannot trust myself to be alone with a jar. read more

Umm, heavenly, scrumptious, addictive, superb, are just a few words I'd use to describe this stuff. I just bought the milk chocolate, cherry, crunch and ate the whole jar. So, the best way to describe what this is like to eat is, cookie dough. When you eat cookie dough, you just can't stop. It's like being on some sugar addict trip where you disappear from your physical body and get lost in a taste adventure. I can always find all of the flavors at R2Go on college near 10th and Mass Ave. read more

This peanut butter is YUMMY!! You really can sit down with a spoon and eat a jar. Scary I know!! But GOOD. They have about 7 different choices to choose from. One thing the yelp location is not unless I did not see in in the middle of the civil war museum. But looked up places they sell it on there web sight and there is one soupremcy about 100 ft from the location on Yelp. Try one but you are warned it is too good. ha ha read more

This is the best peanut butter I've ever put in my mouth. B. Happy was at Yelp Paints the Town Red a few nights ago, and this local business was the best part of the night for me. I couldn't stop going back, and at one point I asked them if they can just give me the tub of peanut butter instead of a spoonful. I can't remember all the flavors off the top of my head, but they had 5 flavors to sample from (I will try to not butcher the flavors): plain, coconut almonds and chocolate, cranberry with chocolate, white chocolate pretzel, milk chocolate and toffee. I can't wait to buy me some PB. I recommend this place to everyone and will start gifting B. Happy to my fellow friends and family in California because they, are missing out! I love you B. Happy Peanut Butter. Other PB will never be the same to me anymore. read more

Ordered the Dream Big, Pay it Forward, and Happy Trail Mix. I am a big peanut butter fan and thus stuff is great. Easy ordering and quick shipping. Thanks for such a great product! read more

See all

Hard to type after scooping the bottom of my first jar with my fingers! Needless to say, this pb is the bomb. Yes, if you are comparing to Jif, this is more expensive... but Jif doesnt compare. This Pb is all-natural, high-quality and is more like a treat than your average spread. My favorite flavor is Dream Big (white chocolate and pretzels?! Heck yeah!). And while the PB isn't necessarily healthy, its a healthier option for dessert, which is what I eat it as. Finally, I love that this is a small local business. I had the pleasure of meeting the owner and learned that the business started as a family summer project to teach their kids about running a business and bloomed into a sucess. read more

I don't know if peanut butter is really the right term for this amazing concoction. Why would I say such a thing? It's made from peanuts, you say. Well, here's the deal. I really don't care for peanut butter. I know, I'm a total weirdo. I blame too many PB and banana sammies in utero, but I digress. THIS, this is not on the same plane as that stuff choosy moms would choose (give them time, they'll choose this too). So here's the deal - B. Happy is amazing. The product, the people, everything! Let me tell you all about it. As a non PBer I'd never tried their product until Yelp's Ten Minute Talks. I immediately fell in love with the husband and wife team who make this lovely product so of course I had to try some (oh and they gave us some to take home, because they're so nice). Well, I've already eaten a jar of it. Yes, I the PB averse have downed a container of B. Happy. I would never dare put this on bread. They mean it when they say "eat it with a spoon." Seriously, just dig in. The texture is really great and "smunchy" with all kinds of delicious treasures mixed in. When we asked "what's your favorite way to eat it?", one suggestion was to mix into greek yogurt. YES. It's amazing. Try that. So here's the deal, go buy some and enjoy the heck out of it. You're welcome. read more

This peanut butter is too good! How does one stop eating this after they start? It's almost like the jar should have directions on how to only eat one spoon full! If nutritional information was listed this may be possible and I really wish they did provide that info and maybe a little more info on the ingredients, what all is in here?! Besides that though, no complaints, I could eat this day in and day out and could only hope of getting sick of it. Oh I bought the "Joy to the World" with white chocolate, dark chocolate, and dried cranberries, perfect for this time of year! I also tried pretty much every other flavor at the Yelp Bazaar (went home with a stomach ache after all that pb) and could have been happy going home with any single one of them. read more

Tasted a couple flavors for the first time this month & loved them both! It's a yummy snack to keep handy at work. Much thinner than your typical peanut butter, just FYI read more

This peanut butter is so amazingly delicious! It is also made by such sweet people. My favorite has to be the white chocolate pretzel PB...it's heaven in a jar! Yes, most grocery stores allow you to make your own fresh PB nowadays, but as good and as fresh as it is, it CANNOT compare to B. Happy's PB variety! Eat/shop local, friends! read more

Don't like peanut butter - only eat it when there's no alternative. It's too thick & glommy. But good golly Miss Molly, these B. Happy people have taken ho-hum peanut butter and bedazzled it with chocolate, coconut, pretzels, dried fruit, nuts; also my favorite, snickerdoodle popcorn. Yes, do eat it with a spoon. Or a shovel. In fact, I wish they made smaller go cups, cause I tend to keep eating till it's all gone. Seems to me plenty of local places like Wildwood, Homespun & R2GO stock it, but does any restaurant incorporate it in their menu? Hello! read more

B. Happy is a great local company that I love to support. I most often purchase it at Wildwood Market or Homespun, where it averages about $8. My only complaint is that it's so popular that it's often out of stock! Our favorite variety is Go Lucky (love those little chocolate chunks!), but honestly, they're all good. Like many others, I eat it with a spoon...it's too special to put on a measly sandwich! I've bought B. Happy to incorporate into local food gifts several times, and it also serves well as a stocking stuffer or random little surprise for a friend. I've met the proprietor at different events around the city, and she embodies the "B. Happy" mentality. She's always generous with samples, too ;) read more

I absolutely LOVE this peanut butter. I finished this peanut butter in a week.(I know that sounds really bad) The peanut butter was phenomenal. I had the chocolate coconut peanut butter and it was so delicious. I could eat it by itself, or with toast. I love peanut butter and banana and this peanut butter pairs so well with bananas. While somewhat pricy, very worth it for the quality and the use! Also natural, and light yet creamy and flavorful. Keeps me satisfied throughout the day, when I eat the peanut butter for breakfast! Will be buying many more :) read more