We have some family friends that live in Norwich. We made our way to this part of town to have…read morefather's day lunch with them. They called ahead and made a reservation for us. It was nice that they had 16 of us in a banquet room, the penalty box. The penalty box was quite spacious for the 16 of us. They had a few tables set up with silverware and popcorn for us. Three of the four tables were great. I really question the last table they set up. It was literally falling apart. It was so unstable. It needed more than just a couple coasters to stabilize the table which they tried doing. Common sense to me is don't use the table but as unstable as the table was, they actually thought it would work. It's quite humorous really, that you thought in the whole process of getting everything set up that in your sober mind it would work. After the whole fiasco of getting the tables rearranged, we finally got our drinks started. After drinks were dropped off, I went ahead and told the servers that we were ready to order. I didn't want to wait any longer. They were gone for long periods of time. With that big of a party that's in the back, you'd think that they would be around more often. For starters we got the giant pretzel to share. For lunch I got the hot honey smothered chicken with extra brocolli subbed for the mashed potatoes. The giant pretzel was very giant. It came with two types of cheese sauces. One was regular nacho type. It had a nice heat to it. The other cheese sauce was topped with bacon. The pretzel itself was not overly salted. It was harder on the outside but soft in the middle. It was plenty for the 5 of us to share. Lunch finally made it's way out. Some adjustments needed to be made since they wasn't enough broccoli for all of us. Our server adjusted two out of the four of us that needed our brocolli subbed. My plate was one of the last to get served. I had to ask my server about my second side since I asked for double brocolli. No other hot vegetable was available so I settled for coleslaw. My chicken was tender. There was a good amount of veggies and cheese on top of it. It was ok, I had a few bites and wasn't all too thrilled about it. The brocolli was roasted and had a nice char on it from the roasting. My son got a side of butter for his brocolli so I added a a little on mine. It was a good addition to it. The coleslaw tasted like store bought so I didn't eat much of it. We started off our dining experience with 2 servers and then ended with 1. Clearly she wasn't equipped to take on a party that big alone. Refills were asked for multiple times. Same with boxes and my husband's slushy. She finally told us that the slushy machine was down after we waited a while for it. She never checked up on us after lunch was dropped off until it was time to close us out. She was gone 85% of the whole time. It was honestly some of the worst service. As a past server, how does one leave a table unattended for that long of a period of time and feel like you deserve 20%? I feel bad that my husband spent his father's day meal here. He does so much for us throughout the year and he had to settle for less than basic food and service. From the table to the lack of service and everything else in between, I would recommend you going somewhere else but here for a meal.

I've been for lunch a few times. Staff seems very friendly. Nice place. Each time I've gone on…read moreThursday for boneless wings.. which are half off on that day.. sweet potato fries are really good too! I recommend, definitely stop here

Cute place for a burger and beer. Really good fries, both regular & sweet potato. Friendly server;…read morequick turnaround. Supporters of local school sports: always a plus!

Excellent menu and service great and right on time! Steak dinner very delicious! Waitresses very…read morepleasant and professional!

We enjoyed the Mother's Day Brunch Buffet at Tavern 1244 at Barton's Inn. It was fantastic!read more

Recently re-opened under new ownership, we had lunch at Tavern 1244 last week. Extensive menu,…read morelots of choices, and 2 separate pages of dinner menu items. Service was prompt and friendly, newly "spruced up" restaurant looked great. I had chicken salad wrap, which was very good with nuts and grapes in the chicken salad, just the way I like it. Sister had an eggplant sandwich which she enjoyed very much. Prices very reasonable. We will definitely return. Look forward to trying the dinner menu.

My girlfriend and I stopped in here an 1.5 hours before a graduation we were attending downtown…read more Now I've been here on a packed weekend during the bar crowd and you wouldn't even know this place has the room it does or food even but thankfully it was a weekday and like 6pm so there wasn't much of a crowd. It's your basic sports bar definitely more than enough TV's to cover whatever sport you'd want to watch. We ordered pretzel bites with beer cheese the pretzels were very salty but warm and in my opinion better without the cheese it definitely is more like nacho cheese rather than beer cheese but it's not bad just nothing to write home about. I got the Caprese Fried Chicken sandwich and it was pretty good and the fries in my opinion are the real show stopper crispy but not burnt the perfect fry homemade I believe too. My girlfriend got the Chicken Philly in a wrap and she enjoyed it. We had a new server training with Julianna and he was great very attentive asked if I wanted a refill when my drink was gone. Which as a customer tells me you care and you're paying attention. We were in and hour in a little over an hour. I would definitely return if in the downtown area!

The service was so friendly and efficient it would have made up for mediocre food but this place…read moredelivered on food and service! We enjoyed our burgers and loved Juliana our server! The sports vibe was fun - we got to watch hockey, basketball, car racing and football all in one spot! Highly recommended.

Was driving through the small town and found this hidden gem!!!…read moreFood was amazing and the staff were extremely friendly. I suggest the patty melt w/ onions, it was life changing!

Amazing food! Friendly staff. All fresh homemade. Fresh cut fries! Just driving through and so glad…read morewe stopped. Huge portions..... burger was cooked perfect and so juicy!

Pretzels were excellent!! Super yummy beer cheese and the other sauce with horseradish just as…read moreyummy. My salmon was on potatoes and fennel with sauce on the bottom. Perfectly cooked, did not expect the dish to be that elevated. Service was great. Kiddo demolished smash burger. Terrific lunch!!

My friends and I did our first tasting of 2026 with a corned beef Reuben from McGirks. Flavor was…read morevery good. General consensus by the group: Corned beef is thick sliced; might have preferred it a little thinner sliced but the flavor is very nice. A little light on the sauerkraut and 1000 Island dressing. Overall a really good sandwich.

I tried Iron Agave and I must say it's a shame I spent $50 on sloppy tacos that didn't even taste…read morelike birria. Hardly any meat or any toppings in it. By far the worst food place around here. Too expensive for poor quality food.

We went here the other night and had a great time. Everything we had was delicious from the corn…read morequeso, empanadas(filling changes daily), lamb tacos, fish tacos, shrimp tacos, beef birria tacos, chicken quesadillas, smash burger and churros! We all enjoyed our drinks. Our waiter was very attentive and we enjoyed the evening!

Group of friends went to the Old Mill last Sunday to celebrate a 45th wedding anniversary. There…read morewere 11 of us. Always love the cheese crock and crackers. SO GOOD! Relish tray had pickled beets, cottage cheese, beans, coleslaw, etc. Blueberry lemonade also available. Everything excellent. No extra charge for the cheese or the relish tray. Variety of dishes ordered. I had turkey with dressing and gravy. Chose the steamed wild rice, others had the mashed potatoes. Steak duo with bernaise sauce excellent. Prime rib very good. Beet salad as entree very good. Everyone very happy with their food and the service was excellent and attentive. Such a nice atmosphere at this restaurant where you sit looking out over the Unadilla River. Plan on a leisurely meal, as there is much to enjoy. Dessert choices included various parfaits with liquors, all delicious. Great place for a special occasion. Open for dinner during the week (seasonal) and lunch available only on Sundays. Do visit if you can - well worth it.

We have been dining at the Old Mill for more than 50 years. We go at least once year to relax and…read moreenjoy the beautiful view of the Unadilla River while enjoying a delicious meal! Their Shrimp Old Mill is a delightful offering with lots of large shrimp covered with a delicious moray sauce on a bed of wil rice. It never disappoints! Well worth the trip up route 8!!