Got takeout for breakfast. Wonderful bagels. We got cinnamon raisin bagels with apple cinnamon cream cheese in one and vegetable cream cheese in the other. A coffee and an omelette as well. Everything was delicious. The bagels were toasted perfectly. One of the best ones I've had so far. Great packaging and service. I am sure their cafe is wonderful too. Hopefully I can visit sometime soon. :) read more

Flatbush Bagels - Cinnamon Raisin Bagel with Apple Cinnamon Cream Cheese - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Overpriced bagels ..They make bagels for the patrons after you first. First come first serve I have to go to work. Don't play with my time. read more

See all

I would say more a 4.5 than a 4! I really enjoy the bagels here and they have so many different flavors of cream cheese which I think is super fun! There is a line sometimes but I would say things move pretty fast! There is some seating which is nice, but they are also close to prospect park so great to grab and go. I took over the .5 because I think it's a little expensive especially if you get a lox's bagel with all three toppings (tomato, onion, capers). I know that lox's bagels are more expensive in general but I believe the total is 16.88 (I could be a little off on the price) which is a bit steep. read more

See all

Local bagel shops. Big fat bagels. $1.75 for a bagel. $20 for a dozen. Close to the prospect park train station read more

Flatbush Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Bagels and cream cheeses are always great! Fast and nice service. Love the jalapeño cream cheese.

Had breakfast here with a friend recently and was quite pleased. The menu has a variety of options to choose from; bagels, omelets, coffee, etc. My friend and I had a delicious omelet with whole wheat toast. I grabbed some fresh orange juice although I wanted an iced coffee (I'll have that next time of course). The line moves very quickly in here and there's seating inside to enjoy your meal. The staff are patient and friendly. I'll be back here soon without question! read more

See all

Stop leaving key ingredients out of omelette and making excuses. All weekend you got my breakfast orders wrong. In a row. Not okay, I'm done! Flavorless omelette without Feta, that's what makes it GREEK! read more

Flatbush Bagels - STOP FORGETTING the FETA cheese in my Greek omelettes. Twice this weekend NO feta! I'm done! Flavorless! - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Ordered a turkey club, but did not realize it only came with turkey and bacon, literally just the meat. No lettuce. No tomato. No mayo. All that was $.50 extra EACH. Ridiculous. read more

I went on a Sunday morning and the place was packed but they work so efficiently and I didn't even have to wait that long. The prices are reasonable, staff is friendly and the bagel is so fluffy and delicious! Will defintely be going back read more

ten dollars for two bagels with cream cheese. Blueberry bagel with tofu creamcheese add avocado, and sesame bagel with plain cream cheese. Fresh bagels lots of workers in the baking part of the store. you can tell its fresh out. Lady working counter is friendly, a good place for bagels but a bev from the fridge is $3. read more

Flatbush Bagels - sesame bagel Plain Cream Cheese - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Big round dough disguised as " bagels"- rubbery. Older lady I assume is manager-very curt, unfriendly. Would not be returning here, and certainly would not recommend. If this app allowed 1/2 a star I would have rated this place as that. read more

I was in and out so quick! The service was awesome. I was more than happy with the bagel that I ordered. It was stacked full with lots of salmon and cream cheese!! Just the way I love it. Thanks so much. I will surely be back again for that pure Brooklyn ambiance. read more

See all

Incredibly mid bagels. I ordered a bagel at 9 am and it was already stale. You're better off buying a bagel at a grocery store for the quality you get here. read more

I love this shop! They're cash preferred which isn't always convenient, but who cares when every bagel you get is delicious? The team is always so friendly. They're quick most of the time, but I have seen them get backed up in a rush. The bagels are worth it! They give a nice portion, too. I always have half for breakfast and half a couple hours later. There's seating for only a handful of people, so I typically opt for take away. It's a great option if you want to pick up some bagels and head to Prospect Park for a stroll after. read more

Flatbush Bagels - Lox Sandwich and Strawberry Cream Cheese on a cinnamon raisin bagel - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

It's a fine bagel and fresh but absolutely no taste. I mean if you add a ton of extras then sure it would be good; just like on a piece of cardboard Not a destination shop unless in the area read more

Flatbush Bagels - Notice salt needed in the everything bagel. Smh - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Walked in for highly recommended bagel and variety of cream cheese and walked out with not only that plus one of the finest service experiences ever! Crew prepped my bagel sandwich order and during a street person-NYPD incident in store gave me the wrong order which I bit into before noticing and, hungry, ate entirely. Went back up for more to take home and the crew apologized and gave me my original sandwich! They managed the incident fabulously, made sure I got my order, and delivered phenomenal food! WIN WIN WIN! read more

We've been ordering from here for over a year bc of lack of options in our neighborhood. Used to be amazing, but we won't be ordering from them ever again. They've sent us the wrong order the last THREE times. Don't bother calling them to let them know, they won't fix anything. 0/10 read more

I stopped here prior to a running event in prospect park. I ordered a cinnamon raisin bagel with walnut raisin cream cheese. The bagels were very fresh and soft. I would definitely return if I was in the area. read more

See all

It's like a bagel utopia right on Flatbush Avenue! I'm not a morning person but whenever I get a bagel from here "it's a good morning". Seems like the bulk of the other reviews have been written by other "non-morning" people who were a little hangry. Nonetheless, I have been here many times in person and recommend that you try them out. Whoa, the bagels! They are hearty and tasty. They definitely embody the classic NY flavor without being dry. The egg bagels deserve an honorable mention. And the cream cheese options are mighty varied though I just stick to the savory ones that preferably have chives in them. The price is on par with other bagel shops in highly re-gentrified areas; steep but you definitely get what you pay for. I gladly fork out the $10.50, $11.43 with taxes for the Italian hero which is the shining star in my opinion. It's a swine lover's dream atop the bagel of your choice. I opt for a perfectly toasted poppy seed bagel and nix the tomatoes. I go and forth with whether to add Mayo or not because it's not completely necessary; the included oil and vinegar hits the spot too. I have only been able to make it through one half for breakfast but trust me the other half is just as good for lunch. I recommend that you come through on the earlier end of traditional breakfast hours, definitely before hunger has set in and you are to patiently wait for your bagel to be made just the way that you like it. read more

Flatbush Bagels - Egg Bagel with Chive Cream Cheese - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I don't get the why this joint only gets a 2 star average. I dropped in here today after my 5K race in the park to bring home some bagels to carb back up. Bagels were fresh, warm, fat, and tasty. Just the right amount of crispness on the outside and soft on the inside. Good flavor too. Sesame, blueberry, cinnamon raisin were all solid choices. Service was friendly and had no problems paying. Paid cash and saved on the CC surcharge they apply here. Much better than a two star experience. read more

See all

No line, maybe the quickest I've ever had a BEC be made for me, reasonable prices, nice guys inside. Oh and the bagels are quality bagels. What more could you want from your local bagel guys? I don't frequent this neighborhood but will absolutely be stopping in again next time I'm near prospect park. read more

Employees have changed recently; They appear to have a few racist Mexicans running the show now. The order taker put in my order to the cook and added a few words after saying egg and cheese that made the cook look at me strangely. I ignored it until they kept me waiting while others received their order and the cook kept looking @ me. And the kitchen looks disgusting they don't keep it clean. I'm black by the way so other may now have the same problem. read more

Solid spot in the neighborhood versus all the Dunkin's. I love getting myself the chicken salad on an everything bagel. I just wish the seasoned the chicken salad more, salt please! read more

Agh-pit! At first glance you might think they have something special here, with the big bagels and fresh spreads and friendly staff, until you give things some time. That is when this restaurant shows its true colors. The bagels stale after one day, for $18 (cash only, BOO HISS!) this is unacceptable. They also have a tiny bagel selection which is inappropriate considering the name. While originals types like plain, poppy, sesame, and egg are okay, they need more eclectic items to attract a better crowd. Their everything bagel tastes outright nasty. Do not roll the dice and gamble your luck here. You will lose. read more

Today was my first time going there, tried a sample of their blueberry and walnut raisin creamcheese, which lacked flavor and was not a fan of the texture. aside from that, i still decided to give the place a chance, chose their blueberry bagel with plain cream cheese and added bacon to hopefully add flavor but unfortunately a few bites in and i noticed it tasted off. i opened it and noticed it was just a bunch of fat strips.. that didnt even look cooked at that. Overall, was not enjoyable and it gave me food poisioning which made me throw up. Would not recommend at all. I also tried contacting them multiple times to get my money back but there's no answer. read more

Hey! Really like your bagels. Trying hard to support yall. But for the love of god can you please start writing down orders!!! Or have some sort of system that keeps track of orders? I've come in when it's busy and when it's empty. It's truly 90 percent the same story. Order something get home it's the wrong order. Come back "you didn't order that". Multiple times I've had to watch you as ya'll make the order to make you don't do something different than what I ordered. Again trying to support you but please. Create a system. It's exhausting, especially when it's met with hostility. read more

Surprisingly I came on a Sunday morning and there was no line! I ordered my usually plain bagel with cream cheese and jelly. The bagels are good quality and fresh. My only gripe is that they are a little pricey and add the 4% surcharge for card transactions -- boo. read more

Flatbush Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

First I want to say get the apple cinnamon cream cheese!! Yes it's that good!! The team was so accommodating and even opened up a little early to prep my 5 dozen order. My staff loved the bagels and the cream cheeses. The bagels were right out the oven and authentically New York City grade A bagels!! The staff was very accommodating and really helped me organize the best bagel breakfast for our amazing staff. read more

Pretty good bagel spot, but more on the average side. I got an everything bagel with jalapeño cream cheese. The everything bagel didn't really have a ton of flavor despite having a lot toppings sprinkled on. It pretty much tasted like a plain bagel. The freshness was also hit or miss. The middle of the bagel was nice and soft, but the outer edges were a bit difficult for me to chew. I also wish they had more flavors of jam because they only have grape. read more

Flatbush Bagels - everything bagel w/jalapeño cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Nothing good, nothing bad, but it is the local bagel shop. The prices are standard and the bagels are fair, but nothing really stands out in a good or bad way. I've been to many better bagel shops, but this one is close by so I can't complain. I generally like my bagels to be crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside, but Flatbush Bagels are just generally a bit dense and have no hole in the middle. I will say that the Lox and Cream Cheese bagel with the add-ons was worth it as compared to your generic everything bagel with cream cheese, but that's not within everyone's price range. All in all, a decent bagel that you can't complain about. read more

IDK what all the negative reviews are about all I know is I just stopped there and got a toasted bagel with lox and scallion spread and it is absolutely delicious. I give it five stars and they were fast and the nicest people EVER, literally read more

Flatbush Bagels - Toasted garlic bagel with scallion and lox cream cheese. Yum. - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I had some bagels delivered yesterday. My toasted sesame bagel was fresh, plump, and loaded with cream cheese. I asked for tomato on it too, which they majorly skimped on. All I got was a thin slice in there. My bf had a bacon, egg, and cheese on a toasted everything pumpernickel bagel and he loved it. I thought it was interesting that his everything bagel had toasted fennel and oats on it. Don't they normally just have toasted onion, sesame and poppy seed? Fennel is kind of an offensive flavor -- you either love it or you hate it, but I digress. We also got a french toast bagel because we were curious what it would taste like and sure enough, fresh toast! It'd be great with a strawberry or blueberry cream cheese. All and all I was satisfied and I'd order from them again. In terms of in-person service, I've been there a couple times and it's fine. The guys run it like a typical NY deli where you're expected to know what you want when it's your turn to order. They're not the warmest bunch, but in this context I don't really care about that. I will say though, it doesn't run as smoothly as it did when it was Bergen Bagels. Both times I've been since it turned to Flatbush Bagels, they've been out of things we wanted, whereas when it was Bergen it seemed like they were constantly cranking out fresh bagels and keeping the baskets full. read more

Flatbush Bagels - Bacon, egg and cheese on pumpernickel bagel - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The iced coffee was not the best, and the bagels were just okay. Salt bagel had too much salt, everything bagel didn't have enough. Plain bagel was delicious and the apple cinnamon cream cheese was good. read more

Love to come here in the mornings when I need a quick breakfast or when I feel compelled not to cook! Always go for the bacon, egg, and cheese on any bagel. I usually go with everything or garlic. Alongside another bagel with just scallion cream cheese. Super delicious. Their bakery items are nice b/c they aren't too sweet while providing a good amount. The best time to go is right when they open or a little past 9 am so you don't have to deal with too many people trying to get in and out of the place, since it's right next to a station. read more

Flatbush bagels is the best. Their bagels are so soft and light. They give a good helping of cream cheese. The workers are always friendly and quick! The bagels are best eaten right away, but they also keep for several hours. read more

My husband and I went here a few weeks ago for BEC on bagels and as usual they were delicious. It's our go to spot in the neighborhood. The service was great. It was during rush hour and the woman working the register was extremely friendly and helpful with getting our order and making our coffees. Will definitely be back soon. read more

Love the fresh delicious bagels here. I wished there one close to me. Friendly staff and come here to get my usual dozen which I then would freeze.. When it's time to eat just microwave it for 55 secs and comes out just like as delicious like freshly baked one. read more

What's with all the hate? This is a great, quick-service, no-nonsense spot with a huge menu. The bagels are usually a hefty size and the schmears are generous. There's a wide assortment of cream cheeses and spreads: my favorite is the egg salad ~*with dill*~, which I haven't seen anywhere else. This place is sooo much better than Nagle's Bagels that used to be on Lincoln Road and the staff is friendly and hardworking. They program the register with funny messages sometimes =) My only wish is that they'd get cold brew on tap. I don't care for the iced coffee, so I usually get my bagel and then head to Cinnamon Girl nearby for my drink. read more

Love the staff, always a warm welcome at Flatbush Bagels....and can't beat those big soft bagels! They are the best. This is our go to bagel shop! read more

Bagels and smear. It's fast and loud and know what you want before you show up, but the bagels are incredibly plump and delicious. If you are going to panic because you're indecisive in a NYC bagel shop, order ahead on Yelp! It does take a while since it seems to always be slammed, but just plan ahead and you'll have the best bagels in the PLG/Flatbush neighborhood. read more