I'm by no means a bagel connessiur but I found the bagels here to be tasty with nice texture…read more Seemed reasonably priced at 6 for $9. The line moved quickly. Fairly large parking lot. 3% credit card fee

Spartan old timey bagel shop with excellent bagels and some sandwiches…read more Bagels have the correct amount of plumpness and chew, perfectly crisp exterior. Many flavors of homemade cream cheese. They are famous for their bagel sticks, which I'll try next time. I had the special bagel, cranberry orange. Excellent orange flavor, not too much cranberry and perfectly plump. Lots of parking adjacent to the shop. Excellent service.

Everyone's so nice in there and the bagel sandwich was awesome highly recommend to anyone!read more

Not the best in NJ, but better than average bagels. They also make a good turkey sandwich.read more

Jersey Joe's makes a mighty fine Bagel. They're big, fluffy, and textured nicely which is why…read morethey're the perfect foundation for any breakfast sandwich or even just all by themselves with some cream cheese you really can't go wrong. I knew I had to stop in when I noticed that all the locals maintain a five star opinion here so my thoughts were that it had to be a superior business and it most definitely is. I find the Coffee here is also worth mentioning too because I literally can't get enough of their Dark Roast Blend which to me is the perfect morning cup for starting the day off right. Gimme a Large Cup and a Super Fluffy Bagel here and we can take on the World!!  or at least just get through the day, Lol. The shop does get very busy especially during peak hours of operation but when a business is this excellent that is totally to be expected. Five Stars any day of the week. Come And Get Your Bagel Munch On!!

Outstanding bagels! Bagels were perfect, crusty and delicious. All varieties were excellent and the…read moreprice was pretty good. Will return next time I am in New Jersey.

Pretty good bagels, on a par with the joint near Kings on Morris Ave. Coffee average. Spotless…read moreinterior. Usually loads of parking. Nice, generous schmear too.

Terrible experience. Waited in line as three workers looked at me, never asked for order and then…read morejumped to take the order at the first Caucasian gentlemen who came in a good 5 minutes after I had been standing there. It was so blatant that the one customer ahead of me (again a Caucasian gentlemen) remarked how blatant the store was in their disrespect. Please be warned if you are a person of color.

Really nice establishment, very clean, very open. There was plenty of friendly staff ready to take…read moreyour order which was extremely comforting and professional. Service was quick, my bagel tasted fresh and they applied the perfect amount of cream cheese. Also treated myself to a cookie, and wow, super good!!

Excellent fresh bagels and toppings, friendly staff, so efficient! There's a reason that this…read morelocation is so popular!

The. Black. Russian…read more The name sounds like something that can get you cancelled-- but it's well worth it. Get it with a little bit of cream cheese. Service is quick. Take out (one table inside) and drive while you eat.

The marble rye bagel at New York City Bagels and Deli Cafe is amazing! The service is also great!…read more Love it!

I really don't have anything to whine about... it was very busy and they have no ac in the small…read morewaiting area. You order ànd don't pay till your order is ready. It slows things down cause the space is so small. The bacon egg and cheese was awesome. Loaded with bacon and egg. She got a cinnamon raisin with regular cream cheese, the bagels were super fresh and tasty. It's out of our way but it's super tasty. I'm a fan.

They have good bagels; they're fresh, soft, and huge. Since I was at Physical Therapy next door,…read morethe place was convenient for me to stop by. Service was good. The ambiance was nice; it was a bagel place with a deli attached, and another customer was ordering so many sandwiches. They seemed to be good. I'll stop by soon to get a sandwich. As for their bagels, excellent.

Great old school deli that makes a fantastic, classic bagel. Bagel was the perfect ratio of chewy…read moreto airy and their cream cheese was fresh and delicious. Staff are really sweet and the whole place has a nostalgic, old timey feel in the best of ways. Would definitely come back!

Millburn has no shortage of delis, but Goldberg's Famous Deli is definitely at the top of the list…read more Goldberg's offers deli traditional favorites like fresh-baked bagels, lox, and sandwiches piled high with deli meats, as well as healthier options like salads when you want something lighter in an unapologetically casual ambiance. Goldberg's has been a local staple in Millburn since Tina and Marty Goldberg first opened the doors back in July 1977. The current owners took over in December 2022 and have done a fantastic job keeping the soulful and "old-school" Jewish-style deli spirit alive while making many subtle but meaningful improvements that today's diners expect and appreciate. However, it still has that authentic, "old-school deli" ambiance where you order at the counter then grab a table to wait for your meal and could end up with mismatched silverware. It's charmingly low-key and with a focus entirely on the food. The deli sandwiches are massive and the quality of the ingredients is consistently high. Unfortunately, that also means that the prices are somewhat higher than you might expect. A single deli sandwich served with a small bag of potato chips is in the $20-$22 range, which feels like a bit of a splurge for a casual lunch. That said.. You definitely won't leave hungry and the portion sizes encourage sharing or taking half of your dish home for a second meal. My dining companion and I split the West Orange sandwich, made with corned beef, turkey, russian dression, and cole slaw, on rye bread, which was excellent. We'll definitely be back. PRO TIP #1: Bring your wallet. I do feel obligated to point out that Goldberg's should be rated as a $$ / moderate price range (indicating $11 to $30 per person) rather than a $ / inexpensive price range (indicating under $10 per person). PRO TIP #2: While they don't have a private lot, there is plenty of on-street parking and municipal lots nearby. Use the mPay2Park app for the pay-by-plate meters ($0.50 per hour). Meters operate Monday through Saturday from 8am to 7pm; all street meters are free after 7 pm and all day Sunday. If the street is full, the Essex Street parking deck (24 Lackawanna Place) is a reliable backup.

Tried millburn for the first time today. My coworker and I aren't from around here. In short, the…read morestaff were kind of sidelining me because I didn't take a ticket. My coworker didn't either, but he was able to make his order and get his food before anyone ever looked at me. Well I guess the owner noticed that I was being very patient and piad for my food. The food is really good and I love the old school deli aesthetic.

Over the weekend I made my at least 5th order here. Every time it is very predictable no matter…read morewhat I get., excellent!!! They have to put a lot of thought and love into everything that they put out. Home of the best Sloppy Joes!! From sandwiches to salad to iced tea and desserts I highly recommend this place. I had to take the time to leave a review this time because I felt it was very overdue. The gobbler sandwich is yummy, The Godfadda, The Gossip Girl, I also have had an egg salad with layer of tuna salad Sloppy Joe-that is amazing! The Cobb salad is also a fave. My friends rave about all the sandwiches they have tried. They are very friendly behind the counter and the order takers are fast and efficient. It gets crowded but moves fast.

Every time it's great evert was grateful food was wonderful I got peanut banana chocolate protein…read moreill be back

Skolnik's looks amazing after the recent updates! The bacon, egg, and cheese is delicious, and the…read morestrawberry banana protein smoothie is a must-try. Customer service is top-notch--they greet you warmly the second you walk in and thank you as you leave. Highly recommend!