My wife and I made a shopping trip to Trader Joes today. My wife mentioned that she was in the mood for a bagel. Well next to Trader Joes is a Bagel shop. We looked at each other and I received a wink. We exited to our favorite Bagel shop and made our way down Beneva to Bagels and Brew. We made the right call. Even though we were right next to a competitor, we were rewarded to the best bagels in town, Bagels and Brew. It was crowded but worth the wait. My wife had her tried and true, plain Bagel, lightly toasted, with Lox Spread. I tried the Western Breakfast on an everything Bagel. Thank you, Bagels and Brew for bringing authentic Bagels to Sarasota. read more

It was my first time visiting, and I really liked the clean interior and overall layout. The service was quick, and the staff were friendly and welcoming. I tried the chicken melt bagel,it was decent, though a bit dry for my taste. I'd still come back to give something else on the menu a try. read more

See all

This is a smaller Cafe that gets a lot of traffic. The vibe is welcoming and upbeat. The service was quick,friendly,and helpful in menu recommendations. The coffee was the star of the show for me. I ordered a caramel kicker,cold and it taste as good as Starbucks or better. My party was also thrilled over the cross ain't rolls stating there "out of this world good". The menu is large and includes a variety of breakfast and lunch items that you can order at any time. So if you're feeling breakfast at noon,they got you... Someone came out and bussed our table when we were finished. They also brought us our food despite being moderately busy. The owner,Nick,was friendly and came over to greet us. Im now a regular. read more

See all

This small spot has been serving bagels and more for many years, and did a nice job serving me a toasted Everything Bagel with cream cheese today. My first visits were back when it was Brooklyn Bagel & Deli and I was happy to learn the same owners are back offering not only bagels but also breakfast and lunch sandwiches. Determining the chewiness of the bagel was more than I wanted to tackle this morning, I just enjoyed my food. Whether boiled of steamed, it was an excellent snack on my way to Costco. I love the saltiness and seeds, the bagel was easy to eat, and the cream cheese a cool and welcome addition. As I mentioned, the place is small with four tables and a few counter seats inside. Parking is available right outside the door and there was a table or two outside. The place was clean and had a pleasant feel. While I was there, I watched a steady stream of customers placing orders or picking up orders placed online, some recognized by the person behind the counter and addressed by name. I love locally owned popular businesses with repeat customers. Yet it was never so busy that there was much of a wait. read more

Bagels & Brews Cafe - Bagels Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

The past 4 years we've had 3 Bagel Shops at this location. The neighborhood was anxiously awaiting for the opening to check out the shop under its new ownership. Visually and atmospherically, not much has changed from the previous owners. When I stopped in, there were just two other customers and a few employees -- I'm sure that'll pick up once snowbird season rolls back around. My order was simple: an Everything Bagel, scooped, toasted WELL, with Scallion Cream Cheese. Unfortunately, the execution missed the mark. The outer crust of the bagel was decent, but the bagel overall was tough and lacked the chew you'd expect from a true New York-style bagel. Also worth noting: there was a very heavy hand with the salt on the seasoning -- not ideal for anyone watching their sodium intake. The scallion cream cheese did have fresh scallion pieces, but the base cream cheese had a sharp, almost metallic aftertaste. Oddly enough, it tasted exactly the same as it did back when it was Brooklyn Bagels -- which wasn't great then, either. As for the toasting? Not even close to well toasted, which was disappointing considering it's such a basic request. I'm hopeful that as the new owners settle in, they'll start to put their own stamp on the place and raise the quality. This area desperately needs a proper New York bagel shop, and with a few key improvements, The Bagels & Brews Cafe could become that go-to spot. read more

Bagels & Brews Cafe - Scallion pieces mixed into the cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Yummy bagels!! I have been seeing this place be mentioned in lots of different tik Tok videos and I figured it was time for me to try it. I got a jalepeno cheese bagel, double toasted with jalapeño cream cheese. This is the first place in Sarasota to take me seriously when I ask for it double toasted, the cheese was melted on the bagel and there was a nice crisp to the bread. The bagel was delicious and the cream cheese portions were generous! Great value and came out super quick! I will definitely be back. The workers were very friendly and a nice vibe to start your Monday off with. read more

Bagels & Brews Cafe - Jalapeño cheese bagel with jalapeño cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

I was told this was the former Brooklyn Bagel owners. Use to frequent them all the time. Place looked very clean with great customer service with everyone working together. Very underwhelming on the bagels. I am not a fan when there is enough cream cheese for three bagels. Today there wasn't even enough for 1/2 bagel at this point. If you enjoy a tough bagel this is for you maybe it will be better when toasted. Usually can knock out several bagels in one sitting today O ate just a little more than half and threw it away. Fresh bagels I am not a fan of toasting. Not even sure they are made on premise like they did in the past. They said they were fresh but did not seem to be that fresh. Like they were made last night and brought in. May have been an off day. Toasted the bagel next day just not a fan of this bagel read more

Bagels & Brews Cafe - Everything Bagel with cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Our first visit. I had an Original with kielbasa on a whole wheat bagel and it was delicious. The place is cute and the people super friendly. We will be back. read more

This place is a gem! I tried the 6 bagels in a bag, lox and bagel, and morning mess breakfast sandwich. They were all delicious. I highly recommend it! read more

I'm no bagel expert, but this place has the best bagels I've ever had. So soft and just the right amount of chewiness. My favorite go-to order is The Original with bacon or ham on a Spinach Swiss Cheese bagel. Soo delicious! Nice and hot when it comes out too. The jalapeño cheese, multigrain, and blueberry bagels are notable too. All the workers there were super nice and friendly. :) Overall, delicious food and great service! read more

On Google search, the listing comes up as Buddy's Bagels, however, they are not Buddy's Bagels. When asked if they were a part of Buddy's Bagels they did not deny it very sneaky. I definitely could tell the difference in the bagels from the different shops. Not recommend Bagels and Brew Cafe! read more

Great staff and yummy food! Highly recommend. I tried the lox of love on a plain and it was super simple, fresh and the bagel was fluffy! You should check it out when in Sarasota read more

Attentive staff and a consistent product. Our go-to for bacon /egg/cheese on a bagel. Priced fairly. A must do-drop-in ! read more

Bagels & Brews Cafe - Bagels Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

I had the western bagel and it was delicious! The muffin was the best muffin I ever had. Not exaggerating at all, seriously, it was so soft inside. Perfect muffins! The coffee was pretty good as well. The workers were very attentive and they were all so sweet. read more

See all

This was our first and definitely not the last time we will be ordering from their store. The bagels were great and the staff was even better. We'll take 20 of the E.T Cheddar bagels please and thank you!! We will definitely recommend to all those that ask for the best bagels in Sarasota - Longboat Key Resort Staff :) read more

How I missed this, I don't know, but I recently overheard neighbors talking about an amazing bagel place on the corner of Beneva and Gulf Gate. It aroused my curiosity and while I wasn't quite sure where it was, I soon discovered a long time it tucked in a small shopping center. The service was friendly, the bagels, amazing, and you can bet we will be back for more.! read more

Great bagels and coffee. Had the everything bagel sunrise scram and Cuban sandwich. Quick and friendly service and they put out a quality product. read more

Bagels & Brews Cafe - Menu in the back. - Bagels Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Had lunch AGAIN at Bagels...GREAT Reuben sandwich and my wife had a Jalapeño bagel with Ham and Cheese and it was also DELISH! It wasn't on their menu, but she asked and their wonderful staff and GREAT impeccable service told her they would make it for her...Wonderful ladies up front will cater to you! Lastly it was a little after noon (they close at 2:00) so they had a noon 'til closing BOGO special (x 6): "Buy 6 bagels, Get 6 free bagels" is that good or what?!?!?!? We gave a few to our across the street neighbor and have a couple in the freezer! read more

Haven't had a pork roll and egg bagel since I moved here from Jersey and this shop hit the spot. Everything was done right and I'll be going back for sure. read more

Highly recommended local spot. Food is great, clean inside, orders come out fast and the staff is wonderful.

So excited to have this Bagel Shop in Sarasota. I missed them when they closed 2 years ago. I love the new name Bagels and Brews Cafe. This place is so inviting with an enthusiastic staff happy to help you, the restaurant is spotless, it makes you feel very welcomed. The bagels here are amazing, chewy and full of flavor. They have the best crispy thick bacon grilled perfectly. The cheesecake is on point. A new product that they have is the Refresher Drinks. It's a Lotus Plant Energy drink. My Favorite Refresher is the Blue Summer Lemonade. Congratulations on reopening. read more

Bagels & Brews Cafe - Blue Summer Lemonade Refresher - Bagels Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Throwback to the good old days--my coworkers and I used to love Brooklyn Bagels! It was our go-to spot, and we were genuinely bummed when we heard it had changed ownership and became Buddy's Bagels. Still, we stayed hopeful that the new team would keep the same great quality and service. Unfortunately, after a few orders, we noticed the food quality was hit-or-miss, and the delivery options kept changing, making it tough to rely on them for our usual office breakfast runs. Eventually, we stopped ordering altogether. But then--great news--the original owner came back and rebranded the place as Bagel and Brews Cafe. I've ordered twice since the return, and both times the food has been fantastic. The everything bagel, in particular, is a standout. If you haven't been in a while, now's the time to give them another shot. You won't be disappointed! read more

Great food and service. So happy they are back!! I missed their bagels and the Reuben! I will be back time and time again. read more

See all

Tasty variety of bagels with many breakfast and lunch options. Their myriad of flavors include everything, egg everything, jalapeño, spinach and cheese, rye, and even the elusive bialy. The Morning Mess sandwich was hearty with 2 eggs, 2 pieces of thick cut bacon and cheese (I switched the American to Swiss) on a bagel, croissant or roll. Good coffee and many deli sandwiches for lunch plus NY cheesecake and more. read more

our nursing unit was provided with a wonderful breakfast! Best bagels egg sandwhich, top notch service. Always greeted with a smile. Will defiantly be back read more

Great bagels! Great food! And great service! And the store is very well presented, super clean.

What sold us was on our initial visit being greeted by Lisa. Great food service and ambience. Their reward program is also very decent.

I have never been more excited for a bagel shop to open! I was sad when Nick sold the business because it just wasn't the same! Now with Nick and his family running the shop again, and the new and improved menu, it's been a great addition back in Sarasota! The bagels are yummy, the flavored cream cheese is yummy too! I haven't tried the new drinks they offer but I will as I'm in there at least 2-3 days a week! Thank you Nick and family for reopening! read more

people here don't have a very high standard. don't bother going there. way over priced and like day old read more

Fair at best. Had a toasts onion bagel with egg cheese and bacon also coffee. Bagel was flavorless and bacon was well over cooked. Coffee was feh. Best thing I can say is that the place is clean and the staff very friendly. read more

The bagels here are super delicious! The garlic cream cheese is some of the best stuff iv ever had! Everyone there is so sweet and kind! The young woman taking my order was incredibly sweet and explained the whole menu to me! Will 100% be telling everyone about this place! read more

Bagels up to the standard of fresh out of a plastic bag from any market in town. Definitely nothing like Buddy's' quality or flavor!

Absolutely thrilled to see this bagel shop back in business under its original ownership! Hands down, the most delicious bagels in town. My husband had the steak and cheese bagel, and I went with the pork roll--both were fantastic. Fresh, flavorful, and ready to go in no time. Welcome back--we missed you! read more

The old owner is back and so is the excellent service and product! Everything was fresh and delicious , the portions were generous, and the vibe was cheerful and friendly with excellent service. The location is great! Walkable for many and if you're driving it is easy in, easy out with plenty of parking. Though they don't have a gluten free bagel (yet?) they do have a great omelette and potatoes, it was a very hearty meal. Muffins, cinnamon rolls, cheese cake are some of the items they have besides bagels, and they are top quality. I heard the cheese cake is some kind of secret recipe and it is ridiculously good! read more

I can't believe what just happened! I called the owner to see if he had a certain bagel. I wasn't sure when I could make it there because I live in Orlando. This man said he was heading my way and he would deliver some to me! This kind of service is unheard of! These owners are absolutely AMAZING! You have a customer for life! Thank you Nick for putting your customers wants ahead of everything to make sure they are satisfied. read more