Chocolate dough + mix ins: oreo brownie, chocolate chips + oreo cream cheese frosting Baked is a very cool concept where your wildest cookie combinations can be brought to life with different doughs and mix ins and even frostings. Pro tip: order a glass of milk to go with the rich and sweetn cookies :D It will come in a cutesy dino cup! read more

See all

They had a table at Food Truck Friday with two types of cookie plus dog biscuits for sale. I grabbed a lemon cookie with cheesecake pieces. It was crazy good and totally exceeded my expectations. The cookie was thick and soft, almost cakelike, and not at all too sweet. The cheesecake pieces were kind of melted into the cookie which created an amazing texture. read more

Baked of Bloomington - Lemon cookie w/ cheesecake pieces - Bakeries Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

Yes, the prices are high, but where can you get custom baked cookies in 10 minutes or less? And the "orphan" already baked cookies are usually a wide selection if you're in a rush. I also love that they sell milk to go with your cookies! read more

We were in the area for the day and tried this place out. Chose the 1/2 dozen pick 2 cookies with a friend. I really liked mine, sugar cookies with cinnamon sugar and white chocolate mix in with cream cheese frosting. Baked fresh to order in about 10-15 min wait. Fun place to try. read more

Baked of Bloomington - 1/2 Dozen (6) Cookies - 2 Kinds of Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

Amazing! Best cookies I've had EVER!! The customer service was great! She was patient and explained everything! They have indoor seating if you would like to enjoy your cookie with milk or ice cream! If you bake your own, the wait is 15 mins but so worth it!! read more

See all

Baked is the best cookie spot in bloomington! You go in and you get to build your own cookies which they bake for you as soon as you order! They have really good combo deals where you can get milk and cookies for pretty cheap! I always get the sugar cookie base with heath, toffee chips, pretzels and caramel drizzle! It always hits the spot everytime! The employees are always so helpful and very patient while you choose what to order! The restaurant has games to play while you wait, a chalk board wall and cool artwork on the wall! (old pictures not current) Stop on in if you're in the area! read more

Baked of Bloomington - Chalk board wall - Bakeries Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

See all

I walked from my hotel to Baked tonight. Location is great and easily walkable from many restaurants. Staff members were warm and friendly. Cookies were great. Crisp on the outside, soft and gooey on the inside. The dough is not overly sweet, which is important if you add a bunch of sweet mix ins or toppings. I would definitely recommend Baked! Top: chocolate chip with toffee, walnuts, and pretzels mixed in, topped with caramel and sea salt Bottom: peanut butter with chocolate chips, topped with Reese's peanut butter cups read more

Baked of Bloomington - Delicious cookies! - Bakeries Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

Great concept but ick did not like the taste nor texture at all...dry, boring, uninspired red velvet & choc chip.

Delicious customizable cookies. Each batch you customize comes with a minimum of three cookies, so if you order 6 cookies, you can choose up to 2 different flavors. Each flavor consists of the dough (chocolate, sugar, peanut butter, oatmeal, etc.), the mix-ins (chocolate chips, oreos, brownie bites, walnuts, etc.) and finally any after-bakes (frostings, drizzles, candy, etc.), essentially toppings placed on the cookies after they're baked. They have everything you could want to build your perfect cookie, and it's super easy to order online. read more

Baked of Bloomington - Menu - Bakeries Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

See all

An okay experience, didn't love it, didn't think it was horrible. We had never been before but heard it was a must try stop. We were sure how to order and the staff was not very helpful with waking us through all the options. Overall, just okay. read more

In the need of a sweet treat?! Look no further than Baked! I'm not sure what they put in these cookies but they are hands down the best cookies you will find in Bloomington. Love that they are open late, deliver or you can stop by and pick from the amazing selection of cookies. I do miss the house they used to be in but their newer storefront is just as welcoming. The staff is super friendly, happy, and knowledgeable. I love the weekly specials - one of my favorites is the Snickerdoodle. They do fun holiday cookies I.e. Butterbeer and Mint Chocolate Oreo. If these pictures don't make you want to get in the car and drive to Baked!, I don't know what will! read more

See all

I love the creativity of making your own cookies, 2-3 of ours came out pretty darn under baked/ half baked which wasn't very appetizing for the pumpkin flavor, but they did give us an extra one, so I guess that's fine read more

Baked of Bloomington - Gluten-free pumpkin, better with Reesie's, PCs, macadamia, nuts, and dark chocolate chips - Bakeries Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

Menu is confusing. Thought we were getting 2 cookies and got 6. Cookies were dry and not tasty.

Our business was nominated for free cookie friday and they showed up with 25 hot delicious cookies . snickerdoodle with cream cheese frosting, oatmeal raisin, chocolate chip , chocolate chocolate chip, these were the most amazing cookies i have ever tasted . What a unexpected treat , i can not wait to check them out this weekend. Thanks for the sweet treats read more

I also took the chance to swing by Baked! of Bloomington ! I was there 4 years ago and had an "unbaked cone". This time I ordered a dozen chocolate chip cookies and they made them while I waited. And the wait was worth it ! The staff is super friendly and there are tons of options to choose from when ordering. Next time I'll have to try something creative. The chocolate chip cookies were good ! They don't have your typical overly sweet cookie. They have their own unique flavor and are soft enough if you enjoy a cookie that isn't too hard. read more

Baked of Bloomington - Bakeries Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

See all

Just waited over 2 hours for my order that i placed online for delivery. Had to call GrubHub support to cancel my order when even the support tech could not manage to reach the restaurant themselves. I typically have great experiences here, yet i've never tried ordering delivery before tonight. i'll just continue going inside the store and carrying out instead. read more

10/10. We always get the peanut butter cookies with peanut butter cups on top and sugar cookies with sprinkles and warm cream cheese frosting. Can't be beat! read more

Baked of Bloomington - Peanut butter cookies with peanut butter cups on top. Sugar cookies with sprinkles and warm cream cheese frosting. - Bakeries Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

Cookies are delicious the Oreo cheesecake cookie is a must try. Service is pretty good. Great spot with a nice ground level floor of the street. read more

This place is so wonderful. I used to order cookies from here during late nights studying in college. Now it's in a new location (very different vibe from the house-type building before) but the variety and quality of cookies is still the best. Lots of options to choose from, you can order online, get it delivered for relatively cheap, and it's open very late. The personalization options are definitely the best if any cookie shop. One of my personal favorite combos is snickerdoodle cheesecake. Highly recommend! read more

See all

we were visiting from out of town and were really looking forward to trying their cookies. placed our custom order in at 10pm for 3 cookies and by 10:55 had still not received them. during that time watched 4 groups come in after us and leave with their order before us. asked an employee about our order and she stated "we were slammed" and they messed up our order. she gave us cookies but they were not the ones we ordered. we left and will never return!!! read more

The 13 chocolate chip cookies for $8 deal is insane. The Cookies are AMAZING right out of the oven, although they do get a little hard and tough on the edges after a while. This place has tons of variety and flavors, and the concept of baking a customized cookie right on the spot is a game changer. They don't take too long either! read more

Baked of Bloomington - Chocolate Chip Cookies (13 pc) - Bakeries Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

I love this place! Where else can you go and get a pizza box full of delicious cookies. And the fact they are open very late at night is a bonus. I just discovered they make the giant cookies too so we will need to be trying those too. read more

The cookies are great. Really used to love this place. We went every time we came to town. Last time we stopped by their box of random cookies went from $10.99 a dozen to $17.99. That's a pretty big price jump. Gouging plain and simple. We no longer come here. read more

Amazing concept and execution. Wish they had these where I live. Hope my son goes to IU so I can enjoy these cookies again.

The cookies were amazing my kids each picked out there own recipe. And they had them done in about 15 minutes. The service was amazing.

So...not bad? Honestly I didn't really like the atmosphere of the store at first because it was a tad dark and upon opening the door there was an interesting smell? Anyways, the cookies itself were pretty good, they came in a mini pizza box and had crispy edges but a soft interior but it wasn't like the falling apart kind of soft, and it was HOT!!!! So that was good. And they have really good deals and a ton of toppings and varieties. Yeah so in conclusion the cookie was better than I thought it would be. read more

Baked of Bloomington - a hand holding a chocolate chip cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

Yummy cookies and super friendly people! Jason was very understanding of our request and went above and beyond. Accommodations provided were superb! Thank you Baked! read more

I absolutely love going to Baked or ordering them on Doordash! They make my favorite cookies and I love that you can customize them! I always choose them over anyone else since they customize. They are better at customer service and they are quick! read more

Went here with the kids. Got chocolate chip cookies. Worst cookies I've tasted. Gave one to my son and he agreed, they were not that good.

Went to baked on a Friday night with some friends as I was craving something sweet. Walked into baked which is small but a cozy place to chill anD eAt some cookies. We ended up gettting 6 cookies of different flavors ranging from sprinkles to peanut butter and red velvet. I tried the red velvet cookie which was oKay. It wasn't as soft as I'd want it but the others liked the other cookies. I was only reallly disappointed that they didn't warm up the cookies as thAt would've made a huge difference! read more

Baked of Bloomington - Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

I came across a lovely cookie place while in Bloomington! I was very surprised and somewhat overwhelmed by the amount of options that could be made with cookies. They have a base flavor of five options and you can add toppings in the cookies and toppings. I got a sugar based cookie with chocolate chips and cream cheese frosting for one set and a peanut butter base Reese pieces and Reese cup for the other. I really enjoyed the peanut butter base as they are a classic cookie to eat hot right out of the oven. read more

Baked of Bloomington - a box of cookies with chocolate frosting - Bakeries Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

Fun thing to do late at night! I was very pleased with my chocolate batter cookie with marshmallow topping. However, I was way grossed out by my friend's concoction! It's not the business's fault that she wanted carrot cake cookies with lots of random toppings. She seemed to somehow like it! read more

Baked is a cookie monster's dream come true. Life doesn't get any better than customizing a fresh batch of cookies. My boyfriend and I stopped by to get Baked on my birthday (ha.) because cookies are better than cake. I ordered a hodge podge of custom cookies (they have all the options you could ever dream of) and also picked a few from the "leftovers" - all were amazing. A few of them were slightly underbaked - just like how my boyfriend likes 'em. I haven't taken advantage of their delivery service, but I definitely will in the near future. read more

Baked! is THE cookie shop of Bloomington - coming from a self proclaimed cookie expert. I have tried just about every cookie place in Bloomington and nothing ever beats Baked. I was a loyal Insomnia Cookies fan before coming to IU but Baked rose to the top pretty fast. I love that I can order them freshly baked, any way I want. The possibilities are endless and they actually don't take too long at all considering you're getting fresh out of the oven cookies. There's something about the taste in the dough or maybe it's left over from the oven but they have a unique flavor that can't be replicated. A lesser used benefit of Baked is their orphan cookies. If you want to try their cookies but don't want to wait for freshly baked ones (or you're indecisive like me) then the orphans are the way to go. I love that I can try all of the different combinations that other people have ordered and loved while also getting some inspiration for my next fresh order. Definitely give this place a visit, it's an IU landmark at this point - I don't think there's a single student who doesn't know what Baked is. They have vegan and gluten free options AND the physical building itself is super artsy and fun to check out. read more

More five stars for the goat of cookie places. Cheaper than Insomnia not to mention tastier and more customizable. I will miss Baked! When i move. read more

Baked of Bloomington - Bakeries Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

See all

What a cool concept! Make your own cookies with unlimited toppings--although I wouldn't recommend more than 3-4 topping without them competing in flavor. Vegan and gluten free choices are available along with cookie cake and ice cream sandwich options. This is such a fun place--definitely check it out! read more

Unique little cookie shop close to campus churning out amazing cookies - classic and seasonal ones. Generously sized, thick, soft and just perfectly on the verge of being underbaked. Love! read more

Baked! NEVER disappoints! I usually only come to Bloom once a year for homecoming and I make it a point to stop by Baked! every time for the best cookies EVER!!! I ordered the Munchies special which included 6 cookies (up to two flavors) and 2 pints of milk. I ordered 3 oatmeal chocolate chip and 3 chocolate chip. I was so happy to learn that they've added almond milk to the menu! Talk about a win/win! I'm so happy I had the chance to get my yearly Baked! fix! Can't wait to come back next year read more

See all

cookies were delicious but the last 2 times i went the cookies were undercooked and raw in the middle - which was kinda disappointing because i adore this place read more

I stopped in Baked without calling in an order and was pleasantly surprised at the wide variety of "orphan" cookies that were in the display case that I could choose from. The guy behind the counter was helpful in identifying the ones I pointed at. Before long, I had a box of a half dozen tasty cookies and was on my way. I picked out the oatmeal M&M's and the chocolate macadamia which were my preferred combo. The oatmeal cookies had a slightly spiced taste that I wasn't expecting in my cookie, so that took away from my enjoyment of those. But the chocolate macadamia were perfect! Nice bite to the texture and the macadamia nuts tasted fresh and had a crisp crunch to them. So, even if you don't feel like ordering ahead of time, you can still enjoy some tasty cookies by just dropping by. Review #2307 read more

See all