You will find this ice cream shop in the heart old town Nashville, IN. There is free street parking and commercial lots within a reasonable walking distance. The shop has an odd set up.You walk down a somewhat long passageway to get to it. The shop itself is not very big. There are some tables to dine at though just outside of the shop, just off of the passage way. The shop had a bunch of ice cream to choose from. I would say about 40 flavors. The guy working the counter was nice enough, but my interaction with him was limited. I orderd two scoops of Black Walnut ice cream. It was ok. I felt that it tasted like your typical ice cream. I think it was definitely over priced at $9. Don't get me wrong, the ice cream is good. It just did not set itself apart from the other ice cream shops that I have been too. Anyway, this is a viable option for those looking to find frozen treats in Nashville, IN read more

See all

Great homemade ice cream. My husband and I tried unusual flavors, apple butter for him and persimmon for me. I am glad this stop has junior and regular scoop size. read more

Tiny shop and lines out the door. Don't be fooled though, the line does move quite fast. I had mint chocolate chip ice cream in a cake cone. Their ice cream is very creamy and I'd describe the chocolate chips as more milky than dark. I prefer dark chocolate chips, so not my fav. read more

Millers Ice Cream House - a hand holding an ice cream cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Nashville, Indiana

See all

HAVE AGAIN: Great place, friendly, with some delicious looking ice cream. NOT HAVE AGAIN: The brown county camping s'more ice cream was good, but not enough to have again. read more

Unassuming and tiny, but the ice cream is tasty! They make it themselves and will give you free tastes. I appreciate that they have fun flavors like persimmon and apple butter. It's also affordable! read more

My favorite ice cream place in town! Such a cute, old school vibe and I love the piano at the entrance. The apple butter ice cream is to-die-for and I love to order it as a milkshake. The persimmon pudding is great too! Free self serve water has always been a plus. My favorite ice cream shop since I was a little girl. Very quick service too. There have been some times over the past few years where they have had unexpected closures--probably due to staffing. Might not be bad idea to call ahead if this is a major stop for your day trip to Nashville--especially in the slow season as they might not be open every day. read more

See all

Staff was awesome and super friendly. We came on a Monday when it wasn't that busy and was able to sample a few flavors. I loved the s'mores and the flavor of the day was trail mix, it was delicious!!! Highly RECOMMEND and run to the candy store across the street while u enjoy your ice cream:) read more

Millers Ice Cream House - Trailmix:) yummy - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Nashville, Indiana

Delicious ice cream and great service! Would definitely come back here anytime I'm in Nashville. read more

Millers Ice Cream House - Apple butter, blackberry, and double dutch chocolate nut - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Nashville, Indiana

B and I recently took a trip up to Nashville, Indiana to mountain bike for the day. After our trek we decided to go into town and check out some of the local spots. After lunch we decided to hit up an ice cream shop, of which there are many to choose from. We spotted Millers, and it looked good from the outside, so we decided to give it a shot. The inside of the shop is meant to be old-timey. There's a dummy at a piano with old-timey music playing throughout the shop. One cool aspect is that they have an old map of Nashville, labeled with all of the shops and restaurants (and their phone numbers, which was kind of odd). It was cool to see the town from that perspective though. Since I'm not familiar from the area I liked being able to see what all is located, or was located, there. You walk through a line into the scoop shop, where the flavors are all listed up on the wall. They do offer samples if you ask for them, but I knew what I wanted as soon as I saw it on the menu - Pralines & Cream. I ordered a scoop on a sugar cone, while B opted for a scoop of Banana Chip on a waffle cone. The flavor of my ice cream was perfect! My only complaint is that when the girl brought my cone over the ice cream was extremely soft; as in running down the sides of the cone soft. She pointed this out and put it into a cup for me. Again, the flavor was great, but I really wanted a hand scooped cone, when what I got was basically soft-serve in a cup with a cone on top of it. Regardless of the ice cream consistency, based on flavor I would definitely return to Millers! I hope to find myself in Nashville more often, as it's an adorable little town, so maybe I'll have the chance to give it another shot soon. If you're in the area, and looking for ice cream, I think Millers is a great spot! read more

See all

In Nashville, Indiana and need a creamy cold refreshing treat!?! We head over to Miller's Ice Cream House... very cute interior in an older building. Clean interior They have cones (cake, sugar, waffle) banana splits, brownie sundaes, and more... not to mention the flavors... persimmon!?! Kids had a single dip cone of chocolate (which is good), cake batter (which tastes like cold creamy cake batter with sprinkles (good but sweet), and the double Dutch brownie nut which was my favorite - YUM! Price was $3.33 each. So reasonable Service was kind read more

See all

Old school homemade ice cream & waffle cones. Persimmon pudding, player piano, very country chic. The Teeny Tiny Sundae is perfect for the little ones (and small appetites) at a price that doesn't break the bank. If you see packs of day old waffle cones, trust me & buy them. OMG SOOOOOOO good. So many uses, such a good price. read more

A tasty treat on a hot day. Millers friendly staff will let you sample all the flavors you desire. The homemade ice cream is full of flavor that the whole family enjoys. Ready for fall they carry apple butter, persimmon, and pumpkin ice creams. Blend them together and you get Thanksgiving dessert. The staff is cheerful and ready to serve. read more

See all

Blueberry Custard = Delicious! Nice and creamy texture and loads of flavor without being overly sweet. Though the store front is on Main Street, you walk into a long hallway with some seating (2-top tables) on the right and a mannequin sitting at a player piano towards the back. You go down a narrower hallway and take a right to finally find the entrance to the shop. Good thing they have signs! Once inside, they have several counters filled with ice cream to choose from and menus listing the flavors mounted on the walls behind the serving counters. Service was prompt and friendly. Good stuff! Review #1630 read more

See all

How am I just now writing a review of Millers!?!?! I have been coming here for YEARS. Seriously, probably longer than some of you Yelpers have been alive. #oldlady They have a cool player piano in the lobby, a strong a/c and plenty of seating. They have your standard ice creams, sundae's, etc, plus some sorbets, soft serve, and apple butter flavor ice cream. Yeah, you heard me. It tastes like autumn in a cone. read more

Wow the choices! So many unique flavors on display. I ultimately got the campfire flavor which was a take on s'mores. Boy was it delicious. Mom got the persimmon which wasn't my favorite but she really liked it. They let you try before you buy which I think is nice of places to do. Not a lot of seating indoors and only one bench outside so expect to eat on the go. read more

I love this place!!! Such a great place for ice cream! It's all homemade and there are tons of flavors. They explained the process of how they make and handle the ice cream. They were allergy friendly! The staff was so friendly, helpful and careful! read more

There is not much to say about this place besides, get yourself there and wait in line for some delicious ice cream! Line may seem long but it will move fast since the actual part that houses the ice cream is small, people move their way out to the tables quick. Besides, you get to look at the weird piano people while you wait... Thick, rich, creamy, delicious ice cream. I got a two scoop of Heath and split it with my husband, we weren't sure it would be enough for both of us, but since this stuff is legit, it was. It was perfect place to stop on a hot summer day while shopping around Nashville! read more

Millers Ice Cream House - Two scoops off Heath ice cream! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Nashville, Indiana

We loved Miller's!! We had a group of 18 of us and it was right before closing and it wasn't busy. The cream was AMAZING!!! Toffee Heath bar, chocolate chip cookie dough, blackberry, mint choc chip ice cream and cake batter were all ones I tried- and they didn't disappoint. Friendly staff. read more

The ABSOLUTE BEST place to get ice cream in Nashville is here! This is a traditional stop for my family and I to get our desert after we've walked store to store for awhile! I've tried many of the flavors they've had but one of my favs to get is their peppermint candy and add some hot fudge on it, makes your mouth water doesn't it?!?! If you haven't tried this ice cream parlor out I highly recommend that you do cause like I said before they ARE the best in Nashville! read more

Millers Ice Cream House - Creepy looking pantyhose people chillin' at the Millers Ice Cream parlor, but that old pantyhose man can really play that piano! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Nashville, Indiana

See all

Stopped in to get the hot cider ice cream float. I gotta say this drink is a treat. Tastes like your drinking a delicious pie topped with ice cream and washed down with cider. I'd be crazy fat if we lived closer to this place. read more

Millers Ice Cream House - Hot cider ice cream float was awesome. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Nashville, Indiana

This place is kinda hidden but well worth the find. This is my second time here and both times was great. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable. They make the ice cream there. They do different flavors depending on the time of year. The strawberry cheesecake was tasty. BUT I went with the mixed candy bar one. It was not overly sweet like I was worried it would be. This place is a must try ! read more

This is one of my all time favorite treat stops! It's tough to find old fashioned sodas, but I can always count on Millers. The chocolate soda is my favorite. The ice cream flavors are also endless- but I have only ever stolen a taste of other people's choices! read more

Millers Ice Cream House - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Nashville, Indiana

We decided to stop in and get a little ice cream at this location and we have been on root beer floats Lately with the kids. So we for around $5 we decided to get one and as she made this so called float we decided not to buy anything else. I have never seen anyone make make a float by filling the cup full of root beer and then adding a single scoop of ice cream and as you can see by the picture that is a $5 float at this location. Usually people fill the cup with ice cream and then add the soda after. Very disappointing with this scenario and the only reason I am giving 2 stars instead of 1 is because I have had a come here before that I believe was descent. read more

Millers Ice Cream House - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Nashville, Indiana

See all

This place serves homemade ice cream. A lot of flavors are provided to customers to choose. I forgot which flavor I chose. If you cannot make up your mind to choose, just asking to the staff, they will provide you some flavors to taste. read more

Millers Ice Cream House - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Nashville, Indiana

See all

Cute shop. Lots of sugar laden goodies. The gelato/sorbetto is fresh and delicious. Try the blackberry, it's like eating them off the bush. read more

Millers Ice Cream House - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Nashville, Indiana

This place never disappoints with their delicious homemade ice cream!! The service is good- many flavors are deliciously seasonal - servings are generous! read more

Amazing custard ice cream!!!!!! We ordered 2 flavors and both of them were awesome. We will return for sure

My group ordered the vanilla, chocoholic heaven, and the apple butter. Delicious! There is some seating reminiscent of an old timey ice cream parlor and a very friendly (very busy) staff! Be warned: one scoop on a waffle cone is about $4.50. read more

Millers Ice Cream House - (Half-eaten) Chocoholic heaven - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Nashville, Indiana

Stop in for a cone. I ordered one dip in a waffle cone. The waffle cone was fresh and crunchy. The ice cream was good. I wish that is would have had more Heath in it. My husband ordered sugar free vanilla and said it was just ok. read more

Yes, it's worth the hype. Yes, it's worth the line. This place is by far one of the best ice cream stores in Nashville. They have the creamiest cookies and cream one would die for! The servings are huge and they have a really good variety. Their ice cream is rich and creamy. Definitely don't bother on checking the weighing scale after since it's so worth it. They also make their own waffle cones. Plus, you can make any ice cream into a milkshake. My hubby devoured on his mint chocolate chip shake with whipped cream. read more

From the outside, Millers Ice cream looks like an ice cream parlor straight out of the 70's. It kind of looks like that on the inside too. We were wanting homemade ice cream so when we went in and saw the old machine from the 70's that is used to make the ice cream, sitting in the window, we knew we had chosen the right place. The ice cream definitely tasted homemade. They had lots of flavors too. The consistency and taste was definitely what I hoped for, really creamy, and really yummy!The only thing I was unhappy about was that they didn't have many toppings or extras you could mix into the ice cream. They didn't even have gummy bears! What an atrocity! This factor aside, this is a great place to get some old fashioned ice cream! read more

See all

Darn good ice cream! I wasn't a huge fan of the apple butter ice cream, however, I could live off of the blueberry custard! Excellent! Creamy! Blueberryie! If you like blueberries, this is a MUST! There can be long lines, so get there early. They also have a variety of smoothies, soft serve, etc. read more

Millers Ice Cream House - Apple Butter Ice Cream Atop of Blueberry Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Nashville, Indiana

See all

This was such a cute little ice cream parlor, and with indoor seating (which was clutch on the 4th)! I love it when homemade parlors offer interesting flavors. I had persimmon ice cream and it was great- not too sweet, a little spicy. The woman behind the counter was great, too. They were pretty busy but she still took the time to ask us where we came from and thanked us for making the trip out. Dave got strawberry cheesecake and peanut butter chocolate chip ice cream and both were really, really good. Especially the cheesecake. It's not often you can get a good cross over from cheesecake to ice cream, but this was spectacular! read more

delicious！i really liked the ice cream here. we ordered the brown chocolate and blueberry and they even made the waffle in house. read more

See all

The ice cream is fabulous. The persimmon pudding and ice cream is by far the best. The atmosphere is a bit dated, but it adds to the nostalgia. read more

We have been eating this ice cream for 40 years and today was as good as back then!! Soooo creamy and soothing on a hot summer day!!

This place has the best homemade ice cream in all of Indiana! They have so many flavors that are all delicious!

As far as Ice Cream in Nashville goes, this is the only place I have checked out so I can't really compare to anything else. It was certainly a good treat on a nice spring day and there wasn't even a line to contend with! I would consider myself an ice cream connoisseur though, and the ice cream here just didn't blow me out of the water. Overall I enjoyed it. The two flavors and the waffle cone I ordered were tasty and satisfying and the service was excellent. If I am ever in Nashville again I would probably come back. If you are in Nashville you should probably check it out! read more

Great place tucked off the beaten path. They have lots of flavors and everything is made there which gives it excellent flavor. Today, I got a caramel apple sundae. It was delicious and included a fresh sliced apple. A definite must visit anytime you're in Nashville. read more

I had my first visit to Miller's Ice Cream House the other day and it's a new must have every time I'm in Nashville, IN! The ice cream is wonderful and they have a huge menu, so there are a lot of things to try for future visits! Spent $10 for two people and we will definitely be going back...many times! =) read more