Great food, decent service and nice ambience. A rare restaurant with room too so you can bring a big crowd!

My husband and I came here on a Thursday night without a reservation and was able to get a seat outside. The servers were great and the location was nice to people watch and wasn't too loud. We had the caesar salad and for pastas we got the Homemade Squid Ink Tonnarelli allo Scoglio and Homemade Orecchiette Squash + Salsiccia. The portion size of the caesar salad was on the small side but it tasted good. The squid ink was spicy which we were not prepared for because it did not mention spice anywhere on the menu. The spaghetti was al dente though, and the seafood was good. I had a bite of the orecchiette from my husband and it tasted good. Portion size is on the smaller side, but I would still give this place another chance and maybe try their pizzas! read more

Barbalu Bklyn - caesar salad, squid ink and orecchiette - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Came from the Barclays and my daughter selected this little gem.. it's meticulously clean and the wait staff are attentive and helpful.. the food is inviting and delicious . You can't help but look at it on everyone's table nearby. And the aroma? Oh yeah.. we had bufala and prosciutto appetizer along with fried calamari and shrimp.. the calamari was light and delicious . The shrimp ? It was ok but the calamari was superb. The prosciutto app was beyond delicious and fresh with buffalo mozzarella.. for dinner I had squid ink pasta with tomatoes garlic olive oil and lots and lots of seafood!! Outstanding ! My diaghter had the lamb chops , cooked to perfection as recommended by our waiter - medium is was but it was more like MR as we indeed wanted it.. I would go back every day as the menu had lots of choices and they all looked tremendous .. read more

Barbalu Bklyn - Squid ink pasta . With seafood etc.. - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I found impressive cooking here! The main dish pricing is decent, though additional items raise costs. My relatives consistently enjoy eating at this restaurant. The staff delivered exceptionally as well. Our decision to come here was rewarding. read more

Date night with hubby did not disappoint! Lovely atmosphere, plenty of seating, and service is VERY nice! All the food we ordered was delicious. Romantic spot for dates and still a great choice for a friendly get-together. read more

Though on the pricy side, Barbalu is chock full of tasty pasta options. The ambiance is nice with some dimmed lighting. Great for a date night. The staff is very nice and accommodating as well. read more

Barbalu Bklyn - Homemade Squid Ink Tonnarelli allo Scoglio - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The food here is so so good!! I'm still thinking about it days later. The 2 of us split a salad, mushroom pizza, and pasta & there was not a crumb left on the plate. Everything is super fresh and perfectly cooked & they have plenty of vegetarian friendly options. Service was speedy & I definitely recommend a reservation because it was packed on a Friday night. The restaurant is not too big so it did feel a little cramped but it was worth the squeeze for that meal. They also have some really great drinks. read more

See all

Ambiance was smooth, romantic and cozy. Great spot for a date or getting dressy with friends for some amazing Italian. Waiters were always available, food came out quickly and fresh and hot. I ordered the prosciutto pizza, big enough to share but also for leftovers. Not too heavy on the toppings and the crust was crunchy and soft at the same time. Just a delicious piece of pizza that I highly recommend! Also enjoyed a glass of rose and complimentary bread and olive oil to start. My friend enjoyed and demolished the ragu pasta and a white wine. Pretty empty at first for a Tuesday night but as time went on it filled up pretty quickly so I'd recommend doing reservations just to be safe, especially if you have a large group. Excellent spot in Brooklyn! read more

See all

We were seated immediately, greeted by a friendly host. The black truffle pizza was the highlight, but everything else we ordered was delicious (the cocktails, the gnocchi, the pappardelle with short rib, and the homemade cavatelli pasta). The restaurant was beautiful, and the whole experience was so wonderful for my family. Can't wait to come back for more black truffle pizza! read more

A late lunch/early dinner and a craving for pizza led me straight away to Barbalu one Saturday afternoon. As a first timer, the ambience was welcoming and service was attentive. We started with a delicious Aperol Spritz and ordered the same pizza--The Parmiagiana. I noticed it took a little longer than usual and after finishing my meal and chatting with the pizza maker, I learned the Eggplant was roasted. The Parmigiana was a personal pizza with eggplant, tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese. Excellent. The portion size was filling and/or can be shared if selecting an appetizer to start. Great service, cozy atmosphere and delicious pizza. Solid and looking forward to returning. read more

See all

delicious pizza, but contents were sliding off the crust a lil too much for my liking. we got the broccolini and diavola. the pasta (bucatini) was great too - delicious really. caesar salad was aight cute space, prob wont run back here but no regrets in going read more

Barbalu Bklyn - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Delicious. Not the biggest menu ever. Basically pizza, salads and pasta. The diavolo pizza was amazing. The crust was tasty and springy. The soppresata wasn't too spicy. Kale salad was also fantastic. Crunchy large croutons and parm cheese. Excellent coffee good service. read more

Barbalu Bklyn - Diavola Pizza - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Very charming, winning feel, kind of like a chill neighborhood house party. The food is subtle but elevated Italian food; simple but masterful, with great textures and tastes. My favorite thing was the polenta with porcini mushrooms. The pastas were perfectly al dente, not too heavy or rich, but delicious. Olive oil cake and chocolate hazelnut cake were amazing. You can't go wrong here. read more

This is actually a great restaurant that I will return to whenever in Brooklyn! The wait staff was kind, smart and super helpful and the Italian food like pizza and pasta and salad, was 9.5 on a 1-10. We were there a bit early and needed to catch a plane, so they packed us food for the flight which saved us from eating bad airplane food. The owner was around and she asked how everything was...a very good sign that she really cares. Go there. Eat. You will enjoy if you love Italian food, a great atmosphere and really nice attentive staff! read more

Barbalu Bklyn - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Cute spot for pasta and pizza! Came with two friends on a Sunday night. We made a reservation, but it didn't seem necessary. While there were enough people, the restaurant never filled up. We ordered the squid ink pasta, the mushroom truffle pasta, and the pizza of the day (mushroom truffle prosciutto). They're able to replace pastas, so we switched out the cavatelli in the mushroom pasta with bucatini, which I appreciated! The squid ink pasta was delicious! A bit on the salty side, but texture was great and the seafood inside was cooked well. Similarly, I found the mushroom truffle pasta to be a bit salty. They overcooked the bucatini so it had expanded more than it needed to, but the flavor was great and an overall solid pasta. Pizza was DELICIOUS!!!!! I really liked the thin crust and you can see the pizzas being made in the back. We also ordered 2 tiramisus - highly recommend! They came in the same water glasses they used, so it was a perfect portion. I was pleasantly surprised by this spot. It has a cute ambiance and overall good food. Will definitely return! read more

One of the best meals I've had all year. The pasta and pizza were so light and fresh. Absolutely delicious!

Amazing pasta! Al dente, delicious options. Great service and modern-looking restaurant. Highly recommended

Eating outside on a gorgeous evening highlighted an excellent meal with great company. Crissi served us admiringly. The black Tonnarelli with assorted seafood was excellent topped with a Johnny Walker Black. The Rousse was a primo dessert. Try it. read more

See all

New. Made to order. Perfect for outdoor dates. I visited Barbalu for weekend late dinner. Even though it was close to 10, the place was packed. Outdoor seating especially was very popular during summer night. The server was very knowledgeable about food and had a great recommendation. As a group, we all ordered pizza which tasted like freshly grown veggies and hand tossed. I would like to try some other entrees like pasta dishes when I get a chance. read more

See all

Cute Italian place in Brooklyn! I liked the decor and vibes of the restaurant! I feel like it's be cute to go on a date there's no loud music and it felt pretty intimate . For food- It was honestly good but nothing too special . I liked the ragu pasta the best and the spritz was tasty! I had the calamari as an appetizer it was a good solid calamari . The pasta was good as well and I really liked the meat they used that was paired with the ragu. For the pizza- I enjoyed the sauce they used! As for service it did take a lil longer to receive my check but I liked that nothing felt rush! read more

See all

Came here for dinner to meet a friend who visiting. Wanted to find somewhere that was easy and accessible, and with good food. This place didn't disappoint! Had a reservation and was sat down immediately, got there right before the dinner rush. Service was FAST, almost felt a little rushed but they were attentive. Good variety of menu (pasta, pizza, main dishes) and a simple drinking menu. Prices weren't crazy which I loved and the dishes were good portions. Food came out fast and warm, well seasoned. A great place and would definitely come here again. Would definitely recommend to check out. read more

Barbalu Bklyn - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

During a quick visit to Brooklyn, o wanted some authentic Italian food. I loved the decor and set up of Barbalu. The service was great. I had the Caesar salad had the all roam out of dressing and was flavorful. For my entree I had the homemade Cavatelli with mixed mushrooms and black truffle. It was light and the pasta was fresh. It was a great meal. read more

Barbalu Bklyn - Homemade Cavatelli with Mixed Mushrooms and Black Truffle - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I know Barbalu Manhattan for it's Italian food and dinner menu but I decided to stop by for Brunch. We got the steak and eggs, eggs Benedict and Italian crepes. The eggs Benedict were definitely the star of the show. The home fries are also really tasty. The steak was cooked medium but was just alright. The crepes were really tasty and sweet but peach heavy. The service was good and the staff was really nice. It was quiet on a Sunday afternoon which was nice on the day and we stayed for quite some time after our meal with no complaints. Will definitely be back read more

See all

One of the best meals I've eaten and went there twice on a recent work trip. Great food and wonderful service. We had a small party one night and bigger one the next. Rare that I eat at the same place while traveling, it was that good. Recommend reservations. read more

My mom and I came for an early dinner and everyone was very accommodating and friendly! Eric especially made our experience even more special by giving great hospitality and making us feel welcomed. Will absolutely come back just to see Eric! read more

This is possibly my favorite Italian restaurant in NYC. The servers were incredibly kind and the space inside was spacious with lots of tables. They gave us a complimentary basket of bread and olive oil, which was delicious. Our pasta tasted super fresh and flavorful and I loved every bite. The service was also pretty fast too. read more

Barbalu Bklyn - Homemade Pappardelle with Braised Short Rib Ragu Homemade Bucatini Amatriciana - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Really good authentic Italian food in Brooklyn! Pizza was very flavorful and the crust was crispy on the outside, light and fluffy on the inside we loved the broccolini pizza. The short rib papardalle was also delicious! Ambiance and service were just as impressive as the food. read more

Very cozy and lovely spot. Had a luncheon/dinner hybrid there. Decor is modern, a lot of space. Food: calamari were fresh and crispy. My complaint about salads was that green salad had jalapeño slices - too spicy for me, radicchio was difficult to eat due to the way it was served and being chewy, however, both ideas were very good. That is pretty much all the critique I have. Pasta dishes were wonderful, we tried ravioli, cavatelli with mushrooms and short rib fettuccine - AMAZING. Everyone had Affogato and we shared chocolate cake (it is traditional Italian version) and tiramisu. Drinks including smash and old fashioned were also great. Service was prompt and efficient. Loved it and will come back PS The restaurant has its own alcohol menu and cork fee is $35 for byob read more

This was a takeaway order! Upon arrival there was a short wait, which wasn't an issue! The staff were super busy and friendly! The restaurant was packed! Ambiance was nice from what I saw! I would definitely recommend and dine in. The food I ordered was really good! I would try something different the next time! read more

Our group of 5 came here for a Friday dinner. The place was packed and we sat toward the back -- It was a bit loud as it looked like every seat was taken in the restaurant. The waiters were responsive and could make out the specific needs of our group. We started with the epic meat and cheese platters which honestly looked large enough for 6 people. We then each ordered a variety of pasta dishes -- though I also had the branzino. From what I gathered, the squid ink pasta was a favorite though the short rib pasta was also excellent. For dessert there was a flourless chocolate cake and something else -- though after dinner and the large appetizers, no one was that motivated. I'd like to come back on a non-peak hour for another meal. read more

See all

This is a 3.5 star spot. The pappardelle was cooked perfectly al dente with a rich tender pull apart braised short rib ragu. The bf had a broccolini pizza but it fell short of his expectations as the veggies were bitter and the white pie dry. He has been here before so he mentioned there was a better tasting pizza. This was all I had so this is all I can comment on. The pizza looked good though! Get the pappardelle if you are a carnivore. read more

Barbalu Bklyn - Homemade Pappardelle with Braised Short Rib Ragu - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The food was phenomenal. Service was quick. Portion felt small but it was so good I could have had more. read more

Barbalu Bklyn - Homemade Cheese & Truffle Ravioli w Caramelized Pear and Cheese Fondue - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The absolute best Italian food! We've been here twice and have never been disappointed. Every pizza and pasta is delicious. We got the Prosciutto and Rucola Pizza to share, which was fresh and flavorful. For the pastas, we got the Rigatoni Alla Norma, Pappardelle, bucatini, and lasagna. You can't go wrong with any of the pasta dishes. The service is excellent and I would recommend making a reservation if you're coming for Friday or weekend dinner. The ambiance is lively and comfortable. read more

Barbalu Bklyn - Prosciutto and Rucola Pizza - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Came here for lunch with some friends and we were very happy with the food and service. We ordered the prosciutto and rucola pizza, the mushroom frittata and the Rigatoni alla norma. The pizza was ok since it didn't taste like traditional pizza crust which meant it wasn't crispy. The frittata was more like an omelette but it was very good. I loved the pasta dish! It was cooked perfectly and the sauce was very flavorful. Our server was very friendly and attentive and we had a great time. We saw a lot of family with kids eating there during lunch time so safe to say it's a family friendly place. read more

See all

Just had dinner here with our family. We had the focaccia, a pizza, three of the pastas, and the chicken plus dessert (tiramisu, pannacotta, and ice cream). Everything was delicious. My son said it was the best pasta he'd ever had. Matteo was our server and he was friendly, efficient, and welcoming. We really enjoyed our dinner here and plan to come back. Great place! read more

what a lovely surprise this restaurant turned out to be! The restaurant is spacious and perfect for a group outing or a date. Was able to eat here without a reservation on a weeknight. The margherita pizza was absolute perfection - the taste and texture was so much better than expected. would absolutely order this again. also had the pappardelle and cavatelli and both were flavorful and delicious. read more

Went once. Got food poisoning from the calamari. Pasta portion was small and taste was unremarkable. read more

We picked this place simply because they could accommodate a large party. However, it was one of those gold mine finds! Food, service, drinks, atmosphere all fantastic! Literally everything was perfect and I can't tell you how many times"OMGs" I heard with every single bite. Everyone loved everything! The focaccia, olives (I hate olives and loved these) pizza and pasta... it was all perfect! read more

Food was just OK and the portions were extremely small for the prize. There are a lot of other Italian restaurants I would go to over this one in the neighborhood. read more

I've had my eye on Barbalu ever since they opened, and on Monday night I came in with my girlfriend around 7:30 and asked for a table. They were slammed with customers but after a short wait we received a beautiful two-top inside by the pizza station. Turns out this is peak dinner hour; I'd suggest making a reservation ahead of time or being patient if you want to dine around this time of day. We started off with a couple bottles of Lagunitas IPA (of course!) while munching the complimentary bread. Tear off a chunk of this freshly baked sourdough and dip it in the flavorful olive oil. Mercifully, the portion size will not spoil your appetite. Our food was taking a little while; understandable, given that every table was full of customers. The hostess sought to ease our wait by offering us a round of free drinks. I was impressed by this level of service and commitment to customer satisfaction. The watermelon margarita was also delicious: highly recommended if you desire a crisp, refreshing cocktail. Then the food arrived. I started in on the capricciosa pizza, a pie featuring red sauce, mozzarella cheese, artichoke hearts, olives, mushrooms, and ham. These toppings made for a juicy experience that I found quite satisfying. The olives are fancier than what I'm used to, the artichoke hearts were delightful, and I enjoyed the texture and taste of the thick mushroom slices. The ham was humble but satisfying, and the crust was studied and nuanced. This is pizza with a PhD. I also shared the homemade strozzapreti, a hand-rolled pasta that is essentially an elongated form of cavatelli. They serve it in butter and tomato sauce with hefty prosciutto chunks and sage. I'm not typically blown away by pasta but this dish hit the spot! The pasta was excellent, and I liked the texture and taste of the prosciutto. I didn't pick up on the sage that much, but the sauce took this dish over the top. Mamma Mia! Barbalu is classy and a little upscale, though the patrons wore such a diverse assortment of clothing that you could probably get away with whatever. That said, dress up! Nothing wrong with looking good. Easily accessibly by the F/G at Bergen Street and there's a Citi-bike rack right out front. Go show them some love. Welcome to the neighborhood! read more

See all