I really want to give Barry Bagels a 4 because we've been regulars, but lately our takeout orders have been wrong. The food's still fine, just not as fresh or consistent as it used to be. Hoping they get back to how it was, we really do love this place! I also submitted this feedback on the website at the same time I wrote this review and haven't received a reply. read more

Not bad bagel. Better than Panera but not a Fox bagel in my opinion. Good taste but not memorable.

My new favorite bagel shop! I got vanilla cinnamon bagels and plain bagels at 1pm and both were warm and soft, and the counter staff is very friendly. read more

They microwave their eggs and breakfast meat. The bagel itself is good, but lacking enough topping read more

Barry Bagels Westerville - Everything bagel - Delis Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

There's a bagel for every taste, both sweet and savory. Of the 15 bagel choices, asiago, everything, and sesame are my favorites. There are seven cream cheese, choices, of which scallion is my favorite. That's as far as I go with the pros. The cons are the employees are unwelcoming. They don't make eye contact or greet you. It takes a long time to watch the sullen workers make your order which is kind of an unpleasant experience. read more

Epic Fail. The staff was a hot mess. I felt bad for them. It is just bagels and sandwiches.

Food is great! The cream cheeses are delicious and so flavorful, and the bagels are always fresh. There is often times a line so prepare to wait since they make everything at the line. There is plenty of seating inside and even some outside options. When we went in today, there was no line. 2 of us went in and the worker took one of our orders and proceeded to make that entire sandwich, then asked me for the next order, all while there were 3 employees just staring at us, not doing anything. read more

Barry Bagels Westerville - Eggel with Meat & Cheese- Sausage, Egg and Cheese with Scallion Cream Cheese on a Sesame Bagel - Delis Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

See all

My new favorite bagel place & corporate catering place! I ordered 2 doz bagels & cream cheese for a school event the next day. I got there too late to pick them up before they closed (3pm). So bummed because I know their bagels are SO GOOD! And this is a step up from the usual. And I special ordered them Cut In Half. I felt terrible. But KAYLA was so kind & patient with me. She assured me they'd be able to use them in a catering order and not to worry, and fully refunded my card. Kayla gave exemplary customer service and with a smile. Part 2- Tried them out again but this time for lunch catering. Their Deli Trays are great, very versatile so everyone can make their own YUMMY bagel sandwich (too many picky people to make happy). The guests raved at how good everything was. And once again THANKS to Smiley KAYLA! What a wonderful human! read more

I have been ordering bagels online for pickup recently because they have pumpernickel. These are hard to find. I order 6 and ask them to slice them, then just keep in my fridge, ready to toast in the mornings. I have also gotten flavored cream cheese. It's easy & quick to order, pay, then go park in front and pick up. The staff isn't the friendliest, but then I am in and out and don't have a lot of contact with them. Happy to keep coming. They do have a nice variety of bagels, including cinnamon, and blueberry. Yum. read more

Pros: Great location Easy parking Fast service at the counter delicious sandwiches - I got the pastrami Easy to order ahead on their site clean dining area Cons: Our sandwiches weren't toasted even though that is the default asked for a pickle on the side - did not get said pickle wish there is an area on line to put in special comments - for example, I would have liked my sandwich to be cut in half Pro tip: Definitely order ahead on line so you can jump to the register to pick up. They get super busy at the lunch hour so be prepared to wait in line otherwise. read more

See all

I've been wanting bagels all week, but I am a night person and bagel places are morning-centric. Most close at 1 or 2. This one is open till 3, and was handy for my errands today, so I stopped in. Small place tucked away in a strip. Parking is cramped. Plenty of options at the counter for bagels, sandwiches, etc. I got lox on onion, and egg salad on garlic. Plus made a combo with drink and chili, and added an Asiago bagel with scallion cream cheese. The lox was great- bright "fresh" tender salmon, excellent bagel, some onions and capers adding texture. The egg salad was good- I asked for two scoops so it was overflowing. Again, good bagel, and the egg salad was lovely. The simple bagel and cream cheese was also good. The chili was like my mom's, tasty but not too spicy. There is a little heat hiding in there, so if you don't like spicy maybe stay away. Great service. Decent prices (and a check-in offer.) Fast and good. And open "late." Glad to find them. read more

The food here was insane. INSANELY BAD.... I watched a young woman put an undercooked egg on my bagel and my sausage was harder than obsidian. it was a catastrophe. read more

Great bagels and breakfast sandwiches. Friendly service although don't call at 7:30am, no one will answer the phone as they are pretty busy servicing a breakfast rush. That being said, still will be coming back as the bagels and cream cheeses were top notch. read more

We enjoyed the yummy, fresh bagels, delicious corned beef sandwich. It's a good location for us.

These bagels are very tasty and delicious! I have been here a few times and have not had a bad sandwich yet. The bagels are chewy and that is my favorite. Service isn't terrible but isn't friendly either. Can be a bit pricy but I will likely eat here again. read more

Barry Bagels Westerville - Hot Pastrami - Delis Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

See all

My new favorite bagel is lox: everything thing bagel with scallions cream cheese. The salmon is always fresh and delicious! Add rice Krispy treat for afternoon snack! Enjoy! read more

This place use to be Awesome and now it is a down right disapointment. I use to buy a dozen bagles weekly but the consistency started declining so I stopped. Tired of flat or half risen bagels. So i hadnt been for a while. So i stopped in to pick some up. There are 2 people working out front. One at the register and one making bagels. There are several in the back. You can see them sitting in the office. The person working the counter kept asking for help. No one would come to help. There was even an aurgument between workers because out of the 3 people in the office only one was on their break. 10 minutes later one of the people come out to help without a care in the world. Who cares people have been waiting for more than 15 minutes just to place an order. Now is the really troubling part. We decided to give them one more try. My wife bought a dozen bagels and a pound of cream cheese on line. No suprise the bagels were there usual half risen mess but the real issue was. They gave my wife a halfpound of cream cheese when she paid for a pound. She emailed the company and received a response from one of their joke of a managers. Who acted like she made it up until she produced pictures and a receipt. Sorry we dont need to try to beat you out a half pound of cream cheese but clearly the manager felt he did with his responce. He literally asked well what do you want me to do about it. I dont know how about you give us what we paid for. Hard to believe a bagel company wants to beat its custome out of $5 worth of overpriced cream chesse but i guess when your a theif it really doesnt matter how much it is. Again this is a shame because they were really good at one time. No they have a crooked manger that doesnt care what his staff is doing or care about their customers. read more

Unfortunately the service we had ruined us ever going back! Young ladies working (maybe 16-17 years old). Very rude and not friendly at all. The "eye roll" from one of the workers was icing on the cake!! Bagel was good, but will not not worth the service. Very disappointing! read more

I went to pick up my order that was for 2:30 a lady there said she didn't have my order that was already for. I left called an a manager Kayla was super rude on the phone said I had to come back. I explained I couldn't come back because I had went to work and I was picking up on my way to work. They refused a refund and refused to replace the food the following day. They are thieves and awful customer service. They will never get my money again. read more

The food is good when they remember to put the turkey on the turkey sandwich. The service exudes no motivation or personality. I purchased a soda, and the individual cashing me out told me the cups were next to the soda machine. They weren't. In the dining room, it is a challenge to find a clean table. Honestly, this would be a two star review if the food wasn't pretty decent. read more

Staff is not very friendly, but the food is high quality. Typically errors are accurate though once my order was way off. The company refunded me, so I will return. read more

Definitely my favorite bagel place. Their bagels are the best and let me tell you we have tried several places. Barry Bagels are very well liked so often times they will run out of bagels but fear not they always make more. It's worth the wait! They have a large variety of flavors to choose from. A few favorites are the blueberry, raisin, everything and the jalapeño. I tried the bagel with lox and was not disappointed! The staff is on top of things. They're fast friendly and efficient. From the moment you're greeted at the door until you leave the service is great. They do go the extra mile to make sure that your bagel is right as well as bringing out your bagel. It's a great place for groups with all the seating. In addition it's not too noisy. read more

Barry Bagels Westerville - Lox and Cream Cheese. - Delis Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

See all

Good God, what happened to this place? 4 years ago, when I discovered it, I would have given it 5 stars, but it has gone downhill the last 6-8 months. Service is not as gracious as before but tolerable. However, either they can no longer read, or no longer count. I place my orders online, but even then they're wrong half the time. It's unfortunate there's not much choice in far north Columbus. read more

I wish I liked Barry Bagels more, as its location is very convenient. The bagels are okay, but not better than the name brands at the store, so I have a hard time justifying paying the extra just for the bagels. The lox and cream cheese bagel, the mark by which I compare bagel shops, was about as close to a southern New York lox and cream cheese bagel as Charlie's is to an authentic Philly steak - which is to say just reminiscent enough to make you wish you were in Rockland County/Philadelphia, but not good enough to satisfy your cravings. Too much cream cheese relative to lox (largely because of simply too much cream cheese), not a New York bagel. I can't remember the name of it, but the bagel shop in the Short North pre-pandemic did a better approximation. As a tea person, Barry's made me wish I had chosen Tim Horton's. There's one option, Lipton black tea, and it's served at 99ºC, so you have to wait 20 minutes to avoid burning your tongue. Tim's serves their tea too hot as well, but has a decent selection of options. Having a green tea option and one other black tea option, be it an Earl Grey or a fortifying English builder's, would be nice. The interior area is nice. Not a ton of tables, but enough, and good lighting. No loud music like at Tim's, so it's easy enough to concentrate, although one of the TVs was unmuted and on Fox - easy enough to stay out of earshot on a not-very-busy weekday, but would be annoying if there weren't any tables far away. I'll probably go back on occasion and try more of the sandwiches, but it's not going to replace my go-to coffee shops. read more

Terrible service at Barry Bagels today, counter person messed up my order, showed anger for her mistake. Bagel wasn't cut in half, no paper wrapping, skimpy toppings. Coffee was boring and stale. Thumbs down. read more

I find it amusing that people from Barry's have SO much time to continue to argue with me about my review when they have so many mediocre to bad reviews. I had given Barry's 4 stars, then 3 stars after our most recent visit when there was almost no lox on my bagel. Instead of apologizing for their poor service, they're wasting their time arguing with me. This seals the deal for me and we'll never buy from Barry's bagels again. In response to the person from Barry's who posted a response to my review. We buy our lox at Kroger or at a Frank's Fish and Seafood Market. They always have great prices on salmon and lox. We would never buy lox from Walmart because they rarely have decent seafood. The following is directly from Krogers website. I maintain that although Barry's food is good, they have always skimped on the lox. Much more so than any other bagel shops. Kroger: Seafood Fish Salmon Smoked Nova Lox Salmon Smoked Nova Lox Trimmings (Seafood Service Counter) $7.99/lbUPC: 0026865640000 read more

Good for a quick fix of a bagel. They are small and bready. Not what I consider a NY bagel.

Best bagels in town. I haven't had a bagel I don't like. The staff is courteous and friendly. They have run out a few times of chocolate chips (they are delicious, so I understand) but they will get them out and ready in minutes. Worth the wait always :-). They impress me with their cutting skills. I get a dozen almost every Saturday and they cut them for me eve 11/23/2019 - Disappointed with the pound of cream cheese given today. Hopefully this is just a one time thing as we enjoy the service and quality normally read more

Barry Bagels Westerville - Delis Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

I've dined in and ordered delivery several times and everything is consistently fresh and delicious! I have ordered a variety of bagels with cream cheese and bagel sandwiches. My partner thought the lox bagel was very good. I like a simple "eggel" with cheese on honey-wheat. The honey-wheat bagel is, to me, the fluffiest and chewiest one but they've all been tasty! My kids love the chocolate chip bagels with strawberry cream cheese! These days, it's so nice to have a quality place to eat with fast service, delicious food, and fair prices. Sometimes the staff aren't as friendly or welcoming as they could be. People need a moment to consider the menu and ask questions before they order from so many options, and on a couple of visits I have found that the person taking my order acted like they were inconvenienced and unwilling to answer questions. The cafe is a neat, clean place to dine in and perfect for a quick date or meet up with a friend. read more

The bagels themselves are great. They're the NY-style bagel that was super trendy in the late 90's before everyone went Atkins-South Beach-Keto dieting. The cream cheeses are fluffy and the veggie ranch variety is unique and craveable. They offer some very interesting bagel flavors I've not encountered before including Spinach Feta and Sunny Grain (sunflower seed) plus the usual suspects Plain, Everything, Sesame, Cinnamon Raison etc. I've even stopped by to pick up a dozen (13) + a 1b. of cream cheese (via Groupon) so I can be the office hero for the day. I will continue to stop here when the bagel crave strikes, but I have a few observations to share: 1) The staff is courteous but they always seem flustered, in a rush or understaffed. For the morning rush, it doesn't ever seem like there's enough people on the line, especially since this location also takes online orders. +1 headcount for rush times, please. This will make a happier, more productive staff and in turn create happier, more loyal customers. 2) As I watch the staff cut each bagel horizontally one-by-one, I wince hoping there are no accidental slice to the hand injuries. For the safety of your employees and to increase production, for the love of poppy seeds, please get one of those automatic bagel slicer shoots. Thank you and you're welcome. I'm a carb freak and I love a good chewy bagel from Barry's. I hope to get in again during lunch so I can explore their soup & sandwich menu. read more

We were so happy to find a Barry's Bagels near us when we moved to Columbus! So good, and so hard to. choose a flavor.

This is my absolute favorite breakfast right now! Eggel on an everything bagel with sausage and American cheese. It's nearly perfect! read more

Barry Bagels Westerville - Everything Eggel with Cheese - Delis Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

if Barry Bagels Westerville has a million fans i'm one of them. if they have one fan i'm them. if they have no fans i'm dead. In all seriousness though; fantastic location, quick & professional service, and a chill atmosphere. Never eaten a bad thing here. we Barry Bagels Westerville read more

The price surely beats that of Panera AND I think it tastes a lot better! It was my first time having an everything bagel and i was impressed! The staff were helpful in explaining the menu options. They do offer all menu options in the morning except the soup as it was in process of warming up. Traffic is bad pretty consistent. The inside is nice, plenty of seating and many large TVs. They were currently playing sports. The price is great for the amount of food you get. Not sure why I have never been here before but it's easy to spend close to $10 at Panera for a breakfast sandwhich and a drink. The breakfast sandwhich here, price specifically , quality and taste, beats Panera hands down. Definitely recommend checking this place out for breakfast or lunch. I can promise you, you won't be disappointed. AND you'll receive 10% off for your check in!! read more

See all

* ordered through Uber* Blt wrap was great. Ordered a grilled cheese but was given bread slices and cheese. Not toasted and not melted. Just bread and cheese. Even asked under special instructions to toast the bread. Nope. Just bread and cheese. read more

Barrys has been and still is my favorite bagel place! Their bagels are top notch and one of the only places with a garlic bagel. It is great!! They have so many cream cheese options as well as bagel options. They have lunch items and cookies too. I LOVE Barry's!!! read more

See all

Great food, great service. Had a BLT on and everything bagel and they loaded up the bacon. Way to go!!!!

This was just a terrible experience. My wife loved this place at Toledo, even over by Tuttle it was okay, but I will never go back to this location. When we walked in, there were two people in line, three employees behind the counter (one cashier and two sandwich makers). Typically I would think that's a recipe for a quick experience, think again. It took us over 10 minutes to check out. We got two sandwiches (they weren't too bad) and two Mac and cheeses (which tasted terrible). When I was checking out, I said "Man, I didn't think we'd ever make it to the cashier". She just stared at me, as if to say, what DK you want me to do about it? Stuck out her hand to ask for my credit card, didn't say one word. No apologies, nothing. Then my wife asked me if I got my Mac and cheese, which I didn't, so I had to ask the rude lady to get it and she just looked disgusted. DO YOU JOB! You're in customer service, stop with the bitchy looks. In the meantime, the freaking line just keeps growing. One guy we can in after was waiting five minutes to pay, just standing there. All the while, there was an employee just sitting there, casually eating, checking his phone, literally the entire time. Why do you need a break at 10:30am? Instead of helping out and making the line manageable this kid just sat there, what a joke. If I had to guess, there was no manager on staff, or it was the cashier (usually you would want a manager handling cash when possible), but she was so darn rude I would be surprised if she still has a job even a week later. The man that helped me had a beard, was very nice. The shorter blonde girl, was very apologetic and could sense that people were sick of waiting (you ordered then there was no sense of process to complete your order). The dark skinned and haired girl at the cashier was frankly a bitch. And then you had the kid who didn't give a crap what was going on, he was going to slowly gnaw on his sandwich and check his Instagram. This place needs some training. read more

Barry Bagels Westerville - At 10:30am an employee just sat, eating food (break at 10:30am?) while the three employees (one of which was EXTREMELY RUDE) - Delis Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

My boyfriend ordered a breakfast sandwich and matzo ball soup and I ordered a bagel with cream cheese for delivery. We were amazed at how HEAVY the sandwich and the bagel was in the wrapping. We were full all the way to early afternoon! read more

I heard of this place for a while so I decided to drop in after my workout from CycleBar Polaris. I wasn't disappointed, the staff helped me figure out what was their recommendation on the menu. Although I was very simple. I ended up going with a bagel with cream cheese. Here's the story on Barry's Bagels they started in Toledo, Ohio and became very popular there and expanded their stores out to Columbus. Where they have one store in Dublin and one in the Polaris area. The manager's knew Toledo natives wanted their favorite bagel place to be close to them so they built a location in Polaris to please those natives who loved their bagels so much. I loved the matzoh ball soup as it's matzoh ball is bigger than my mom's and sister's. That's a huge compliment since I've been waiting for a big matzoh ball to be made! I've only ever had the tiny ones. The bigger the matzoh ball, the better the flavor and texture. The bagel tasted fresh and I got it toasted with scallion cream cheese. Great with the soup! Especially on a cold rainy day! If you happen to be in the Polaris area stop by Barry's Bagels and give them a try. You won't regret your experience here! You may try something you like or have never had before too! read more