I wish I could them a 3.5 because it was honestly pretty good for fast casual. My expectations were not high but I needed a quick meal. I ordered the sandwich/salad combo. I got the chicken club and powerhouse salad for $12, which was enough for 2 small meals. The club was good, with chicken breast, bacon and I pot hot peppers, tomato and lettuce with the spicy bbq sauce, not too much bread - just the right amount. The salad was solid too, tons of toppings. The service was fine for fast casual. The ambiance is as expected for fast casual. I was pleasantly surprised and would go again! read more

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - Powerhouse Salad - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Met up with a friend passing through town, and we decided to hit Potbelly--because nothing says "catching up like adults" quite like soup, sandwiches, and chips that burn slightly on the way down. It's been a minute since I've been here, and honestly, I forgot how good it is. I went all in with the Chicken Pot Pie Soup, Mama's Meatball sandwich with peppers, and a bag of Zapp's Hot Pepper chips--because moderation is for people who don't love flavor. The Chicken Pot Pie Soup? Well, let's just say it leaned more "cream of chicken" than "pot pie." The crusty topping... I'm not sure what sorcery that was, but it had the texture of something between a crouton and a pulverized Ritz cracker that lost its way. Not bad, just... confusing. cracker The Mama's Meatball, though, stole the show. Delicious, saucy, and stacked like it's proud of itself. The peppers gave it just the right kick. And Zapp's chips? Always a chaotic good choice. Overall, great lunch, great company, and a reminder that Potbelly still knows how to make comfort food without overcomplicating it. Would I come back? Absolutely. Just maybe I'll skip the soup--or bring a pie crust of my own next time. read more

Excellent sandwiches Their macaroni salad & potato salad are only second to my Mother's. You won't be disappointed in this choice of sandwich shops... read more

While I am a deli hound and love sandwiches. The bread is just not even close to being right. Worse than subway bread. A sandwich in the wrong bread is like getting an F in sandwich class. Im sorry I can never come here again. read more

This is starting to turn into my favorite sandwich shop. The atmosphere is nice and always clean. I do alot of to go orders, but this time me and my family ate inside. Either way the customer service is always good. The variety of sandwiches, sides and salads are good enough for anyone to find something they would like. The only things I have tried was soups and sandwiches now I'm looking forward to going back and trying the salads. To me this is a must try read more

I've always wanted to try Potbelly's for a quick sandwich for lunch and finally did it today. The roll was outstanding, crunchy on the outside and soft inside, with great flavor. The tuna salad was a perfect consistency with some fine minced celery in it. I added provolone cheese, jalapeños and pickles as toppings. I will definitely visit this place again. read more

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - Tuna Salad on multigrain roll - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Great staff with good suggestions, love the Iralian sub with the pepper mix highly recommended.

Ya know, there's just something about stepping into a potbelly sandwich shop. Everybody has their own order, and I feel it's very rare people step outside of their comfort zone at a place like this, which is okay! I never have ordered anything other than a wreck, with mayo, mustard, lettuce, EXTRA hot peppers, and Italian seasoning. It's always accompanied by a bag of voodoo heat zapp chips, a dream bar, and an ice cold fanta. Every blue moon there is a musician for your listening pleasure, and I've never had anything other than friendly service here. Seeing my sub slowly roll off the oven brings my heart joy like no other. If you haven't tried potbelly, I highly would recommend it. You won't be disappointed. -chip Very tasty, yeah -Munchie read more

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - Chips chip - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Very clean inside and out. Staff greeted me almost immediately. Hardly any wait to grab my pickup order (they were literally wrapping it up when I came in). The store and staff 5/5 stars. The sandwich 3/5 stars. Basic as basic can be turkey sandwich (ordered with extra mayo). Nothing exciting or attention grabbing about it. read more

See all

I ordered the turkey sandwich and it was very good. I also liked the soup a lot. It was thick and creamy. The staff was very helpful and answered all of my questions. read more

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - Broccoli Cheddar - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I really enjoy the food here. My go to is a wreck, subbing out the salami for more game or turkey. So I guess it really isn't a true wreck. The people there work well behind the counter and are efficient in processing your order. The place is in general, good order. My biggest problem is every time I have gone, I have to clean off my own table. Those same people refuse to come out from behind the counter and wipe off a table. Some of those tables have a permanent stickiness to them and need an overhaul. Over all Good place. read more

Potbelly is the bomb. The local crew here is great. Tso good I got it two nights in a row! read more

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - Italian - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

First time going to Potbelly. Soon as we walked in we were greeted by the staffs. We went on a weekday around 5:30pm. The place was pretty empty. We ordered the food to take home. I ordered the mac and cheese combo from the kids meal. The mac and cheese was pretty good. The combo came with apple sauce, 1 cookie, milk and of course mac and cheese. I also ordered from "pick your pair, sandwich and soup." I got the chicken tomato mozz sandwich and the broccoli cheddar soup. Both were pretty good. Great customer service. Good food. Clean restaurant. We will be back here again. read more

See all

Looking for a great deal on a family meal? Look no further! Potbelly has a family meal deal that feeds 4 for $19.99. The meal includes 4 sandwiches, 4 chips & 4 cookies. Wow!! The cookies are fresh and moist. The sandwiches are made to order and toasted to perfection. They also have great salads, soups, milkshakes and kids meals. read more

See all

We were traveling and found this place, thankfully we chose to stop. This was the best sandwich place ever. The sandwich and salad were both amazing and it was so much food! read more

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - Powerhouse Salad Mediterranean Nantucket Nectars Orange Mango - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Handy, and Sweetie loves Potbelly. It's fine, just not my top choice. Service was great, even during the lunch rush. There are a wide variety of sandwiches, toppings, soups, etc. Sweetie got turkey, with bacon, as usual. I got a dumpster or whatever they call it, all kinds of meat, your choice of toppings. Baby K got mac and cheese, of course, and the kid's meal accoutrements. Decent bread, decent meats, fresh toppings. I mean, it's a fine sandwich, just doesn't do much for me, and is a bit pricey for what you get. Reasonable wait time. A nice environment if you stay and eat. Warning: signage is all over the place. I could not find the kid's menu, and didn't see the soup list till I was leaving. Signs scattered all around the counter and on the walls make it hard to find what you want. You'd think they'd have it all on the big menu as you wait in line, for your, and their, efficiency. read more

I love their sandwiches. I always get a skinny roast beef and turkey with provolone cheese, mustard, oil and Italian seasoning with a side of pepper. They also have great cookies! It's a nice dine in area as well(always clean). The staff is super friendly. read more

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Great sandwich place! They have soups, salads, sandwiches, shakes, cookies, chips, etc. Lots of options for someone looking for a bite but might not know what they want! I chose to order the pair where there's a choice of soup and half a "skinny" sandwich. Very filling & satisfying! My boyfriend ordered the full skinny sandwich! Not to worry if there are any add-ons you'd like, you're able to choose more! read more

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - Chicken Club with Avocado - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Oh Potbelly what would I do without you? As someone who happened to be on the road for a few events during the midst of the pandemic, I needed something that I could take with me to eat. Even though this location is a little bit of a drive, thanks to Covid-19 and their amazing delivery radius, I was able to order from here several times. Every time I ordered even if I had to make a tweak, I've always gotten my orders done perfectly. The sandwiches are prepared well and wrapped up extremely well. I've tried many of their sandwiches and never had a bad one. While I have not stepped foot in the shop, I do appreciate every effort Potbelly makes to ensure a safe Covid delivery! read more

Ordered a chicken club and half farmhouse salad. I felt that the quality of chicken could be better but overall was a decent meal. Came with a lot of food for a very reasonable price. read more

Potbelly has been running a deal for BOGO on the Wreck sandwich. So we stopped in to get two. It was a Weeknight and not very busy. They had a whole section of the dining room closed for cleaning which seemed odd in the middle of dinner time. Again it was not busy so there were plenty of open tables but all the booths were in the closed section. This is a decent warm sandwich for the price. You can customize your toppings like any sandwich shop. read more

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - The wreck - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I don't know if it was me or the day i ordered sandwiches from this place. Beef and Mediterranean chicken sandwich were just too dry. The whole experience of potbelly sandwiches i had in chicago made me order from here, but this turned out to be a drag. I am not going to order anything from here again. Usually the sandwiches are fresh and warm, not sure what happened when they made mine, it felt worse than a subway sandwich.Not dissing subway at all here, but usually potbelly is more premium than subway is what i have felt. Regardless, the ambience and the sitting arrangements at this location were clean and quiet spacious. The place was well lit and a good location to be at in polaris. read more

See all

Great sub sandwiches they now have soup and salad . It's been awhile since I had a potbelly Sandwich . They were delicious and freshly made to order . We tried the chicken enchiladas soup very tasty read more

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - Hubby enjoying a Italian - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Loved eating here with my family. Fresh and healthy food and a wonderful staff. Shout out to Kim who made my nephew's day with her kindness!

Food: 5 Service: 2 The gentleman working was not at all friendly and also messed up my order. He didnt offer me a receipt either. I'm assuming I just caught this place on a bad day because I have been to this and other locations and never had a problem. The food was delicious as always. I had the turkey club(taste and texture like chicken..am I crazy?!) and Voodoo Hot chips. Awesome bacon on the club. As always, quality ingredients and great side/drink options. read more

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - My favorite chips. - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I'm a big fan of Jimmy John's and Quizno's. I would put this place up there with them. Closer to Quizno's in sandwich style. I'm not much into Subway. I have had several great experiences at Potbelly. They make great food, it's clean, employees are friendly, the food is fresh, it smells good, and it actually feels like someplace I want to eat my lunch! They had live music on the weekday that I stopped in, which added a little something extra for me. The only veggie sandwich on the menu is the mushroom melt, but you can customize anything. I also enjoyed that it feels more like a quaint small town sandwich shop, with reasonable prices. read more

I've ate at so many Potbelly's (this one, Florence, Louisville, West Chester, Boston Airport, and probably more I can't think of) and all of them are really good. The hot peppers are amazing as are the staff. The building is also nice and clean, and the location is great! read more

While at work today I found myself back in the standard "what should I have for lunch" situation and thought to myself, "Hey, self! Remember there's a Potbelly just down the street?" Oh yeah! It's been quite a while since I've been to a Potbelly, especially since the location closest to my home closed, so down the street I went. The store was clean and I was quickly greeted. My order -- large turkey breast and Swiss on whole grain -- was assembled and placed in the heat box where the toasty goodness is made. When it came out the other side of the heat box my sub was removed by another friendly person and topped with lettuce and other yummies. Total for the sub, small bag of Zapp's BBQ kettle chips, and a 20oz Coke was $12.62. Although that's a little more than I traditionally spend for lunch the receipt had a survey to complete which earns me a free cookie in my next visit and who doesn't like free cookies? read more

Mac & cheese outstanding & chicken noodle soup delish. Definitely suggest you to stop here Fast friendly and fresh just as their logo says Stopped by again on December 26, 2017 the weather was brutally cold so the Mac and cheese was so good. Warm and comforting. Broccoli cheese soup was soup of the day and it was outstanding. The staff is friendly and helpful. Well probably go back again read more

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - Mac & cheese with bacon and hot peppers - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Potbelly's. Yeah, a chain. Yes, it's subs. I love it. The staff is always super upbeat and friendly, and the food is always good. We have had take out orders/catering, and by far, it is one of my favorite places to get food from. read more

The toasted bread makes the sandwich. Their meatballs are absolutely delish! They're a little light on their portions, though. I always order double meat and I feel I'm not getting it from them, despite being charged for it. read more

Love coming to this location! The manager matt and his staff are always so friendly. Food is always Fresh and consistent . Restaurant is always clean! read more

Now I would rate this place higher but my last experience was horrible. The service was okay, the food was not. I ordered a vegetable soup and needless to say there are vegetables but no soup. Soup is about the only thing I can eat right now so imagine my disappointment when I noticed there was no soup! The vegetables were mushy, tasted like it had been sitting for a while. Very disappointed. read more

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Long story short; I usually only get a sandwich from Potbelly's whenever I have a "buy one, get one free" coupon. And I always get the same sandwich. Today I changed it up bc I had another coupon, but it didn't apply to the sandwich I usually get. Anyway, when I got home I found that I had two sandwiches in my bag. One with the order I placed for the new sandwich with coupon, and the other with my name on it. Opened the name one and it's my fav sandwich. Fr love Potbelly's read more

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Haven't been to Potbelly in a couple years (only because we moved out of state). This restaurant never disappoints! Fresh DELICIOUS food! Super clean. Excellent customer service! Love the decor. This was my 8 year old's first time here. And halfway through his sandwich, he asked if we could come back tomorrow! I got the Mushroom Melt on Whole Grain with all the toppings. He got the Pizza Sandwich. SO GOOD! And they have Zapps Chips. CLEAN restaurant. Kind employees. Delicious food. 5 Stars-it's obvious! read more

Inside of restaurant is dirty. Two employees behind counter on their phones texting and tables, chairs, floors, trash area, and soda fountains are in need of serious cleaning. Front doors are full of hand marks and in need of cleaning. Four customers in restaurant and no one ordering on a Thursday night at 6 pm. read more

OK, so I've been to Potbelly several times before (exclusively airports), and so this was my first time in a proper Potbelly. I have to say, I enjoyed it just as much as my previous times, and probably a bit more. The nice thing about this is that the people working there were really pleasant. My previous Potbelly experiences in airports were your typical grumpy airport employee. So, on to the food - it was really good. I REALLY like their Turkey Club. I feel like it just has the right combo of ingredients, and the quality of their meat is great. Something that I've taken to doing is subbing ranch for mayo - it really kicks it up a notch. Their BBQ chips are also really good; however, I wish they had a wider variety of Zapp's. Not sure if Zapp's makes other flavors, but it would be nice to have something like a Sour Cream & Onion or something cheddar-y. Anyways, definitely stop by here - you can't go wrong! read more

So what actually is Double A Wreck? Because if it is double meat then I don't know what I spent an extra $2.59 on. This sub has about as much meat on it is I would get on a normal 6" Subway sub. read more

Review on the meatball sandwich. Landed early evening on Sunday in Columbus, Oh. I haven't eaten all day and i went on my search to have my first Columbus fast meal. I checked on Yelp for anything near me and Potbelly Sandwich Shop (I mistaken the name as Porkbelly Sandwich Shop LOL), I hopped into my car set the GPS and drove around the corner to this sandwich joint. Driving around it is kind of hard to miss as the area isn't very well lit, I parked up front and questioned if the place was closed or not. I walk up and nope, it wasn't close. Looking at the menu deciding what i wanted to order, i went to my comfort zone and decided on the Meatball sandwich. I was kind of confused on how to order as I've never been here before until a young lady came up and asked if i decided what i wanted to order. I placed my order and told her what kind of bread i wanted (the original), as she was preparing my meal she starts talking to her co-worker. As they were talking I heard the lady who was preparing my sandwich if marinara goes on the meatball sandwich and was relieved that it does. As i was left standing there not knowing what to do. I just walk towards the register and realized.... Oh! this is like Subway, then another co-worker grabbed my sandwich and asked if I wanted anything on it, I declined and paid for my meal and left to devour it in my hotel room. Sandwich review: The sandwich itself wasn't the best I've had in fact, I'd prefer Sunbway's meatball sandwich over this. The sauce was very light leaving the sandwich tasting very dry along with the meatballs, the cheese was very skimpy as well. The price point didn't justify what I got and I was left disappointed. End short sandwich review. read more

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - Meatball sandwich was average - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Food was okay in my single experience there, but I felt it was over priced. It's probably fitting for the area/clientele at the one I visited, but I can't say I'd suggest it. read more