The negative reviews are throwing me. I think they were from growing pains a year ago. This place is bomb, and the pancakes alone are worth driving a long distance for. The setting is so peaceful and quaint. Service was great and helpful. Menu is short but quality. read more

Bedford Post Tavern - Pancakes - American Near Me - Bedford, New York

See all

My family and I found ourselves at Bedford Post Tavern for an early Fathers Day dinner. I had heard about this place sometime last year when it first opened, but it was never really on my radar. Nevertheless, my dad suggested we try it - and since I'm never one to turn down a new dining experience I booked a table and we made our way over. As the name suggests, BPT is located in Bedford. It's actually one of the onsite restaurants for the Bedford Post Inn - I was browsing their website and it looks like a super luxe place to stay (then again, Bedford so...). While the name suggests that the restaurant is a tavern, there's really only a standard bar in the first room upon entry to the restaurant. We were seated in one of the side rooms which was very nice but did not have a tavern feel at all. The space was open and airy with a bright, neutral color scheme and light woods throughout. The menu isn't too large, and contains mostly elevated American fare separated by snacks, apps, mains, and sides with an additional raw bar selection. We decided to start with two snacks - namely the popovers and smoked trout croquettes. I did not partake in the croquettes, but the popovers were pretty good. They were huge and paired with a honey butter that provided a nice complement. The consistency of some of them were a little off, though - to the point where one of them did not pop fully and came to the table cold in the middle; we brought it to their attention and they quickly rectified it. For my app I went with the heirloom tomatoes - this was in fact a burrata that was paired with the tomatoes and watermelon. This was good, the ingredients were fresh and the melon paired well with the melon. The cheeseburger was speaking to me so I decided to go with that for my main - this was a relatively simple burger paired with cheddar, raw onion, and tomato. It also came with fries that were paired with ketchup and dijonnaise to dip. The burger was tasty, and I appreciated the raw onion and unmelted cheese as it added texture and prevented the cheddar from sweating. The fries were also really good - just overall a solid dish. We opted for dessert; I had the cornbread sundae which was delicious - creamy ice cream paired with blueberries and "corn soil" (ie, crumbled cornbread) mmmm. Service was good - everyone was really friendly and made us feel super comfortable. I do feel they need to fine-tune some of the details; in addition to the popover issue I mentioned, there was a slight delay in my mother's app coming out (pet peeve of mine). Also, my dad and I both ordered the burger but cooked to different degrees - upon inspection I noticed they gave us each other's burgers; a simple swap resolved that but I'm glad I inspected the burgers first. Overall, we had a really good experience at Bedford Post Tavern - I'm always nervous dining out on holidays but they really came through. The food, service, and aesthetics were all solid. I wouldn't hesitate to return for another meal. read more

See all

We came here to celebrate my husband's birthday and the food was amazing. We started with the seafood tower and the shrimp and oysters were amazing. We also liked how it came with salmon ceviche and tuna tartare. They both were great and tasted so fresh. We then got the fried olives, which I wouldn't get again, as well as the onion tart which was amazing and very different. Next we got the branzino which was so good and the skin was perfectly crispy. We also got the steak, which was cooked perfectly and tender. I would recommend both of these main dishes. Lastly, we got the cookies and milk and lemon tart and both were good. I would definitely recommend. read more

See all

Excellent brunch buffet! Amazing fresh seafood of shrimp, lobster, oysters, salmon and salmon crudo. There is an omelette station, full breakfast station, fruits, salads, pastries, bagels and desserts. The Prime Rib was cooked perfectly served with au jus and choice of sauces. The quality of food and excellent service was well worth the $78. read more

Bedford Post Tavern - American Near Me - Bedford, New York

A destination brunch spot, so it feels special to begin with. I've had dinner at the restaurant but first time at the tavern for brunch. Love the menu and the execution. Fun ambiance but the layout with tables is a little squishy. Service is very good but does lack that feeling of hospitality, which you'd expect from relais & chateau. A few overall notes: playlist was not dialed in while we were there, lots of shuffling around and skipping of songs, which can break the mood a bit. Also, I very much dislike the outdoor smoke pit outside the tavern. It is usually light on the fire and heavy on the smoke. They should switch to a smokeless version. I don't enjoy getting nicely dressed and then leaving with stubborn smoke smell on my hair and jacket. Last, the parking is strange during events. Why can't they open up more? Parking is usually the first touch point, and it doesn't seem professionally managed, and often creates confusion for guests. read more

Small but refined menu. Introduced to my neighbors, they loved it too. Surprised to see negative reviews, which mainly effected by other non-food related factors. Not chip, but good quality and I like chef's creativity. Don't miss on cocktails! read more

We ate our way through the menu here while staying for a weekend. Everything was amazing. And the popovers were the best I've ever had! Would definitely go back. read more

Pork chop overcooked and pasta undercooked. Would not honor a gift card in violation of the law and hostess handled discussion about it in a ridiculous fashion Will not return read more

There was only a few menus for a crowded restaurant. Not enough staff. we waited at least 30 minutes for our orders which were cold when received . the table was so crowded that our plates were half on table and half on our chests. Plus we had to ask for check three times . we came here it was highly recommended and had good reviews. Cappuccinos were tasteless and cold No thank u U just lost four customers. and we drove over 45 minutes read more

This place is a disaster. I can only hope it's growing pains as I believe the current management has only been running the place for a few months. The menu was a joke. I couldn't com up with a more basic and boring menu if I tried. I had to beg for water. Even sparking water that I was happy to pay for by the bottle. When it came it was warm so then it took me another 15 minutes to get a glass of ice. And they were not that busy. I was close enough to the bar and server station to see people standing around doing nothing as I begged for water. And then we had to beg for salt as the food was woefully under seasoned. They also brought us the wrong food. Not even close to what we ordered. And I was at a two top. I will say the desert was incredible. But I can great deserts at Stew Lenard's. I wouldn't eat there again for free. read more

My boyfriend and I came here for a date night last night and it was outstanding. The cozy, rustic vibe was so good I didn't want to leave, every plate we shared was incredible, and the service was impeccable. Alex took amazing care of us, and shout out to the manager, Coleman, who went above and beyond. Do not sleep on: the caesar salad, the crab cake, the steak tartare, the cheeseburger, and the short ribs. And DO NOT forgo the chocolate tart. It's insane. Thank you Bedford Post Tavern! read more

See all

I've been dining at Bedford Post Tavern regularly since they reopened last year, and I can honestly say it's one of the best things to happen to our local dining scene. The food is consistently excellent -- highlights for me include the mushroom toast, the heirloom tomato, watermelon & burrata salad, the garlic shrimp, and both the chicken and the steak, which are always cooked to perfection. I haven't tried the burger yet, but it looks incredible every time I see it go by. Desserts are next-level -- the cornbread sundae in particular is unforgettable. And the cocktails are top-notch. I'm genuinely surprised when I see negative reviews. It honestly makes me wonder if some of those people actually dined here -- or if it's just the unfortunate reality of online reviews where great places can get unfairly dragged down. Every experience I've had has been warm, welcoming, and delicious. It feels like we finally have a NYC-quality restaurant right here in our neighborhood. Thrilled to keep supporting them. read more

Went there with my wife and son ... everything was perfect... special thx to Kerri who looked after us magnificently

Just experienced a truly incredible meal, one of the best I've had in a long time. The mushroom toast, popovers, and lobster pasta are incredible. For dessert, the cornbread sundae is non-negotiable. Possibly the best ice cream I've ever had. The service was outstanding, Sarah was an incredible server. So warm and welcoming, and we really appreciated getting to know her as well as the fantastic manager Nelson. There's a reason they're both a Relais & Chateaux property and have achieved Michelin Bib Gourmand status. I could not recommend this restaurant enough. read more

Portions are small and pricy. Service and ambiance are very good. Hard to recommend when you are still hungry after dinner

We had our company Christmas party there last night. They gave us the private, wine cellar room. We had a separate sitting room with a fireplace and our own private bathroom. The whole experience was simply superb. Family style food selections, including Short ribs which was the best I ever had. Also have a great sommelier . Highly recommend for parties and/or regular dinner read more

Newest hot spot in Bedford! Great staff and management. The food is very well thought through. read more

I came here on a Sunday for an early lunch. I enjoyed the ambience outside on the patio area. Our server was very sweet and attentive. However, I was disappointed with the food. The menu is rather limited. I would have liked if there were a few more options to select from. I ordered the burger (medium) but it was over cooked. It was your average burger. There was really nothing special about it. I also had a cinnamon roll which was ok, but a little dry. Unfortunately I will not be back based on the food. I feel for the prices being charged the food should really be better. read more

Food was fine, Service ok trying hard. Energy of owner- kind and effusive to some- not all, ourselves included. We had to reserve early, place was empty, tried to seat us at a crammed table, no drink order for ten minutes- just lousy hospitality in a so so setting. Make all welcome- we are all buying your food and beverages. Would not return. read more

food sucked. way overpriced. they gave us a crappy table in the middle of traffic. the hostess at the front looked unpolished. total junk. I'll never go again. terrible experience. read more

The current star count has to be in error. Perhaps it's a product of the former restaurant in the hotel that went out of business 2 years ago. Maybe it's jealous competitors in the area because I can say with confidence it was the best meal we've had in northern westchester/Fairfield county in the last 6 months. It was also the most chic scenes I've seen in sleepy Bedford. Every table was full with beautiful people late into the night on a Saturday. We had the popovers, onion tart (sleeper hit), salmon ceviche, stuffed lobster (perfectly cooked and the half size is more than enough), branzino and burger (exceptional, dry age flavor with McDonald's worthy fries - and I mean that in the best way). A post drink meal at the fire pit is also a must. read more

They opened about a month or so ago, have been twice now, both times were great! Friendly & helpful hosts, bartenders are great, food is delicious! Sat at the bar the first time, and then outside the second time. Tables outside are close together, but it's a lovely setting! So happy to have another great dining option in Bedford. read more

Wonderful dinner in a beautiful setting. Save room for dessert, they are not your typical restaurant afterthought; well crafted and truly delicious! I would be doing a disservice to the amazing cheesecake and others to describe them here. At the waiters recommendation I had the beet au poivre as an app, something I would have never tried and it was fantastic. Our party had the lobster frites, steak frites and branzino...all delish as well. Cocktails were lovely. We'll be back! read more

This restaurant has a ton of issues. They sat us 70 minutes after our reservation time. Took 45 minutes to get a drink once we got there. Employees clearly untrained had NO idea what they were doing. Worst of all food was borderline inedible. What a huge disappointment. Got some food and drinks comped but STILL well over $100 a head. Go anywhere else read more

Great experience at the Bedford Post Tavern! Chrissy was amazing, great service and 100% on her recommendations! Will absolutely return!

This could be the worst dining experience that we've ever had. The staff, especially the management and front of house staff is downright rude, obnoxious, and has an air of arrogance about them. It's super reminiscent of what you would find in NY city, where they have this attitude of doing you a favor by giving you a table. I absolutely refuse to go back and give these people my hard earned money. No restaurant survives in this space, but this is the first time we've ever had an experience where we have totally written off a restaurant to the point where we would NEVER try it again. If you're in the service business, you need to be nice to your customers. Dine at your own risk. The food is beyond mediocre and the drinks are weak to top it all off. Absolutely no reason to go out and spend money to be treated poorly. read more