Great location in the strip mall attached to Costco in Plain City. Great place to meet friends and family for lunch or dinner. Met some family while I was I town for my mom's birthday. Took a while to be seated as we arrived shortly after they opened for lunch on a Tuesday. Loved our waitress. The month of September is Oktoberfest so they have a special menu. Only one of us ordered from it. Classic smashburger is good. Fries are not so good. Order their Buckeye Blitz for dessert. It's great. Attached: 5 photos read more

See all

Hire more staff Waited15 min at reception desk. No napkins or silverware on the. table. Asked for a beer and took 10 min to get. Place obviously understaffed even on weekend. Will not be going back and will not recommend. Food. Ehhh!! read more

Courtney was a great server. Her personality was great. Listened to our order that was complicated due to changes. Repeated it back to make sure we were satisfied. Drinks never ran dry. Food out in a timely matter Great time. Thanks Courtney read more

Large menu and all of it is good. We had a groupmof 13 and they kept us all well supplied with drinks and food. .

My first time here. Parking was an issue due to the other stores and the fact that it's Friday night. We came here especially for the pizza. Rumor has it everyone needs to try it at least once. Well, this was my time and I'm glad I came. They did not disappoint. Now please understand, I used to live in NJ for a bit so I'm used to NY/NJ pizza. Where you fold the slice in half and watch the oil drip off. This was nothing like it. But it was still good in its own right. The difference is the dough and the water that is used. There was just 2 of us so Madison told us the 14 inch would be fine and sure enough she was right. After saying that I will come back to try out the rest of the menu. It's a nice comfortable place and our server Madison was patient and helpful. We even ordered dinner to go. Thanks for the friendly service. read more

See all

Cold fries, never got the lemon in my beer I asked for. Brussels sprouts were not cooked. Burger was ok, overcooked and hard though. Salad was good. Won't be back. read more

I love the Beer Barrel in Lima so I always want to go to the ones here. We have been to the Dublin one several times. It is definitely a place that you have to realize it's going to take a little longer. This experience was especially disappointing. It took a while to get greeted by the server, it took a while to get the server back to our table to order. We had several staff members that we interacted with that were more attentive than our server. The food took a little longer than average to get to us but was good Pizza and my son loved his kids cheese pizza. The full size pizza only had topping in the middle not all over. The other wait staff refilled our water and my husband had to stand up looking for our server to get a refill on his drink. I told the server at the beginning of our visit that we were going to get the s'mores desert. She brought us our bill and said "is there anything else I can get for you". I reminded her about the s'mores. It seemed like it took a while to it out and the fire thing was dirty and looked like it was just thrown together. We got this desert a year ago and it was much nicer looking. When we were done I couldn't find our server anywhere and she didn't have our check ready. Just seems like service and food quality are going down hill. My husband said "it always takes forever when we come here." We had previously tried the location on Roberts which we thought was worse service so we stopped going there. I guess we will have to try that location next time. Makes me sad because I want so much to have a good experience there. Please let this help you do better and improve quality. read more

Came in for brunch the other day and it was great!! The corned beef and hash was out of this world!! Also I got an $8 mimosa and it was huge!!! Nice job!! read more

Delicious pizza. Wide variety of items for everyone. Consistency is an issue. Sometimes heavy sauce and other not so much

Simply wanted a receipt, no response from their Corp Office and had to make numerous calls to the location & still waiting. Food/atmosphere at the location is great, but apparently follow-up is not in the training manual. read more

Food quality is mid and not a great value. Service was outpaced by the food. Disinterested bartender. You should train them to put utensils in front of a guest along with the menu. Food was cold by the time she eve looked my way for me to ask for a fork. More interested in her phone and joking with other staff. Won't be back. read more

a group of 9 of us went to Beer Barrel for dinner, sat quickly. our nachos came out with about 3 pc of cheese, we sent them back and when they returned they were burnt. Had to ask for our salads, with that half of the groups food came out. reached to a manager inquiring about the rest of the food, (another waitress) a lame excuse that hot and cold food got mixed up??? then our waitress claimed we yellled at her, total bs. After 90 min we asked again for a mgr, who was working in the kitchen instead of running the restaurant, this guy blamed it on a IT issue that apparently only affected our table! he comped the 4 meals that did come out, and we left. We will NEVER return to Beer Barrel! Do better! read more

What happened to this place. Wow...jacked the prices and shrink-flation. We're long term BB patrons. Findlay, Maumee, Lima, Plain City. Times are tough on restaurants but damn. read more

Had dinner here for the first time with my daughter and son in law. They had been here before . Very casual place but good food. I had the fish sandwich which was very good and chrispy . The others had the bbq glazed shrimp tacos and the pesto chicken sandwich and they really liked it. I understand the pizza there is really good . It was a sat and they were busy but our waitress, kamarie took good care of us read more

Beer Barrel Pizza and Grill - Burgers Near Me - Plain City, Ohio

See all

This is a good place to go if you want a casual beer and some average quality food but at a great price. The service is a bit slow and sometimes there's a lot of kids there so it is a bit annoying. read more

The service here was very good. The food we ordered was tasty. My daughter enjoyed the spaghetti, especially the meatballs. Her husband got a salad, very fresh and I ordered a Ruben sandwich, no bread. I have had better and I have had worse. There was a tiny container of salad dressing for the salad and very little on my Ruben. We asked for more, got small containers, and was charged extra for each of them. Except for that, everything was fine. read more

This is a great place for groups, kids, any age to have a great time and a good meal. Very good vibes, food is always well prepared, fast, and yummy, and the service at the bar is always five stars. They're lucky to have Kennedy at the bar. I come in frequently and she's always handling a huge crowd impressively and is a lovely gal all around! Easy stop after Costco or TJ Maxx and never disappoints! read more

Friend recommended this place for lunch. We were not disappointed!! Friendly service, very clean table. I got the Bourbon shrimp tacos,hubby got the meatball sub. It was all delicious!!! We will definitely be back!!! Oh had dessert, some kind of ice cream and cookie, YUM read more

Below average food at above average prices. Atmosphere is nice but the food was sloppy. Specifically the dry chicken both grilled and fried. Fries were cold and soggy with little to no seasoning. Appetizer of bruschetta was decent but that was it. read more

The one star is for the server. He was absolutely incredible. He needs to move on to another more upscale quality restaurant. The food was lacking in so many areas I hardly know where to begin. The beef soup as my appetizer was so tasteless. The ribs I ordered were hard as a rock. It seemed as if they might have been deep fried. I honestly do not know what was going on with them. I would never return to this restaurant. Such a waste of money. I had most of my food packaged up to go, and took it home to toss it. It's a never again for me. RIP Beer Barrel Pizza as I see you currently on hospice. read more

This place has a lot of average reviews...maybe I'm easy to please, but I loved my food! Our server was chill and the wait time was normal considering covid. I ordered the cauliflower bowl with salmon. The salmon was fantastic! So soft and flaked apart beautifully. At first, I thought the bowl looked kind of small, but after mixing it, there was plenty of food! The avocado chunks were super tasty too. I was very pleased with my meal. The real winner of my dinner was the s'mores because I got to roast my own marshmallows!! A little stove was provided with a blue blob inside that looked like flubber. Lol. Our waitress lit it and we used wooden sticks to roast the marshmallows. It was super cute!! It's pretty big inside the restaurant and there's a few large TVs. I bet this would be a good spot to watch a game. I would certainly return! read more

Beer Barrel Pizza and Grill - Cauliflower Rice Bowl With Oven Roasted Atlantic Salmon - Burgers Near Me - Plain City, Ohio

See all

Food ordered: fried pickles, hot pepper cheese balls, turkey club sandwich, mashed potato and bacon pizza, fish tacos....total $79. Food was very, very bland. Pizza had absolutely 0 flavor. I don't know if they ran out of the cheese balls but for the price we only got 10 ( yes, I counted). I just felt the food was very underwhelming for the price. Would come again but only if there were no other options for dining places.....for the price, definitely not a regular dining spot. read more

Beer Barrel Pizza and Grill - Mashed potato pizza (no flavor at all) - Burgers Near Me - Plain City, Ohio

We eat here about four times a year. Last night we met our daughter who lives in Columbus and ordered meatloaf dinner and two manicotti dinners. Both tasted "leftover". The manicotti in particular was obvious "nuked". The pasta was so dry on the edges it looked like a tortilla. Filling had a bad taste. The sauce was thick and sparse. Yuck. Staff did respond appropriately and asked about meal and how they could take care of things. Three staff addressed issue. I asked for discount and received it. Our server was good and offered information about menu items. However meal was quite a turn off and not sure when we will be back. read more

Super slow service - food was average - food items sat for over 30 minutes waiting to be delivered

Nice spot for lunch after hockey, staff at the front are not very friendly and the waitress was also blah. The food was good, the place is like a BW's with TV's everywhere and a big bar area. Prices are fair, decent spot read more

Beer Barrel Pizza and Grill - Cobb salad - Burgers Near Me - Plain City, Ohio

ITALIAN HOT HONEY (dolce speziato) Spicy Italian Capicola ham, sweet peppadew peppers, whole milk mozzarella, crispy pepperoni on top, pepper-infused hot honey. That is the best pizza I have had in a while. Thin. Crispy. Like crunches when you bite into it. Ask for Amanda. read more

Beer Barrel Pizza and Grill - Hot honey pizza. - Burgers Near Me - Plain City, Ohio

Terrible place to eat. Always under staffed. Wait time for food to come out is long. I had to ask the buss boy to find my waiter. Never got my second beer but was still charged for two beers. Waiter never apologized for the error. Not likely to return. read more

Sour kraut bites 5/5 - dipping sauce was excellent Garlic knots 5/5 - dip in both the garlic and the marinara Pretzel sticks 4/5 - it does come with 2 sides of cheese which was nice for sharing We split the Ruben 4/5 - no flavor really stood out, the bread was good, thousand island was ok too! Average priced food & drinks. Clean bathroom, decent lighting, and nice servers. read more

Good food at a reasonable price, they have specials almost every day, $11 for a big dish of pasta , with a side salad, Wednesday and Thursday, $8 big burgers, can't beat it ! Service was excellent and it's a fun place, and serves any size party! read more

I was looking forward to this opening, but also a little leery, since I was disappointed in the pizza at the Hilliard location. That was thin crust, and maybe was just a bad day, but I went with their original, thicker crust this time. I got the "Big Meatza" 10". It seemed even bigger when it came out, and was stacked with cheese and meats. Tasty, filling- I had so much left over I had some at work later, and it was even good reheated. Not the best pizza in the world, but pretty good, and a good value. I also had the fried green beans. Very, very good. Pretty much a spin on french fries- crispy, tasty, with a good Thai dipping sauce. Service was great. Drink refills right when I needed them, friendly and efficient service. They seemed overstaffed, which makes sense for the week they opened, and I came at an off time. Big place, lots of wood and windows. Plenty of seating options. It would be a good place to watch a game. I passed on drinks since I was on the way to work, but they had some interesting beer offerings, and a lot of mixed drinks. Glad there are more food options out this way. Wendy's and Tim's were getting old. Now if that Asian place would just open... But I'll be back here. I'll give the other pizzas a try, and they have wings and burgers, salads, subs, even chicken and noodles and some pasta dishes. It's a chain, but a local one, and I'll try to support them. read more

Beer Barrel Pizza and Grill - Fried green beans. - Burgers Near Me - Plain City, Ohio

See all

awful experiences at this place. Forst time was hairin my food. Gave them 2nd chance and was forced to wait 27 minutes in the drive thru for an online order I showed up,on time to,pick up. Food was cold and awful. Not even a sorry or offer of drink. Bad food and worse service. read more

Let's start with the good things. The service was really good, and so was the ambiance of the restaurant. Now onto the bad, I ordered the Chicken and Broccoli Alfredo, which took at least an hour to come out. Granted I was with a large group at the time, but there was not many people there. The chicken was super chewy, and the taste of it was horrible. The noodles were undercooked, and the sauce tasted like they just took it out of a jar and nuked it in the microwave. The only part of the dish that was good was the broccoli, which if they messed that up it would have been an accomplishment. Would not recommend. read more

Oooooooffffff. Terrible. We walked in and got sat immediately at 6pm - 4 of us. Hostess brought the menus with her. 21 minutes later I had to flag someone down to tell them we would like to order. 6 minutes later our waiter showed up and now it's too late to order food since we only had an hour. He said he wasn't told we were sat. Terrible. Be very cautious if you're going to come here. read more

Beer Barrel Pizza and Grill - Seating area - Burgers Near Me - Plain City, Ohio

literally took forever for the most mid food and took forever to get the bill. Pizza tasted like nothing and the service was so slow. It smells like old people in here. read more

Good social distancing at this restaurant, but service and food are only average. Got the 10" 2 topping pizza and the sauce lacked any flavor. The cheese fries appetizer was watered down liquid cheese. Sadly, I left and didn't bring home the leftovers. read more

Beer Barrel Pizza and Grill - 10" 2 topping pizza - pork sausage and mushrooms - Burgers Near Me - Plain City, Ohio

See all

Wonderful service by Macy and Marissa behind the bar! They are both so friendly and provide amazing service. So happy to see them when we come in!! Oh would you consider Potato Skins on the appetizer menu? read more

Other than being extremely cold in the restaurant, the staff were exceptionally friendly. The service was spot on and the food was fabulous. Reuben sandwich with chips was the best I've had in quite a while! The meatloaf and mashed potatoes with brown gravy was also quite tasty! There was a lot of food for the price and a go container was needed for both of us. The setting is open, friendly and very comfortable. Thank you for a great dinner experience!! read more

Great food selection, lots of variety! Big set-up, lots & lots of TVs, and a fun place! The staff is super nice, the hostess kept waving to the kids and our server Cassie was amazing! There is pizza, salads, pasta, subs, tacos, and BEER! read more

Beer Barrel Pizza and Grill - Lots of TV and a couple big screen TVs! - Burgers Near Me - Plain City, Ohio

Beer Barrel has been one of my favorite places to eat for the past few years. The location in Plain City is my favorite Beer Barrel location (same shopping center as Costco). The restaurant is clean, visually appealing, and there is no shortage of TVs in case we don't want to miss the game, or simply run into a lull in conversation. Throughout the pandemic, we have opted for carry out or delivery via DoorDash. Ordering delivery directly from Beer Barrel's website/app will NEVER happen because of the ridiculous delivery fees Beer Barrel charges ($9.99 delivery charge + driver's tip to my home which is 4.2 miles away). I cannot say enough about Beer Barrel's French Onion Soup - the best I've ever had - simply amazing! Beer Barrel's Baby Back Ribs are insane! The Triple Pepper Burger is one of the absolute best burgers I've had and they are consistently outstanding! Beer Barrel also has great chicken wings, Au Gratin Potato Casserole (unbelievable - must try), and of course, the pizza's are very good. We usually get the Supreme EBA (everything but anchovies) on original crust. It is loaded with toppings; however, I do wish they would use more pizza sauce and put toppings closer to the edges of the crust. They charge for extra sauce and the pizza is usually a bit dry without it, and there is a good 1" to 1.5" ring around their original crust pizzas that doesn't have toppings and that area tends to be dry and a waste of money. Their pizza is not cheap, so I expect a little more for the price! read more

First time here and great experience ! We sat at the bar and the bartender was very attentive . Food was very good Great space ! We will be back read more