Got a tip from a friend to check this place out. Took a drive out to Plain City to try Pioneer…read morePizza out. I was met my a super nice girl (didn't get her name) , they were super busy already. I ordered a medium 38 mm pepperoni, cracker crust and hot honey. FORGOT to order the garlic butter crust. I sat down and watched some basketball in the dining area, they also have a bar area next to it. Not even a doubt that they can accommodate a lot of people. The pizza came out pretty quickly even though they were busy. The pizza was cooked perfectly, the sauce had a great tomato flavor. nice and smooth. They then layered the perfect amount of Grande cheese, then loaded up on Ezzo's pepperoni and then topped it off with a good amount of Hot Honey on top. This was a perfect pizza and the taste. Yummy!!! I did get to talk with John-the Regional Manager while I was there. He said they had been in business since 2019. They emphasize that the customer always comes first. They make their dough fresh every day. Besides the indoor area they have a patio also. A rarity is they have their own delivery drivers, not wanting to have to depend on another company. If you get the opportunity you have to check them out. You won't be disappointed.

for extra sauce on sub. It barely had any…read more Obviously their is no quality control. CHECK YOUR FOOD.

We live about 20 mins away from this restaurant, but had seen it come highly recommended on one of…read moreour local FB pages, so we thought we'd give it a try because we are never overly impressed with our local pizza options. We ordered their "feed the fam Friday" which included a large 1 topping, Italian sub, garlic or cheesy bread, and 2 liter of soda for $25. When I tell you this meal was worth every single penny of $25! The topping, meat, and bread ratio on the sub was outstanding! The flavor of the sauce that came with the cheesy bread was soooo good. Sweet, yet savory. And the pan pizza with the old fashioned pepperoni grease cups. Man... We are officially stuffed for the night with almost a large pizza and half an order of cheese bread left lol The staff was so nice too! They saw me trying to carry my large order and opened the door + offered to walk me to my car and help me. We will definitely be back!

We went here on a Thursday night for the first time & were EXTREMELY impressed! This was our first…read moretime here, & we wanted to try something new. From the moment we walked in, it was 5-star treatment! Service was VERY friendly & helpful. We placed our order at the counter & went to sit in the dining room to wait for a kitchen staff member to come out with our pizzas. The wait was approximately 20 mins. The pizza we ate, was a large deluxe & it was fantastic! Plenty of sauce, plentiful toppings with good distribution & nice thin, crispy crust. Wonderful taste. Just excellent. I overheard the Mgr. talking to my fiancée about how they had been in the area now for approximately 30+ years. HOW HAVE I NEVER HEARD ABOUT THIS GEM OF A PIZZA SHOP?!? This place is GREAT & you should take some time & drive out to Plain City, OH & check this place out! (Check out their website for full menu.)

Now under new management they have decided to illegally charge TAX on their food, shame. I know…read morethey know it is against the law because some of my friends told them and even showed them the state law on their phone. This is a big mistake for the new management. Stop the TAX!

Wow I've been coming here for a while now and go on a Tuesday at 230 and they say no more per game…read moreit will be 20 dollars for half hour or 40 per hour. I usually can get 4 games in an hour by myself. Before the increase I would pay like 15 bucks for 4 games. I won't be back

We had our Christmas party there, good pizza . Bindery&Specialties printing company !read more

Simply great! More later if I get a chance. Classic small town atmosphere. Ezzo was delicious. Dori…read morewas a wonderful host

Staff members are awesome- great tavern pizza - get the charred pepperoni pizza. Nice outdoor…read morepatio, restaurant is clean and organized.

This place has one of the best atmospheres of any pizza place I've ever been to. The staff are so…read morefriendly and welcoming, and you can actually see very well into the kitchen all of the effort and careful preparation they are taking to make these wood fire pizzas. You can actually see they don't use any pre-packaged cheese because they shred it right in your field of view from real loafs of cheese. I have experience in a deli so I know my cheeses, and while I was talking to the chef, I got to know precisely what kind of mozzarella they would use to get the best quality on a pie (a low moisture type of mozzarella that doesn't affect the cook in the brick oven). The sourdough bread they use is fantastic, can't recommend it enough, go try it for yourself.

The sourdough crust is awful!!. The crust is chewy which is fine but it is soggy. I forced myself…read moreto finish the last few pieces just so I wouldn't throw it away I'm a New Yorker born and raised, and new to this area and I've had some of the best pizza in the world at Bruno's in Brooklyn. And the bar was high lemme tell you! THIS is fine if you've never had good pizza before, but horrible if you have. I appreciate the time and care that Tyler's puts into their product but this was just nasty. I guess I'll be going back to Vicks pizzeria (Which ain't great either!) The problems with Tyler's pizza: -Sourdough crust-nasty -not enough sauce -smoked sausage is not Italian sausage This is NOT NY style pizza and the hype is misplaced. The tang of the sourdough is off-putting and disrupts the flavor profile. On a positive note the delivery guy was super nice!

Service inside was friendly , though it was the first time I ever threw pizza away. Ingredients…read moreluke warm and tasted old and not fresh. Dough undercooked. Whole pizza tasted like mush. Was not expecting a premium pizza from Domino's, though this was inedible.

Wouldn't order pizza from anywhere else! Love the food and our service was so above par! We go out…read moreof our way to order from here.

What a great find in Hilliard. This food truck punches well above its weight in delivering…read moretraditional Indian flavors in inventive fast casual fusions. I only had one of their Indian pizzas - the Chicken Tikka Masala - but if I had the stomach capacity, I would try several more. Along side the pizza, I had the Chilli Manchurian. This one had some REAL spice to it, so know what you're getting yourself into before ordering. It's good if you can handle the spice or dilute in with some rice like I did after getting home. Don't sleep on the sauces either. You will absolutely thank me if you get the Tandoori Ranch.

OMG! The pizza is amazing! I think about it a lot:) Quick…read moreand unbelievably delicious! I highly recommend!!

Every time we go here, the staff is always friendly. This time they had a band inside playing…read moreChristmas music which made the environment super fun and the food is phenomenal. They messed up our order and gave us that pizza and remade another one because they felt so bad and both were delicious.

Wonderful pizza and a huge space. Live music every Friday and Saturday. Lots of parking space…read more Separate beer garden. Not a great selection of beer was a disappointment. I ended up with a white claw.

Awesome wait staff! Meatball sub is a 100/10…read more Garlic bread, pretzel bites and popcorn were all delicious as well

We are new to the area and was told to try Buckeye Family Pizzeria by our new friends since my wife…read moreand I really love Benny's. I ordered the BLT pizza and my wife ordered the Parm and Garlic Wings. We noticed everyone received complimentary popcorn and we weren't even asked if we would like some. The place was not really busy at all, probably because it felt like it was less than 60 degrees inside and everyone was wearing coats. One person at the bar had gloves on. We asked our server if they could turn up the heat and we were told that this is typical this time of year in here. The bathrooms were dirty, freezing, and the water never even got warm washing my hands. The service was slow and it took what seemed like forever to get our food. When we finally received our food the pizza's lettuce had a little brown texture to it. The pizza was extremely greasy and taste-wise didnt hold a candle to Benny's. My wife's wings were slimey on the inside. We told our server and she told us that happens when customers don't ask for them twice baked. She took the wings back for the second baking. This made a big difference and she said the flavor was a little better prior to them being twice baked. Her soda was fine and she was offered a refill. I had a Coors Light that tasted flat so I switched to water after that. Probably would have had 2-3 beers but not when it tasted flat. Overall we were very disappointed with the experience. Not a clean restaurant, food was not good, service was mediocre, restrooms were cold and dirty, and we froze for the hour and a half we were there. We will not be returning and will just stay at our staple. Bennys!