Best pizza outside of NYC! Staff is friendly and accommodating and the pizza is AMAZING!

Still great pizza, service and inside is your classic pizza slice place, nothing overly fancy but clean. Stopped in to try their collaboration pizza slice with another local eatery, a general tso's chicken pizza. It was well done but I think I will stick to ordering them separately! Husband enjoyed his two slices of pepperoni! Still one of our favorite pizza places in Williamsburg! read more

See all

If they are ever actually open, you will enjoy the pizza. I suggest you check the website or call to make sure they are open, hours seem to change very frequently. On the bright side, the pizza is delicious and the crust is crispy. They are on the pricey side but quality pizza. I've ordered several pies recently and the guys taking the order always mess the order up and make a large instead of a medium. I end up paying more for my order than expected and this has happened twice in the last month. 8.5/10 for pizza and 6/10 for customer service and location 7/10. read more

Bellissimo Pizza Cafe - Large pizza and menu - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

Fantastic pizza, great crust. They had a huge selection of options. Staff was very friendly.

We came in about 30 mins to closing time. Didn't realize it was almost closing time. Once we noticed that, we wanted to take our food to go so they could close up. They insisted we stay. Next time, we'll help them sweep up before we go as appreciation. Oh. Food review. We got calzones. Do not get a calzone for a single person unless you want multiple days of food. They're definitely good enough to enjoy for multiple days though, so don't let that deter you. They are awesome, they are big, they will probably break your plastic fork. I'll always look for an opportunity to return. This place is just that good. read more

Never had a bad experience or pizza from this place!! New job makes it easier to get to for lunch break.

Wow this place was a bad experience. First of all, all of their pizzas are pre-made... they just toss it in the oven. I know this is a common practice, but this does not live up to any real good New York style pizza. Honestly, this level of pizza is akin to something you might get in a bowling alley. The one good thing about the pizza is that it's very thin, but they are so greasy that you need a mop to sop up all the grease--and the crust is dry like cardboard. The interior of the place is nice and the bathroom was clean. What grossed me out is the fact that the owner or the manager was just standing back in the food prep area/space where you select your pizza just scarfing down pizza slice after pizza slice. Nobody wants to see that. Oh, and you can't get cups of water there, you have to buy a bottle. Bottom line is that this place isn't any good. It's not good pizza. Little Charlie's and Sal's are much better pizza options in Williamsburg. read more

See all

I really enjoyed eating here. Most of the staff was nice and welcoming as we entered. Service was relatively fast. They got us our pizza slices quickly and it took a few minutes for our garlic knots but that was expected. They also checked on us frequently if we needed anything else which was nice as well. The food was so good!! I can't wait to move down here and be able to eat here occasionally. read more

Bellissimo Pizza Cafe - Specialty Slice: (forget what the first was called) but it's an all meat and the second slice is a buffalo chicken slice. - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

The food and service was on point. We particularly enjoyed the Bronx Bomber and chicken wings.

Coming from NY, Belissimo is a close to NY pizza you'll get! Great service and awesome atmosphere! The best in the business!

First let me say that the pizza here is some of the best in the area. Service is decent and the ambiance reminds me of NYC Pizza shops. I would normally give 5 stars here but I have to mention that their daily operating hours are totally bipolar. They change often and sometimes you can show up during their scheduled open timeframe and be disappointed by a paper note taped to the door stating a totally different schedule than advertised online. For that reason I can only give 3 stars. If they get more consistent their schedule I would comeback and update my review because they definitely serve a really good pizza product here. read more

Bellissimo Pizza Cafe - Sicilian slice! - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Delicious pizza and the best customer service . Ambiance is amazing. 10/10 would go back again.

Had lunch there recently while out shopping and split 2 slices with my wife, costing nearly $13, no drinks. Scrumptious pizza, from toppings to sauce and wonderful crunchy thin crust. Sticker shock probably a sign of post-Covid times, but maybe a function of a reduced schedule of being open? Will likely return for the occasional few slices, but $32 for a 19" pie, regardless of flavor, is a bit much outside of NYC or other major city. In same breath, I can't imagine trying to own and run a restaurant in today's economic climate. read more

Bellissimo Pizza Cafe - Pepperoni and sausage as well as Buffalo Chicken - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

we ordered a pizza to share but you can order by the slice as well.. so yummy!! quick service. nice staff!

Outstanding pizza by the slice One of the best New York style pizza I have had here in Va. read more

Best Pizza in town!! Classic crisp crust, very high quality toppings. Wish we had one on our side of town. They need to open another shop!! Forget the rest this is the best!! read more

Being from NY/NJ area this pizza is close. My personal opinion is the dough should be thinner (personal preference). It has great taste. Good ingredients. Staff is quick. Room to sit down. read more

Our family loves pizza and this is our favorite!! Always fresh pizzas different varieties of pizza. The store is always clean. Service is ok, they seem like they don't want to be there but I don't really care cause we keep going back read more

I'm picky about pizza and the 'Burg doesn't have many really good options. Lots of pizza places, but most are mediocre at best. Bellissimo is an exception. Their pie has just the right amount of cheese and sauce and I love that crust is slightly crispy on the bottom. Topping are excellent and the service is quick and friendly. As an independent shop their prices are higher than a chain but it is well worth the extra $. Their hours are limited to 11-3 due to staffing issues, but they are now open until 8pm on Fridays (the hours listed on Yelp are wrong). I'll forgive the owner for being a Yankees fan. :) read more

Great pizza Definitely New Jersey /New York style We had the family special and the server was kind enough to let us have both toppings on the larger pie so we could have a plain small pie for the kids It's definitely more $$ than other local pizza places but it's totally worth it Highly recommend you check this out for the next game day or poker night ! read more

We came in on a Thursday afternoon with our 5 kids (9 and under). It was past their lunch time and they were all a bit hangry, especially my 1 year old. The customer service was absolutely incredible. They went above and beyond to help keep our little ones occupied including giving us garlic knots, asking if we would like our pizza cut a bit smaller, and giving a cookie to share. There is a reason why this place has won awards. The food is incredible and so are the people. We will DEFINITELY be back!! read more

Best pizza I can remember. You may have to travel to New York to match this quality.

Good people, great service! We were visiting from out of town and I didn't think she charged me for one of my slices of pizza when I mentioned it she not only let me have the pizza she gave us free garlic knots! Very kind! read more

Coming from a girl born and raised in the heart of Brooklyn NY, this Pizza is pretty good for Williamsburg VA Pizza. The pizza crust was pretty impressive and the sauce was pretty good too. I ordered the Buffalo chicken pizza, a regular cheese slice and the white slice. My review is...the white slice is way too garlicky and the cheese is extremely over the top oily and salty. If it wasn't for the cheese I would have given this place four starts. The cheese taste a bit like school cafeteria cheese. Is it close to New York style pizza??? I am going to say NO. However, it's still pretty good. I would still recommend. read more

Bellissimo Pizza Cafe - a slice of cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

Such a wonderful pizza place! The pizza is delicious! The restaurant is always clean! The people who work there are always friendly and on top of things! We enjoy this casual family friendly pizza place! read more

Solid pizza spot which we found through yelp on the way down to Busch Gardens. It was after lunch on a weekday so we were the only ones there. The guy who toasted up our pizzas was super nice and we got four slices of different types with two drinks for $20. Definitely a great quick stop if you're in the area. For us, it was a much better alternative to eating the overpriced basic pizza at the park! read more

Bellissimo Pizza Cafe - Stopping in for some slices! - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

This place is some of the best pizza I've ever had. Out of nowhere my fiancée and I checked this place out and we were not disappointed at all. A 19" Fordham is out new weekend tradition*. Love you guys. Please don't leave. *Not fat, just love pizza* read more

Pros- *They perfectly toasted the bottom of the slice. *The lady behind the counter and the girl helping out were sweet as pie. *Their Roma Pizza was different and good, usually I only eat strait cheese pizza. Cons- *Other then like 2 stickers on the floor there was no form of distance between people. We sat down to eat and the rest of the table, back to back, filled up after that. No separation. *I understand days suck, but acting like that to customers doesn't really work well. He wasn't mean but more of a your bugging him by asking for your pizza and he just kinda blowing you off when he walks to do it. *There was no sauce in anything, the slice or the meatball sub. I had to go up and ask for some. This is the second time we have tried this place. It's not exactly bad food but more like an eye rolling experience that isn't worth doing a 3rd time read more

Pizza was good, however, I did notice them touching the food without gloves on so I'm a little creeped out. I saw the guy cooking the pizza turn the pizza twice with no gloves on. It's not sanitary to me. Guy behind the counter did attempt to not touch the food but again had no food handling gloves on. read more

Great pizza! Some interesting toppings like pickles, some old faithful toppings like pepperoni. Friendly staff and convenient service.

The suicide chicken pizza is so good! The pizza in general reminds me of back home in NY. Definitely worth the stop!

Good pizza - my wife and I came from Suffolk to visit this place on one of our "Pizza Safaris" where we try new places. Fortunately, they sell by the slice too, so we got a few different slices and had them cut in half so we could try different things. Their sauce has a very nice, sweet flavor to it. And they use Grande brand mozzarella cheese that is one of the best I've tried. I posted a picture of the Italian tomatoes they use as a basis for their sauce. Wonderful! They will sell you this "over 6lb can" for only $4.95 as well. The only reason I deducted a star is because of the environment - while clean and nice, it's more of a fast food environment than a traditional pizza restaurant. Definitely worth checking out. read more

See all

Eureka‼ Native New Yorker living in Virginia since 1999, recently moved to Williamsburg (last summer) and I finally find real NY style pizza @ Bellissimo Pizza. The freakin best! read more

Bellissimo Pizza Cafe - New York Style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Top tier pizza. Went here for lunch the other day with a coworker and I can say that this pizza was better than most other places I've been. I'm not Dave Portnoy but if i was this was a solid 9. read more

It's true that the Pizza Belt stretches from Philadelphia to Boston. Outside that Belt, it's tough to find good pizza. You'll find it at Bellissimo, which is competitive with any pizzeria you'll find in North Jersey or Long Island. read more

Loved coming back here! They have pickle pizza!! And the best quarter-pound hot dogs sautéed with onions, spicy red sauce, and mustard. read more

Bellissimo Pizza Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

My white slice was thick with cheese and deliciously garlic-y. The garlic knots were chewy and hot. I would add just a little more garlic and oil to them to make them perfect . I'm not really a red sauce fan, but the sauce on the side was tasty as well. My young companions enjoyed their plain slices. If I lived in Williamsburg, I'd definitely be a regular. We'll be back next visit. read more

I stopped by here on my lunch break yesterday and had the 2 slice and fountain special. The pizza was ok, the display of pizza kinda turned me off because the pizza looked old like they've been sitting there for a few hours. The pizza was pretty regular, nothing fancy. read more

See all

Best Pizza in Williamsburg, especially the Sicilian. It is awesome!! Hope they are open for full hours in the near future.

Good food it was delicious but a bit pricey for a couple of slices of pizza but they have a lot of options and