Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Benedetti's Supper Club

    4.0 (55 reviews)
    ModerateSeafood
    Closed Closed
    Updated over 3 months ago

    Benedetti's Supper Club Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    More like Benedetti's Supper Club

    Recommended Reviews - Benedetti's Supper Club

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Brenna S.

    Our whole Saturday night experience was wonderful! Great drinks at the bar from Nate, and our server Trish was friendly and answered all our questions about the menu. The salad bar was well stocked and clean, and the chicken gnocchi soup was amazing! We all ordered steaks and I added on a lobster tail. Everything was delicious. Steaks were prepared as ordered, well seasoned, and the lobster tail was done to perfection. All the staff was attentive and friendly and the new owner stopped by our table to check on us. It's been a while since I've been here, but excited to add it to my regular night out rotation, food and service have definitely been elevated since the previous ownership.

    Road sign
    Summer S.

    Our visit to Benedetti's Supper Club was a complete disappointment. Our party of 12 arrived before 5 pm without reservations, hoping to enjoy an early dinner. The hostesses, unfortunately, were the epitome of unwelcoming; their refusal to accommodate us, despite numerous open tables, left a sour taste from the start. We even suggested splitting our group into smaller tables to no avail. A kind fellow diner relinquished their table, offering it to us, and we ended up scattered across three tables. The hostility continued when the hostess showed displeasure as my 17-month-old walked from our table to his grandpa's. To add to the frustration, one of our tables was rushed to finish and leave, citing the need for the table, only to find it unoccupied half an hour later. This unacceptable, they seated us and did not mention a "time limit" and they were only dining at the table for 30 minutes. The culinary experience mirrored the service--disappointing. The fish, American fries, French fries, and baked potato were all disappointingly bland, and the kids' Mac n cheese resembled a budget box of Kraft. As out-of-town visitors spending time with family, this experience was a low point, and we won't be returning. Treating patrons with respect seems to be a lesson lost on Benedetti's Supper Club. Even after expressing our grievances to the manager, an apology was offered without any meaningful attempt to rectify the mistreatment of our group. A regrettable experience that left us with no desire to return. All I really wanted was the grasshopper and after part of our group was rushed out I wasn't about to order anything more.

    See all

    Photo of Mary H.
    70
    39
    0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    The Friday night fish fry is excellent. Lightly breaded cod tastes like it has been baked, not fried.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Laura L.
    67
    96
    15

    12 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Dave J.
    8
    388
    4

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    16 years ago

    Helpful 4
    Thanks 0
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of g s.
    8
    28
    16

    15 years ago

    best in rockford area,great portions

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Benedetti's Supper Club

    Is this phone number correct? I tried calling today and it's giving a busy signal. Seems weird for a business.

    View All 2 Questions

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Liberty House Grill - The salad was chilled with great house dressing blue cheese. So fresh

    Liberty House Grill

    4.1(36 reviews)
    3.6 mi

    Have gone there several times within 2 months. Their Italian dishes are huge. We went there with…read moreanother couple on a Saturday and one person ordered an Italian dinner. The plate was huge. The one dish that is really healthy is the AHI Tuna appetizer. Actually, it is enough for a dinner and is reasonably priced. We tried the AHI Tuna appetizer apiece and added on order of the Bang Bang Shrimp and it was almost too much for two. The next time, we just ordered the AHI Tuna- one apiece. Not many places around here offer AHI Tuna - they should. A healthy alternative to a Prime Rib or Steak. Drinks are excellent. Half the bartenders in WI can't make a Manhattan right. This place makes them right - 2/3s bourbon, 1/3 sweet vermouth, NOT a "Dash" or a Drop of Vermouth - 1/3. A "dash" of bitters - yes. They also use the antique cherries in them. A quality bourbon (George Dickel 8 yr.old) Manhattan was $10 (very reasonable) Great ambiance. We get there before 5PM to avoid the crowds. Probably best to call to make reservations for four or more - especially if you're going after 5PM. Next time, I will try the Italian dishes. ALSO- desserts are top rate and $10.

    I am very happy and excited that we found a new place with great food that can be delivered. Last…read moreweek I ordered a Chicken Parmigiana, A loaded baked potato and salad. The food arrived in record time and I do not live down the street! It was hot, fast and most of all good! I called to compliment them and found out that the cook/owner/main man is from Chicago. Well, no wonder. The portion size ended up to be two dinners and a lunch for me. I'm stuck at home for a while and will be ordering again. It was so nice to get a call back from Joel who also told me about his brunch! YUM. Can't wait to get in there soon! Better and faster and hotter than any delivery I've had in the last year!

    Photos
    Liberty House Grill
    Liberty House Grill
    Liberty House Grill - Cheese curds: they are so good

    See all

    Cheese curds: they are so good

    Velvet Buffalo Modern Italian

    Velvet Buffalo Modern Italian

    4.0(100 reviews)
    4.2 mi

    Great food, amazing service (Karen-server/waitress & Jim-Food & Beverage Director/Manager) &…read moreatmosphere was nice! First of all the table bread was delicious, I was never fond of butterscotch but Karen suggested the Budino & YUM! Jim gifted us Tiramisu to take home. Made my 60th birthday dinner even more special!!!

    I was staying at Hotel Goodwin for a night as I was in town traveling for my partner's job. We…read moredecided to try the restaurant downstairs, Velvet Buffalo, since we had already tried the restaurant Merrill and Houston's Steak Joint across the street (which we absolutely loved and I did a review on that restaurant as well). We ordered burrata appetizer, which I forgot to take a photo of since we were so hungry, while he ordered the farmer's trio for himself and I ordered the Short Rib for myself. Burrata and the table bread are actually fantastic. The entrees we received are very generous portions which makes it good value for the money, but at the same time, it was very heavy and a little too rich in flavor. Presentation was already great. Halfway through dinner, I was really debating between 3 or 4 stars. Because of all the positives, I was going to give it 4 stars even though the food didn't really impress me that much. Desert unfortunately tipped that scale to 3 stars. We ordered Tiramisu. It was the saddest looking tiramisu. We could tell the bottom was watery and soggy. The cake part was dried out. It does look like either it was too old or it was refrigeration issues. We took a bite regardless to be sure and we could tell by the taste that it was an older cake. As someone who's been in the restaurant industry for 30+ years, that actually could be a health violation. We did send it back and they said they'd bring a new freshly made one... which I declined. They should have done that first rather than offering that after the fact. However, the service is great overall. Just could use some work on certain things. And regardless of the restaurant, the hotel is actually very nice. If I was to be back in the area again, I'd stay at this hotel again but eat at the steak joint across the street at Ironworks hotel instead.

    Photos
    Velvet Buffalo Modern Italian
    Velvet Buffalo Modern Italian
    Velvet Buffalo Modern Italian

    See all

    The Butterfly Supper Club - Potato Skins

    The Butterfly Supper Club

    3.2(192 reviews)
    5.2 mi
    $$

    I've never had a bad meal at The Butterfly Club, and that history is exactly why I'm hoping they…read moretighten a few things back up. The prime rib and shrimp was fantastic, no notes there. But the baked potato came out only warm and undercooked, and the French onion soup needs some attention: the onions weren't caramelized, so it lacked the rich depth that dish should have. None of this is a dealbreaker, and I'll be back. I'd just love to see them sweat the small stuff again rather than lean on nostalgia and their loyal regulars. Get those details right and this is easily a five-star spot.

    The bar service was great! It was all downhill from there…read more My wife and I ordered seafood. I got the orange roughy. It was okay. The side of au gratin potatoes was at room temperature. My wife ordered cod with french fries. The cod was less than room temperature and the so were the fries. Our server came by to ask us how was the food, but didn't wait for an answer. When she did come by later we told her that the food was cold. She asked if we would like to have my wife's seafood dinner boxed up and we said no. The problem was with the attitude of the server. She didn't care. We didn't get a coupon for a different meal. Nothing. They took her meal off of our bill. All we got were the smug looks from the server we complained to management and the manager did nothing but tell us that we should have told her earlier. I have been told for decades that this was a great place to eat. I've been there four times now and twice the food was unacceptable. We will never go there again.

    Photos
    The Butterfly Supper Club
    The Butterfly Supper Club - The 'Loaded' baked potato - Side option with meal

    The 'Loaded' baked potato - Side option with meal

    The Butterfly Supper Club - Doorway

    See all

    Doorway

    Coyotes

    Coyotes

    1.0(2 reviews)
    4.6 mi

    This place is a joke! not at all how it use to be, ripped us our money, we went there asking if…read morethey had two rooms for different genres they said yes, thats the only reason we decided to pay. once we paid there was only one room with a band, they said they would pay some different jams once the bad was done. which was only gona take 40 mins. Band lasted all night. After the band was done finally we kept asking for dj to play different genre music like he promised. NOTHING! I never felt so discriminated. Never going there again! dont waste your time or money

    We arrived there on Halloween weekend at about 1:40 am. They still made us pay the $10 cover, which…read morewas very surprising. Red flag! But we proceeded. We then order 2 doubles Tito's from the bar. Some how they didn't have club soda or roses lime lol. Those are standard, run of the mill mixers. If I'm paying to get in, I expect the place to have a fully stocked bar. That's silly to not have regular mixers. The bartender was like, "we have Pepsi." Lol she really suggested Pepsi for the substitute for club soda and roses lime. What kind of bartender does this? Like no other suggestions of available mixers were suggested. Just Pepsi lol. So we order the Tito's with pineapple. We get the drinks and the total is....wait for it...$48!!!! For 2 double Tito's! I went to Vegas in August. The drinks at Coyotes cost more than any drinks I purchased in Vegas! Worth mentioning, it's located in South Beloit Illinois lol. The inside is merely decent. Not worth the cover. Drinks are highway robbery! Stay far, far away from Coyotes if you value your hard earned money. Coyotes is a money grab! There are far better places in the state line area that are reasonably priced. You don't get what you pay for. So it was $68 for 2 covers and 2 drinks and my experience was less than stellar to say the least. If you want to charge these prices, then step up your game. Stock your bar, hire knowledgeable bartenders, and elevate the overall aesthetics in the place. This is South Beloit not Vegas!

    615 Club - Scallops with crostini

    615 Club

    3.7(132 reviews)
    4.3 mi
    $$

    Outstanding food, service and atmosphere year after year... One of our long time favorites!read more

    Such a great supper club!!! Wish I could give 4.5 stars…read more We made a reservation for NYE. They were very accommodating. They let us know right away the credit card machine was down but they'd reimburse us the ATM fee. We sat at the bar and ordered a drink for about 10 mins so they could get our table ready. Upon being seated we were greeted and told the specials. We ordered a special thinking it was an appetizer. They made the exception for us and turned it into an appetizer! And thank goodness, one of the best appetizers I've ever had. The scallops were buttery and cheesy. A combo I wouldn't have thought of. The scallops were perfect and not rubbery. We ordered steaks which come with soup AND salad AND bread AND a potato. I've seen other reviews where they get a relish tray. We did not, but maybe because it was NYE? Everything was incredibly fresh and tasty. We were so full by the time our meal came. The service was top notch, the ambiance was what you'd expect for a supper club. The only thing we felt didn't hit the mark were the drinks. The wine menu is sub par and the cocktail menu is fruity beach drinks?? Otherwise everything was fabulous and I definitely recommend the NY strip steak with the cheesy potato's!! Will be eating here again.

    Photos
    615 Club - A view into the south dining room

    A view into the south dining room

    615 Club - Bread basket (some had been taken out :))

    Bread basket (some had been taken out :))

    615 Club - Old fashioned

    See all

    Old fashioned

    China House - Hibachi Steak, Hibachi Chicken, and Sushi

    China House

    3.2(25 reviews)
    2.3 mi

    First time trying this place did an online order, the pick up was fast & the people were fast &…read morefriendly as well, I was impressed with how good the food was I did a lunch special chicken lo mein with fried rice. Doesn't come with eggrolls like most combos do & was slightly small compared to other places but no complaints about the quality or taste of the food!

    This strip mall China House Buffet has plenty of strip mall parking and has a large dining room…read more Right when we entered, the staff was attentive and very friendly. The restaurant is very clean. It's bright, has the smell of fresh food. As I have an MSG allergy, I asked China House staff if they cook with MSG and if the buffet had MSG and they were very honest right away about it and said that yes, most of the food has MSG at the buffet. So what they recommended was that I order off the menu and they recommended certain items that would definitely not have msg. I did go by the buffet, and it was very clean, full of interesting options, and fresh and maintained. Because of my allergy, I adored the after the menu and I got General Tso's chicken. The order came quickly, and the plate look lovely with a very large mound of chicken in the middle and fresh green broccoli all around the sides. A side order of rice was large. The Taste was fresh, hot, and tasty, although not the world's best. The restaurant was busy with plenty of families, it was never loud. Staff was attentive to every table. We had a lot of fun.

    Photos
    China House - General Tso's

    General Tso's

    China House - Lo mein

    Lo mein

    China House - General tso's chicken!

    See all

    General tso's chicken!

    Benedetti's Supper Club - seafood - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...