This bar has stopped serving Fireball. WTH Get Fireball…read moreback or lose us. Ridiculous

Great neighborhood pub with an even better staff. Relaxed atmosphere; perfect for a casual evening…read moreout.

Great Erie pub with a variety of food! I love it because of nostalgia. It's an Erie staple that has…read moregreat bar food and atmosphere!

Ordered a quesadilla and it was okay but there was too much chicken for my taste. The fries were…read morevery good, best part of the meal. The service was kind of slow but that could've been because we had a large group.

Good food. Best wing in town. Like getting a pitcher of beer. Clean bar. Good service. Comfortable…read moreseating

we were there on Jan12, 2025. Great service and food. The bartender/ service guy was spectacular…read moreand the cook prepared great food.

Visited this place on my way to Niagara Falls stopped in Erie for the night. Had the shrimp tacos…read moreand a beer both were delicious and reasonably priced. The waitress was pleasant and tended the bar great. They have an excellent selection of beers to go. Definitely recommend stopping if in the area.

9/15/2025 Ate List:…read moreTurkey Rachel - 5.7 Public House over the years has changed a lot. Near it's opening and when I lived locally. This spot was bumping. Food was amazing and would be THE spot in the area to go. Lunch, Dinner, it wouldn't matter - there would be a wait. With every visit over the last decade or so, my experience continues to decline as the food and service has suffered with time. What once was a staple meal has become a poor iteration of what once was. Bread is obnoxiously thick. The flavors on the ingredients feel off. It's disappointing. Still feel like there's a chance this spot recovers in time but with their expansions - this location has suffered.

Clancy is closed. The owners have both passed on…read moreunfortunately. While it was open - it was pretty good food. Thanks Marty and Peggy for your years in our neighborhood!

Had take out other night from here. First time eating and it was great, Cheap ,Large portions and…read moreoutstanding flavor. Ordered jamacin jerk wings pretty good for a dry rub wing, crispy and delicious. Also had tacos, BLT sub, Combo sub ,and Taco Fries which are my new fav..

Great food! Friendly staff! Nightly weekend entertainment that can't be beat! I highly recommend!read more

My friends and I visited on July 27th. Our waitress was very nice at first. She took our orders…read morewithout writing anything down. Which we were impressed about. Only to return shortly later asking us to remind her what we ordered. Most of our food and drinks came out at a decent time and were good. My friend did not get her pizza. When we asked the waitress about she stated that the kitchen had burner the pizza and were making a new one. And asked if my friend wanted a box to take her pizza home with her. She did not get to have her meal with the rest of us. We're under the impression the waitress forgot to put the pizza order in because when the food runner dropped off our food he seemed confused when we asked about the pizza. I asked for some sort of accommodation for my friend for the mix up. But management refused, which was disappointing.

I absolutely love this place. The drinks are fantastic and unique. The service is phenomenal and…read morefriendly. The ambiance is perfectly quaint and relaxing. My wife and I try to make there every Friday that we can for and end of the week tradition which is more about getting a good drink.

Love the ambience and the good selection of their drinks here (it is quite pricey, but it is well…read moreworth the experience) . The schoolhouse is a great place to grab a drink and hangout with your friends. Though, there are limited selections of food/snack items offered.

We have eaten here many times when we are in Erie but I have to say the last time was not our best…read more we started with bread it was maybe better when they first brought it out but it came long before the pasta bowl I ordered so it was kind of hard and really stuck together the pasta was way over cooked but the worst part was the salad, I had a piece of plastic like Saran Wrap I assume the lettuce wrapper in my salad and honestly once the dressing was on I didn't notice it and almost ate it I reported to our waitress who's comment was oh that's funny do you want another one and ill make sure the kitchen knows I mean really that could have been a chocking hazard my husband had the perch and liked it

Dog friendly place--their outdoor patio has plenty of shades, so it's a lot better than other…read moreplaces we checked (a lot of other places have outdoor patios but somehow not providing any shades, which won't work in the heat). The older female server is extremely friendly. Our dog somehow puked and she cleaned it without making a big deal of it, which we really appreciated. Food is good except that I am not sure why chicken wings would be "market price". I've never seen chicken wings being of market price.

Stopped here for lunch on Wednesday afternoon. I started with the tortilla soup and it was very…read moreaverage. There wasn't a lot of chicken or anything else in it - it was mostly a semi-thick broth surrounded by lots of tortilla chips. My husband ordered the Reuben and was so so disappointed. The corned beef was tender, but he was appalled when he removed the bread to find a layer of corned beef folded in half to cover half of the sandwich. There wasn't much corned beef at all. Cole slaw also tasted like bland cabbage. :(( Not sure we would return.

Great service at bar Very honest menu suggestions…read more Had a some good shrimp taco's as well as good steak salad. Beer selection was fair. Good vibe

Empty on a Monday night. Haven't been here in over 5 years!…read moreNice inside. They've expanded. The wings were good. The Butter Garlic Parm is better than the Butter Garlic. Service was okay. I would return.

We came into Andy's Pub tonight around 5:45 and the service was awful!! We are regulars at Andy's…read morePub and came in tonight to play pool and eat dinner. On arrival there were not many patrons at the bar/restaurant. We came into the downstairs bar side which has several pool tables. We got our pool ball's and began a game. After several minutes one of the group went over to the bar to make them not only aware we were here but to get a round of drinks. The bartender made our drinks but sent them back to the table with the member of our party who ordered them rather then a server. Bartender was made aware at that time that we wanted to order food and we were told "Nick" was responsible for taking orders in our area. After over 30 minutes of watching Nick standing talking to patrons and staff of the bar, delivering food items to a table that came after us, and actually coming into the pool area where we were and vaping, we still had not had our order taken. Finally we paid out alcohol tab and returned the pool ball's to the pool hall. The bartender apologized to us and we left. At the time we walked out the door to leave Nick was standing talking to Mark, the pool hall manager. We are disappointed and have felt the service at Andy's has been declining. Do better Andys Pub and please educate Nick on proper restaurant service. Coming in to vape but still ignore patrons with menus waiting to order is distasteful and rude.