I've been to Benny's many, many times the last few years and the place never disappoints. The shop always has cheese, pepperoni, and sausage on the menu, but they also have 2-3 monthly specials with one always being vegetarian. I visited in January and had one of their monthly specials: pineapple and jalapeños. I was hoping for a sweet and savory/spicy flavor and that's what it delivered. I wish, however, I would've added on the hot honey drizzle ($1 extra) to embolden the hot and sweet flavors. My friend got the pepperoni with hot honey drizzle and it was exquisite. That might be my next order. Benny's staff is always friendly and service speedy (it takes about 5-7 minutes to heat up a slice). Prices are great (you can have a slice and soft drink or water all for under $10) and the ambiance is always lively. Seating can be limited when the shop is busy, so be ready to sit at the bar or order for takeout. They also have a limited selection of beer. read more

Benny Vitali's - Pepperoni Pizza Slice and January 2026 special: Pineapple and Jalapeños Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Virginia

Recently, we got takeout from here for an event. Very easy to pick up! The boxes are insanely big, which highlights how big a slice will be! Tried pepperoni & cheese--loved the thin crust, but definitely a pizza that's best when hot (definitely not the same cold). read more

Benny Vitali's - 28-inch Cheese Pie - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Virginia

Favorite pizza slice in the Fredericksburg area. It's priced fairly for the quality and quantity of food and always has a nice drink selection so that you can get a good meal under 10$. They are pretty speedy too, I've only had to wait max 15 minutes for a freshly heated up slice. read more

Good pizza. Great vibes. What's not to like? The pizza slices are massive so while you may think $6 for a slice is a lot, wait until you realize how big they are. read more

Benny Vitali's - The pizza boxes are at least twice the size of a normal large box. - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Virginia

See all

I came here on a recommendation for pizza. They only have three main options: cheese, pepperoni, and sausage (mild or spicy). There is also seasonal? specials for a little bit more. Got the pepperoni and spicy sausage to try. The slices are so big two plates are needed! The pizza is very tasty from the cheese to the topping to the crust. They have parmesan cheese, crushed red pepper, and oregano to shake on your slice. They have a drink cooler with many options and variations of drinks. They also have beer as well to choose. The prices aren't too bad for what you're getting. And tax is included. The seating is limited with four booths, some bar seating, and two small tables outside. In general you probably won't wait long to sit unless there is a long line. I suggest expect to order to go with a possibility of sitting down. Definitely will be back to try the specials. The bruschetta sounds interesting. I recommend coming here for a great slice of za! read more

Benny Vitali's - Paddle designs - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Virginia

See all

This is the first time I have been here. I ordered one slice of cheese pizza. The slice is humongous. This is what they are known for. One slice is 5.50, not bad for what you get. The staff is friendly but it is small inside for seating. This place stays packed. I want to try other pieces in the future. read more

See all

Pizza here is the real deal. We came with five in our party and ordered a whole pie, sausage and pepperoni. This thing is huge. It cost about $40 for the whole thing. The sauce was delicious, edges crispy and thin. Didn't take long for us to get the whole pie. Wait till you see this thing! Recommended for sure. read more

Benny Vitali's - Pepperoni and 28-inch Pie - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Virginia

I ordered online which takes 60-70 mins to make and pick up. I ordered half pepperoni and half cheese. The pizza was decent but would have been better with more cheese. read more

Benny Vitali's - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Virginia

Fantastic!! I felt like I was back in NYC! You order at the counter. They call out your name when it is ready. You pull your drinks from the cooler and you can buy a giant slice. The crust is thin and delicious! You can fold your slice in half and eat it like a sandwich. The pepperoni is legit! The sauce is so good and not sweet. This place was delicious, packed and cranking out the pies. I'll be back!!! It is small and has massive ovens, the staff is hardworking and efficient and there are a few tables inside and out. They do have a slice bar where you can sit and watch them cook. It's fun! read more

See all

Ive been here a handful of times and every time I come here I really want to like the pizza but I don't know what it is I just really do not like it. The sauce tastes so strange to me and the pizza never has much flavor. Not a huge fan of the crust either. Definitely good bang for your buck though! read more

Had to have second dinner. We just had something, walked past, it smelled so good! and it was still so good!

Pizza was amazing. Service was quick! We got our pizza to go but there was a good amount of seating. read more

Benny Vitali's - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Virginia

The bar was made with the most elegant of craftsmanship!! The service has been A1 since Day1 and the food is perfect read more

See all

Vanessa behind the counter said something about ordering a whole pizza for ourselves. But we would never do that. Called us tanka Jahari. Was very weird. 100% would recommend to a friend. They'll play rockstar by Nickleback is you ask. read more

What a great pizza place and great location!! Every time we came downtown, we grabbed a slice here. The slices (and pizzas) are huge and definitely worth it! The vibes inside are also great and the workers all seem happy. It gets busy so come at the right time and expect all the seats to be full inside haha. Overall, this place is a must if you come to downtown Fredericksburg! read more

See all

Stumbled upon this place while walking downtown Fredericksburg. It is a small quaint establishment with limited seating. They sell pizza by the whole pie and by the slice. The slices are MASSIVE!! Indoor and outdoor seating available. Tried the spinach, feta and artichoke slice. PLENTY of food, could easily share a slice with one other person. Service was prompt and welcoming. Slice was good, had great flavor. Would definitely return when in the area to try more items. read more

See all

Pretty good, pretty good! Came here with my family on a nice cloudy Sunday. We were all hungry and seemingly had a taste for pizza. We ordered an XL half pepperoni pizza and the slices were huge! I've always wanted to try a pizza where you had to use both hands to eat. All I needed was one slice and it knocked the hunger right out. The pizza came out hot, fresh, and flavorful! The service was pretty fast and efficient. The lady operating the register was friendly and rhetorical staff made our pizza pretty quick which was a plus. The inside was pretty neat. Just a typical hipster downtown pizza spot. Just an environment for everyone. read more

Benny Vitali's - Half cheese half pep The slices were huge! - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Virginia

The pizza was soooooo good!!! Ambience was just OK lots of partiera there after the bars but this is what we planned for. Definitely worth the visit! read more

Benny Vitali's - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Virginia

We got take out pizza since we had multiple kids that all just wanted to play at my brother's house. The pizza was HUGE and could feed an army. Thankfully it was also super tasty too! read more

One of my favorite pizza places. Whenever I am crossing Fredericksburg, I always make it a point to stop by at this place. The place is open late hours and is on the street of historic district among other great stores. Love their pizzas, they have a special menu everyday. A small quaint pizza place with beer and drinks. read more

See all

Pretty good pizza. It is almost always full. Seating is hit or miss regarding finding a spot. Slices are HUGE. It's OK. I drop a star for the limited, free-for-all seating situation. read more

Cool vibe in this slice shop pizza joint. The gimmick is that the pizzas are HUGE. A slice is at least the size of two regular slices. They add hot honey drizzle in slices for an up charge. One Bite 6.9 score. read more

See all

Great as always ! Still wish white sauce was an option, but maybe one day. Service was superb and it wasn't so packed. My friend enjoyed looking around and checking out the cool ambiance. read more

Benny Vitali's - Lunch - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Virginia

Absolutely the worst pizza my husband and I have ever had. He always said there's no bad pizza. Well he changed his mind after today's lunch. He had a slice with Italian sausage. I had the pepperoni. The pepperoni slice was so thin and flavorless. His wasn't much better although the dough was ever so slightly thicker. Still lacked flavor from sauce or sausage. If you like eating cardboard you might like the pizza there. If I could give 0 stars I would. read more

What do you say about a pizza place that serves a 28" pie? Where do I sign up! Came on a beautiful sunny afternoon and decided to have a slice of pepperoni and then split a slice of a mushroom ricotta. I liked the pepperoni a lot but the mushroom ricotta was amazing. These slices are BIG, yet they keep the crust thin and crunchy (how I prefer pizza). Seating is an issue: there is a long bar for seating and a few tables. We started outside and ended up inside; it only takes 10 minutes and your pizza is gone leaving you wanting another slice. read more

See all

Bennys is always a great choice if you are looking for a quick slice of pizza. This was our first time ordering a slice of their monthly option and it was one of my favorites! The pancetta and roasted pepper pizza was amazing. I kept going back for more bites! I want to go back one more time before the menu changes.... IT WAS THAT GOOD! Also they have an assortment of options for ipa's for the beer lover. read more

Benny Vitali's - Pancetta and roasted peppers - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Virginia

See all

The slices are huge, pizza is baked right in front of you! Sat at bar, solid selection of soda & beer. Workers were smiling and engaging during lunch time slam! read more

Look at the UFO above the fridge. Have gone here for years pizza & customer service is exceptional. They always have new beverages to try I usually get the (I have a small wiener) from One Family Brewing. read more

Benny Vitali's - 28-inch Pepperoni/Cheese Pie - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Virginia

Pizza is always good. Whenever we are in Fredericksburg we always stop by. Today we had a very cheerful person named Daniel talk to us. Really good conversation while he was making the pizzas. A fun and yummy visit read more

Massive slice of pizza! Seriously, I've never seen a piece of pizza that big. Cute place and tasty pizza! read more

Benny Vitali's - Benny Vitali's - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Virginia

This is the place for anyone visiting to try one time. Get ready to eat at a bar standing, and devour a huge thin slice of pizza with a can of soda. It was cheap and great for kids in the past, but we recently have felt that it's slightly overpriced for what you get these days. It's a young persons atmosphere with loud music and lots of busy noises. Don't expect to go holding conversations. You're here to hang out, eat a slice, and get going. The service is quite fat for the gay paced nature of this restaurant. read more

I think once you get through the hype of such a huge slice it's overrated. The dough and sauce tasted decent but something seemed off with the cheese. Not sure if they use a mozzarella/provolone blend or what. The service was great they. read more

Benny Vitali's - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Virginia

Ambiance is that of a college pizza place. Busy in a a Saturday afternoon. Pizza was ok. Huge slices, which is cool (makes for a cheap lunch) but they aren't crisp. Sauce and pepperoni was pretty good, not spectacular but ok. Crust was just okay. Chewy. I'd go back, especially if I was in downtown and craving a slice. read more

Benny Vitali's - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Virginia

Awesome atmosphere and Huge pizza slices! They are not joking about the size of a large whole pizza! read more

Benny Vitali's - Sausage & Pepperoni 28 inch Pie - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Virginia

See all

Okay, it's a really big pizza...a really big $40 plain pizza. With LESS cheese and sauce than a much smaller standard large pizza. There was 3" all away around with nothing on it...just dough. The cheese was also very sparse. You also can't customize your pie...either plain, pepperoni or veggie. I just wanted onions...NOPE. I have a picture of the pitiful slice with VERY LITTLE CHEESE AND SAUCE to prove my point. As far as service goes, i ordered my pizza in person...no calling it in first. I was seated right outside because it was full inside. When I walked back in, there my pizza sat...getting cold...why ask my name if you're not going to let me know when my pizza was ready? My grandchildren thought it was cool when I walked in the door with this HUGE BOX, so I gave it a star for the cool factor. I've had a slice about a year ago, and it was pretty good...so stick to slices. I probably won't be back, and the only reason I went there this time was because my usual pizza shop was closed...see my review of Brothers Pizza. This franchise, yup it's a franchise...has a niche market...close to colleges and universities. read more

Benny Vitali's - 3" of nothing, just dough. - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Virginia

Incredible local spot that is also a somewhat regional chain. Huge slices of pieces and they're affordable. Staff is always nice and vibes are there 100%. Very yummy pizza for when you're in the mood. Unfortunately, and this is no fault of the place, but it's super touristy because of the size of slices and the out of towners are mad annoying and have no manners and hog limited seating just wait for take out or they hover over near the counter for pickup. I'd avoid during rush hour or busy weekend days during lunch rush. read more

Benny Vitali's - Bruschetta Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Virginia

This place was great!! Pizza was huge and just fantastic. The staff was super friendly and offered great beer recommendations. This place was busy even on a Monday night which should say at it all. This is a must go to when in town. I'll be back for sure!! read more

Benny Vitali's - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Virginia

Authentic, wholesome, cheesy pizza. Satisfies the sole, and the appetite. Massive slices for great prices.

Me and my wife stopped in for lunch today visiting from out of town very good pizza for a very good price.

One of the best pizzas I've ever tasted and the slices are the size of a personal pan! So glad we found this hidden gem....