The sauce on the pizza has a lot of flavor and it makes the pizza. I wish the margarita pizza had tomatoes on it but the sauce still makes it taste good. The fries are very good. They are not hand cut but they are crispy and have good taste. Remember that you need to pay with cash though no credit allowed. read more

See all

Always delicious pizza whether a whole pie or by the slice. We order often as it's nearby.

Great food made by great people! Consistently well made meals. I eat there at least once a week. Support a quality local business! read more

This place is great the food is great and the people are supper nice. Always a great place to eat when we are out this way.

Great NY style pizza. Party pizza was a big hit at one of our parties. Lasagna also very good.

This pizza was awful. Barely any sauce or toppings. Crust was way too thin and tasteless.

Unquestionably the best pie in Fredericksburg. Native Chicagoan that knows good pizza there and from a decade also in NJ metro NYC area. This is more akin to a NY/Brooklyn pie. Nice crust, ample fresh tomato sauce and fresh ingredients always. The calzone also top shelf, as is the sausage roll. Check for daily special - they make excellent lasagna. Family owned and operated. Our go to for almost 20 years. read more

Nice little pizza and subs restaurant. I had heard that the pizza was very good, and we got a large pepperoni and I liked it. This is like the pizza I grew up eating, and I will definitely go back. read more

Great subs! So yummy. They only take cash though so remember before you go. Friendly stuff. read more

Brothers Pizza My husband and I tried this pizza for the first time in September 2018, as recommended by our realtor. We thought it was awful! Like, some of the worst pizza we'd ever tried. Fast forward to today. With all the positive reviews on this pizza, I decided to pick up lunch there today, and give them another chance. I ordered a 12 inch ham and cheese sub with lettuce, tomato, and mayo, and 1 slice of pepperoni pizza. Hubby and I split the sub and a slice of pizza (just for a taste). The sub was decent. I'd probably order again if I had to order from here specifically, but it wouldn't be my first choice. This was my first time experiencing the subs. The first time that we ordered the pizza in 2018, we got a large. It seemed burnt and dry, with a layer of cold oil sitting on top. This time it was better, but still not good to us. The crust was pretty good, but it lacked sauce and flavor. Maybe it's something that has to grow on you? Either way, I wanted to like it, but 3.5 years later, and I still don't like it. At least it was edible this time. But again, would never be a place I'd choose. Also, in this day and age, who only accepts cash or check? Just my food review. read more

See all

The pizza was great NY style pizza for this area, however the menu on here slightly differs from the real thing. The buffalo chicken isn't grilled chicken it's fried, it also has onions on it. We got the pepperoni, cheese, and buffalo chicken all great minus the onions. Will for sure be back. read more

Ordered the Brothers Supreme pizza, which was delicious. A small for 2 people was definitely enough. The cheese garlic bread and manicotti was also delicious. Staff are great, welcoming and friendly. Seating is minimal so just be aware that there are only about 5 tables available. Recommend trying this place out, good food, reasonably priced, and great staff. read more

See all

Meh, just ok pizza, not great but not the worst I guess....but they don't take credit card? Come on people, its 2024. read more

First time visit, thought we'd give it a try. It's a quaint hole in the wall with minimal, on top of each other seating, but seems to have a good take out business. One of those places you might think twice about as you walk in. Walked in and the gentleman tossing dough didn't initially acknowledge us and after about two minutes a young lady popped up, took some phone orders and then spoke to us. We ordered two small pies, one pepperoni, the other cheese and an order of mozzarella sticks. Drinks by the can and fountain drinks are offered. The pies were both tasty and had adequate toppings and a nice crispy crust. The mozzarella sticks had a very flavorful cheese but the marinara sauce was a bit watery and bland. Upon the delivery of the pies, the gentleman was much nicer. It was a decent experience, gonna try some of the other pizza joints. read more

See all

Very basic no reason to add to your list of places to go. Pizza is very blah, blah, blah. Sauce was very plain surely not freshly made. Toppings too abnormal in size making it difficult to enjoy eating a slice without toppings falling off. read more

It's been awhile since I've been back to the place. Most of the time I was going to stop I didn't have cash. We ordered the pizza and it was good. Be careful when you take a bite make sure it's cool enough to bite. It's definitely a hot pizza. It's good though the crust is a thin but tasty. The establishment was clean and the service was great. It's definitely busy so seating is limited. They do have some out door seating. Make sure you have cash when you go they don't take credit cards. Will be back to try a few other things. read more

See all

We had a fabulous meal! We started with mozzarella sticks and onion rings which were crispy and delicious. Then we had 2 pizzas - extra cheese, and extra cheese and pepperoni. They were so hot we couldn't eat them at first. When they cooled a little the cheese stretched and hung and it dripped and man was it delicious! I want to go back and try other menu items. The service was friendly and warm and we even came at a time we could get a table for 5! Seating is limited and they only take cash. Definitely recommend! read more

I just don't know what all the hype is about this pizza. It's thin crust. Bland. We ordered extra cheese. Really? That means at least cheese. Sauce. Bland. My husband had one slice. I had two. The other five are in a zip lock bag. They'll probably hang out for a couple days in the refrigerator then be tossed. read more

We had a cheese pizza and it was not for us. It was hot and crowded inside and we did not enjoy our dinning experience. They do cash only and that is a deterrent for us. read more

Great NY style pizza, wonderful family feel with incredible service, room to sit, we did pickup but there were indoor and outdoor seating so you had options! If nearby, would definitely come back again! read more

Pizza and baked ziti from here so far real good . Wait was a little long though . Over all I would recommend

Their pizza is the best around! It tastes authentic and not like a modification of 'pizza'.

Good food great ingredients family run! Remember to bring cash. Old School pizza very cozy.

We've been going here the last 2 years. They are great, always just what we ordered. Warm and cozy atmosphere of a family run business. Our number one go to pizza joint. read more

Best Pizza I've had in FXBG. It is not on par w NY but it's good pizza. One thing to know before you go, it's Cash & Check only. There is not much room for dine-in or groups larger than 6 ppl. If you are Covid-paranoid then don't even think about dine-in as the booths and tables are relatively close to one another. The staff and service efficient which easily translates not very conversant. Not rude but they are so busy b/c it's good pizza) there isn't much time spent on a lot of pleasantries. read more

Our family loves this place. Whether a pizza or a philly sandwich, we are always super pleased with their dishes. Locally owned family estabishments are THE BEST! read more

Made my stomach feel terrible, and the vibe in the place was not very good and it was kind of dirty too . The meatlovers pizza was over topped with meats read more

Got a pizza and a sausage roll. Both were excellent, pizza was thin crust NY style with great sauce. We were passing through but would definitely get from them again when we're back. read more

While in the area I stopped in for a sub.... I grew up eating and loving Brother's Pizza and Subs in Dale City and hoped this place would be the same. It was similar, but different bread. Flavors were decent though. Service was friendly, but the lady who I paid (they only take cash & check, no credit cards) was wearing gloves, which I never saw her change (Hmmm?). The place was clean and they have a decent amount of business at lunch time too. Food was good overall, but nothing special. Other locations (like Brother's in Dale City or any of the Sam's chain) do better with subs. read more

Brother's Pizza - Chicken Cheese Sub - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Virginia

See all

The pizza is so good! Thin crispy delicious crust and fresh toppings. The sauce is not too acidic and full of flavor. We love Brother's Pizza! read more

Absolutely the best steak sandwich around! Owners are great, like one big family. Get the steak and cheese deluxe.

The best Pizza in the Burg, never been disappointed. Great atmosphere to share a pie.

You have my business!! Ordered their Buffalo chicken pizza, spicy wings, and a Cesar salad and we were very happy with our meal. They were quick despite being busy for carry out. Love to support local businesses. Will be returning read more

Best pizza around! Very authentic and as close to NYC as you can get without going! Just bring cash!

Very good pizza and chic parm sun and salads. Cash and check only but very good for area and will be back

NYC pizza! IYKYK. I did not think I'd find anything like this South of Brooklyn. I thought about deducting a star because the place is cash or check only. Seriously?! It was worth the drive in Saturday traffic to get to the nearest ATM, and then drive back for a slice of heaven/NYC! read more

Great margarita pizza. Awesome plain cheese pizza. Wonderful sauce. Love seeing the family every visit!

Highly recommend the cheesesteak , very tasty with lots of meat. Pizza was good, very close to Brooklyn pizza. Make note though, they only accept cash or check, no cards. Good place to go for takeout not much room for dinning in. read more

The very Best NY style pizza in the area, in my opinion. As a New Jersey native, where good pizza is abundant, I've tried dozens of different "pizza" places...some, a outright insult to Italians...Fugetaboutit! It literally took me years to find a good pizza! Let me save you the trouble...Brothers is the real deal...and now is my go to for Pizza, Hot Subs and Calzones. It's always busy...so, be prepared, call ahead and bring cash (no credit cards). Making me hungry just writing this review! See you there...Caio! read more

Absolutely worth the stop for some delish pizza. It was cheesy, yet foldable for the perfect NY style bite. I got pepperoni and mushroom this time. We also got the spicy sausage roll. The sausage rolls comes in spicy or non spicy and with a side of marinara for dipping and it's crazy good. Only upset that we didn't buy more sausage rolls. 100% worth the stop. read more

Brother's Pizza - Large NY style pepperoni and mushroom pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Virginia

See all