Wish I would've checked reviews first but really wanted a white pizza and this was the only place I found in my area. Not only was it nowhere near the flavor I was hoping for, but the pizza had a funky dirty dish sponge smell that was impossible to get past. And then they have the nerve to serve a tiny FROZEN piece of Costco cheesecake for FIVE BUCKS?! Noooo. This place is a huge NO. read more

Bens Pizza - Tiny frozen Costco cheesecake - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

Ordered delivery thru Surprise Express. It arrived quickly and still hot! I asked for the oil and vinegar for Submarine Special Hoagie to be on the side so it wouldn't get soggy. It was not on the side. And it was a disappointment. Hardly any meat on it. It was basically a small bun filled with shredded lettuce and tomatoes. For $13 I thought it would be a nice big sub. It was not. Plus it was soggy because they didn't put the oil and vinegar on the side like I asked. The chicken bacon ranch pizza was not good. The chicken reminded me of cut up, twice or 3 times baked chicken nuggets . Napolitano pizza with pepperoni was good. Overall, just paid almost $70 for food and I can honestly say, lesson learned. I will not be ordering from this place again. read more

See all

The food here was AMAZING! great service and all family owned. The food tasted super fresh. All handmade in the back. Love the cheesecake as well. The place was very homey and a nice environment. read more

We've gotten Ben's Pizza three times now since we've moved to Surprise and it has been consistently good each and every time. The pizzas are so good and taste homemade. Tonight, we ordered the buffalo chicken pizza (I LOVE Barro's version) but this version gave them a run for their money. I think I might like it even better. The service is always good and the delivery time is way quicker than estimated. Give this great little place a shot if you haven't tried them yet! read more

Bens Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

We wanted to try a new local pizza place and thought this would be a good one based on great reviews. Boy, were we wrong. Hardly any sauce on the pizza and the whole thing was tasteless. Pizza was loaded on and too thick. We also got garlic knots that were tasteless. Garlic tasted raw. We couldn't even eat them. Definitely would not order from here again. read more

This place was awesome. So glad we have something new in Surprise. The old restaurant that was in this space was awful, but Bens is great! I'm a plain cheese pizza fan, and theirs was so good. Crust was the perfect amount of crispy, and the sauce was fantastic. Service was great and we felt very welcome by the guys. Definitely give this place a try if you're looking for something new in Surprise. We'll be back for sure since there's a bunch of pasta and sandwiches on the menu we want to try in the future! read more

Delicious pizza at great prices. I love that they do pricing specials and are very obviously family owned and operated

I have ordered there "meat And cheese" ravioli twice. No meat only cheese. I called and was told it's or not and I said then you need to change your website. His reply I don't have a website it's doordash not mine funny I just went and looked it up and it says and Not or. No longer getting anything from Ben's Pizza read more

My new Favorite Pizza or Italian place to eat at or order takeout or delivery! Omg, love the pizza and antipasto salad, went back in a few days later because the family loved the food so much. So far Everything we tried is super yummy. Nick makes the food and you have to talk with him and see his dedication to his food and customers. This is a Must try place, don't pass it up. read more

Ordered the special pizza. Really yummy. Will definitely be ordering again next time for pizza. Taste homemade read more

Bens Pizza - Special Pizza. Really yummy - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

Pizza-was good. Oily a bit and the cheese wasn't cheesy. Kind of more like broke apart. Wings- were good. They were better than I thought they'd be. The Hot Wings were "Hot" and flavorful. The Honey BBQ was alright. Taste more BBQ and no honey but the wings had a decent amount of chicken on the bone. Customer service was excellent. The people there were polite and helpful, place was clean. read more

First time having pizza from here and it will definitely be my last. The crust was burnt, the inside was raw and all you could taste on the loaded was the sausage. What a HUGE disappointment for the cost. I would give it a negative if I could. read more

Order from Ben's regularly! We love it and prices are very reasonable. Wings, breadsticks and pizza are all good!

Very good Pizza!! Perfect crust generous topping baked to perfectly. Derive and price are good too

We've tried all the pizza places in Surprise and this is by far the best! We've gotten the gyro pizza and pepperoni pizza from Nick and Ben's before and it is the same food. Just ordered the Gyro pizza, garlic knots and jalapeño poppers and they were amazing. I'm pretty sure the garlic knots are deep fried which somehow makes them even more delicious while still being light and fluffy. We will be ordering from here once a week! read more

Bens Pizza - Gyro Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

See all

Ordered 16 inch pepperoni pizza from Bens for the first time, was not what I would call NY pizza I was born. In Brooklyn and had my first pizza at age 6 in Brooklyn in 1951. The crust was very tough and not very good won't be ordering again! read more

Ordered from here for the first time after hearing how great it was. Wish I didn't listen!!!! The wings are small and dry and either over sauced or not sauced enough. The pizza was missing certain toppings and the pizza sauce was bland. The appetizer combo was meh at best. The mozzarella sticks were rock hard, the fried shrooms and zucchini was decent! The chicken parm dinner waa atrocious. All the water from the sauce had made the breading on the chicken mush!! The cheese on the chicken parm was burnt and the marinara sauce was bland. I will never order from this place again!!! read more

Good pizza and all but I don't really like the new owners I would prefer the other owners if you didn't know bens pizza used to be Leo's pizza and it was the best with great wings and great pizza read more

Found this place traveling through. Amazing food! everyone is VERY friendly, which is hard to find these days. Nice and clean bathrooms, will definitely be back! read more

My girlfriend nudged me to try this place but just the name was a turn-off. Ben's Pizza? So finally one day we tried it and it turned out to be the best (thin crust) pizza in Surprise. Now, once in a while Native will turn out a decent pie as does NYPD, but they're super hit or miss, and you have to eat them there to be any good. Ben's, so far, has been "consistently" good with the same crunchy crust each time and still piping hot when it gets home (we don't live far). I'd give them 5 stars, but Pizzaria Bianco or Federal Pizza it 'ain't. I don't have faith the City of Surprise will ever see anything that caliber even though it has the potential. Their best effort to date is Oregano's with its soggy attempt at deep dish. Try The Rec Pizza up north with its high-sided cheese crust if you want an interesting deep dish pie. UPDATE! I had Ben's at 4 stars, BUT, after our 4th visit I took one star away. We tried a salad and their wings. Their "Garden" salad is described at having romaine lettuce and it DOES NOT. It's your typical zero nutritional iceberg lettuce. Don't advertise something that's not. If you're out of romaine at the time, that's ok, just let customers know when they order it and let them make up their mind. We also ordered the garlic wings and not only were they small, they had no garlic flavor. So thumbs down on both of those and that's why they went from 4 stars to 3. We still like their pizza. read more

Great pizza!!! Service is great and so is the food. We had the deep dish pizza, a total keeper.

Walked in and the place looked like it was ransacked. Cheap looking tables. Junk strewn about the room.. the order counter was littered with junk. they had a worn out office chair behind the counter. Pizza boxes everywhere. Went for a two pizza slice deal. Guess I learned you don't get the drink with your meal after 4pm. I asked for a specific topping and got pepperoni. Cook said he could correct it. Didn't feel like waiting any longer. I bartered a free soda. So that was cool. The pizza cheese was good. The crust was a bit tough. I think they need to clean up their place. Make it more desirable to stay. Pizza could be fresher. read more

The food was great, very nice staff, great service. Maybe put your overstock supplies somewhere else? Kinda feels like we were eating in a storage room. read more

Bought a cheese pizza and wings. Have yet to eat the wings because the cheese pizza is that good. Its amazing ... the cheese pizza deserves 5 stars on its own. I have yet to still eat the wings. Im sure it's good though. read more

We tried Ben's Pizza for the first time tonight. Our pizza was excellent, as was the service. We definitely recommend this reasonably priced family restaurant. read more

Pizza is pretty great, we ordered the special (Jumbo pizza 20 wings, medium chicken bacon ranch, medium stuffed pizza. The ONLY reason I didn't give them 5 stars is the boneless wings, I'm not sure how they're bone in wings are but I wouldn't recommend the boneless. Pizza is definitely on point, flavorful, crispy crust! read more

Pizza was a little greasy. Crust was burnt. Wings are small. I asked for extra crispy and they did comply. However, the sauce wasn't mixed well. Seems like was squirted with sauce. Zucchini wasn't that bad. And they did have good real ranch. Wouldn't be my top choice. But o would eat it again. read more

I order Ben's Pizza through DoorDash every week. There is a message on the DoorDash app that says that Ben's Pizza delivers its own orders so DoorDash can't track the courier's progress. When I ordered tonight we waited for over an hour and a half. We decided to look outside to see if it had been dropped off before calling the store. The pizza was just sitting there. God knows how long it was out there but it was quite cold. No one ever rang the doorbell or knocked on the door. We called the restaurant and their first response was "well how do you we know they didn't ring the bell? We don't know that they didn't." So a customer calls you with a problem and the first thing you do is insinuate that they are a liar? Things went downhill from there. Basically, Ben's Pizza couldn't care less. We were told to contact DoorDash, even though DoorDash clearly states that if there was an issue with the order to call Ben's Pizza. I called DoorDash. They were immediately helpful and refunded everything but the tip. I will NEVER order Ben's Pizza again either directly or through any service. Mistakes happen. It's how you respond to them that shows the true character of a business. Ben's Pizza doesn't care about its customers. read more

Bens Pizza - Ben's DoorDash listing - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

Specifiy said in comments half cheese, half pepperoni and when the pizza arrived it was all pepperoni. It also was not very good. We will not be ordering from this place again read more

Bens Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

Been ordering at least once a week for a solid year and they've never disappointed. Great people and even better food. Five stars

Don't think twice just go. Great customer service will definitely return. The pizza was delicious and I almost ordered garlic knots to go cause they were *chefs kiss* . Obviously were coming back because we love supporting authentic quality food from nice people. read more

Super good pizza and the owner is really nice. Order was ready for pick up and we cracked some jokes about football. I really enjoyed the pizza and was really happy with this place. I will be ordering again from here. read more

Delicious pie! Best I have had so far in the Valley and I'm from Jersey originally. Nick was a great guy. Can't wait to go back soon.

Always good! We've lived in surprise for about a year and a half and my friends told me it wasn't worth it. Finally tried myself couple months ago and it's all we order now for pizza and wings! read more

All i can say is yum .. its mmmm good .. you won't be disappointed .. better than barrows

I just recently relocated to Arizona, I decided to have pizza, so I just Google pizza near me and Bens Pizza appeared. I read some of the reviews, which were all positive, so I decided what the heck and ordered a large veggie pizza. This pizza was very good!! The crust tasted fresh, the veggies were not over cooked, it was overall an excellent pizza!! I will definitely be ordering again! read more

First time ordering Ben's. Got the Sicilian with peperoni & 20 wings. Great sauce, just enough spice to want another bite. The chese was perfect and the giant thick slices filled up my older teenagers with one slice. That is not normal for teen boys. Very happy to choose Ben's over our normal Pizza Hut choice. read more

This place is amazing. I used to come when it was Leo's. I think it's done nothing but improve. I bring my wife and two daughters here every Friday night. Food is delicious no matter what you get. Pizza and hoagies are the best I've had. New York style food. The staff is the most friendly you will ever come across. I love this place and the people working there. They are so great to my kids. You feel like family when you come in. read more

We have been wanting to try this place. Ordered tonight pizza was good home made pizza. Staff was very friendly, good lunch prices! Make sure you try this place out and support a local business! read more

First time ordering from here, after hearing so many good reviews. They messed up my pizza out the wrong toppings on. and the dough was rolled so thin it was soggy with the toppings that were on it. Sandwich was OK, but not worth the money when it doesn't come with any kind of sides. It's a sandwich for $12. Overall, disappointed. read more