4 stars on my first serving of Amici's margherita pizza and garlic knots. Based on food delivery. I ate a slice of margherita first. It was still hot and oven fresh. I carefully ate it so I didn't burn the roof of my mouth from the hot cheese and tomato sauce. The ratio of crusty bottom to pillowy mid-section to cheese to sauce was perfectly equal. Every bite was a perfect bite. And the garlic knots. Those are the first I enjoyed seconds of. It was pillowy thus light, tossed in minced garlic and oil. That garlic though...I used the knot to scrap the loose garlic in the container it came in. Yum! The dough here is not heavy. I had to stop after 2 slices. So good!! read more

Most meals are good.Do not order veal cutlet, parm.It's like shoe leather, they ordered the wedge, and it was terrible

If I could give them NO stars I would. I can't believe they're still in business. You either get a soggy undercooked slice or a cardboard textured overcooked slice. This is my second time trying the pizza at this establishment and it won't be a third time. read more

I used to love this place, but not anymore. Ownership changed hands, chefs changed and ingredients are of noticeably lesser quality. Very disappointing. read more

I used Amici's to cater my Moms 100th birthday. The pizza was cold, the mozzarella sticks were not cooked. I ordered a full tray of mozzarella sticks and there was only one layer on the bottom. delivery man had an attitude. I spent a fortune there and was disappointed. I ordered the birthday girl a special dinner and my husband was shocked they-never comped her dinner. The salad was good. The gave me 10% off and the bill was almost $600 with the discount. So sad I was a customer for years. You live and learn next time I'll go to Bella's or Nonna's. In your response to my review, the Pizza was eaten as soon as it was delivered. It was delivered cold and I'm not gonna defend myself. I have 50 people who were there and saw that the pizza was cold read more

Restaurant is amazing. Food is delicious! Service is wonderful. Great place and wonderful music while you enjoy dinner.

Great food and the staff that works there are great. We have been going there for years and the food never ceases to amaze me.

Amazing pizza , only place in Peekskill I can get great service & great pizza .. would definitely recommend to anyone who wants good pizza in Peekskill read more

Amici's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Great pizza box !!! - Pizza Near Me - Peekskill, New York

In my opinion, best pizza in Peekskill/Cortlandt Manor hands down. Large cheese pie every friday. Call early because they get busy. The sauce tastes great and not too cheesy of a pie. Have never had pizza by the slice here, I'm sure it's great too but you must get a large pie if you really want to experience a place's pizza right? read more

Terrific cozy renovated! Excellent! Went day before Valentine's Day. Service, ambience superb. Simply a neighborhood gem revitalized! read more

I always order from Amici's great customer service friendly staff and the food is great. My favorite is Fried calamari they do make it a delish. read more

This is a great place. Excellent food with ample free parking. Pizza is thin and crisp which is the way I like it. Attached to the pizzeria is a very good Italian Restaurant (Amici's). Friendly staff. All styles of pizza, calzones and entrees are served to stay or to go. Soft drinks and beer only on the pizzeria side. Full menu white tablecloth in the restaurant. No one should be disappointed with the food at this establishment. read more

Excellent service, friendly nice and attentive. Eggplant rollatini was very delicious, their sauce is excellent. Very generous pour on the glass of wine. Chicken Francese was tasty but for $22 portion was small and sauce could've been thicker with more lemon. read more

Our party ate the burger and fries, wings, Cesar salad, a pepperoni pizza and a pep/Italian sausage. Everything was freshly made and delicious. My son devoured the burger and fries. The crust on the pizza was thin and perfectly crispy. We love wings and try them everywhere we go. These did not disappoint!! Way better than BWW we had eaten the day before. Our only disappointment is we live in Texas and can't come more often. Every time we come back to NY we will make sure and eat here. read more

This review deserves a negative star..... This place has gone so down hill I will never eat there again.... Call in for a salad 25mins in advance just to get there just to wait another 10 mins while no one is there...Covid or not this place just straight up sucks now read more

Food is good , service is excellent and friendly. Always feel welcome and at home. The staff here is great!

Our favorite for pizza. Thin crust, always good. Delivery or take-out. We've even had pies delivered to a softball game. Service is pleasant and timely, read more

Something has happened to this place. It used to be good, but recent experiences tell us it went down hill. As an example, we ordered two dinners, two desserts and a pizza today. After waiting more than an hour, the delivery man gave us the pizza and nothing else on a $100+ order. We called more than 15 times and the calls were never answered and the mailbox was full and we could not leave a message. The delivery person delivered the rest of the order 40 minutes later. It was ice cold. No apology, no attempt to make it right. No client service whatsoever. Stay away!!!!! read more

Try the pizza. So many selections. Veggie, eggplants, white, Caesar , sausage, lasaggna. Don't see it ask fir it. Want a pie. Get the grandma. You won't regret it. You don't want pizza try the fresh soups. The best. You taste the freshness. Not a better soup anywhere in town. Try this hidden gem read more

Amici's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Assortment of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Peekskill, New York

I heard their pizza was very good, but I ordered two pies of pizza for the people I work with at the hospital for the holidays and it was delivered to me ice cold. It cost me over 40 bucks and I had to present cold and old pizza to them. That was most unfortunate. read more

Great pizza and friendly service. I observed that dining room is clean and comfortable and look forward to enjoying a meal there. I'm a fan! read more

All you need to know in ONE sentence: Fried calamari appetizer and a (single) slice of buffalo pizza... $18.00!

Family style unpretentious informal restaurant with delicious pasta dishes homemade. Make sure to reserve a table, also takeout. Reasonably priced, family owned. read more

Great food all around. Great place to sit outside to eat for lunch. Great variety of meal items.

Family owned restaurant with delicious meals. All around good service. There is a pizza side for quick food, and then a restaurant side also, with white table cloth service and a bar. Lovely atmosphere and the food is amazing. Definitely come and check it out !!!! read more

I gave this place a 2nd try and still the same. The pizzia wasnt good and they should really contact the original people who ran Amici's so they can learn how to make real pizza. read more

Used to be good. The pizza and place has really changed for the worse. We started going to Amici's about 15 years ago. The pizza was hands-down Peekskill's best. The place has lost its soul. read more

The food is okay. The service is not as great. We had a party of 7 and when we asked for a table we were ignored the whole time. read more

Always great! Solid, dependable Italian soul food. Delicious calamari, pastas, chicken francese. Wonderful, fresh, tasty take out experience. read more

This was our go to restaurant growing up in Peekskill and I hadn't been in years, so I decided to stop by while visiting and it was like I had never left! The food was just as I remembered it, so delicious, and it just tasted like home! I hold Amici's near and dear to my heart since I have so many childhood memories there, whether we were just grabbing a pie on our way home or picking up some calamari to eat by the river, they never disappointed! read more

See all

I really like ordering their delivery. I've been inside a few times and each time was great. I don't know how they make their bread but it's amazing. The food is always good and delivered on time. read more

Best pizza north of Full Moon Pizza on 187th in belmont. Always the same never ever different,sauce cheese crust,yum! the type of pizza that needs nothing shaken on unless you prefer spicey! wedges,salads,pasta dishes,calamari everything here is the best italian in peekskill.Oh did I mention the working boss is Italian not mexican or albanian?! I have only had one bad experience due to a lack of communication in the hispanic kitchen,it won't happen again. The only downside is the delivery guys all hang out in the joint side of this place(it does not bother me I could see it bothering others). the restaurant is excellent,nice ambience,great food,good service. My favorite is the paste bolognese,no it's not just a meatsauce! Bring a friend or especially a date its a sexy place! read more

Delicious! I found a new favorite pizzeria! Robert had recommended this place to me a while ago, I finally got to try it and he was right. They have the best pizza int he area. The 'large' pizza is actually large - not just a medium sized box with pizza cut into 8 slices. The staff is really nice too. read more

I was told by several people the new owners would be keeing the same cooks- well then something is wrong. Maybe they aren't using the same high quality ingredients, because I has baked ziti take out and it did not have the same amazing flavor- no to little seasoning, the sauce flat. Garlic knots not so garlicy. I've also had their pizza on a few occasions since the takeover and that has changed too! It's a shame- this was hands-down the best Italian food anywhere in the area! If a something isn't broke, don't fix it- bye Amici's. read more

Been ordering from Amici's for a long time. Tough competition in the area but the food here is just that much better. Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice, Buffalo, BBQ you name it! Always great service read more

I don't know how this spot doesn't have more 5 star reviews...then again most people in this area don't know what good food is if it bit them in the a**. This spot reminds me of a bunch of nyc pizza spots. The quality of the personalized pizzas are on point and it's relatively inexpensive. I will always go for the Margherita or Caesar salad personalized pizza. I order from this spot at least two times a month! read more

Great Pizza! I usually get the margarita and it's always on point. I just tried the Sicilian and it was really really good.

This place has wonderful pizza and the restaurant portion is amazing the ambiance is quiet and nice. The food is well cooked had a cheese calzone didn't plan on stopping by for a full dinner, the waiters and owner were so friendly and stayed on top of refilling the water and drinks. The dessert was amazing had a cannoli, Tiramsu, and a chocolate fudge cake was so yummy to die for, highly recommend this place! read more

Amici's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Peekskill, New York

Haven't been here in like 4 years and the place must have changed hands, as the pizza is definitely not the same. Unfortunately, it's just not good, anymore. read more

I have to say I've been extremely disappointed in Amici's since the new owners took over. After over 15 years of being a loyal customer, always ordering at least once a week sometimes up to 3 times a week, I'm ready to try somewhere else. Tonight was the top of the iceberg. I called in a soup and large pie to be delivered. The gentleman said it would take 45 minutes. After 1:30 the food arrived. The attached picture is how my cold pizza looked! All flipped over on itself. Also, our SOUP was cold!!!! That means our order had to be sitting there for a really long time!! The quality of the food and the personal touch are sadly no longer there! Very sad to have to post this but too many times I've been disappointed by the new owners!! read more

Amici's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Peekskill, New York