We had the burgers and they were excellent. The people next to us had the brisket and a steak and they said both were very good. The french fries that came with the hamburgers were really good. Service was super. Our server Patti was wonderful. Jack made my evening even more special by playing and singing with his great voice I will go again Very casual place and relaxed read more

Oh goodness.....where to start...... I like to start on a good note so let's start with the pros. Let me state that we stopped in to eat on Saturday night around 5:30 pm. It was not very busy. Pros: Nice presentation on the food and it tasted good. We ordered the Dirty Dozen (chicken wings) and Crab Cakes for appetizers. Our entrees consisted of hamburgers and fries for everyone on our party. Cons: I'm not even sure where to start. We chose to sit outside in the patio area as it was "choose your own seat". The outside seating area was not very well taken care of - tables not wiped off, chairs dirty/covered excessively in dust. We had a party of 3, waitress only provided 2 menus and then needed 1 back while we ordered because she was not familiar with food items. Menu was multiple pages and just loose instead of in folder and considering prices found this tacky. Waitress also immediately upon seating us let us know that she had just started and was just "thrown" in to job with little training and then provided us with a list of food items not available - there were several. Waitress also stated more than once that cook was upset and yelling at her because she kept asking for clarification of items not available. Upon receiving our entrees, we were "asked" to share our ketchup because they didn't have enough containers to serve all of us. I also ordered a mixed drink when we first arrived and was told they were out of some portion of the drink and I'm fairly sure it was the alcohol. The drink was supposed to be a salivated vodka mixed with lemonade and the drink tasted and looked purely like lemonade. I did ask and did not receive a clear answer but was charged for an alcoholic beverage. In addition, they are still using glasses from the previous business. Overall: Considering the price point I was not at all impressed. This location has the potential to be an amazing restaurant. I would love to say that I am going to give them another try but I'm not sure. Just not impressed at all. read more

See all

Another disappointment after waiting a half hour we didn't even get a drink order in. It is our last attempt.

Having dined at Bertie's 2 The Stockyard several times, we have had pleasant experiences. Food was delicious and the service (although short staffed due to low turn out) was pleasant and attentive. Only draw back was the lack of desert. read more

Berties 2 The Stockyard was absolutely amazing. I have been there twice in the last month and it was nothing short of phenomenal! The food was great, the service was great, everyone seemed to be having a wonderful time. I wish I would have gotten a picture of the Rodeo Burger the first time I went, but since I didn't, it was one of the best Rodeo Burgers I have ever had. The 2nd time I went I had the chicken Alfredo (pictured) and the chicken was seasoned amazingly and the Alfredo sauce was delicious. My friend had the other plate and he devoured it. I have nothing but awesome things to say about this place. The owners also came out to check to see how we were enjoying our food both times and were extremely friendly/treated us like a family. Staff, food, owners, atmosphere are all absolutely wonderful! read more

Berties 2 The Stockyard - Steakhouses Near Me - Pinetop-Lakeside, Arizona

See all

The shrimp cocktail was delicious! The sauce was not the original cocktail sauce, and so yummy. Vegetables tempura was crispy and perfect! The only thing missing was a secret sauce. The flavor was great and the veggies cooked just right! We shared a Brisket plate. The meat fell apart on the fork and melted in my mouth. The sauce was just right, Not to sweet. The garlic mashed potatoes blew my mind! SO a melty and fresh. We also tried the baked potatoe... the cowboy beans were sweet abs spice and paired perfect with the baked potato. Now I'm driving home with Carrots cake... We will be back very soon. Dare I say, my new favorite place on the mountain! read more

See all

Worst restaurant experience we (4 persons) ever. Waitress was so friendly she sat at the table to take the order. The family from the next table stopped by to tell us their experience and let us know they would never be back. The table on the other side of ours finally told them that if their food wasn't out in two minutes, they were leaving. Anpther older couple were getting ready to leave without eating. As we left, the couple near the door were examining their food with a flashlight. Most of our food was not as ordered. TERRIBLE FOOD WE DEFINATELY WILL NOT BE BACK AND WILL WARN OTHERS. read more

This place was great. Food was fantastic. The prices are very reasonable for a steakhouse. The staff is very friendly. They have live music on the weekends and the man on Friday was awesome. Music was classic country. Will definitely recommend and go back. Thanks for a great dinner! read more

Excellent food, service always great! Music on Fridays and Saturdays always enjoy. Country style atmosphere, has outside seating for warmer weather. Definitely recommend, love this place! read more

I wanted to like the Stockyard because I do like Bertie's Cafe. But we went today (Sunday) and you could only get the buffet. We were told it had brisket, prime rib and shrimp along with breakfast. So we thought we'd give it a try. We won't be back. The prime rib was close to medium (I like rare) and it was about 1/8 of an inch thick. I've never seen prime rib so thin. It was overly salty, as were my husband's ribs. No brisket to be seen. There was overly cooked, dried out salmon also. For $28 each, we should have stayed home. Definitely nowhere near fine dining! The breakfast items were also unappealing. The biscuits looked stale and cold, like bricks. Eggs, pancakes, all cold. The staff was friendly. I feel sorry for them having to tell everyone how much people love this buffet. Yeah, like I said, won't be back. read more

I give a lot of leeway to restaurants on the mountain. This was probably the worst that I have had in the area. The steak was tough. The cuts of meat were poor. They were almost out of everything. The presentation was poor. Imagine an ice cream scoop of mashed potatoes on your plate Next to a steak that was cold or overcooked or undercooked. There was hardly anyone in the restaurant and the service was very, very slow. Even the baked cauliflower appetizer was undercooked. The baked potatoes were undercooked. We didn't get part of our food. They were probably out of four steaks, possibly five they ran out of vegetables. The only thing that I can say is that the staff was very friendly. Most of the staff were hanging out with friends or family. I would not recommend this and I will not be back. There were just too many things wrong. read more

Berties was off to a bit of a rocky start, but they're tweaking their menu and making adjustments as any new restaurant would. Our dining experience was okay and good enough to try them again in a couple more weeks. Their soup and salad bar is fantastic. We asked for gravy and an extra side of vegetables to complete our meal. Looking forward to the next visit. read more

Food, service and music are great. The wait staff and managers are excellent. Very personable.

Jim at the bar was so kind and helpful. Sweetest guy. Food was AHMazing! Ordered the shrimp cocktail with homemade tortilla chips, filet and prime rib. Salad bar provides so many delicious choices. To die for!! Happy hour prices are great! $5 off appetizers and $2-3 dollars of draft beer. Open from 3PM-close. Google is incorrect. Also!!! Love music on Friday and Saturday. Do not overlook this place. So worth the trip. read more

Berties 2 The Stockyard - Menu - Steakhouses Near Me - Pinetop-Lakeside, Arizona

See all

Our dinners tonight were delicious! We had a citrus salmon and the fish and chips. Everything was fantastic! Jim and Shannon are kind, friendly and genuine! Cherokee Jack played nice background music. We truly enjoy him. Wonderful evening! read more

Service seemed a bit slow even though there was not many people in the restaurant. It took almost 20 minutes just for the server to bring us the bread, which was underwhelming at best. The food came in about 35 minutes after placing the order. All in all, the food was just okay, nothing special. Steaks were undercooked, Chicken was just chicken and the Pork was also just okay. They are going to have to step up their game if they want to keep the place packed. We would go back, but it certainly would not be our 1st, 2nd, or 3rd choice for a restaurant. read more

Second time we've eaten there and loved it! Service was great, salad bar was huge and our food was amazing. My husband had the trout and was really good and I had a filet and was the best I've had in pinetop. Can't beat the mashed potatoes read more

After 2 hrs I ask the manager where our dinners were. The untrusted waitresses had ignored us since taking order. The cold inedible meals totalling $240 +) tips that we foolishly left )were boxed and taken home . A very distressing evening experience and very expensive dogfood Especially sad because we often enjoy Berties 1. read more

Awful....read all the reviews and listen to the other 4 families who had the same BAD experience we did. AND go somewhere else. They'll be out of business soon. Service was non existent. Server was not informed, not engaged, made excuses for a short handed kitchen. Place was basically empty. Our family came to have a Full dinner of steaks, trout etc. we started with a quesadilla, literally after an hour we did not even have a SORRY. The server had no idea where it was. She final came Back and said oh....10 more minutes. We walked out sorry we ran out and WILL-never recommend or go back. And she said the trout was Chilean....so uninformed She meant the sea bass. DO NOT WASTE YOUR TIME and get a bad experience. We live here and such a disappointment to a have a new place care so little. Saturday night and no manager to even to make a complaint read more

Food was very good as was the service. My N.Y Strip was cooked to perfection and very flavorful. Price was reasonable for the area. Nice salad bar, will definitely dine there again read more

We had lunch here a short time ago. The burger was great and the BLT was full of bacon. Staff were courteous and attentive! We will definitely be back read more

First let me say, that we read the reviews. However manager assured us that things had improved. Unfortunately that was not true. The salad bar was surrounded by flies, the Prime Rib was not good at all. Husband ordered 16 Oz and I ordered the 10 Oz, both where the same size, but his was $15 more. AND don't even ask about the baked potato not sure how they could mess that up but they did. Like the previous reviews the service was terrible, and still is. When we asked about the bread that says it comes with, the waitress was like OKAY. It tasted like it had been previously froze. read more

We were there on opening night didn't have a very good experience at all. Decided to give them another try despite the numerous bad reviews and we're glad we did wonderful experience. My husband had the New York and I had the filet mignon. Both meals were delicious salad bar was amazing and fresh Wait staff were friendly so glad we decided to give them another try great steaks and a fair price read more

Food is great the service was great and the atmosphere is very nice. We will be going back for sure. They also have early bird specials happy hour and drink specials daily read more

We had a great lunch, My wife had the fried fish which she loved. I had the salad bar, This place must have the best salad bar in the area. We had the best peach cobbler for dessert. The service was great. We'll be back. read more

We came for lunch. The BBQ and chicken sandwich were both very good. As a side you can do one trip to the salad bar. The salad bar was great and unusual to find today. I'd go back just to get the salad bar. They had a cider on tap which is also hard to find. We've always enjoyed the atmosphere in this location. Bertie's did a good job inside with the new decor. The prices were typical of most restaurants today. We plan on returning and trying dinner. The service was good too. read more

Went there Friday night for our Anniversary with a party of 6. Had big hopes. Very disappointed in everything. While staff was very friendly. Service was practically non existent. Only 4 tables including ours. Everyone left within 30 minutes. So we were only customers. Took 30 minutes for waitress to even stop by and say she'd be back to get our drink orders 30 minutes finally arrived. Over an hour before we even ordered arrived at 6:30. Finally got food by 8:00. All sides for all of us, barely lukewarm. Entrees not much warmer. Thought all the bad reviews were just because they are new. Unfortunately they are all true. Ruined our night. If they're still in business in 6 months, I'll be surprised. Especially if they don't change. Don't know what staff was doing but they weren't even out in dining area. Lastly. They don't answer their phone. Tried for 3 days. Always busy. Wanted to know about reservations. We won't be back read more

My sister and I went there Sunday around 5:30. She ordered ribeye steak and I ordered the prime rib. When we got our meals, neither looked like what we had ordered. The steak looked like it had been butchered apart then seared. It was tough and tasteless.. The prime rib was very solid, tough and tasteless. Prime rib should ooze flavor and melt in your mouth. Even the an jus had no taste. We were so disappointed. I personally believe they are buying cheaper meats and passing them off as quality. Not worth the money or the time. Such a waste. I live in Show Low not in San Francisco and have for over 5 years. read more

Make the food fresh when ordered instead of frozen, pre packaged. Specifically the chicken cordon bleu.

Delicious food, tastes homemade. Great friendly service. And then there's the pastry. . .yum! The western themed decor is the cherry on the sundae. read more

Wanted a strawberry mojito, but they were out of mint. So I drank water. Shrimp tacos were gross and I sent them back.. I mean why was there cheddar cheese on it, yuck, and when I asked for cilantro, they said they didn't have any. Husbands "brisket" was not brisket. It was sliced roast beef with BBQ on it. Sauce was yummy and the mashed potatoes. Apple slaw was bland. And the butter for the rolls is margarine and tastes funny. I normally don't mind waiting over an hour for food, but when it's bad food, it ruins the whole night. I would've tried the salad bar, but for $18 for like $3 worth of food??? No thanks. Wish I took pics, sorry. read more

We don't go out to eat very often thought we would try Birdies since Hungary Buffalo closed. We were seated promptly and got our drinks. Waiter took our order about 10 min later. Ordered an appetizer and chicken fried steak With house potatoes wife ordered chicken strips and tots son ordered chicken Alfredo. 56 minutes later appetizer came out cold and not appetizing. Complained to waitress and wanted to talk to manager. She came over and said cooks were new and her hands were tied. Waitress came back and said we should get food soon. About 30 minutes later we got our food. Chicken fried steak with no potatoes wife's was not chicken not sure what and had fries not tots son's was spaghetti noodles with a lititle chicken and sauce no sides. Manager came back again not very apologetic told her bring my bill so we can go. Probably worst experience at a restaurant I have ever had. Watched 3 other tables get up and leave. read more