Affordable good food always hot for carryout. Fast friendly service. Eat hear regularly never have had any issues. Only good food!!

I wanted to give this 4 stars for some reason, but I couldn't think of one bad thing to say. Loved the casual bar type atmosphere. Server was extremely busy, but managed to stay on top of all our needs. Food portions were huge and everything was great. Made the mistake of ordering a 20" pizza as I wanted some to take home; I underestimated the actual size of that, haha. Wife had prime rib sandwich and a bowl of chili. She said it was the best chili she has had. One of my daughters had Mac and cheese and it looked pretty great. Also ordered a large soft pretzel. It was gigantic and the dips were fantastic. Probably going to be my new favorite spot. read more

See all

Let me start saying the food was awesome. The service was a little chaotic. The atmosphere was odd. They had this large table with very old people and they were very loud shaking their bottles and wine glasses so the waitress could get them a refill was hilarious. there is this lady in the corner that just sat there and talks so loud maybe her hearing aid was off that she could not hear herself talk but she was very loud. It was funny like I said the food was excellent. Those people were just rude. read more

See all

They were a little busy, and we did wait 15 minutes to get seated, which i can understand. The busyness did die down, however, after ordering, we waited TWO HOURS for our food to arrive. My wings were completely cold, Not warm, damn near freezing. Our waitress did replace them, but i didnt even get the same amount and she gave us bone in wings to make up for it. i just wanted my boneless wings she was on top of drink refills tho. read more

I eat small portions so the Sunday fun is so good! I love these, Jamie does it the best! lol read more

Billy Goat 9 and Dine - Sunday funday always good at the Billygoat! - American Near Me - New Carlisle, Indiana

We were surprised to come across a tavern by a golf course. Super chill spot which had a sports bar vibe to it. The waiter was extremely prompt and upon her suggestion I tried the raspberry ice tea, perfectly refreshing drink that was much needed on a hot summer day. The food took a while to come however the taste was not compromised! read more

See all

Walked in to a friendly environment with happy servers. Best first impression ever. Ordered The Guido as an appetizer with a couple Old Fashioned cocktails. Server was great and we will return based on atmosphere and service. Food was tasty and made from SCRATCH! Stop by... it's worth it read more

I was pleasantly surprised! My family has lived in this area for over 30 yrs. Places have come and gone and my mom and I used to golf at birch tree. It's not a fancy course, so I was weary to come here for a quick lunch with my kids and my mom. We just visited the dinosaur museum and tried to get a table at the south bend public house but there was a 30 minute wait despite several tables being open. I'm glad we came because the burgers here are super fresh, not frozen, hand shaped burgers. For $9 you get a lot of food. Waffle fries were awesome and ranch sauce is made fresh in house. The place was spotless, waitress was nice and it's family friendly. Plenty of tvs to watch march madness. We were very hungry and this place hit the spot. I have no doubt what we had would've been $20 at the public house and the south bend chocolate factory has club sandwiches for a whopping $14. If you're visiting the dinosaur museum, drive an extra ten minutes into new Carlisle and have lunch here. Lots of options, big menu but very fresh, you won't be disappointed read more

Billy Goat 9 and Dine - Great vibes on the inside, very clean, lots of TVs. Nice servers. Food was super fresh, I could taste the quality. - American Near Me - New Carlisle, Indiana

We were glad we chose Billy Goat 9 and dine to eat in New Carlisle. The food was unbelievably delicious, and the staff was great.

Great place for a beer and food. Come here often. This afternoon ran into a young lady hostess who gave us a lecture. We offered we have reservations and could we set at a different table. "I didn't take a reservation for you. You don't have one.". After she left, we went to the table we thought was for us and sure enough there was our name. Customer is always right. :). Despite that, had great time as usual. read more

Went here for a birthday dinner for my husband and had an absolutely fantastic time. The atmosphere was great, lively, but not overwhelming, and our server was super friendly. The owner of the restaurant noticed that we were watching hockey on the TV behind us and went out of his way to turn on another TV for us so that we could get a better view of it, really great guy. We had the giant pretzel as an appetizer, and it could've fed four of us easily. I had probably the best cheeseburger I've ever had in my life, and my daughter had a calzone that was the size of her head. They didn't even mind that we brought in a birthday cake from outside, they gave us plates and a knife, even helped to sing happy birthday. This is definitely a great place to go for delicious food, excellent drinks, or just to hang out and watch some sports. read more

Sunday Funday Bloody Mary's here are the absolute best. The atmosphere here is great and the staff is excellent. read more

Billy Goat 9 and Dine - Sunday Funday Bloody Mary's here are the absolute best!!! - American Near Me - New Carlisle, Indiana

The best lake perch I have ever had. It's very casual and they have daily specials. Everyone else got a hamburger and fries for $500 dollars and $2.00 beers on Tuesday. I got the lake perch, which was generous. $16.00. They have a nine hole golf course and it's very casual. I stress very casual in the restaurant. read more

Oh the Billy Goat. Everything on paper with this place just makes sense. A golf course, pull tabs and moderate beer prices. But let's dive just a little deeper shall we. The golf course is an absolute joke. Probably the worst greens in the area outside of the now defunct Valley Hills in Rolling Prairie. The bar isn't too bad. The service kinda sucks if you're not sitting at the bar. If you hit $599 on a pull tab, prepare to wait for forever. The short guy who owns the place hates paying out. The pizza is okay if it's cooked all the way. Mondays they have a special for slices of pizza and sloppy joes. Don't go in too late though, they tend to run out of sloppy joes rather quickly. The bathrooms aren't bad when there's toilet paper. But several times I've gone there and you could smell the bombs that have been dropped in there. read more

food was absolutely awful from their cardboard pizza to their undercooked mozzarella sticks this place is an absolute WRECK... it's too bad New Carlisle will put up with a shitty restaurant and not keep a good old bakery around..... read more

I love this place. I placed an order for 4 extra large pizzas for the Career Academy Robotics club. I knew it was a tall order for a small kitchen but I just love their pizza so much Especially the Sharon their buffalo chicken pizza which I highly recommend. There was a little hiccup but the owner was extremely kind and compensating and we got our pizzas to the event on time and the kids gobbled them up. I told everyone there you have to try the perch and the Walleye .It's a down home regular friendly place that I love to visit. Fantastic food great value and friendly service read more

I love this place!! The food and drinks are always great. The menu has a huge variety of options. The staff is friendly and up beat. It can be the perfect place to have dinner with the fam or go out for drinks with friends. The 9 hole golf course is perfect for an unskilled player like myself, it's quiet & inexpensive. The pavilion outside hosts some pretty stellar musicians in the summer months. I'll always be a return customer! read more

What a great place! The staff were all so accommodating and the food was amazing. Expected to come here and have the typical bar food and I was completely wrong. Oysters, prime rib, perch, everything was delicious! The place was super busy but our waitress made us feel like we were the only ones there. read more

I placed my order, wings ( the special ) and a salad.. after 90 minutes people that just came in were being served. My experience last week was not any better with the owner having a child like tantrum . I will not be back that's for sure. Too bad the food is quite good. read more

First time trying. Place was super busy but the waitress was pretty good. Event going on. The apps we got was the yummy brussel sprouts & fried green beans. Both very good & tasty. Wing special was awesome. MEATY with great flavors. She got the prime rib bed? Very good. Got the white pizza with Xtra mushrooms, great mouth feel cause the cheese was MEATY but I felt it really lacked flavor. Added salt to help... boys pizza was fire I'm jealous & don't go healthy anymore. Meat meat & more meat next time. Saw a chilly bowl go by that's my next try. read more

Good food. But last two times I have been there been 2 plus hours wait. The poor servers avoid your table because they cannot answer what the kitchen is taking so long. So if you don't mind wait. The food is good. But plan on two hours to get it read more

You know it's a bad day when you can't count on a restaurant to get a glorified patty melt right. They use to be our go to for take out. But, during COViD the mistakes just keep adding up. Limited menu items, terrible customer service and now this. Never again. Don't waste your money here. read more

We went here to eat on our way to see Mama Mia. I ordered the knot pretzel and a wedge salad for my dinner, my grand person ordered a grilled cheese and my daughter-in-law ordered fish and onion rings, easy right? Well it took me 20 minutes to get a drink delivered and 40 minutes later they were waiting for their food. It ended up the waitress put my food in as an appetizer. We asked the number of times where our food was and she had an excuse. Finally she said well they're plating it now. After another 10 minutes and no food we told her we couldn't wait any longer and d it we would just pay for what we had. It ended up in kerfuffle. The waitress screaming at us that we were dining and dashing even though we paid for the food that we had! She said she was calling the police for dining and dashing. They did not have a manager and we talk to others working in the restaurant and no one could help us. What a poor excuse for service. I will not go back there again. read more

Great place, terrific servers. Can't believe they still sell Bud Light.

Very friendly staff and quick to serve you. Food took almost an hour on a Sunday to be served and it was Mother's Day. More people in the bar area at first then the dining area filled up. Ordered a cheeseburger and tater tots and a buffalo chicken wrap. Requested the cheeseburger to be cooked medium and it was burnt black and not even warm. The tots were not warm and the chicken in the wrap was overcooked and hard. We were very hungry and ate the cheeseburger and half of the wrap. The onion rings were good and this place has good pizza. We were not charged for our meal and asked to try them again. read more

This business has decent bar food and their pizza is OK. They also had a Trump supporting slogan on one of their rotating electronic signs. I'll never go back. read more

I placed a simple order for pick up. got there and waited at the desk while the wire waitress stood right in front of me. wouldn't even look at me. Two gentlemen walked in and waited behind me. She then looks up and tells them they can sit where ever they want. at this point, I'm still being ignored for some reason. I waited for her to acknowledge me, but she was more interested in serving the men instead. after waiting 15 minutes for her to even say a word to me, I gave up and walked back the bar to ask for my food that's probably cold at this point. it gets worse every time we do pick up from here read more

Billy goat more like billy joke. Lets start with the the "billy" cheese steak sandwich. You'd think they'd make it like a philly cheese steak. Nope. Not this place. I swear to god, hand on a bible it was nothing more than sloppy joe style meat with cheese. For 9.99, that's really steep. The waitstaff is good for the most part. They could stand to be a little quicker with drinks. I basically look like a alcoholic every time I order because I have to order two drinks. Who the hell wants a warm beer? The bathrooms are decent. But one time there was no toilet paper and this guy who was playing darts next to me smelled like literal shit. He said there was no toilet paper. We mentioned this numerous times to the bartender. She didn't do a thing about it. It just kept smelling like shit. read more

Decided to try for the first time, waited on everything..to be seated, to get sodas, to have our order taken, and after an hour received our cold sad looking Italian beefs and fries, wasn't busy when we got there, lots of kids working, limited menu, lady I can only assume was the owner, (the lady in the "dog mom" hat, telling kids what to do) walking around outside with a beer ‍ what a mess, never again! read more

Stopped in for lunch today and my wife and I each ordered a salad. There were a few people in the bar and no one except us in the dining room. Finally after 30 minutes our salads arrived. During this time our waitress Alexis never once came to our table to see if we needed a refill or to explain why the long wait. Salads were very good but service was terrible. I find it odd that the owner(s) don't respond to anyone's reviews read more

The best bar Fish and Fries with Guiness batter, and because I don't eat meat, I am always searching for good fish places. Prices are great, service was great and beautiful view of the golf course. read more

This review is during COVID. We always try and support local but waiting over an hour for take out (burger, fish and breaded mushrooms). Food was cold, missing sauces. I realize they could have been short handed, however during this time of more takeout and trying to keep business, this isn't the way to do it. Probably be a long time before we go back if we do. read more

This is one of my favorite places up town. It delish and serves the best chicken ranch grinder. I'd love to go back for more! The prices are amazing and not to expensive. read more

I like this restaurant very much it's it's on the golf course and get beautiful views it's got a bar and a restaurant children are allowed in the restaurant are they've got a sandwich called the anti-burger which is delicious it's chicken but you couldn't eat it in one sitting the waitress staff and bartender are very polite and very busy hard workers really give this restaurant five stars read more