Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Birdseye Dairy

    5.0 (1 review)
    Closed Closed

    Birdseye Dairy Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Birdseye Dairy

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Brain Freeze

    Brain Freeze

    4.4
    (22 reviews)
    3.0 mi
    $$

    Brain Freeze - Where Taste Buds Go to Party and Your Brain Yells, "WORTH IT!"…read more If I ever go missing, check Brain Freeze first. Deanna and her team are the real reason my GPS keeps rerouting me back there like it's a rescue mission for my soul (and sweet tooth). Walked in for "just one scoop." Left with a cone taller than my future and a smile so big I had to hold it with both hands. The ice cream? Creamy, dreamy, and possibly churned by angels. Prices? Let's just say I paid less for my sundae than I did for a bottle of water at the gas station. That's sorcery. Delicious, creamy sorcery. Deanna, the mastermind behind this frozen wonderland, is the kind of person who probably gives ice cream to her enemies just to win them over. Her helpers were so friendly and upbeat, I thought I'd wandered into a Disney movie--minus the musical number (although I did hum while eating). Bottom line: Brain Freeze is what would happen if Willy Wonka ditched the chocolate and focused on making the happiest ice cream shop on Earth. 10/10, will absolutely be back... once my taste buds forgive me for the cold snap. P.S. Try the cookie dough. You'll get misty-eyed. It's that good.

    Delicious ice cream, tons of options! Not the best interior but I always just get it to go, as do…read moremost people. My only critique is when the line gets long, the service can be super slow and you'll be waiting a while to order.

    Photos
    Chocolate peanut butter cup
    Chocolate peanut butter cup
    Single mackinaw island fudge in a waffle cone
    Single mackinaw island fudge in a waffle cone
    Stop in today and buy one and get dad's half off! Happy Father's Day!

    See all

    Stop in today and buy one and get dad's half off! Happy Father's Day!
    Zesty's Frozen Custard & Grill

    Zesty's Frozen Custard & Grill

    3.8
    (46 reviews)
    6.0 mi
    $

    Obviously zestys is a classic. Always so good. Friendly service great ice cream. 10/10 of courseread more

    My husband and I tried Zesty's for the first time on Friday, April 24th…read more The good: the custard is very creamy, smooth and delicious. The bad: my Chocolate Mint Oreo Scramble tasted a lot like chocolate and not very minty. I would have preferred it made with vanilla custard, not chocolate. I did not order the Grasshopper Pie Scramble because they add butterscotch and graham crackers to it. A grasshopper pie does not have either of those so I am not sure why Zesty's add them. The Mint Blast sounded like it had too much chocolate added to it, but I probably should have ordered that one as in hindsight it actually looks minty. More bad: my husband's PB Banana Bliss was missing the fudge and did not look like the picture on the menu. Big disappointment. The worst: it took 45 minutes to get our order. All we ordered was custard. There were 3 people waiting to get their food when we walked in, and 2 groups of 2 in front of us in line. That is a ridiculous amount of time to wait for custard or any food, for that matter. Also, 1 of the people waiting when we walked in, asked how long it was going to be to get her food. The cashier gave the customer her food a short time later, got very close to the customer's face and went on a rant about how the food is made fresh. I sure hope the customer contacted management. Completely unacceptable behavior for an employee.

    Photos
    Turtle brownie sundae. Knife needed to cut through brownie.
    Turtle brownie sundae. Knife needed to cut through brownie.
    Zesty's peanut butter custard. Very yummy!
    Zesty's peanut butter custard. Very yummy!
    Zesty's Frozen Custard & Grill

    See all

    Deprey's Frosty Tip

    Deprey's Frosty Tip

    4.2
    (25 reviews)
    16.6 mi
    $$

    A one of a kind roadside ice cream spot in Luxembourg Wi. Their sign says "since 1954." We…read morestopped on our way up to door county for lunch on a Sunday in August. While mainly about ice cream, the burgers are also pretty good served on a unique crispy home-made style bun. I couldn't resist so indulged in a delicious strawberry shake while my wife enjoyed a chocolate malt. Others in the group enjoyed the Oreo flurry (like a DQ blizzard) and a sundae. Just a short drive off the main highway so worth a quick diversion.

    First things first - it's cash only…read more As we arrived there is a plentiful amount of parking. The ambiance and surroundings are nice and welcoming. There are tables all around and the water isn't too far either. Going up to the window, we ordered the cherry frosty. The women responded with "you know that's the syrup, right?" I am not sure if it was a long day, but looking back she seemed a bit short. This was double downed when we received our order. Which was completed in a timely manner. I looked at the scope of ice cream expecting something a little different. Rather than her asking or showing any concern, it was - "I said it was a Sunday." I'm not one to ever argue with the one that makes my food so I smiled and grabbed it. Also, a note about tipping culture. If you expect/ want a tip, than give singles back so the person is more inclined to tip. If you just give a five or a ten back, don't expect them to tip more then what they paid for. The icecream with cherry was very good. Unfortunately, I don't see us coming back to this establishment. Seems a little pricy for what we got. Plus the service was a side of sour.

    Photos
    Deprey's Frosty Tip
    Burger
    Burger
    Look for the sign

    See all

    Look for the sign

    Birdseye Dairy - juicebars - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...