This place was amazing. From the waiter, Brad, to the amazingly delicious beverages and food. Most definitely will be going back! We were greeted by Brad, who would be our "mediocre waiter" (his words, not ours!!) for the evening. Brad could not have been more efficient, helpful and personable. It was very apparent that he enjoys what he does and he does it well, and with a light side of humor. I ordered the sangria, which was outstanding, and the table shared the pancake cheese curds (OMG!). I chose the halibut and it was absolutely delicious; prepared to perfection with amazing flavor and the portion size was perfect. Had I not been full, I'd have ordered more of the cheese curds for dessert. This is a must when you're looking for a great place to dine and ask for Brad. read more

Black Sheep is so unique! If you want to have a nice experience where you're dressed up and want some small plates and cocktails it's an option... but where Black Sheep shines is that you could be more casual to go get a flight of wine (mix and match self serve) AND get a bomb hot dog (gf if you want!). It's a great new idea for a Sunday Funday - or a more low key Friday night option if you've had a long week and want to stop somewhere with your sig. other or girl friends. read more

Black Sheep has been on my radar for quite some time and it truly proved worth the wait. The menu is absolutely intriguing and no matter how satisfied you are with the meal you will see something else you will want to try. To start I had the bread cheese which is absolutely right up my alley. I am all over cheese with various additions that help elevate taste. We actually had this same cheese grilled with honey at clock shadow creamery, the same place that Black Sheep got the cheese that is in this dish. I think about this 4-5 times a week now because of all the amazing flavor combinations. One of the best dishes on the menu As for sides; we shared the Spicy Korean Cakes, Mac & Cheese, and Arancini. Our server recommended the cakes and she came through big time on that call. Fried warm cakes that are dipped in a sweet and sour sauce had me begging for more. The mac was good but not mind blowing and I did really enjoy the Arancini with siracha, another suggestion from the server. For my main dish I had the burger which I will not spend too much time talking about because it was just ok and not cooked to medium rare as requested. Really had a great experience at Black Sheep. The only thing holding back 5 stars would be the initial service which actually did not exist as we stood in the main entrance waiting to be seated far too long and the burger was not something I would order again. The menu has so many other options to explore and with sides like we had, I could go for beer and sides every day. read more

See all

The bartender that worked on 3/3/22 was extremely rude. Won't let people who need to use the bathroom go because the bathroom is for "customers only".... Since when?! I've lived, worked in this area and have been to this place numerous times and have never heard or seen anyone coming from the outside in, being stopped on their way to the bathroom to see if they were going to "purchase something". Black sheep has had much friendlier and more professional bartenders in the past. Maybe get rid of that one read more

Great atmosphere, fun date night environment. Service was great and the food was awesome. The pancake cheese curds were amazing. Overall very great dining experience. read more

Black Sheep - Wine Bars Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

JD was great! We had a great time and he was super accommodating and friendly. Will probably go back to black sheep if I'm ever in Milwaukee again. read more

We were visiting for the weekend from Chicago and had never herd of this place, but we ended up at Black Sheep for Saturday drinks on the patio and flocked back the next day for brunch. The staff is very friendly and outgoing, not at all sheepish (especially JD!) Ewe will love the mimosas and I'm gonna go out on a lamb and say the chicken & waffles are the best I've ever had. Their whole brunch menu really raised the baa & we wool definitely come back when we're in town. read more

Can I call Black Sheep a hidden gem? I mean I feel like not enough people recognize it's goodness so I vote yes. The ambience in the restaurant is perfect for a date or a drink with friends! It's just dark enough to be alluring without feeling like I need a headlamp for the menu. The bar is awesomely long and my favorite place to sit. The drinks are delicious and the wine is awesome. Now let's talk about the food. My favorite entree is the cauliflower dish - it's so unique and delicious. If you don't get the cheese curds, either pancake batter (with a mimosa of course) or with the giant pretzel you're missing out. I've saved my favorite overall bite for last - the beer cheese sauce that comes with the giant pretzel. I'd eat a bowl of it. When my friend and I go we have to ask for extra because we won't share it nicely. It's that good. Look the pretzel is great but I could also just use a spoon on it. Best beer cheese sauce ever. Get over there for some awesome take out right now too! Easy ordering and quick service. read more

Holy cow is this place LOUD! They blast music even during the afternoo. the food was good no issues there, just the noise.

A really fun wine bar! They have dispenser wine cases where you can pick and choose what you want to try. Also a full restaurant menu! read more

Black Sheep - At the bar - Wine Bars Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

I really liked this place when I went for brunch on Sunday morning! I was pleasantly surprised that when I showed up around 12 pm that there was no wait list and to be honest, hardly any people in there. We were able to sit at the bar right away and had great service. The Bloody Mary was delicious (pretty spicy) but good and had some great toppings. I got the B.E.L.T. and it was awesome! I had been craving a bagel and since it was served on an everything bagel, I had to get it. Let me tell you though, I do not regret this decision (even though I solely got it because of the bagel). The tomato was fresh and the bacon was delicious and very crispy (which is just how I like it). My boyfriend got the chicken and waffles which he devoured so I am assuming it was awesome as well. The reason I am giving this place 4 stars instead of 5 is just because I found the brunch menu to be a little pricier than most others in the Walker's Point neighborhood (i.e. many things on the menu were ~$15) and the food did take a while to come out. I will certainly be back though! read more

This place is about as meh as it gets. I had happy hour here with my husband - we had drinks and a couple appetizers. There is nothing about the service, food or appeal of this place that would make me want to come nack. It actually seems a little overhyped to me. We won't be back. read more

My boyfriend and I stopped here for brunch as the original brunch place had a long wait and we didn't have the time. We got in immediately and we got to sit in this cool basement area. The servers were extremely friendly and gave me different suggestions on what to try. I had the lox bagel and my boyfriend had the chicken and waffles. We also got an amazing appetizer. The food was phenomenal. The service was extremely amazing. I'm super happy we ended up going here. It will definitely be a brunch place we come back to again to try new plates! read more

Sunday brunch was amazing! Highly recommend the breakfast risotto, rich and filling but doesn't make you feel icky after eating :) Special thanks to Sean...his service made all the difference. I was in a very thirsty mood that particular day, and he kept my array of beverages full at all times! Thanks Sean, and Happy upcoming Birthday!! read more

I have only been to Black Sheep a few times recently and I have to say that it is one of the most delicious places I have come across in the 5th Ward. Excellent suggestions on their brunch/dinner menu so there is always something for you to find at a reasonable price. I've been to many restaurants where there's a "disconnect" between staff and customers, but Black Sheep has proven time and time again that it is not one of those places. Not only was the food prepared excellently but the service was great! Our server Sean was very attentive, offered suggestions and had an infectious smile whenever he came to check up on us. It was very personable and great appreciated. With this great synergy between the servers, bartenders and the kitchen, Black Sheep has a great team that does well to its benefit. I will definitely be recommending Black Sheep to family, friends, coworkers and associates and will be back again read more

Recently brunch at Black Sheep and our server Sean was fantastic! Not only was it delicious, but the service was outstanding! We can't wait to come back! A+ brunch menu!! read more

We stopped in for Sunday brunch. The food was excellent. The bar tender was a very hard worker, however, it did not seem like she had adequate help. Most of the reason for not earning 5 stars is the value. The food was high quality, but also high priced and low quantity. I would absolutely visit again. read more

So for the past couple years friends and I celebrate my birthday by having brunch. Due to previous spectacular reviews I chose Black Sheep MKE for this year's brunch. What a disappointment! The food was nothing like the pictures posted in other reviews, there was a ridiculous long wait time for food and dishes had to be returned because they were cooked incorrectly or burnt. It didn't help that only one person was offered a $10 gift certificate for their meal and no compensation was given to the other people who's meals were sent back. I had such high hopes for the meal. The only good food were the pancake battered cheese curds. read more

Black Sheep - Wine Bars Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Stopped in for brunch, them menu was the normal fair and I was intrigued by the pancake battered cheese curds, I might stop back in to give them a try. I did have eggs and they came out undercooked which was disappointing.. The potatoes were good, very basic which i liked about them. The hollandaise did not taste like proper hollandaise and more like what you make at home out of the packet. It was okay for what it was and the staff was very friendly, which is probably the biggest draw as to why I would consider going back for drink and light apps. read more

Black sheep has become one of my regular go to's over the last year or so. It's a great balance of really well done food, a great bar and fun people. The crowd at black sheep is a little older and more sophisticated than many of the places in the area. The food is surprisingly good, every bit as good as Braise, Morel and the other restaurants in the area that are really noted for food. I'm surprised black sheep doesn't get more attention to their cuisine because they really put out some nice things and they refresh the menu often. The cocktails are very good, they come up quickly and they are well done. Overall just an almost perfect balance between a bar, a cocktail lounge, and a really good restaurant. Very good price to value ratio also. read more

I went out for brunch with friends. The place we wanted to go had a waiting list so we went to Black Sheep to wait. It worked out great. Bartender Adam was fun, drinks were good, food was good, definitely coming back here on purpose next time! read more

Love the food and ambience!!! Everything we've tried here has been amazing. Not one complaint. Would recommend it to anyone - and if you can get there for happy hour prices - even better :) read more

Very nice upscale bar. Loved you, miss you, should not have moved away from you. Great booze selection, nice waitstaff. If you are looking for somewhere to relax, in a nice, clean, calm atmosphere, this is the place to drink. You can come here and actually speak the the people you are out drinking with, what a concept! Sarcasm aside, establishments like these are my favorite. Parking outside is relatively easy, except when purple door ice cream is packed. read more

Went here with another couple to share some plates this past Saturday. We got the pretzel & curd board, mushroom bruschetta, and hummus trio - all were so delicious. We love the vibe of the interior and the decor is fun too. Our service was slower because our server had too many tables. We all have worked in the industry and could tell she had way too much to do. Thankfully, we weren't in a rush and didn't mind the longer waits. Hopefully it was just a short staffed night and not their norm to run with a smaller staff. Will be back to sit outside along their sidewalk! read more

Pleasantly surprised by this place. Atmosphere was electric, wine selection top notch and all of our entrees and appetizers were delicious. Our new favorite place! read more

We sat at the bar for brunch on Sunday and had a great experience! Kelly Ann(?) was our bartender and she was AMAZING! Fast drinks, great service, awesome personality! Food and drinks were awesome, made our day great! read more

Really good biscuits and gravy. Mimosas are awesome too! Our server, Andrea, was really prompt and friendly. Drinks were always full and our food came out hot! She was very knowledgable about the menu too. We liked the atmosphere too! read more

best sangria around town! always a good time at Black Sheep and it's perfect for a summer drink (they open up the garage doors!)

Black Sheep is in a super cool location and I've always noticed their outdoor seating during the warmer months. Tried going here once without a reservation, which was my bad, and couldn't get seated. Tried again and they only had one time slot available and we had to put a $25 hold on the table. First time I've ever had to do that in Milwaukee but still wanted to try since last time we couldn't get in and the built up hype over just trying to get in. Our server was good and the group I was with enjoyed the happy hour deals. While we enjoyed our time there, I'm not sure if it was what we ordered but I wasn't super impressed with the food or impressed enough for the struggle to get a decent reservation... we also were there for over two hours because we couldn't get our check to leave. I think it's a combination of staffing shortages and trying to space tables out due to Covid but not sure I'll be rushing back anytime soon read more

After a few visits I feel comfortable saying I approve of a visit to Black Sheep, but wouldn't make it a "must" destination. I have been there a few times, once for brunch and a few other times for drinks. I have never had a full dinner there, so I can't review that aspect. The atmosphere is very cool. I love the sky high ceilings and the lovely bar and design. However the set-up with the wine dispensing area makes for some awkward movements throughout the visit depending where you're sitting (sitting at the bar feels most comfortable to me and requires the least walking all over the place). The natural light around brunch time is delightful. At night I've been there a few times when I thought the music was too loud for any kind of conversation despite this being more a of a sit-down venue. The concept is cool- I want to try a bunch of wines, duh! However, be careful if you're tasting on a budget. Those small pours add up quickly and you can easily rack up a hefty tab. The functionality of the wine concept has been hit or miss. I've had troubles with the card not working, had to wait multiple times while they restock various wines, and had awkward periods of waiting in line while drunk girls block the vending area complaining about their ex instead of pouring their wine. Don't get between me and my wine people! The other cocktails I've had there have been mostly above average but nothing outstanding. Service- not that awesome. Granted it's always been decently busy when I'm there but I've had to do a lot of flagging down to get needed items, sat thirsty with an empty water cup and empty coffee cup, and had to ask multiple times for the same thing before obtaining. Everyone has been friendly and good intentioned, but overall service was rather slow and not impressive during my visits. The food- meh. The pancake cheese curds... ummmm YUM. But all the other brunch food we tried was mediocre. Chicken and waffles- the waffle was something I could have made with my 30-in-1 infomercial grill and the chicken was mushy and salty. The biscuits and gravy were nothing to write home about either. The mimosa special was nice for a table of 3. I'll be back, but I won't brag about it. read more

I liked it. Waited for things to settle in and I knew I was going for hot dogs and wine, so I think that mitigates at least half of people's problems with this place. Biggest problem was spotty service, as it seemed like maybe there was only one server on a Friday night and he was stretched thin. So have more than one guy on, Black Sheep. Poor dude was RUNNING. But our food was good - the trailer park hot dog was on point and filling, the pesto aioli that accompanied the truffle fries is a thing I'd like with pretty much 75% of the things I eat and the cheese curds were crispy and yummy. The happy hour specials are great - $3 house wine (and its good!) until 7 pm on a Friday?! My white sangria for $5 was also delish. Tablemates ordered more than one prosecco cocktail, so I'd say that doesn't suck, as well. The apps were $5, my hot dog was $8 - so everything was in line. We each had two drinks (at happy hour prices), we split two HH apps and we each got a dog and our bill was $60. I didn't think that was out of line and I left full and warmed from my wine drinks. I'll add to Rachel F's comment on the bathroom to let you know that the sheep heads are on naked men in the other unisex bathroom - they are equal opportunity here :) read more

I really wanted to like Black Sheep, came back for a second try and still disappointed. The atmosphere is great but unfortunately the food was a let down. The cheesy hash is a block of melted cheese with a little bit of potato in it. I love cheese but the proportions are so strange, call it cheese with a sprinkle of potato. The bloody has good flavor but overpowered with cocktail sauce. The pulled pork benediction was not pulled pork, it was slices of pork. I will give Black Sheep a try again later, I really want the food here to match the atmosphere. read more

Black Sheep - Cheesy hash = melted cheese with a sprinkle of potato Pulled pork = sliced pork - Wine Bars Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Here is an equation I can't quite figure out. Backstreet Boys + "Haute" dogs + wine dispenser + white Eames chairs with eiffel bases and Bertoia bar stools = ?? The only answer I can come up with is: Super awesome expensive designer furniture to make up for a very lackluster everything else. First, kill the 90's Pop Pandora playlist. It doesn't work. It was not enjoyable. I was really looking forward to some amazing appetizers and wine at a new "wine bar" but left unsatiated. I didn't have many options other than "truffle" fries that didn't taste at all like truffle, and pre-made edamame pot stickers (likely frozen, and thrown into the fryer). Milwaukee has some really AMAZING restaurants to choose from these days, with menus boasting local, farm-to-table, handmade dishes. It seems like they are opening up everywhere. "Haute" dogs don't seem like a viable niche on which to hang their hat. Especially in the age of increasing health consciousness, vegetarianism and gluten free diets. Did they blow the budget on furniture and have to make up for it with a limited menu? Looks that way... The wine dispenser is cool, if that is your thing. It just doesn't fit with the rest of the place. It honestly makes for a really poor use of space. On a positive note, I wanted to steal the furniture. read more

I have been to Black Sheep many times in the past and understand the general price range of their menu items. This weekend, I took my mom to show her the awesome wine machines. We are both trying to eat healthy and opted for the cauliflower entrée and the root vegetable salad with added salmon. Everything was ok, nothing to rave about... when the check came, I thought there must have been a mistake. No mistake... they just charged $26 for the salad with salmon and $14 for the martini... These prices are outrageous for the market and we left disappointed and out $84. read more

Black Sheep - Wine Bars Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Went out on a Wednesday night to check out the neighborhood's latest & greatest addition. Latest? Yes. Greatest? No. However, it's not without it's redeeming qualities, so let's start there. PROS: 1) I LOVE the interior - it's trendy without trying too hard, but still feels like it belongs in the "up-and-coming, but not-quite-there" Walker's Point neighborhood 2) I tried 3 of the wines (2 whites and 1 red) - they were all very good. Really like that you can try a small sample, get a 1/2 glass or go balls out and get a full pour. Also, they provide a little 'bio' for those wines that people may not be all too familiar with CONS: 1) Food - Pricey for what you get, I mean $10-14 for a hotdog?! And I don't know about you, but hotdogs are indicative of a ballgame, not sitting in a trendy wine bar - The Calamari was $10 and an ok portion, but it was cooked improperly & felt like I was gnawing on rubber bands. Not good - No healthy/light food options besides hummus 2) Wine - I know I said I enjoyed it, but it doesn't mean it's without issues - Again, a little pricey for what you get. I didn't try the smallest pour (which, I believe ranges from $1.75 - $2 something), but if it's smaller than the 1/2 glass option, it must be just a splash - There were 2 empty bottles in the case, reducing our options for trying different wines. Once again, if this was a weekend, I would understand, but during the week, how hard is it to keep up with? - Was surprised that we were not offered clean glasses after each "round" - not sure if that is standard or due to the less than desirable service (see below). I personally like to switch between reds & whites and don't necessarily want my red residue permeating my new white selection. 3) The female bartender pretty much ignored our group for our entire visit & on more than one occasion, we had to flail our arms about in order to garner her attention. She seemed to be more concerned with pounding shots with two customers (or maybe they were her friends). 4) Being a new concept, you would think SOMEONE would offer to walk us through the process of self service wine - perhaps it was the bartender who couldn't be bothered to do her job, but I found it terrible that on a Wednesday, when the place was NOT crowded, we were never offered a quick tutorial on how the whole card/self-serve wine thingy works. Thankfully we are all intelligent women & we figured it out, but I can't help but think this place isn't going to last long when people are left to their own devices & end up walking out because of poor service and/or feeling dumb for not intuitively knowing how to work the wine system. 5) Did I mention how bad the service was? Ok, not to harp on it too much longer, but having been in the service industry for many years, this is simply not acceptable. I'm talking specifically about the female bartender (there were two other guys there, but not sure they were supposed to be 'tending' the bar...they may have been the owners). We sat back & watched her do AT LEAST six shots with two female customers (friends?) at the bar. Honestly I was ready to leave after waiting over 5 minutes from the time we sat at the bar to the time we were acknowledged by the bartender - at a crowded place on a Friday or Saturday night, this is expected, but this was a Wednesday and there couldn't have been more than 8 other people in the entire place. Finally got waited on, she plopped down a black card & a wine glass and walked away...ok, I guess it's up to me to figure out this whole new thing. Got the wine. Want some food. Waiting...why won't she even look over here? Waving my arms, I got the attention of one of the guys/owners & he instructed her to come over. She took our food order & walked away. Some other guy brought the food & we didn't hear from the bartender again for an eternity. In fact, as our dirty dishes sat in front of us, we, once again, had to waive her down to get our check. I live in Walker's Point and not only LOVE when a new place opens up, but wholeheartedly support my local business. At this time, I simply cannot support Black Sheep, but have a few suggestions - Alter the menu...you can still be fun, quirky and trendy without charging $14 bucks for a hotdog...or even selling hotdogs. Offer some lighter fare, maybe a nice artisan salad, a Crudités plate, a beautiful fruit plate with some chocolate covered fruit options or fresh bruschetta - Consider implementing happy hour specials for the after work crowd...you don't have to give away the place, but again, being a Wednesday, I was surprised to see that there weren't any specials - For the smallest pour, the cards should have 1 or 2 'freebies' so you can truly have a taste before choosing a full glass. Spending $2 on a splash and then another $8 for the full glass puts that glass of wine at a price point more congruous with Chicago or Boston, NOT Walker's Point Good luck Black Sheep, I hope you can turn things around!! read more

Hot dogs. Self-service wine. Cheese curds. Basically, some of my favorite things all in one place. I think the concept is fun, atmosphere is cozy, no real complaints. I don't think they're quite marketing themselves in a way that lets people know what to expect. But, personally, I was pleasantly surprised. read more

It was a cold November Sunday and I was on my way from Walker's Point to the Third Ward when I just couldn't take it anymore - it was just too cold! Solution: grab a drink in a bar en route and warm my tummy up! Cue - Black Sheep MKE. The first thing about this place is the decor. They nailed it. Industrial-feeling while still grasping the artsy feel. The bartenders and hostesses were equally cool. Not to mention attentive and sweet. I was a little surprised at the lack of business at nearly noon on a Sunday, but the menu's price point seemed a little bit higher than what some consider MKE-norm, so not too surprised. Overall, a great experience. A manmosa (orange vodka, champagne, OJ in a wine glass) and an irish coffee - what could go wrong? read more

I've never been to a more classy wine bar ever...I was I a first date and the bartender d trizzle aka dj. He helped me find my Prince Charming! ( picture to follow) thanks for such a great time !! read more

Black Sheep - Thank you DJ - Wine Bars Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

We went there on a Saturday for dinner. There were five of us girls. We had a reservation for 6:00 PM, so we could enjoy happy hour. We arrived, and it was not at crowded. We took our seats at the bar, and ordered drinks. The Sangria, according to my friends was fantasic! We were then seated for dinner at a lovely table at the window. Comfy seating, great light, beautiful. We ordered two apps. The tator tot nachos, and the french fries . Both were outstanding. The sauce that accompanied the fries was especially fantastic. garlicky goodness in a mayonnaise-based sauce. This is where the disappointment occurred. My friend had wanted to come to try the mussels. She had her heart set on them. Well, that didn't happen because they had sold out. Seriously?!? There were not that many people there! If you are going to have a very limited menu, you should be able to accommodate one person at 6 o'clock in the evening on a Saturday night. I truly do not believe that it's too much to ask of the restaurant. If it had been 9 o'clock that would've been a different story and we would've understood. So, then I wanted the salad that was on the menu online. Only to be told it didn't exist anymore. Strike two. And, instead of getting mussels for dinner, my friend ended up with a sub par lobster salad. Strike three. My salad was no better or worse than any salad I've had from any sub shop. Would we come back? Maybe for cocktails and appitizers , but never again would I bring friends for dinner. On the bright side, the staff was great, and the bathrooms were beautiful and totally kitschy and fun at the same time! Too bad the food and menu need some work. read more

I was pretty disappointed by this place, honestly. I was immediately turned on by the Saturday happy hour, and the cool location/decor. I went in and noticed it's pretty small, but the bar is big. I sat down and chatted with the friendly bartender who explained their FOUR taps and the jug of sangria. We asked him if we needed to wait to be seated and he said to sit anywhere. Jen and I tried to sit at a couple tables and were confronted by a rude (manager?) employee that they were reserved. Well we were there about 2 hours and many people were turned away from them, causing them to leave the restaurant entirely. Maybe if there's an 8:00 reso tell people they'd have to be out by then instead of turning away service - not to mention rudely. The drinks were good, and the HH prices made me happy. As a vegetarian this is not the best place - I ended up with mac n cheese and tots. Bar food. The other stuff seemed cool, but the best part was usually the plating - as other guests informed me that they were also blase about their food. The menu is incredibly small for such low quality. I won't be back. read more