Great food, i order from there A LOT, everyone is always nice and the pizza is always great

The pizza is good and staff is great but I cant stand the portions. Every time I get a sub I am extremely disappointed at how little of whatever the meat is, is on there. Last time I ordered a large chicken finger sub it came with literally 2 chicken fingers on the entire sub. Today I ordered a turkey bacon club, there were 4 pieces of bacon on the entire sub for $16 a sub you'd think they'd be able to add more meat and less fillings. I stopped ordering the sub lunch special because chicken finger subs have a singular finger on them and there were only about 15-20 fries included. Not sure why they're so skimpy but be warned read more

first of all, I've been eating their food for the past 10 years. I really liked their food and their workers . Tonight I ordered a small steak pizza.. I'm not sure if the dough wasn't cooked all the way or there was too much cheese on it and that wasn't cooked all the way. It was probably the worst steak pizza I ever had. Also they didn't put anything underneath the pizza so it's stuck to the cardboard box so tonight they get a one star when you spend over $25 on a pie you expected to be edible . Bob M read more

Blasdell Pizza & Subs - bad pizza - Pizza Near Me - Blasdell, New York

Service is a fucking joke they messed up my pizza then the girl manger starts yelling at me would not recommend terrible service

Great food they now offer a sweet sauce for pizza highly recommend subs have plenty of meat service is great

Love love love This is a family favorite in our house. Every time we are near Buffalo we have to stop here read more

Blasdell Pizza never disappoints whether your in the mood for wings, pizza, subs, salads or wraps .I particularly enjoyed my large eight slice pizza with the right amount of sauce and cheeseyness it was delish , plus fast and friendly service to boot . read more

Blasdell Pizza & Subs - Blasdell Pizza Large Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Blasdell, New York

See all

I ordered the large cheese eight slice pizza and it did not disappoint. Pizza was hot, the sauce was tasty and very cheesey.Service was fast and friendly, great staff.They also serve a variety of subs, wings, salads ,wraps and tacos. read more

Blasdell Pizza & Subs - Blasdell Sheet Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Blasdell, New York

See all

If you're trapped in a fiery pizza oven, you're in Blas-hell. Hopefully that won't happen to you at Blas-dell. But if you're going to go, there are worse ways to go than eating Blasdell Pizza. There are also better ways to go. (Like eating Imperial Pizza) (ohhhh I went there) (literally) (like, way more often than I went to Blasdell) (oops ok I'll stop). You'll have a Blasd when you come here. They sometimes do dynamiting in the back yard, so stay out of the Blasd radius. But the pizza here is otherworldly, so step onto the gooey pepperoni rocket ship, and Blasd off. If all the slices in WNY were in a slice deathmatch, this one might be the Blasd one standing. It'd definitely be top 10, sort of like Sepp Blasd-er is in the top 10 worst things to happen to football (real football). So you know Imperial is amazing, right? And it's not far - just minutes from this location and seconds from the other Blasdell location I go to, on Seneca. So the best way to describe Blasdell: Basically exactly like Imperial with rich sauce and carpet bread and just really good on the whole. Yum it down and thank me later, after your pizzacoma. The main difference between this place and Imperial Pizza is service. I don't care about service much, to be honest, but even though Imperial have inconsistent friendly/hostile service at the desk, the Blasdell service at the other location is consistently bad. At this location, though, it's much better, so I try to swing by this one when I can. And it's very close to Apollo - the best Chicken Souvlaki probably in North America. Prices are comparable, and while Pizza is probably a little better and hotter and fresher at Imperial, the slices are tasty and perfect at both places. Like gorgeous sisters that it's impossible to choose between (or brothers, if that's your thing) (what do you mean you have no idea what I'm talking about) (yes that happens a lot to me). Thick and spongy dough with delicious rich tomato sauce and thick mozzarella cheese, with the typical Buffalonian upturned grease pool pepperoni slices on top. Blasdell does have the edge in terms of variety of slices. Imperial usually sticks to cheese and pepperoni whereas Blaisdell often has a display counter with several different types. But overall I would always send someone to Imperial over Blasdell even though Blasdell is one of the best. More chance it'll be fresh and hot. More chance they'll be served with respect. Just like Aretha was when she went there. Hence the song. Now I've had a Blasd sharing this with you, but I need to move on to the next review and Dell you about a different place. But if you do come here for a slice, then Dude... you're getting a Blas... Dell. read more

See all

So I stopped by here on Monday April 29th. At 840 pm. The advertisement on the sign stated small cheese 1 item pizza 12.99. I originally just wanted 3 slices of cheese pizza but they didn't have any ready. Told the clerk then give me the small with just cheese. He stated they weren't making hot items anymore that night. THEY CLOSE AT 10! It's not like I was there at 940. SMH! So I went to Bella. They actually made a pizza for slice sale. read more

2 slice lunch special! Huge board on the wall for the menu. Slices are fresh and come out fast. I ordered at lunchtime, the cheese and pepperoni was coming out of the oven while I was ordering. Manager was working the front counter, and was a machine helping the customers so quickly. People stop they are their lunch break or tons of pick up orders. As soon as one person would love, another would come in. The place is large enough to eat inside and everyone other booth marked off for social distancing. It's nice to be able to sit down for a minute when you are driving around all day. The pizza was so good! read more

Blasdell Pizza & Subs - Pizza Near Me - Blasdell, New York

I ordered 30 wings. When I got home i noticed I was given wings with no sauce. When I called the woman I talked to was being all disrespectful admitting no fault. Im good I have no time being disrespected paying for overpriced wings. Highly don't recommend this trash ass pizza place. read more

You cannot fix stupid!! Ordered at Blasdell Pizza Seneca Street by Cas Park. My order was a small pizza, cheese , mushrooms, oil, tomatoes. No Pepper , herbs or spices, I am Allergic/ Intolerant . I get this great pizza, take a few bites and get a rush of allergic reaction! Fold the cheese back, and totally spiced! So I call, the girl says they did not add any spices, the oil comes seasoned and they cannot make a pizza without oil. I asked why would you say you cannot have the oil? Why would you give me something I am going to get sick from? She hung up on me! Anybody know if Harry still owns Blasdell pizza? Who do I send the er bill to if I have to go. Ruin my evening, maybe the next few days of sore throat and like sinus infection because allergic is not a strong enough word to use and hang up on me when I ask why would you want to make me sick! I did not say it once I reiterated plain, no spices or herbs. I worked for Abbott pizza, I know Harry from years ago, that is not the way to run a business! read more

Unfortunately I chose a Papa Harry's from Blasdell Pizza on South Park Avenue in Blasdell as my 1st choice for my birthday dinner because I always loved this pizza! Instead when I received my pizza it was burnt on the crust, the steak was black and the pizza was dried out from being over cooked leaving it with no flavor. I contacted the pizzeria immediately and nicely tried to request a new one. Instead the girl told me I was lying and that both she and her manager personally saw and made the pizza, at that point they were unwilling to remake my pizza and I let them know I would be filing a negative review... the girl in turn told me to go right ahead and hung up the phone on me. This was yesterday evening. Since then I have called the location spoke with a wonderful day manager which has been so far the only respectable person I have spoken with and have requested the owner to call me back which at this point I have still not heard from. I am very disgusted with the lack of customer service and satisfaction from their staff I received and do not appreciate being accused of lying. Beware if you order food from here and you are dissatisfied you clearly may be treated in this same ignorant manner! read more

See all

Really disappointed. Not quite sure who is to blame. My daughter and I ordered via DoorDash. One large pizza, cheese and pepperoni, one whole and one half sub. Total with fees, tips, whatever, came to $72.00. When the order arrived, we received the subs. Nothing else. $72.00 for a whole and half sub. My daughter contacted Blasdell Pizza. She was told that once the "dasher" picked up the food, it was out of their control. She then contacted the "dasher - Shannon" and was told that "if you want that pizza so much, go and pick it up". What the hell did we just pay for? Anyway. Some of the money was refunded. Not the tip or fees. This is ludicrous. I would be very cautious if ordering from here. read more

This use to be our go to place. But now they are deep frying the bacon. I always loved the turkey club but now it like eating shards of glass in my sub. Been like this the last couple times. Gonna find a new place that doesn't DEEP FRY THE BACON. read more

Blasdell Pizza & Subs - Turkey club with deep fried bacon...not good - Pizza Near Me - Blasdell, New York

Shawn's Pizza Reviews REVIEW # 7 BLASDELL PIZZA SOUTH PARK AVE. BLASDELL, NY SCORE 6.4 This pizza had so much potential. Unfortunately it was overcooked just enough to make is taste burnt. I thought the overall ingredients would've made for a great taste if only it was pulled out the oven a little sooner. I have had a better experience in the past so maybe I will give it another chance soon! read more

Really good food for reasonable prices. Quick and convenient. Very cozy, well air conditioned dining area inside. Blasdell Pizza has well prepared and tasty options in comparison to other local pizzarias/sub shops. With stiff competition in the pizza department, Blasdell Pizza stands strong against local places like Bella and Imperial. When it comes to subs, Blasdell Pizza is yet another local establishment that easily puts Bella Pizza to shame. Prices are lower and quality is way better! I suggest you drive a bit further or vice versa, a bit less to stop here. Check it out folks! read more

So I went back here for a last try with them. Two employees were loudly bickering with each other. Chicken finger sub with "steak" on it, was obviously a steak umm, cold and covered in grease. My fault for going back. Never again read more

We ordered Pizza Night Special on Sunday and had it delivered. It had been years since I had Blasdell Pizza and when I tasted I remembered how great it was. The pizza was amazing, HOT, loaded with toppings and had us all wanting more. Delivery was fast, the driver was very nice and quick...I will definitely order their pizza again! read more

Ordered a chicken wrap was like eating a grease covered wrap it's was awful I couldn't even eat it .... I have boycotted them before but now I will never eat there again read more

I would definitely say that Blasdell pizza is alright. It's definitely not bad but not the best also. There really isn't another pizza place close by except Bella which I like more but that's a personal preference sort of thing. The prices of everything in the world are crazy expensive right now so that's fare. I don't want to beat it up too much because the staff is really good. Friendly, quick service, clean. I would definitely go back. But I wouldn't make this my first recommendation. read more

Ordered three large pies. One pizza contained a surprise! HAIR! Yes hair. After spending $70. you would think upon calling the South Park location they might want to help. NO - Both managers Jamie & Heather said there is nothing they can do. Told to call the Southwestern location and speak to Corry (The owners son). After arguing extensively I finally got a replacement pie. I have been a regular monthly customer at Blasdell's for over ten years. After all my gas & time driving from Niagara Falls I decided to get some wings too. Guess what - FOOD POISONING from the wings. Blasdell "Hairy" Pizza is a joke. read more

Blasdell Pizza & Subs - Yes that is hair! - Pizza Near Me - Blasdell, New York

See all

I love Blasdell Pizza. They always have a nice selection of slice pies up. Good chance they will have orders of 5 wings ready to go as well. The steak pizza is my favorite behind the standard cheese and pepperoni. Good Buffalo style dough that is always consistent. I usually go to the South Park and Southwestern locations because I live right in between both. The barbecue wings are good. The hot wings are crispy and usually well coated with wing sauce. The subs are always really good. I am a hot sub person so I have had the chicken finger sub, steak hoagie, BLT sub and several others. I have eaten many beef tacos hot from here, never disappointed. My children like the French fries they are shoe string style and come with a side of ketchup. Blasdell Pizza is a good restaurant to visit to take out or sit down. They always seem to have plenty of staff at the counter and working the kitchens. They run pizza and sub specials which I usually read off the sign when I drive by. So if you want good food go to Blasdell Pizza. read more

Blasdell Pizza & Subs - Single order of wings hot - Pizza Near Me - Blasdell, New York

Got two slices. They keep 'em in a glass case out on the front counter with some ready to go wings. No reheat of the slices so they come out about room temp with that next day flavor. All the flavors from the ingredients on the steak slice just weren't there. Not bad, not exceptional. read more

Blasdell Pizza & Subs - Steak pizza by the slice - Pizza Near Me - Blasdell, New York

When I looked set the menu online is said they preferred online ordered I wanted to order from the Seneca location. It had me on the S Patk. So I changed locations finalized order sent my husband to Seneca st wasn't there. Looked at email s park location ok no big deal. He goes there no order. This isn't the first time this has happened. No more online ordering and if I can't get through due to staffing shortage I guess I'll be ordering some place else. Fix your online ordering.... read more

I've always had OK experiences the times I've eaten Blasdell Pizza. However, this past Friday evening, some friends and I ordered a large cheese and pepperoni pizza, and a double order of wings - hot, and everything was disappointing. This was a 10:45 PM delivery order, they close at midnight, this isn't an uncommon occurrence to order at this time. We were told on the phone that it would take an hour, but it showed up 20 minutes after ordering. We were very surprised seeing someone pull up that soon, but, we weren't going to complain about fast service. Then, we opened the boxes... The pizza was extremely undercooked, the dough was sticking to the bottom of the box, the cheese literally fell off, and the pepperoni were just little disks of grease. The wings were very over cooked, weren't "hot" whatsoever, and the bleu cheese tubs had a SLIGHT bit of bleu cheese in them. We had to heat the pizza in the oven for almost 30 minutes, wings had to be eaten with a fork because they were so crunchy and hard. I don't know if it was just an off night, or if we were the last order and employees just wanted to get out ASAP. But, if the food quality is going to suffer after a certain time, close earlier. read more

Love the onion and hot pepper pizza. It's one of our favorites. They have the best one.

dont understand how your business can still be open. First your employees are rude and nasty. Then the pizza was burnt(litterly black on the bottom) asked for DOUBLE pepperoni only 20 peices on it (charged me double for it) the wings i asked for hot no taste to them and dry and gressy will not be going back ever again. They need to get better food or shut their doors for good. 0) read more

Stopped in the other day for lunch here. Walked in and placed my order, and was given a number to place on our table. I ordered the sub of the month for 7.99 which was ,chicken finger and it came with fries. The food order was delivered to our table., which was nice. The food was really good. The dining area is spacious, and has 2 large seating areas, which has tables and booths and TVs. They also have a self serve pop machine to help yourself with your soft drink of choice. The restaurant was clean and casual atmosphere. Will definetly be back again. read more

Blasdell Pizza & Subs - Blasdell pizza - Pizza Near Me - Blasdell, New York

See all

Came here on a recommendation from a local I met on the flight here. Had previously tried Duffs famous wings and I hated it, feel free to read about them in one of my other reviews. We ordered a simple order of BBQ wings and terriyaki wings. The wings in general were decent and better than most places. It is still somewhat dry for me. I am a firm believer than wings should stand alone without the sauce and these passed for good but not great. The terriyaki wings were drenched in sauce. Way too much for me especially considering how their sauce has a large sugar base and it was more like eating sugar. Wings themselves were a bit drier than their BBQ counterparts. I have had much better wings at university cafeteria. At this point I would give them 3 stars. Their blue cheese sauce is their saving grace. Best blue cheese I had. I don't remember ever having a better one. Words can't describe it. It went so well with their wings that it made up for a lot of the downsides of what they were lacking. I would come here again. Something I can't say for Duffs. read more

Blasdell Pizza & Subs - The BBQ wings looked so delicious but unfortunately looked much better than they tasted. Still pretty good nonetheless - Pizza Near Me - Blasdell, New York

Got a small c&p pizza tonight. There was 10 pieces of pepperoni on it, at the most I was both surprised & disappointed, because I love their pizza. Maybe a staff issue? read more

This place used to have awesome food but now they are overpriced and have gotten shoddy over the years First of all I got charged full price for 20 wings when I only received 10 and when I called about it they said that I ordered 10 wings and charged me $22 which is outrageous also I ordered 10 chicken fingers plain we received five chicken fingers mild the taco fry however was decent however overall just not worth what we paid I have ordered from here for years and will no longer continue to do so because I come here for quality and for a decent amount of good food for under $100 I'm not going to pay almost $100 and not receive what I ordered I am very displeased by the price gouging and the decreasing quality to not match it read more

Placed an order via Uber eats consisting of THREE items. I did receive 3 items but one was not the correct item. Blasdell pizza loves the excuse "the driver did not grab it so you need to contact Uber eats," and this is exactly was Jamie said. She didn't tell me directly but she was in the back telling a guy to tell me. I told him that although that was a nice try that there were 3 items in there but they weren't the right items. Why not admit you messed up instead of blaming the Uber driver. I was then told " do you know how busy we are? We have a bunch of 16 year olds working here. What do you expect?" I was then told if I ordered directly through them instead of Uber eats then they would of helped me. How about don't affiliate yourself with Uber eats if this is obviously an issue?!!! There wasn't even an apology!!!! I'll never order from there again read more

Stop there today and grab a couple slices of pizza.. cheese and pepperoni. Freaking amazing! Two thumbs up!!

I enjoyed the pizza. It was decent and the price was fair for the portion size (small is 14" pie). The woman working the counter was pleasant and had a good attitude. Was just passing thru from MD and was craving pizza. If I was a local I would return. read more

Blasdell Pizza & Subs - Pizza Near Me - Blasdell, New York

Person at desk was rude. Pizza not great, French fries sucked. Will never order from there again

Stopped because someone had to use the restroom and grabbed a few slices, terrible , it was frozen pizza basically but worse.

We just came for a BBQ chicken finger sub with provolone and a couple slices. Though we still had a little wait for the sub, but it was worth it. I just wish they'd get on board with the rest of the Buffalo pepperoni, theirs just aren't as crispy as the others. I highly recommend the chicken finger sub, it's a buffalo classic. read more

I use to order from here alot. I quit because the pizza was not cooked enough. I went back and the food was good but after ordering online, I still had to wait at least 25 minutes to get my food. The wings and sub were very good. read more