Excellent pizza. Amazing meat stuffed subs. The young lad who took our order (we ate inside) was a little arrogant at first but his attitude improved when he served our order. Crust was thicker at the edge, chewy and tasty, good amount of cheese, pepperoni and mushrooms. Sauce could have been thicker but was tasty nonetheless. One of our top pizzerias. read more

This place used to be the best pizzeria in Hamburg when I was younger. The service has gone downhill, they close earlier than advertised, and the food quality is getting worse...Ownership needs to step up... read more

Best blue cheese. I've been ordering from here for years. If anything is ever wrong with my order, they make sure to make it up to me. Wen the pizza is good, it's GOOD. Easily in my top 5 pizza places. read more

been eating their chicken wings and pizza at Ninos Hamburg for nearly 40 years. Great people! Delicious wings. White pizza is the best.

Great pizza. Great subs. Friendly staff. Have been going here for decades. Never been disappointed

Tried to order a small cheese pizza at 7:30pm and was told they're closed (I live 5 minutes away). Change your listed closing time if you're not going to take orders over a half an hour before close. read more

We have been ordering here for 40 years plus - it is "home" for us - so many favorites and the staff are AMAZING ALWAYS!

I have always ordered from Ninos, however lately quality does NOT meet price. Skimpy proportions. read more

Nino's Pizzeria - Like a cheese/sausage pizza should have more sausage. This isn't the 1st time, its just the 1st time im complaining. $30+ - Pizza Near Me - Hamburg, New York

Yesterday my friend ordered pizza and wings for 7 pm delivery. At 7:20 we were told that the kitchen was "slow" but they would deliver ASAP. At 8:00 still no pizza; we were famished. At 8:30 my friend called for the third time and was told Nino's was CLOSED. Outrageous. DON'T PATRONIZE THIS PLACE. read more

Fabulous subs- haven't tried the pizza, but I will return every time. I am in the area for a delicious submarine sandwich with a very good roll. read more

I cannot visit my home town of Hamburg without a stop at Nino's for my favorite pizza and an order of wings. Top notch in all ways: * 30 minutes to pickup * Crispy traditional wings par excellence inclusive of bleu cheese, celery and carrot sticks * Great pizza with flavorful crust that is both chewy & crunchy. Nowhere have I found better quality toppings...especially large pieces of queen size green olives. And now a 5% discount for veterans & AARP members. read more

Food can be good but the quality and consistency is so over the place. Orders are commonly messed up to the point my mother in law makes a joke whether or not the "a" or "b" squad was in that night. This has been an ongoing issue over the past 2-3 years. I'm not a big "portion guy", but the price hikes have been massive when compared to the amount of food you get. You'll also get three different prices if you look at the menu in the restaurant, on their website, and their own online ordering platform. Just very annoying. Have started going a lot less lately. read more

I have enjoyed Ninos for 18 years. Product is good, but today I ordered a $26.99 5-topping large pizza (Monday deal). I only wanted 4 total toppings and split two toppings on each half. Told I could not split with the Special so I agreed to have toppings on entire pizza. When I picked up pizza I was charged $33 and told I did not get the special because I only got four toppings. So I ended up not paying special price and not getting toppings spilt on as I had requested on the phone. Told "it was West Seneca's policy" but I was in Hamburg. My family will not eat at either Nino's after this experience. If you order for pick up I recommend ordering online so you have a record of what you actually ordered. read more

My family placed a large order with Nino's a few days ahead of time for a Saturday evening birthday party consisting of a sheet pizza, a bucket of wings, an order of chicken fingers, and various other items. The food was ready at the promised time despite the restaurant being noticeably busy, the service was friendly, and, most importantly, the order was accurate and the food was tasty. We were all very satisfied with the meal and will definitely consider ordering from Nino's for future get-togethers. read more

The pizza is wonderful as well as the homemade desserts. We had our nephew and family in town and could not wait to take them there to try the fare. They loved it saying the best restaurant in their town (Orlando Fl). Is far inferior to Buflo Bistro Pizza. We were able to share a variety of pizzas and desserts. Each wonderful in their own way. Thank you for a wonderful meal. read more

Ninos has some great pizza. Ordered to large cheese pizzas with pepperoni and all. I must say, not surprising some of the best in the world, because this is New York. There chicken wings are bomb here too. Very crispy and delicious. Pizza dough straight out of the oven. No heat lamps lol. Good manager, and nice folks working here. I promise, we will be back. read more

Nino's customer service has just become the worst. Tried to order a personal Meat Supreme pizza and was told it wasn't on the menu anymore. I was looking at an older menu, so I ended up ordering something that I didn't even want because everyone else was ordering and I had no time to look up the current menu. When I was done, I checked the website and it's ON THE MENU. It's still on the menu! I can "order online" and it's still an option- costs $11.99. I called back to tell them and got someone else that said "well, it's not in our system anymore but you can still order it". That option wasn't even given to me the first time! I was just told that I couldn't order it. The kid asked if I wanted to speak to the manager and I said "no" because I know the manager doesn't care. Another time we ordered food from there and picked it up and brought it home, MY food was missing. They completely forgot my dinner! When we called back, we talked to the manager and all they said was that there was nothing they could do about it because they were closing in 10 mins and they don't have time to cook it now and refunded us the money for my share. So I didn't have dinner than night. Such horrible, horrible customer service. We've been going to them for years and they couldn't care less about their loyal customers. read more

Food can be iffy from here depending on the crew they have working that day. When you get a good crew the food is fabulous but when you have a bad one you wish you never went. read more

Shawn's Pizza Reviews REVIEW # 4 NINO'S PIZZA HAMBURG, NY Score 8.3 Recommended by Louis & Jen. You automatically get excited when you pull up and see that Black awning. Walk up window with takeout only. Didn't seem to have a dine-in area and only had a single table out front. Service was fast and friendly. This pizza was GOOD. Nice thick slice that was just dripping in grease. They were spot on with this recommendation and I'll give it my best score yet. read more

Nino's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Hamburg, New York

The Village of Hamburg NY has several pizza places and Ninos is never thought of when I'm thinking about pizza. I stopped going here due to the inconsistency which I know it's from the kids working there. Your orders will get messed up and your food well spin the wheel and hope you get what your ordered in addition to the food quality. Nino's was not like this back in the day. It was a hard decision on what pizzeria you choose and Ninos often was our choice. Service and consistency have gone downhill. With the Now, Edie's, Buteras, and Kozs your better off just driving by this place and save yourself from a bad experience. read more

The best pizza in West Seneca and Hamburg!!! My family won't go anywhere else. We actually pass 4 other pizzerias to Nino's and they don't even compare. Everything from their pizza, to subs, to tacos... Everything is fresh, cheesy and delicious. I've never had a burnt or super greasy pie. I also love that they have just cheese slices. Allot of pizzerias don't offer just cheese slices because they are harder to sell than pepperoni or specialty slices. Their slices are also much cheaper than other places. You can get two slices for $5. Awesome. If you have a Nino's anywhere close to you, you must try it!! You will never go back to mediocre pizza! read more

Nino's Pizzeria - Check out those slices! - Pizza Near Me - Hamburg, New York

First time having Buffalo style pizza. Pretty good and very good wings. Definitely will go there the next trip

The sauce was great. Needed another top tier place to order some pizza from and Nino's mushroom pizza hit the spot!

I picked up a pizza that was literally wet & damp with the cheese just sliding off the dough. The manager said, "we tried to DRAIN IT before you picked it up." unreal. go elsewhere, as this place is just a bunch of teenagers slinging disgusting, wet pizza. read more

Nino's Pizzeria - wet, runny, sloppy pizza that somehow was deemed good enough to sell to a human. ninos management thinks you're a joke - Pizza Near Me - Hamburg, New York

See all

Awesome pizza! Subs are great! Especially Italian sausage with cap ! Awesome! Wings are the best! Best sheet pizza in Buffalo! Don't know why it's better that regular round pizza! read more

Nino's pizza is a great option. It is very conveniently located right on Buffalo St in the Village of Hamburg. Last night we decided we wanted pizza and gave Nino's a call. We love Cheese and Double Pepperoni for our pizza so we ordered it that way. We were told it would be about 30 minutes. I arrived just after 30 minutes and the pizza was ready and waiting for us. The service was quick and seamless. The total was $26 and some change. It seems a little expensive for a pizza, but prices are going up everywhere right now so we did not mind. We got home and ate our delicious pizza. It was perfect. The pepperoni was all chared and the cheese was all melty. We were very pleased and we will go back to Nino's again soon. read more

Great pizza! Easy to order. The staff is very friendly. Easy to park. Will definitely recommend. read more

Another good place to have pizza in the village of Hamburg love the taste of the place is good too

The food is amazing, however there is nowhere really to sit in the restaurant. If you're looking for a pizza place to sit and eat there, Nino's is not the place. But if your looking for some pizza for game night, it is the best choice. I order every Friday. read more

The pizza and wings were amazing. A little pricey but you can't beat Ninos. I have never had a bad pizza from here! It's right around the corner from me so it's the perfect location. read more

Been going there for years I had some company from California we went there and they really made us feel welcome everything was fantastic

used to be delicious. what happened? need delivery too!!! maybe you need some new people working?

Don't bother going on the website for any pricing, because they're going to tell you that they change it all the time on the phone. False advertising. They also don't warn you that there's extra charges for literally every single thing that you might want, including sauce on your wings. Nickel and diming your customers is trashy. read more

My favorite local pizza place. It tastes exactly the same as when I ordered this as a kid. Good amount of toppings and cheese. I am now gluten intolerant and I was happy to see they offer a gluten free crust option. It is as close to the original version as you can get, in my opinion, with the obvious taste and texture differences in the GF crust. My personal favorite GF pizza ever, I have tried many. The base/ crust isn't as dry and cracker like compared to other GF crusts. Like other GF bases/ crusts it is thinner and not as spongey than their standard crust. The size is the same as the other GF pizzas you would get anywhere else. I reheat in the toaster oven so the dough doesn't get as soggy as if you reheat in the microwave. The wings here are always wonderful. Plump, juicy and crispy. We usually get a double order of half medium and half BBQ. There is always enough blue cheese and fresh cut carrots and celery. Finally I will advise on the ordering and pick up during the pandemic. The wait times are accurate. When picking up there is a window that can be accessed from the outside. Customers stand in line outside, socially distanced spacing, in between each party. It's great that no one has to go inside and the staff can be seen from the outside wearing masks. read more

See all

We ordered a large pizza with sausage and onions which cost close to $30.00 and it was all dough with minimal toppings. Worst pizza I've ever had. I threw half of it out. Never going back read more

So.. I ordered "food" from Nino's Hamburg and it was abysmal! The wings were rubber and the slices had no flavor,blue cheese was gross and the pepperoni was on par with dollar store. Never Ever Again. Oh and management was absolutely indifferent when I called. read more

One of the best place to grab a slice of pepperoni. Just they need a bigger dinner. Really good thing about this place is They don't give you old pizza always fresh read more

Very dissatisfied the service when I called was horrible today the food was good but not a great atmosphere. My friends told me to try it out ! Never again read more

Pizza and breadsticks were fantastic. From the initial conversation until delivery the customer service was top notch. Will continue to order from here! read more

Ninos is my GO 2 !! Hands down the best blue cheese in the world !! Consistent good quality food with that buffalo flare