Loved the pizza here. It's in Micanopy which makes for a nice lunch destination when I go riding with my gang.

Best pizza I have everrrr eaten, so fresh and amazing customer service. So worth going there, I haven't eaten pizza from anywhere else in a very long time. read more

I had sicilian panini. It came with chips and a pickle. The chips were pretty good. Possibly kettle type, not the typical "plain" variety. The sandwich was AWSOME. Unbelievable. I thought it was going to be "fair@ since I watched the toss it in micro- but it was genius. They use micro to get meat and cheese warm (open face) then close it up and throw it on p-press. Did I say awesome? Awesome! read more

Delicious pizza, salads and more. In the season there is usually a wait so do take out if you can. Definitely a must do in the Micanopy, FL area. read more

Great food. Very fresh. Greek pizza, thin crust was awesome. Shrimp bruschetta was a little soggy but good. Pizza overall very very good. Busy and service was a little slow but worth the wait. read more

Excellent thin-crust pizza, especially with clams (vongole) and shrimp (scampi). Friendly service, too.

Awesome people. Food is made to order so don't bother going here if you're short on time or just an impatient A******. The staff are hardworking and upbeat and make sure their customers are given the best service possible. read more

My husband and I stopped in today while passing through town. This restaurant is great! The decor is charming, our server was kind and friendly, and the pizza is very tasty. We ordered the antipasti platter and loved it. It had very generous portions of meat, cheeses, roasted veggies, caprese salad, hummus, olives and focaccia bread. Everything was fresh and high quality. We also ordered a pizza to share and the crust was very good. The perfect amount of crunch and full of flavor. The toppings were also very fresh. Loved it! read more

Delicious pizza, sandwiches and salads. Love Blu Hwy salad w balsamic dressing. Love vegetable panini and lamb piadine too. Plus, the folks that work there are friendly and aim to please. Be prepared to wait 15-25 minutes for a seat most nights bc it's a small space but well worth the wait. Offers great food and vibe in one of the coolest old time Florida small towns...Micanopy. read more

As good as our pizza may have been, we waited nearly an hour and a half for our pizza. As soon as we arrived, it was clear that many of the tables had yet to be served but 1-2 looked like they would be getting their check soon. The servers were very nice, assured us it wouldn't be a long wait and meanwhile we could put in our orders. So we put in our orders for two Sicilian pizzas. They also asked if we wanted drinks, so one of us ordered a coke. We did not realize it was canned and not free refills, nor were we informed. My friend was not given her can, but still paid full price. 30 minutes later we sit down. We then wait at least 50 more minutes at the table before ever receiving our pizza. The pizza was good, but also undercooked in the middle (see picture - wrapped to go after we ate). Highly disappointing since it took so long for the food. We were understanding of how busy it was, but also did not appreciate the constant empty promises that our food was "almost done". Overall, probably would not return. If anything, definitely order take out. read more

Blue Highway Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Micanopy, Florida

Shrimp bruschetta to die for. BH is not just good, its Always Good!

Blue Highway has amazing creative pizzas and sandwiches. There are only a few other restaurants near Gainesville that have ingredients and quality and a local-feel like Blue Highway. I never really knew what good pizza was until I started going to Blue Highway. Once Gainesvillians discovered Blue Highway, they started flocking to the restaurant- making the 10 min. drive across Paynes Praire- so sometimes it can be a little crowded. But be patient, its worth it. read more

As ALWAYS, the food was amazing and the staff nice as pie....but dang...the air and the fans were running so hard and so cold we were miserable! And the mosquitos were horrendous! Will not return for a long time, if ever because I was simply miserable the entire time. read more

I really like Blue Highway and I'm exceptionally critical about restaurants. The food is great and the service is spot-on. If you want hipsters looking down on you for doing something with your life other than keeping up on the latest Emo band, go to Satchel's. If you want good pizza with edible dough, go to Blue Highway. Oh, and as for the "cornmeal crust", I'm pretty sure that they don't actually have cornmeal in the crust. Cornmeal is often used by pizza places in place of grease to keep the pizzas from sticking to the pan without having a greasy pizza. Some places avoid this by using screens and some just use grease. read more

Well, there are a lot of other pizza places to try before this one. Blue Hwy is okay but not great. I'll give it another chance if I'm out that way, but with all the good pizza in Gainesville I'll probably never make it to Blue Hwy again. read more

I Love Blue Highway Micanopy the first of the line. But lastnight I realized that now the Importance for Blue Highway is becoming a chain store pulling in the bucks not staying true to the brand they created. I ordered my favorite cal-zone the italian sausage with pepperoni instead of the sausage, and my first clue to the change was the box was half the size as before, and no my eyes were no seeing things the cal-zone was alot smaller, and then when I went to eat it the dipping sauce was not the same either it tasted like it came from a can. And the dough was tough and chewy not the same product at all I hope Blue Highway doesn't allow these changes to become common place because it is a game changer. The loyal customers that keep following you and supporting the growth with the Haile store and now the ocala store won't be there to support you anymore read more

Awesome pizza's and great salads... every person I've talked about this place is oh ya their food is wonderful

Great pizza! We discovered the blue highway pizzeria from yelp. We decided to give it a try.. Great service great pizza... We drive through this area once a year and we will definitely be back. read more

Service was incredibly slow, which would have been okay if they served fountain drinks -- but once my can of Diet Coke was gone, the 40 minute wait seemed v e r y long. One of our table had a marvelous pizza with mushrooms, and I enjoyed my bite. For myself, however, I ordered a small salad with a scoop of tuna salad. Came to over $9 for a wee bit of lettuce and the most taste-free tuna I could imagine. On the whole, what was good about the place was that they let us sit (and sit, and sit), so we tipped very well for taking up the table . . . The service, when you could get it, was warm and friendly enough. But the food . . . Not up to "meh." And oh yes, the restrooms - you go outside (I had some trepidation that they might actually be taking me to a privy - not to worry). Then you find it, and yes, it is a real restroom, and it looks like it may have been cleaned around Labor Day. This was Sunday, so perhaps they'd just had a busy Saturday night and hadn't got to the cleaning yet. Who knows? One thing for sure - if we do get back that way again and need to eat at Blue Highway, I'll be ordering that fungi pizza. read more

Food is ok but nothing to brag about. Service is slow. This was not horrible but I would not recommend it.

From the outside, it looks like something you should pass by. Do NOT be fooled! Inside, you'll find great service, excellent food and people who truly love what they do. I wasn't even hungry when we went, but by the time we left I was clutching the leftovers like a prize. The pizza crust is delicious; whatever toppings you get, you'll be good because a fine pizza starts with a well-made crust. The Greek salad (with tempeh added; so tasty) was more than enough for two people to share as a meal, and the bread triangles that came with the hummus (I'm guessing they owe a lot to the pizza crust) put to shame the usual pita bread mini-wedges you find at most restaurants. Even the Key lime pie is worth ordering, something which, alas, cannot be said for every KLP in North Central Florida. It's a small place that fills up quickly, so going at an off hour might be a good bet, and yes, this location only uses disposable dinnerware; this is something you'll need to take up with the good people who run Micanopy if you want it to change. If you drive by, give this little restaurant the second glance it deserves and treat yourself! read more

While the service was great (the server had an enthusiasm that was almost overwhelming) the food was fairly boring and mediocre. We got their tossed salad and usually I think tossed salad means that the dressing is tossed with the salad but apparently that was not the case; although the balsamic vinaigrette was tasty and the greens and vegetables were nice (no iceberg lettuce). I did try a bit of Heather's hummus and it was really good with a nice hit (not hint) of garlic. But....the pizza at a pizza place should be the star, right? Well...I found their cornmeal crust tasteless, I know it's easier to make a crispy crust if you use lots of cornmeal but it doesn't necessarily make it more flavorful. The sauce didn't have much flavor (I prefer a spicier tomato sauce on my pizza, this tasted like canned tomatos to me) and the "fresh" mozzarella was most definitely not fresh mozzarella. I know it's nit picky of me but I *hate* it when restaurants give you paper plates and little plastic cups. Steve broke his plastic fork and it just feels wrong in a place that isn't a pizza counter or take out place to not have real utensils, plates and glasses. I doubt I'll make the trip out to Micanopy again when Satchel's is five blocks from my house. read more

We live in Ocala and our daughter attends UF in Gainesville. Driving back and forth on 441, we noticed that Blue Highway always had a crowd. We thought that maybe this was one of those little jewels off the beaten path and had been searching for good eateries since leaving the Baltimore area. What a disappointment. They only had 12" pizzas that were pretty expensive. This might have been ok if they were really good "gourmet" pizzas but they were not. Would not recommend. read more

One of our favorites. A real local hole in the wall type of place that probably used to be a small 2 bedroom house, they make GREAT pizza's, calzones, sandwiches and salads. Everything's homemade. People drive all the way from Gainesville for their tasty food and fun atmosphere. It's a little loud, so be prepared and has a little bar with plenty of different beers and wine too. read more

Best pizza in Gainesville! The Greek pizza is my favorite! Love the atmosphere of the Micanopy location!

Small place with a bar and a tv. Small amount of seating so may be a wait. Worth it though, pizza was amazing . Bbq chicken pizza and we did a build your own . Both had a great crust and sauce really good. Great for Game day instead of getting onto I- 75 and fighting traffic. Lots of people getting pizza to go as well. read more

We have eaten here several times now and Blue Highway NEVER disappoints! Today we tried several new things-- the spinach and Brie flatbread was to die for! In addition, we had the amazing lamb piadine and their delightful chicken salad. Our waitress was phenomenal and attentive despite the number of patrons she had to care for. Do not leave without trying the key lime tart-it is heavenly! Do yourself a favor and drop in! read more

Everything I have ever had here is really good.I LOVE the salads with the pecans,& the pizza is GREAT.It is also a really nice atmosphere...a little hippy joint in the country...which I really like.I've been coming here for at least 5-6 years & every time I really enjoy it! read more

Awesome little eatery. We had the most amazing buffalo chicken Pizza. Staff are very friendly and we were served promptly. Highly recommended if you're passing by. read more

My boyfriend and I stopped in on our way up to Savannah as he recalled going there years back and liking it a lot- his memory was spot on! It was delicious. We got the bruschetta app and the BBQ and tempeh pizza. The touch of cilantro on the pizza was perfect and the one-room dinning area was a great cozy atmosphere for yummy pizza & beer. Fair prices for beer and food alike, I definitely recommend Blue Highway. read more

The atmosphere is very rustic. We had a italian sausage calzone which had an amazing crust a little bit of crunch outside and super moist inside. The filling had great ratio of meat to cheese to veggies!! We also tried a Sicilian style pizza. The sauce had a nice heat to it without being over the top. Again good ratio of meat to cheese to sauce. The crust had a good flavor except was too thick. I would recommend the thin crust which is more like hand tossed. Looking forward to our next visit read more

Love the food, the salads and pizzas. Greek pizza is my favorite. Only thing I can't stand is using plastic forks and cups to eat my pizza. To make this a 5 rating they really need to get real silverware, glasses and plates. It is great for takeout though..... read more

Horrible service, again. 4 of the last 6 times I've gone here I have been dissatisfied with the service. When we called to pick up and asked to have it ready at a specific time and were told it would be, we waited 15 minutes. Took a group from work another time- 2 tables that ordered 7 lunches at the same time. 5 lunches came. Today I sat at the bar to get a take out order. One server took an order to a table, one folded pizza boxes, another picked lint or hair off her shirt. I checked out the little flip-menu, watched some tv, looked around-I waited at least 5 minutes and absolutely no one acknowledged me. I have kept going back previously despite the poor service to support a local business, but maybe with 3 locations now they've gotten too big to need my business anymore. read more

I was really looking forward to eating here after hearing/seeing the rave reviews... food was decent for the price, but service was beyond abysmal. If you've got half a day to spare, go for it, otherwise run for the hills. read more