6/21/26: Blue Square Pizza continues to impress and is easily one of my favorite pizza spots in the area. This visit we ordered the Mushroom Truffle and the NY Pepperoni, Burrata & Hot Honey pizzas, and both were excellent. The Mushroom Truffle had a rich, earthy flavor without being overwhelming. The truffle complemented the mushrooms perfectly, and the crust was crispy on the outside while staying light and airy inside. The standout for me was the NY Pepperoni, Burrata & Hot Honey. The pepperoni had a great crisp, the burrata added a creamy richness, and the hot honey tied everything together with just the right amount of sweetness and heat. Every bite had a great balance of flavors. One thing worth mentioning is that while the food has always been fantastic, the pickup time estimates can be pretty inaccurate. On previous visits I've arrived based on the quoted ready time only to end up waiting significantly longer. It hasn't stopped me from coming back because the pizza is consistently worth it, but I'd recommend giving yourself a little extra time if you're ordering for pickup. Overall, outstanding pizza, quality ingredients, and flavors that keep me coming back. Just don't rely too heavily on the estimated pickup time. Highly recommended. read more

Blue Square Pizza - DT Mushroom Truffle SM - Pizza Near Me - Hopkinton, Massachusetts

See all

Pizza is fabulous Ordered chicken wings didn't get them I got chicken drumsticks I noticed others have stated the same about this in the past This is not a mistake it's intentional to save money on raw chicken. Lying online to drive up profits is not acceptable A company that lies about such a little thing will lie about anything That's why I'm so irritated by this Hey Troy S while you've got better things to do try telling the truth to your customers David W read more

Tried Blue Square Pizza for the 4th and final time. The utter lack of concern they show their patrons is not acceptable and we won't be doing this again. Waits of 30 min 45 min and 75 min beyond the promised time shows no respect for their customers who are shelling out $30/pie. It's good stuff, not amazing and we won't be back. Here's their MO: place order online, state 20 for pickup, arrive on time and clerk says sorry it'll be ready in 5 min. The digital board says the pizza is ready. Clerk comes back after 10 min and says I'm sorry it'll be another 6 minutes and then another 5.... I urge everyone to boycott this establishment. read more

Blue Square is absolutely the best pizza ever!! Friendly folks, amazing pizza! Classic cheese is amazing. Love the Grandmas anything etc. read more

Blue Square Pizza - Cheese pizza done perfectly - Pizza Near Me - Hopkinton, Massachusetts

First time in, I've been wanting to try for quite some time. The location itself is small, and doesn't have much seating so I would recommend doing takeout. The pizza is delicious! Nice and thin! The crust was sooo good and I don't even like crust normally. I will definitely be back!! read more

Blue Square Pizza - NY Gambino LG - Pizza Near Me - Hopkinton, Massachusetts

The NY Gambino LG was not a disappointment! They put the perfect amount of ricotta cheese and were not shy with the pepperoni. The crust was perfectly cooked with the perfect amount of crunch! The menu has so many options from different styles of pizzas to all different types of toppings and cheeses. I can't wait to try others! read more

Blue Square Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hopkinton, Massachusetts

See all

Some of the best pizza I've had in this state. The taste and texture is really close to some of my favorite places out of NYC. The staff are friendly. Not a big dining area and you have to park on the street, but I would highly recommend trying the pizza here. I will be back to try other pies. read more

See all

We've been going to the Hopkinton location for a while but I decided to try the new Natick location. My friend and I ordered a large NY Style with pepperoni, onion, mushroom and peppers. It was seriously delicious. It was a combination of the sourdough crust, the sauce and the ingredients. Something about it. We couldn't stop eating it! read more

Life is short . F...it up. Family, Flavor, Friends Came in last minute avoiding the thunderstorm got the Grandma vodka meatballs pizza.. this place still creates dough into master pieces for your mouth. Great balance of sauce good crunch and and chew from the dough. A hint of sour dough in every bite. A lil bit if char in the bottom but doesn't taste like char ( it's butter). Just to get one. read more

Blue Square Pizza - Grandma Vodka Meatball - Pizza Near Me - Hopkinton, Massachusetts

Went recently and tried three pizzas. New York style- Pizza. Other than all the Semolina that really isn't necessary this is one of the best New York pizzas in the state. Perfect crunch , a nice bold and mildly sweet sauce and a flavorful cheese. I could've eaten the entire large ! Detroit pizza. This was up there with Volo. The crunch was spectacular and the light airy bubbles made it easy to keep eating. This pizza was worth the 40 minute drive alone. Grandma Pie. Wasn't impressed at all. It was thin but chewy and not crunchy. The cheese ate like it had been sitting wich was odd because we are there and got each pie out of the oven. They are a tiny place with only 3 tables. So plan on taking it to go. Highly recommended. read more

See all

Ordered a pizza, just a NY style large cheese pizza. Ordered it at 5:30, at 7:42 it Still wasn't delivered. When it arrived it was cold and dry and when we called the offered to refund but here's the thing. This is straight up really bad pizza. These people have huge balls selling this garbage. I'm wondering if the delivery guy went for dinner himself? Maybe he pushed his car, that would at least explain a 2 hour wait for a pizza. How could a pizza made today be that fucking dry? Are they trying to conserve insulated delivery bags, is tomato sauce a rare commodity? Absolutely trash, imagine thinking anyone would want a gift card from this place. Hahahahahah I've had better pizza at a hockey rink. If Yelp allowed it this would be a negative 5 score. Deplorable and they were not at all concerned when we called. Never again. Zero point zero! Ordered a Papa Gino's cheese pizza after the burnt turd from Blue Square arrived and what do you know, it was delivered hot in 26 minutes and didn't look like someone had made it 2 days ago. I feel bad because I should have driven to Hopkinton to ask them to explain how they could so badly screw up a pizza but thought better of it because it's obvious that they don't care. read more

Blue Square Pizza - A cold dry just delivered shit pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Hopkinton, Massachusetts

Great pizza, but very frustrating delivery process. If your driver is picking up multiple pizzas, and yours is ready first, it just sits there until the other orders are ready that the driver is signed up for. Nearly two hour wait times are tough. If it's going to take this long, it should be advertised on the app when ordering. The times that are shown on the app are incredibly misleading. read more

Pizza is incredibly delicious. The guys and chefs making the pizza are outstanding, friendly, and talented. I messed up my order, but they accommodated me without hesitation. Excellent customer service, and I'm glad I come here whenever I get the chance. read more

Blue Square Pizza - Small DT Pesto Burrata w/pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Hopkinton, Massachusetts

Blue square pizza crushes the red sauce game. We've tried many of their pies and can confidently say any pizza with their signature pizza sauce is delicious whether Detroit on NY style. Their meatballs in their marinara also hit the spot. Highly recommend this joint! read more

The pizza has gotten much better over the past year and they are probably the best pizza option in the area. I'd recommend them for sure. read more

Blue Square Pizza - Burnt - Pizza Near Me - Hopkinton, Massachusetts

See all

Love their grandma pizza. Will travel to get it. Excited for a new location in Natick!

Blue Square makes amazing tasting quality pizza! Several styles to choose from including New York, Chicago, Detroit, Grandma, and Gluten Free. Online or phone ordering! Can't say much more than I enjoy every pizza i have gotten from them. read more

Wow . Really the best pizza I have a new England. I took the large truffle oil New York style and added pepperoni, mushroom and roasted pepper and basil. The pizza is excellent and the price is fantastic. It is best to order online a bit ahead of pick up time at this location . I wish I took a photo, but we devoured it very quickly. Pick was extremely quick and nice people at the counters. read more

Update: the owner reached out to me based upon my review. This fellow cares about his business, product and customers. We tried Blue Square again, going with a round NY style pizza. It was Amazing. Perfect tang in the sauce, flavorful crust, loved the meatball topping. Ordering a pizza is a bit of a challenge for those looking to talk to a human, it is all automated. We ordered on the early side of dinner hour because wait times can be very long on weekends. Will return, thank you! read more

See all

We are in town for a few days and enjoyed Blue Square take out on Friday and plan on ordering for dinner this evening before heading home. Order and pick up was an easy process. The pie is delicious and the crust, in particular, puts their pixie in a category of its own. We enjoyed the traditional cheese, buretta and honey as well as the pesto pie. Great crunch, fresh ingredients and yummy enough to think of when we will be ordering again. read more

See all

Ordered Blue Square for lunch takeout catering and it was awesome. They offer so many different styles of pizza and all of them were very good. Very light and fresh with a great crisp on both the round and square styles. I will definitely be back to try it fresh out of the oven! read more

Blue Square Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hopkinton, Massachusetts

Good local pizza or if you're driving by Hopkinton (just a couple miles off 495) but the Detroit pizza isn't good enough to make a dedicated trip just to try it. The pizza had good carmelization of the bottom and cheese on the edges of the crust. The pizza was about one inch thick - I was expecting a slightly thicker crust. The dough was unevenly cooked - some parts of the dough were slightly gelatinous from being under cooked. The sauce was sweet - a little too sweet for my tastes. There wasn't much pepperoni on the pie. The pepperoni were scattered along the edges of the pie. The price was reasonable at $17 for a small Detroit pizza with four slices is more than enough for one person. The restaurant is a takeout place with a few tables where you can eat. It seems like a lot of good pizza places follow that approach to keep costs down and focus on making good pizza. Overall, I think the Detroit pizza is better at Square Mfg in Natick, but if you're in the area it's worth a visit to Blue Square. read more

Everything about this food was amazing! I tried the Detroit style while my spouse tried the new York style. Both were so good. Definitely going back. read more

Today was the last straw. Pizza took 55 minutes. 25 minutes PAST the estimated 30 minutes. This has happened to me almost every visit. On top of that, 2 of the 3 pizzas were totally burnt on sides and bottom - completely solid black burnt. There was an army of people working and still can't get the food out in a reasonable manner. This seems to be a complaint from many people. Also, tell your staff that sitting down and eating behind the line when it's this busy looks absurd. Get it together. You just lost multiple customers. read more

I ordered the pepperoni Detroit style, and it was absolutely delicious! Five stars for the pizza, but I have to deduct one star for needing to speak to an AI agent on the phone to order. Hopefully this is just a temporary situation while you're understaffed, because it's much more enjoyable to speak with an actual human! read more

This place is absolutely excellent. Pizza is a 10/10, great service and restaurant is super cute. I love it here and will continue to come back. read more

Incredible pizza, and really exceeded expectations. I was concerned that a shop doing so many different styles would struggle to be great in any of them. We had a detroit style and a new york style. The pizza was ready when they said it would be. The pies were amazing. Freshness really came through, execution on the crust of both styles. Highly recommend. read more

How do you rate pizza when there's nothing else quite like it? You really can't. The only fair way is to put it in its own class and judge anything else in that class against it. Blue Square doesn't just put pizza in your mouth, it puts it in your mind. You can't shake the feeling you've been eating pizza wrong your whole life, yet at the same time, you're buzzing with excitement like you've just discovered a hidden gem. We've been eating Blue Square since they first opened in Hopkinton, and it quickly became our go-to spot--whether we're hosting out-of-town friends or just craving something better than your typical Greek-style pizza (no offense to those delicious classics). Blue Square is worth the drive. The fresh ingredients, balanced flavors, and creative toppings that just work make every visit memorable. read more

My party of four ordered a small Detroit-style red top cheese pizza, small New York-style pepperoni round pie, and small New York-style mushroom truffle round pie - TASTE: 4/5 - the Detroit-style red top cheese pizza was definitely the crowd favorite! The NY-style mushroom truffle pie was next, w strong truffle flavors TEXTURE: 5/5 - again the Detroit pizza blew us away, with thick fluffy dough and a nice crisp crust. Would come back to try more of this style! PRICE: 4/5 - the total came out to $50 SERVING SIZE: 4/5 - brought a couple slices home for leftovers SERVICE: 4/5 - walked in at 6pm on a Sunday, placed our order at the counter, and got our pizzas 15min later ATMOSPHERE: 4/5 - small space inside but there are a few tables in the back outside with more room PARKING: 4/5 - got a street spot right on Main St, though there were a couple of parking lot spaces seemingly available around the corner on Walcott St read more

Blue Square Pizza - Small New York-style pepperoni round pie, small New York-style mushroom truffle round pie, and small Detroit-style red top cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hopkinton, Massachusetts

Unfortunately another subpar performance at Blue Square. The first 2 times we ordered there we were blown away, ever since then we have been chasing the dragon. If I'm paying $28 for a pizza with pepperoni, sausage, and bacon on it - is it really too much to ask that each slice has pepperoni, sausage, and bacon on it? I paid extra for red pepper on the whole pizza and then red onion, and mushroom for half, is it just me or does 8 slices of mushroom seem slight? And typically you can't count the number of onion and pepper pieces on a pizza but... I think I'm paying enough for you not to cheap out on super basic toppings. I want to continue to like you guys. I really do. I can even almost overlook the fact that the pizza is always cold when I get delivery no matter who delivers or what "keep warm" bag it comes out of. Other places manage to get me at least lukewarm pizza, but whatever. The DT pizza seems to have been a little more on the normal side of things toppings wise, the NY pepperoni was fair. I seem to always overlook that the Detroit pizza is ALWAYS oily, soggy, and greasy on the bottom, (even when I order there and wait and bring it home) I keep telling myself it's the toppings I'm choosing - however when it's a pizza from the menu I just don't understand. Or are ALL Chicago pizzas soggy on the bottom unless you eat them immediately at a restaurant? Doesn't seem right, but I'm from New England, so what do I know i guess. ‍ At any rate, I just can't keep justifying $100 for 3 pizzas when it's always so disappointing. read more

See all

I came here because they offered vegan cheese on their pizzas. I've never tried a Detroit style pizza before, but I love a thicker crust pizza and it was amazing. I am so impressed by the vegan options that I need to come back! It was made very fast and was decently priced for how good and unique it was. There was only street parking and inside was very small, but otherwise was amazing. read more

Blue Square Pizza - Summer veggie Detroit pizza with vegan cheese - Pizza Near Me - Hopkinton, Massachusetts

I may have eaten more pizza in more places than anyone alive. I have traveled around the country for work, for speaking engagements and with my daughter on her national AAU team and everywhere I go, I get the best pizza there is in that area according to Yelp. In addition I watch videos on pizza making, to learn about the best places in the country and about the way things work on the back of the house. As a result, I know my stuff. And I know what's good, bad and great. I found out about Blue Square from a Phantom Gourmet video and subsequently another video from a pizza marketing source. I was impressed by the owner Troy and his borderline psychotic obsession with making the perfect dough and sauce. He makes a complex sourdough that he uses for all three varieties of his pizza, Detroit style, Grandma style and classic New York style pizza. Blue Square is a reference to the particular steel pans used to make Detroit Pizza. That's their bread and butter (or sauce). It's a tiny little spot that's set up primarily for takeout. Just five tables. And two of them are being constantly used to assemble boxes, it's hard to keep up with the demand. We got a small Detroit and a grandma, both with pepperoni. Both were outstanding. The Detroit was as expected. Thick, airy, light, crispy crust. Top quality cheese and THE best, freshest, most simple, yet flavorful sauce I have had. It came out first and was very impressive. A great pizza, particularly if you enjoy that style. What stood out were the bites that had no sauce. Normally this is not something I enjoy. Even good pizzas don't often have crusts that can stand alone as delicious. This sourdough stood alone as an amazing flavor profile. Then the grandma came out... and my life has changed forever. I had to spend a little while considering this statement to make sure it wasn't the euphoria or recency bias. It's not. The pepperoni grandma pizza at Blue Square is THE best pizza I have ever had. Literal perfection for it's golden brown, incredible crisp and unbelievably flavorful crust to the top shelf cheese combination to the sauce... OMFG that sauce. As simple as it was flavorful... The best I've ever encountered. It's as fresh as it could be and seems as simple as it could be. It was like Troy took fresh San Marzanos and crushed them up, added some olive oil, a little spice and released this masterpiece into the world. Bright, fresh, brassy, incredible. That pizza was a 12 out of 10. I can't imagine a better one exists anywhere. And I've been everywhere. Take the trip, hope there is a seat and understand how special this experience is. read more

See all

Will be taking a break from Blue Square for a bit. Pizza is awesome--NY, Detroit, Grandma's, all great. However... it's getting very, very old having to stand around the shop for 30-45 minutes past the estimated pick up time. We order most Fridays but picking up the pizza has become a game of Russian Roulette. Sometimes the orders are ready, sometimes you stand around waiting for almost an hour--more frequently, it's the latter. Note: I wrote the review above after standing around for twenty minutes before receiving my pizza and was going to sit on it. Finally received ten minutes later. Just got home. This is my "pepperoni pizza please add vodka sauce" -- absolutely ludicrous. The order is incorrect and somehow the cheese is congealed. It's almost like it was sitting around waiting for however long before they called my name. Edit: Ownership was prompt with response and resolution, amended rating for now and will reassess in the future. read more

Blue Square Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza "please add vodka sauce" (they didn't add vodka sauce) - Pizza Near Me - Hopkinton, Massachusetts

Should be called "the Emperor has no clothes"! Called in an order person couldn't communicate. Showed up hoping they had my order. After they finally found my order I put the 2 pizzas in an insulated bag and zoomed home. When I opened the bag both pizzas were stone cold. The pepperoni was so overcooked and dry even my 7 year old granddaughter wouldn't eat it. Terrible service and terrible product. When you grow so busy it's still important to keep your eye on the ball. read more

Need to get it together Went in on a busy evening to place an order, person at counter said it would be 75 mins is that ok? I said sure. A manager type overhears and interjects "actually we can't take anymore orders". Ok, whatever. As we were walking out - another person was taking a new order on the phone also advising it would be 75 mins ?! So ok to order by phone but not in person...very odd. read more

Ordered a DT red top large. It was ready on time and tasty. Parking is still a persistent problem.

We've been here several times and it is always amazing! We love their Detroit style pizza! A must try!! read more

Blue Square Pizza - Detroit style. Amazing! - Pizza Near Me - Hopkinton, Massachusetts

Ordering, price and wait times outweigh the food quality. Was super excited to read about this place opening, and since it did, have ordered 3-4 times. Tried again last night, putting in a pick up order at 6 PM or a bit after via the web site. Upon acceptance, the app listed a pick up time of 7:45, more than an hour an a half. This was an unhappy surprise, but worse was when we tried to call 2 times to cancel the order and were met with the voicemail hell phone system. We left messages and asked for a confirmation call back, no one ever called. Sure enough 2 hours later we finally got a call (Caller ID didn't even say Blue Square) asking when we were picking up our order. My very patient wife explained that we had tried to call twice and left 2 messages. Blue Square said they would refund the purchase. The pizza is very good, though the high prices for toppings make it an overly expensive option. But I can't get past a pizza place simply not picking up their phone. If you are that busy, then please turn off your phone service entirely as well as any web ordering services. But if you are taking 1.5+ hours to fill a simple 2 pizza pick up order I'd say you have some internal challenges to deal with. read more

This is some of the best pizza I've ever had. the NY is outstanding and I haven't even tried the other ones.

Placed an order for 3 different pies . Very long wait, pies were light.. good undercarriage , scarce toppings on the 2 pies that had toppings, very pricey .. place was pretty clean .. 99% carry out couple tables for dining read more