Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Bobby Bay's

    4.2 (55 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Order Bobby Bay's Takeout or Delivery

    Bobby Bay's Photos

    Business Info

    BOBBY BAY'S ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Bobby Bay's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Kids turkey sandwich
    Samantha H.

    Stopped here for lunch with my family. It was a Sunday in Lancaster which meant most of our usuals weren't open so we decided to try Bobby Bays. We ordered at the counter and sat in a booth. I got the classic burger. Burger was good but I think route 66's are better. We also got a side of loaded fries which were very good. My daughter wanted a turkey sandwich which she also enjoyed. Defintley on the pricier side for a fast casual place but I would go again if it happened to be convenient.

    Crispy chicken-needs crispy bacon and then would be a 10 out of 10
    Kendra S.

    We were waited on by a friendly lady on a Monday night and even though there were multiple to-go orders - our food was served within 5-10 minutes. I had the crispy chicken which I enjoyed. The flavor was GOOD. The only negative was that the bacon wasn't crispy on my sandwich or my SIL's burger. Next time I will make sure to ask for crispy bacon. All of us enjoyed our meal and will come back again.

    OG Bobby's Cheesesteak

    Not what it's hyped up to be. The restaurant was clean and there were no other patrons inside. The subs came out hot, which was expected since we were the only ones dining in at the time. The fries did not seem to be hand cut. But the fries were over cooked and not enjoyable. The cheesesteaks were overly greasy. Depending on the cut of beef, I know it might be a little greasy. Do not add oil to the bun. Too greasy to eat. Def not worth $15 a sub for a subpar sandwich. Very disappointed in this place.

    Big Vito and burber

    Sandwiches are definitely a step above others. Quality ingredients and really good bread. A sweet woman is the cashier occasionally. Nice place. Mortadella.

    Yummy yummy fries
    Sherry U.

    Shopping at TANGER. Wanted a quick nosh. Fries are absolutely amazing - hot, fresh and skin on. Coleslaw - fresh, cold and just a little kick. Chicken cheesesteak with Cooper Sharp - bun just right and lots of protein. Craig got The Big Vito - bread just the right texture, fresh ingredients, lots of Italian cold cuts and the right spice. Will be back.

    Chicken Philly and fries
    Jenny M.

    I'm from the St. Louis, MO area. So I was excited to try this while I was in Pennsylvania. I saw it had good reviews so figured it was worth a shot. And it was! So here's another good review. Food came out quick and was soooo yummy!

    Chicken Cheesesteak and Bobbys Cheesesteak
    Becky F.

    Good service - nice cashier Cheesesteaks were good but a little bland for my taste Loaded fries were nice and crispy with real bacon and a good cheese sauce. Booth seating

    Loaded Fries
    Danny M.

    HEY BOBBY BAY YOU MADE MY DAY YOUD BEAT BOBBY FLAY THERE IS NO AMOUNT I WOULDNT PAY ANYONE WHO GIVES THIS LESS THAN 5 IS CRAY Ok, but really this is fantastic. The sandwiches are in the mid-teens for price but I could easily get two meals from one sandwich (they are 10in). You really can't compare the cost to other spots when they are baking the rolls fresh, cooking everything and using high quality meats and cheeses. The Italian was even excellent the next day after it spent 4 hours in the danger zone unrefrigerated. The bread is tremendous. Fries were good but wouldn't get again.

    The Turk
    Anna B.

    I loved Bobby Bay's!! we had the Sorrento Salad and Don Parma, and The Turk. The service was quick and sandwiches were delicious. Although you wouldn't necessarily come here for salad, they are not to be slept on because ours was delicious too. The inside is cute and well decorated, if a little small. Would love to come back soon and try another of their unique and tasty options!

    Bobby cheesesteak
    Charles B.

    Ok when I saw the menu and the ingredients ( Truffle Whiz, cherry pepper mayo ) that I didn't know if I'd like them or not on a cheesesteak BUT! I was pleasantly surprised the ingredients went together very well and the beef was a high grade meat very very delicious.

    Italian sub

    See all

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 1
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    We love Bobby Bay's! The best sandwiches in Lancaster area by far. The Johnny Boy with fig jam added is a must try.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 1

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Good sandwich but very expensive. Cheese steak was ok but a little too fancy for my liking.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    So good! Their fresh bread is amazing. The sauce on the cali cheesesteak is delicious. We will be returning customers!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Travis B.
    113
    54
    1

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Bobby Bay's

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Sandwiches 564 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Lancaster Salad Company - Winter Beet Salad - winter feature salad.

    Lancaster Salad Company

    3.7(3 reviews)
    3.0 mi

    My salad didn't look like any of the promotional shots they have posted here but it was LARGE and…read moreworth the ten bucks!!

    On one hand, there is so much potential for awesome salads here (given the proximity to fresh local…read morefoods) but unfortunately over half of my experiences here have been underwhelming. Some mornings when I stop in to grab lunch on the way to work, the person behind the counter is friendly, knowledgeable, and efficient while making my order. Usually on these days the quality of the order is A+ (good portion, no missing ingredients, quick). However, there's other mornings where I make a quick stop en route to work only to find some of the most painfully slow service I could imagine just for one salad and maybe a cup of soup. To top it off, the person behind the counter usually doesn't know what type of soup they have (why isn't it just labeled?), usually doesn't fill the salad bowl up all the way, doesn't know what type of dressing is what (again, why aren't they labeled?), and usually doesn't have half of the salad ingredients prepared. Just this morning I ordered the special "summer salad" only to be told that literally half of the ingredients weren't prepped yet. I've certainly had some good lunches here which keeps me trying but overall I'm pretty disappointed in the quality of staff behind the counter.

    Photos
    Lancaster Salad Company - Our salad bar! Prepped fresh every Market day.

    Our salad bar! Prepped fresh every Market day.

    Lancaster Salad Company - Summer Salad - summer feature salad.

    Summer Salad - summer feature salad.

    Lancaster Salad Company - Buffalo Chicken Salad - Summer feature salad.

    See all

    Buffalo Chicken Salad - Summer feature salad.

    Cafe 23

    Cafe 23

    3.0(2 reviews)
    4.2 mi

    Love this place! I went in on a Monday afternoon and it was so quiet and such a cool spot to hang…read moreout. I tried the backyard BBQ panini. So Good! And the best part? It was made with homemade bread! the service was excellent and my order came out promptly. will definitely be back!

    Food was great, but service was horrible…read more My family & I are from out of town - POC. We stopped by for lunch in hopes of eating a good meal due to all the reviews. We ordered 3 paninis and tenders, along with drinks. Beverages were served shortly after. Four to five couples & groups came and ordered after us. Oddly enough, their food was served first. We waited roughly 30-45 minutes. Didn't think anything of it, until one of the workers dropped the tenders we ordered for my child. Instead of immediately saying she would replace the tenders, she asked if it needed to be replaced. Logic dictates, especially if you work in the food industry and you, as the server dropped it on the counter replace the items immediately, no questions asked. Obviously, I want the items replaced. First & foremost, my child is hungry. Secondly, I paid for the food & expect my order to be fulfilled in its entitreity without racial bias! I confronted the server about her lack of common sense and unacceptable behavior. To which she said, "But you won't let me talk" or "You won't even listen to my side of the story". I mean cmon, you work in the food industry - take accountability! Why am I educating you on healthy food standards and food safety? I told the employee to sit down & her response was "You're not my mother". Real professional! Please note, as a mother I don't raise idiots. Her own mother would likely be disappointed in the way she took zero accountability for her lack of actions and decisions. I waved her away. It's quite obvious that she expected my child to eat tenders that were contaminated from when dropping it on the counter & my group, persons of color to excuse her behavior. We left the establishment, fully aware that the treatment we endured was racially driven. All the other customers who ordered after us were not people of color & somehow got their food before us! Outside, a person of color approached my group. She noted that she has also been mistreated due to the color of her skin & was treated as less than in the same location. DO NOT VISIT THIS PLACE! Employees are racist, lack human decency and common sense! Additionally, employees are improperly trained/educated on food safety.

    Photos
    Cafe 23 - Backyard Bbq panini

    Backyard Bbq panini

    Cafe 23 - Backyard BBQ Panini with Sweet Potato Fries

    See all

    Backyard BBQ Panini with Sweet Potato Fries

    CAVA

    CAVA

    4.1(71 reviews)
    4.1 mi
    $$

    Live. Laugh. Love. CAVA. I have been a regular at this Cava location for years but I am just now…read morewriting a review bc my wife and I made the dismal decision to eat dinner at CoreLife the other night for a change of pace, and when I tell you they are trying so hard to be Cava but their food has ZERO flavor. You guys are doing it so much better and it's nottttt close. Hot honey harissa bowl is my go to. (I'll post my most recent photo of one here that I picked up and ate for lunch.) Portions are generous, produce is fresh, meat is well-seasoned, sauces are rich and savory, vibes are immaculate.

    "It's like Chipotle, but Mediterranean food!" This is how friends and family described Cava to me…read morewhen it first opened, and it's the reason why I'm such a late convert -- Chipotles are usually dirty and their food is in the news too often associated with making people sick. Cava is nothing like that. I got a chance to try the food for a work lunch event and enjoyed the food so much that I've introduced it to my husband and daughter as one of our more health quick dinner options. I've tried a variety of proteins and topping options in the BYO bowl and have been really pleased with the food quality and variety--I love all the traditional sauces (harissa, tzatziki), and the hubs loves the crazy feta. For dressing options, I highly recommend the lemon herb tahini and tahini Caesar. The online ordering is so simple and everything is completely customizable -- the hubs and kid can nix onions from their bowls and I can add all the onion options to mine. Everyone's happy! There are reserved to-go parking spaces right at the front entrance, so it's convenient to park there, run in to the pick up rack and grab my order. In and out in less than 5 min. If you eat-in, there plenty of room and seating inside and they even have a little outdoor area out back during the warm weather months. The staff work quick, so the order line generally moves well, but you occasionally have someone who is new to the concept asking a lot of questions about options, so that takes a little more time. For the most part the staff are patient in helping people who are struggling with the menu. The one miss? The desserts. We ordered the chocolate chip brownie once to share and were surprised by how small it was-- a little bigger than an AirPod case and an inch thick. Two bites, which for one person is enough, but not really a shareable. And for the price? For a pre-packaged brownie, essentially? Not worth it. Skip the sweet stuff and stick with the bowls.

    Photos
    CAVA
    CAVA
    CAVA

    See all

    Bobby Bay's - sandwiches - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...